- 21,207
- 30,214
- Thread starter
- #3,801
Bro she looks Birkan
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
One Piece General Discussion: Egghead
- Thread starter KingTempest
- Start date
-
- Tags
- one piece
- 18,101
- 15,799
Lol?
- 21,207
- 30,214
- Thread starter
- #3,803
The people on Skypiea with wings
- 6,414
- 6,499
- 6,414
- 6,499
- 6,414
- 6,499
Also I've heard that the film red twitter account has said that while the events aren't canon, some of the information within the film is.
And this won't be a "beat the big bad guy" type movie either.
And this won't be a "beat the big bad guy" type movie either.
- 18,101
- 15,799
I know
- 4,780
- 7,390
IK I'm reaching but
Assuming it COULD fit within the canon timeline- and this is a longshot, Uta looks like she was around Luffy's age when she was with Shanks. If Shanks was with her then left to give Luffy his hat, he'd be 27-- and assuming she was anywhere between 8 to 10, there's a window of 3-ish years where he COULD have had a daughter.
Even if I'm 99% sure Uta's just an adopted daughter, if she ain't then it could technically make sense with the ages and all.
Assuming it COULD fit within the canon timeline- and this is a longshot, Uta looks like she was around Luffy's age when she was with Shanks. If Shanks was with her then left to give Luffy his hat, he'd be 27-- and assuming she was anywhere between 8 to 10, there's a window of 3-ish years where he COULD have had a daughter.
Even if I'm 99% sure Uta's just an adopted daughter, if she ain't then it could technically make sense with the ages and all.
- 3,208
- 2,600
After seeing the Red trailer: Shanks joins the group of deadbeat dads
- 15,345
- 15,039
Wow, Shanks is a deadbeat dad who abandoned his daughter
Looks like Shanks is ripping off Gildarts
Looks like Shanks is ripping off Gildarts
- 17,703
- 12,986
Holy shit... 8-10 seconds of shanks and look at these comments 
Maybe this? Link
Man.... I swear...
Proof/scan?
Maybe this? Link
Man.... I swear...
Last edited:
- 17,703
- 12,986
True!!! What's the option?he actually doing the best option
GodlyCharmander
He/Him- 5,744
- 4,996
Who cares, the movie's not canon. I'm not watching, just like I did with any other filler in OP
- 17,548
- 11,953
And what exactly does that get you?
All you're doing is punishing yourself by missing out on great stuff, such as the entire G-8 arc.
- 17,703
- 12,986
Who cares? Um literally everyone that likes one piece... It being non canon does mean shit, I HATE that word (which is even made up).... It's like putting something in a box and only allowing someone to only go through one plotline, that literally contradicts everything in the show... I would literally watch luffy just going on a walk in his hometown and not complain
Not only does Oda himself care but so does everyone around him... So why the f should you not care? Because they're not going to go find the one piece which you don't even know about?
- 17,703
- 12,986
It being filler doesn't matter really, it being bad filler does... Especially when they are placed badly and stuff in the middle of something in the main show...
- 17,703
- 12,986
There are literally different batmans and superman but no one complains about canon or filler bs there.. 
I swear, I wanna know who the f made that word canon bs
I swear, I wanna know who the f made that word canon bs
- 3,208
- 2,600
TBH I'd rather have a decent filler arc (and One Piece has some good ones, like the aforementioned G-8 arc) than the absolutely shit pacing that Dressrosa had
- 3,208
- 2,600
It pertains to religion/theology
Unsurprisingly, the question "what is actually in the book?" assumes a lot of importance when the book in question could regulate every aspect of a person's life
- 17,703
- 12,986
- 3,208
- 2,600
The origins of the word "canon" relates to religion/theology
- 3,208
- 2,600
Last edited:
- 17,703
- 12,986
a collection or list of sacred books accepted as genuine.
This?
In fiction, canon is the material accepted as officially part of the story in an individual universe of that story by its fan base
I SWEAR PEOPLE CHANGE THE MEANING OF THIS FOR THEIR OWN BS HEADCANON, I literally don't care... If Oda finds them important to one piece then it's literally canon that's all the proof I need
- 10,605
- 9,429
really?
i think it'll be interesting
- 18,101
- 15,799
Same.really?
- 4,780
- 7,390
While I get where you're coming from and was on that mindset once, Oda's words of it being an important adventure as any other (or something around those lines) kinda drew me back.
- 15,345
- 15,039
You really gonna reference the guy who believes the Raid will still fail as a source?
How far we have fallen
- 18,101
- 15,799
- 4,780
- 7,390
The raid already failed. Everything post round 2 is actually just Luffy seeing things after Kaido knocked his ass off Onigashima
- 15,345
- 15,039
Dude made that video and made up all these rules... And failed entirely to mention Jimbei, who doesn't fit any of his rules
Despite the two latest members of the Straw Hats not following the system Morj just explained, they still joined
Like his Raid will fail theories, Morj has once again capped hard
Despite the two latest members of the Straw Hats not following the system Morj just explained, they still joined
Like his Raid will fail theories, Morj has once again capped hard
- 10,605
- 9,429
Damn this was a very very good video
- 10,605
- 9,429
Regardless I think his theory has some validity to it. Though you make a good point about Jinbei
- 15,345
- 15,039
I think his argument had some validity to Pre-TS Straw Hats, but Oda has changed over the years and Brook and Jimbei prove that the rules of someone being a Straw Hat have changed from the start of the series
So I don't think he made any valid points
- 10,605
- 9,429
Agreed
Well I'm mostly referring to the last part of his video where he talks about when Yamato took the wrong message from Oden's journal: that Oden should be adventuring out in the sea; when infact he should have stayed and ruled Wano.
Though a counterargument could be that since Yamato's whole character is basically derived from Oden and his journal, her character arc will be breaking from that, and instead of staying in Wano she instead goes out into sea and doesn't look back (unlike Oden).... or something like that idk
I still think his points are valid, Im still pretty neutral on the whole thing tbh
- 4,780
- 7,390
He lost me with his "Kaido won't lose because we don't have his flashback" argument being so reaccuring.
Like Katakuri's flashback didn't come after he lost-
