- 13,328
- 21,295
That's appealing to what you personally believe should be necessary, which I feel is too much scrutiny for the sake of it
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
If it doesn't show any acceleration I'm sure it's a quite necessary pointThat's appealing to what you personally believe should be necessary, which I feel is too much scrutiny for the sake of it
I don't agree with that, and it's doubtful that'll change given that this comes down to a disparity in belief for how these things should be handled.Also it needs to be the same. If they have different frame rates that just means we can't compare if it's same or not. Not "it doesn't need to be the same"
I wrote that explanation as the problem was not seen in different frame rates, but that it could be slow at first because it accelerated.
Acceleration argument itself was for debunking it being slow at first because it accelerated. But now we all agree that 9 frames period was a slow motion scene. There isn't any obvious acceleration there but the point is that it doesn't change anything as it being slow for 9 frames isn't a used counter-argument now. I already explained that hereLuffy went from his fist being plastered onto Kaido's face to doing a 180 degree swing. There's obvious acceleration in there, and yet going by your claim, there's none.
I wrote that explanation as the problem was not seen in different frame rates, but that it could be slow at first because it accelerated.
Like, that's just how acceleration works? That's not something depending on agreementI don't agree with that, and it's doubtful that'll change given that this comes down to a disparity in belief for how these things should be handled.
Luffy's fist isn't slow at first, just that scene has different frame rate (like how both KingTempest and you said)Like, Luffy's fist being slower in the first 9 frames and then speeding up in the last one is basic acceleration.
Things like this are admittedly on the trickier side to evaluate it, but my rationale is that when you watch the entire scene at full speed and scale, there is what I consider to be a continuous flow. There's a well-defined arc to Luffy's motion here.
Luffy's fist is slower at first. A slower frame rate can easily depict that. Worth keeping in mind, too, that saying "it's just the frame rate" isn't exactly a valid counterargument without proper substantiation. This is pretty much an arbitrary belief of "the scene needs to be this way", and I don't agree with that.I will explain as simple as I can
Luffy's fist isn't slow at first, just that scene has different frame rate (like how both KingTempest and you said)
As how acceleration works, for that 9 frames Luffy's fist also should speed up, but it doesn't
There being acceleration or not doesn't change anything because there isn't a counter-argument of "Luffy's fist was slow at first" which should be debunked by acceleration argument
Understandable. Personally it doesn't look like that to me.Things like this are admittedly on the trickier side to evaluate it, but my rationale is that when you watch the entire scene at full speed and scale, there is what I consider to be a continuous flow. There's a well-defined arc to Luffy's motion here.
No? Why scene having slower frame rate should mean anything about fist's speed? I'm sure slower frame rate even mostly used for scenes with higher speed but that's not the point. If it has slower frame rate, then it has different frame rate so you can't just directly compare it. Idk how you agree about having different frame rate and also say Luffy's fist was slower at first.Luffy's fist is slower at first. A slower frame rate can easily depict that. Worth keeping in mind, too, that saying "it's just the frame rate" isn't exactly a valid counterargument without proper substantiation. This is pretty much an arbitrary belief of "the scene needs to be this way", and I don't agree with that.
Multiplying degree by pi/180 to find that it was pi radians and then multiplying radius by pi radians. There isn't a 2× hereUnderstandable. Personally it doesn't look like that to me.
One of the things I'm slightly confused about is how the distance that the fist travelled was calculated. The formula there currently is essentially the circumference of a circle with the length of Luffy's arm as the diameter.
2 x radius x pi is what this is 106563.59228944 * 180 * pi/180.
Not quite sure how a 180 degrees rotation ends up equalling a circle.
I see, so the length of Luffy's arm is being treated as a the radius here.Multiplying degree by pi/180 to find that it was pi radians and then multiplying radius by pi radians. There isn't a 2× here
Only now I noticed that part of your reply. Yeah, it makes sense as all of fist's parts have different speeds. I think we should call KingTempest then.My issue with that then if that it assumes that the entire mass of Luffy's arm is at the end of his fist. It should be calculated the movement of the center of mass.
