- 1,287
- 2,182
I think anyone who missed the stream should watch it when it becomes available later before making assumptions.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
DEATH BATTLE! Discussion Thread (2024–2025) (All-time Death Battle Spoilers Alert)
- Thread starter TMaakkonen
- Start date
- 772
- 2,167
Guys what’s that screaming noise
- 521
- 891
Eeeeeeerm, why are you criticizing the researchers?? Are you toxic???
0ホルスファルコン将軍0
He/Him- 1,357
- 2,460
He called out Guts VS Nightmare, he just doesn’t go into powerscaling unless if the result contradicts the episode’s own logic.
- 1,287
- 2,182
Less didn't address it, more so focusing/interpreting the wrong issues
- 2,703
- 3,576
That's not addressing the concerns or admitting anything.
Hey you got this question wrong?
Eh that was a month ago
- 22,414
- 48,250
alright i'll post it
so didn't do a good job addressing shit i take it
- 13,800
- 13,960
Animation and music aside, i dislike how they researched it, which most of you already heard of it from me a million times
But the issue is it made some idiots like the mentioned guy above from reddit and others like him believe the meat riding given, which really any mu they done before had a similar issue, gaslighting characters that arenr actually as they say at times
- 2,703
- 3,576
Also not revisiting the research seems irresponsible.
- 13,800
- 13,960
If they will treat faulty episodes like this, in the future they get in trouble again, how many will help them anymore lol
- 4,696
- 5,118
ngl I would have appreciated more if they did a DBC making extended arguments to why they're right and all over them just handwaving the opposition to saltiness.
When was the last time they made a DBC where they go on full long explanations to why they are right about their verdicts? Did they stop doing that?
When was the last time they made a DBC where they go on full long explanations to why they are right about their verdicts? Did they stop doing that?
- 772
- 2,167
Ben vs Hal was the last time I remember that happening
- 521
- 891
Same people who thought anyone but like 6 people worldwide would want Traveler vs Aang lmao
- 2,565
- 2,209
Why didn’t they address it in a qna blog? Why a livestream with someone who wasn’t even the calcer for the sun disc?
- 13,800
- 13,960
I never understood why this mentality of "judge it by episode logic" is a thing
Why should i judge an episode from their episode logic instead of the supposed general logic, if they said homelander won and it was correct under their logic for example, is that suppose to be ok?
- 772
- 2,167
Too much effort not worth 730k
- 4,696
- 5,118
Wow, what a fall from grace
You know, I think they should do more stuff like that, I know there are people who are still salty about that matchup, but there are also a lot of people who defend Death Battle for their verdict in that fight
Death Battle is pretty much doing the same thing, putting the important calculations in the black boxes rather than address them in the video
- 496
- 1,085
So, what is the intended implication of saying it was done a year ago? If they stand by it, it shouldn't matter how long ago it was done.
- 1,287
- 2,182
I feel like at that moment, they realized "no matter how much we explain it to our fans, there will always be a loud minority who won't accept it, so why bother?"
- 2,565
- 2,209
apparently they do address that they should start saying things in the epsiode rather than black boxxing
Anyway's someone managed to calc the sun disc to star level using only the highest of high ends for the planet size. His mid ball was "brown dwarf" level
- 2,565
- 2,209
So it makes me think that there was a massive overestimation on what the planet size was
(Even If I think star level invincible is based and I want it to be real cause I like it)
(Even If I think star level invincible is based and I want it to be real cause I like it)
- 3,927
- 5,687
it’s literally the reason the wrong character won the episode.
- 15,644
- 11,715
Yeah, I know. And? It still isn't a big deal. These are the Gaara vs Toph people.
- 4,696
- 5,118
For example, I think Ben vs Hal is a wash for Hal, I have seen the arguments for Hal, and they make more sense than the arguments for Ben since Hal is faster, resists what Ben can do, can be scaled higher, can have better haxes, etc.
What was their fault. They didn't nail it enough how much faster Hal is than Ben, nor did they explain well their reasonings. Even Death Battle dicksuckers pointed that out.
They got paid 730k by the fans, I think we deserve better explanations rather than them running away to their hugboxes. It can't be that hard to publicly address the opposing arguments after you release an episode. I mean, if you already researched the characters, just record yourself doing a QnA to what the haters say.
tbh sometimes I have felt angry about their outcomes, but I changed my mind after hearing more about their reasoning
- 2,565
- 2,209
Gaara vs toph is like 10 years old, are people still using that? Cause like vsbw had scarlet king at 5D a few years back lmfao
If your going to shit on deathbattle scaling, at least use more recent examples
- 3,927
- 5,687
they got 730k from fans so yeah actually it is.
- 772
- 2,167
Wait, all that ******** on doomers and now this defense and you don’t watch the show? Wtf why are you posting in the thread for a show you don’t watch?
- 15,644
- 11,715
I watch the stuff, I'm just casual about it. Also, I was objectively right on the doomer thing, the channel factually came back.
- 22,414
- 48,250
well old grudges don't die easily
- 2,565
- 2,209
Thing is, I wouldn't even mind the sun disc if they managed to explain away the viltrum anti-feat like the G^omega blog did
Would it be good? Meh. Would it be far more reasonable? Yeah.
Would it be good? Meh. Would it be far more reasonable? Yeah.
- 15,644
- 11,715
I was using Gaara vs Toph as an example because it was a while ago, so there isn't much contention anymore.
- 2,703
- 3,576
Ngl those arguements are still ass.
- 15,644
- 11,715
I forget, does Viltrum have a canonical size?
- 496
- 1,085
Ngl, "their calcs are so bad that they shouldn't have to explain them" is not a defense I was expecting to hear.
- 772
- 2,167
“They aren’t obligated to explain”
And the fans weren’t obligated to donate, they did because they cared. This is just showing me that the crew doesn’t have that same care in return. That’s my issue with this, wrong result? Whatever. But to ignore literally the entire community raising huge concerns after they saved your ass is insane.
And the fans weren’t obligated to donate, they did because they cared. This is just showing me that the crew doesn’t have that same care in return. That’s my issue with this, wrong result? Whatever. But to ignore literally the entire community raising huge concerns after they saved your ass is insane.
- 1,287
- 2,182
Yeah, it was. But it also didn't help when Kuro the Artist decided to pit his Omnitrix in the race and try to debunk the episode, which didn't help matters.
I do miss those days...
Yeah, but not everyone is like us. If we get mad about the outcome, we take it on the chin and move on.
That's not the case with certain fan groups. Like even when Death Battle is right when a certain character loses, none of their fan bases take it well.
Case in point, the Ben 10 fan base still refuse to accept that Ben loses to Hal. Berserk fans were upset when Guts lost to Dimitri. Sonic fans were stewing when he lost to Mario at the time.
When you keep dealing with those types of people from time to time, you'd eventually just handwave it all and just try to move on
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
