• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is gonna be for the Mid-High Tiers.
This is a lot.

A lot of these characters have "possibly" on their ranking for High 7-A. The possibly's have no backing to why they're possibles, even though some of them scale off Luffy who has a solid High 7-A rating.
Some scale off the Admirals who were decided in this thread to be High 7-A or High 7-A+.

I have no issue with these being denied btw.
Here are my suggestions:
Is Katakuri, Doflamingo, and Cracker agreed on?
 
Katakuri has quite a bit of support for baseline High 7-A, yet Cracker is stated weaker than Katakuri so I'm not sure he scales; unsure though since he did cut him. Since this only applies to Doflamingo's durability I'm still uncertain since I'm pretty sure Luffy in Boundman did destroy Doflamingo's awakening strings at one point.
 
Luffy is going to be 1.131, Kata will be in that level, Smoothie and Cracker could very well be 1.130 or 1.050, whatever, they aren't far behind Katakuri, that is the point, so they all should be H7A.

Btw, how many have agreed with Luffy's dura raising to H7A after Katakuri has his 7A+ end removed?
 
Katakuri has quite a bit of support for baseline High 7-A, yet Cracker is stated weaker than Katakuri so I'm not sure he scales; unsure though since he did cut him.
Cracker uses bladed weapons and he barely fights, the soldiers do for him.
Since this only applies to Doflamingo's durability I'm still uncertain since I'm pretty sure Luffy in Boundman did destroy Doflamingo's awakening strings at one point.
Doflamingo blocked with 2 layers and Luffy couldn't go through. He blocked with 1 and he went through.
 
Base Zoro ~ Amped Kaku > Base Kaku > Base Jabra > Sanji. Your point is? Manga said it.
Base Jabra > Sanji????
Sanji could fight against Hybrid Jabura, even without diable jambe.
No. His specialty is tekkai. Specialty ≠ best. Zoro's specialty in the group is Armament but Luffy has better armament than him.
Disagree. Zoro had better armament than Luffy before wano.
Zoro turned his attack into nothing then one shot him.
and Sanji first kicked Jabura with a no-named attack diable jambe, then one-shotted him with a flambage shot. Feats are comparable, since Jabura had tekkai actived when Sanji attacked him, while Zoro shotted a Kaku without tekkai actived.
His attacks are durability negation.
in the first chapters of one piece, it is said that sanji can't withstand well the impact of his own blows because they're too powerful.
Biologically, not overall. Or what, Sanji > Katakuri and Luffy now? Or Big Mom too?
and what I said? Katakuri > oven because Katakuri protects himself with haki. But Cracker took the hit without amrmanet haki protecting him.
You mean the snack that lost to Eustass Kid?
Losing to Luffy's rival, wow, what a shame.
Sabo's the 2nd strongest in the revolutionary army and he stresses with Fujitora who scales to Gear 2nd and 3rd Luffy.
Or what, Fujitora ~ Akainu now? Gear 2nd Luffy = Akainu Level You guys.
Akainu and Kuzan were the strongest marines without any doubt, but I still think Fuji should scale well above gear 2nd and 3rd Luffy. He's an admiral afterall and Dressrosa Sabo is really understimated, he should be at least comparable to Ace, because the two since kids were physically equal, but then Ace obtained a fruit and Sabo trained under Dragon and obtained really powerful armament haki (he seems to have ryou). Someone with Ace's potential and growth, better haki than Ace and 2 more years of training compared to Ace, but less experience with mera mera no mi, that's Sabo. I would totally scale Sabo at Large Mountain level and Fujitora too.
 
Didn't someone say in another thread we shouldn't give a solid rate to someone like Fujitora who did all his feats (the 377, 420 and 6C feats) without any shown effort?
 
So why is Sabo stressing with Fujitora an anti-feat for Sabo? Due to his position and fame, it could very well be Fujitora using more power than what he used with Luffy.
 
So why is Sabo stressing with Fujitora an anti-feat for Sabo? Due to his position and fame, it could very well be Fujitora using more power than what he used with Luffy.
That's what I'm saying. Fujitora could've been using much more strength, but since all we've seen from him is his casual feats, it doesn't matter
 
Which one? The Conquerors haki clash one?

Also, I just noticed that Zoro trained for a day. I highly doubt Zoro could've went from Mountain to Large Mountain in 1 day of training, so the scaling chain of
Zoro ~ Killer ≤ Kid still fits.
 
Also, I just noticed that Zoro trained for a day. I highly doubt Zoro could've went from Mountain to Large Mountain in 1 day of training, so the scaling chain of
Zoro ~ Killer ≤ Kid still fits.
He trained for three days & keep in mind training in Enies Lobby boosted the straw hats largely. Killer also doesn't scale to Santoryu Zoro since he was one shot by him.
 