A bit confused, I just traveled a long distance, but a 180 degree arc should basically just be pi x radius (since you'd need to divide the equation of a circle's circumference by 2, pretty much canceling out the 2 from the initial equation)Understandable. Personally it doesn't look like that to me.
One of the things I'm slightly confused about is how the distance that the fist travelled was calculated. The formula there currently is essentially the circumference of a circle with the length of Luffy's arm as the diameter.
2 x radius x pi is what this is 106563.59228944 * 180 * pi/180.
Not quite sure how a 180 degrees rotation ends up equalling a circle.
Thanks, that bit was also clarified by Floxy178, but i had a new point here:A bit confused, I just traveled a long distance, but a 180 degree arc should basically just be pi x radius (since you'd need to divide the equation of a circle's circumference by 2, pretty much canceling out the 2 from the initial equation)
I see, so the length of Luffy's arm is being treated as a the radius here.
My issue with that then if that it assumes that the entire mass of Luffy's arm is at the end of his fist. It should be calculated the movement of the center of mass.
Which is a bit of a problem when trying to find the kinetic energy of it though.I don't believe that's what's assumed here? It's just that Luffy's entire arm is being swung that distance. That's how we always do these sorts of arm movement calcs, because the entire arm is being moved rather than just part of it
The entire arm is not travelling that distance though is my point.The entire arm contains the total mass, though
It really isn't. That black line there? That corresponds to this red line:The part that wouldn't be is an essentially negligible amount, as it's coming from Luffy's regular width arm. The actual enlarged fist is traveling that full arc, and that's where essentially all the mass is
, as it's coming from Luffy's regular width arm
They should, I used the center of mass to calculate the distance of the swing here instead of using the very tip of the metal plate.Also with limb swinging KE calcs, this sort of thing's never been applied before. I don't get why suddenly start now
Thank you! I'm glad someone gets where I'm coming from with the centre of mass being an issue.They should, I used the center of mass to calculate the distance of the swing here instead of using the very tip of the metal plate.
Genuine first time I've seen this doneThey should, I used the center of mass to calculate the distance of the swing here instead of using the very tip of the metal plate.
Yeah yeah Clover's just in denial trying to wank One Piece, we know what you're thinkingThank you! I'm glad someone gets where I'm coming from with the centre of mass being an issue.
I wasn't implying you were in denial; to be more honest I was more frustrated with myself for seemingly being unable to explain it properly.Yeah yeah Clover's just in denial trying to wank One Piece, we know what you're thinking
Anyways would it be more around the center of the inflated fist?
Yeah, pretty much.Anyways, where would the center of mass be? At the center of the inflated part?
Didn't come off that way to me but I'll chalk that up to standard Internet shenanigans + today being tiring
I can adjust my calc to include the speed at the center of mass and its kinetic energy later. However, I wanted to discuss the sheer inconsistency of Luffy's fist size:
If the size of Luffy's fist isn't consistent, then a mass or speed can't be found for kinetic energy, as using a different images would yield completely different results. Could anyone provide some insight into which image to use for the size of his fist? I understand that anime studios aren't consistent with sizing, but which image would be the most reliable (if any)? I'd assume it would be the second-to-last image in the Imgur album I linked, as the last image only shows the width and height of his fist, not the giant bubble behind it. However, the size of the fist in the second-to-last image is contradicted a few seconds later by the final image in the album, so I'm a bit lost.
The same thing applies. With the flame dragon, the size is inconsistent, and without it, the size is also inconsistent.Nothing is inconsistent here. Kaido's Flame Dragon is much, much bigger than his actual Dragon Form. There's also stuff like pre-decompression and post-decompression
fist and arm excep fist are likely symmetrical, so it's easy to find their mass centers seperately. For finding mass center of entire arm I just need fist's length, arm length(except fist), fist's mass, arm's mass(except fist)Anyways, where would the center of mass be? At the center of the inflated part?
It's not rod-like here so probably we can't use 1/3*m*L^2 for II know that mentioning this now might be too late (I just have free time now), but if we really want to use the maximum arm swing distance, wouldn't it be better to use Rotational Kinetic Energy similar to this calculation?
Zunesha's Trunk (Alternative Method)
vsbattles.fandom.com
However, what I typed might not be useful anymore since there has already been a discussion on other calculation methods.