He trained for three days & keep in mind training in Enies Lobby boosted the straw hats largely.
Nah it was 1.
4 days prior to the raid, Zoro gets the sword.
3 days prior to the raid, Zoro trains.
2 days prior to the raid, Kin'emon tells everyone to get ready to leave.

Yeah you're right I just noticed😭"
Killer also doesn't scale to Santoryu Zoro since he was one shot by him.
Good point
 
Had a read through the thread, looks like the majority of staff and members agree with putting Katakuri at baseline High 7-A so would it be fine to apply that now or would it still require more input?
 
Staff: @Damage3245 & @DemonGodMitchAubin agreed for baseline High 7-A. @DarkDragonMedeus & @Antvasima liked their posts and said they trusted their judgement.

In terms of of members it's harder to find but I believe (sorry if I'm mistaken) @KingTempest, @UchihaSlayer96 and me are for baseline High 7-A Kat, maybe more I can't quite remember.

Edit: Sorry i misread I thought you said who agreed for baseline H7A Kat not dura for Luffy, as far as I can tell there isn't any staff agreement on that.
 
Well, Zoro has H7A dura because he took hits from Apoo, shouldn't Luffy also scale? Ulti, who scales above Apoo, wasn't able to damage Luffy much when he was on guard, but yeah, Damage disagreed with scaling based in Katakuri, but i think with scaling from Apoo, Zoro and Ulti (as well as Katakuri) H7A is much more valid.
 
She does, Apoo isn't able to become a Tobiroppo, and in the beast pirates strength grants you a higher rank.

Also, Apoo's DF should scale to his own dura (equal or above) which is 7A+ for clashing with Drake, who is 7A+ for... scaling above Apoo's DF? Isn't that already circular scaling or i am forgetting someone here?
 
She does, Apoo isn't able to become a Tobiroppo, and in the beast pirates strength grants you a higher rank.
The Tobiroppo are the strongest of the headliners and Apoo isn't a headliner. Plus from what we learn during the raid it's rare opportunity for members of the beast pirates to show their strength to garner the right to gain a higher rank; for example the Tobiroppo had to find Yamato just for the right to challenge a Calamity and move up in rank.

It's not like the Beast pirates have scouters to determine if characters are actually stronger at any given time, and we know someone like X Drake who was regarded as quite a strong Tobi Roppo wasn't any stronger than Apoo based off his feats.
 
upon checking Apoo's page:
Attack Potency: Mountain level+ (His "Fighting Music" put a deep cut into Zoro and momentarily incapacitated Base Luffy during the Siege of Onigashima. He was able to leave a mark on Luffy from a blunt force attack, even with the latter's Blunt Force Resistance).

Considering the feats I've highlighted, wouldn't that warrant Apoo and "at least 7-A+" AP rating? Since overcoming Luffy's blunt force resistance obviously would require more than just scaling equal to base luffy's durability & K.O him would require more than baseline as well.
 
The Tobiroppo are the strongest of the headliners and Apoo isn't a headliner. Plus from what we learn during the raid it's rare opportunity for members of the beast pirates to show their strength to garner the right to gain a higher rank; for example the Tobiroppo had to find Yamato just for the right to challenge a Calamity and move up in rank.

It's not like the Beast pirates have scouters to determine if characters are actually stronger at any given time, and we know someone like X Drake who was regarded as quite a strong Tobi Roppo wasn't any stronger than Apoo based off his feats.
He isn't a headliner, but his position is still below the Tobiroppo since he still wanted to have one of their spots, meaning he didn't have all the privileges their positions grants to them, and more privileges are granted only to those with strength in the Beast Pirates.

He wouldn't have reached this special position outside the normal ranks without showing his power to someone, be it a Calamity or Kaido himself (the latter is more likely due to Apoo being a Supernova), meaning they evaluated all the Supernovas in one point, leaving Hawkins (who has the weakest feats) as a normal headliner, Apoo with this special position and Drake as a Tobiroppo (who are only below the Calamities), so Apoo was strong enough to be above headliners (his feats are better than Hawkins') but not strong enough to be grouped with Drake and his peers (was fighting a casual Drake), this is consistent afaik.

Just like Zoro wasn't serious, Drake also wasn't, he didn't even use his X-Calibur, an attack which was portrayed as being in the same level as a Kong Gun, Zoro isn't the only one who is saving energy to fight the real problems, the only reason Zoro turned serious was because he saw Kiku's severed arm, otherwise they would still be fighting, meaning none of them was interested in wasting energy against Apoo.

And Apoo's music punch left a mark in an off guard Luffy and didn't turn Luffy in his serious state, while Ulti used her base Ul-Zugan while Luffy was on guard, also left a mark, and made Luffy realize he was understamating Kaido's crew (all of that after Luffy fought Apoo)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top