• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
There's nothing that indicates that man, they were matching each other and no one had an advantage over the other. Only rayleigh was getting tired because of old age.
0512-007.png
Kizaru was literally trying/being serious and screaming... Got cut and said how how troublesome Rayleigh is.
Gets stopped
Gets stopped again
Rayleigh is holding kizaru back as a distraction to let the strawhat escape while doing that not paying any attention to kizaru...

Not once was kizaru able to do a thing to rayleigh, unless you count stamina 🐵

Now bye... You literally can't bring up any argument so don't even try because I won't respond to bs or your bs on what I say is bs
 
In any significant way, sure. But it does affect one's overall abilities, as shown with Marineford WB.
TBF, WB's crew warned him about bot removing the medical treatment just before marineford & WB being much older there while Crocus said Roger was still in perfect shape when fighting Shiki in episode 0. Either Roger was in good shape too when he fought WB(likey as WB commented on him looking pretty good) or anytime his sickness would cause him trouble, they would call off the fighting for a break.
Rayleigh is holding kizaru back as a distraction to let the strawhat escape while doing that not paying any attention to kizaru...

Not once was kizaru able to do a thing to rayleigh, unless you count stamina 🐵

Now bye... You literally can't bring up any argument so don't even try because I won't respond to bs or your bs on what I say is bs
Yeah, you're right. Also if Old Rayleigh<Kizaru or Old Rayleigh=Kizaru(+better stamania), then how the heck did Kizaru fail to arrest him?
 
Marco and Yamato over Shiki, Roger, Garp, and Sengoku is so wild.

Payback Teach under Marco when he beat a more in shape Marco is crazy
 
Kizaru was literally trying/being serious and screaming... Got cut and said how how troublesome Rayleigh is.

Gets stopped

Gets stopped again

Rayleigh is holding kizaru back as a distraction to let the strawhat escape while doing that not paying any attention to kizaru...

Not once was kizaru able to do a thing to rayleigh, unless you count stamina 🐵

Now bye... You literally can't bring up any argument so don't even try because I won't respond to bs or your bs on what I say is bs
Nah man you're reaching. You're acting like rayleigh parrying him a few times means he's stronger.

Yeah, you're right. Also if Old Rayleigh<Kizaru or Old Rayleigh=Kizaru(+better stamania),
Because their fight was brief while they can actually fight for a longer time before ever losing.
Marco above WB is crazy
Borsalino above Rayleigh is crazy
A lot more on that list is crazy
That is the only placement I have contention with. If marco has weaker armament haki than whitebeard then I'll gladly put him lower.
No it isn't give me a reason and I'll change it.
Such as?
Marco and Yamato over Shiki, Roger, Garp, and Sengoku is so wild.

Payback Teach under Marco when he beat a more in shape Marco is crazy
No yamato is just that strong, she was the only one other than luffy who can actually 1v1 kaido while he's fighting seriously.
Marco is definitely stronger than he was pre time skip, I'm not scaling teach that high.
Doesn't "much stronger Kaido" statement about who can fight him debunk a lot of that list?
Elaborate? If you're talking about dudes who can fight kaido then this doesn't contradict it as many of those in that list can harm kaido easily.
mingler-orangutan.gif

Well... That was a lie...

More support of
Man just stay silent.
 
Elaborate? If you're talking about dudes who can fight kaido then this doesn't contradict it as many of those in that list can harm kaido easily.
No? My question is well elaborated.

Harming Kaido isn't a milestone anymore, Fluffy, get on with the times. Kin'emon and Killer could do it, and they are DWARFED by Kaido in strength.

Nearly no one in your list can fight Kaido by themselves, they'd get killed, mollywhopped, dunglebungle'd by Kaido insane speed and power, plus god tier stamina capable of buttf-cking even Marco. Nah, we have a clear list of people who can fight Kaido, which includes Whitebeard, straight up contradicting your very doo doo scaling about Oden surpassing WB.
 
No? My question is well elaborated.

Harming Kaido isn't a milestone anymore, Fluffy, get on with the times. Kin'emon and Killer could do it, and they are DWARFED by Kaido in strength.

Nearly no one in your list can fight Kaido by themselves, they'd get killed, mollywhopped, dunglebungle'd by Kaido insane speed and power, plus god tier stamina capable of buttf-cking even Marco. Nah, we have a clear list of people who can fight Kaido, which includes Whitebeard, straight up contradicting your very doo doo scaling about Oden surpassing WB.
Nah man there is a difference between fodder marines stabbing through whitebeard with swords and oden cutting kaido and scarring him for life mentally and physically. You have to realize that kinemon and four others despite being able to pierce kaido are still not able to actually wound him even when four of them together and they still can't match oden's 1 attack.
If whitebeard fought kaido, he'd actually be able to harm current dragon kaido and scar him like that. If you are scaling to or above kaido at all then that qualifies the "can fight kaido" thing. You are forgetting that the scaling chain I gave for kaido earlier is extremely tight so the superiority is actually small. If say current kaido fought prime whitebeard, they'd be fighting for days before ever reaching a conclusion.

Doodoo scaling because you disagree.
 
That is the only placement I have contention with. If marco has weaker armament haki than whitebeard then I'll gladly put him lower.
WB’s Buso > Akainu’s Buso > Marco’s Buso

Prime WB ~ Sick Roger > Oden ~ Base Kaido ~ 1 Homie Big Mom ~ Hybrid Marco

There is no multiverse where Marco will ever scale above WhiteBeard.

No it isn't give me a reason and I'll change it.
A rusty old shit stamina Rayleigh cut Kizaru’s face and matched him, and said he could’ve done more in his prime.
You put King over Akainu and Ace.
You put Sanji over Killer.
You put Marco over Shanks.

No yamato is just that strong, she was the only one other than luffy who can actually 1v1 kaido while he's fighting seriously.
And was noticeably superior.

Shiki fought Sengoku and Garp at the same time.
Garp and Roger fought Rocks and Kaidou who had help.

Kaidou isn’t one random strong ass villain compared to everyone else. Those guys have the feats to put them above him.
Marco is definitely stronger than he was pre time skip, I'm not scaling teach that high.
Marco flat out didn’t even fight since the payback war, and that’s when BB beat him.
Elaborate? If you're talking about dudes who can fight kaido then this doesn't contradict it as many of those in that list can harm kaido easily.
Harming Kaido easily doesn’t mean you can fight him.
The people in the 30s can harm Kaido easily. They got smoked
 
WB’s Buso > Akainu’s Buso > Marco’s Buso

Prime WB ~ Sick Roger > Oden ~ Base Kaido ~ 1 Homie Big Mom ~ Hybrid Marco

There is no multiverse where Marco will ever scale above WhiteBeard.


A rusty old shit stamina Rayleigh cut Kizaru’s face and matched him, and said he could’ve done more in his prime.

You put King over Akainu and Ace.
You put Sanji over Killer.
You put Marco over Shanks.


And was noticeably superior.

Shiki fought Sengoku and Garp at the same time.
Garp and Roger fought Rocks and Kaidou who had help.

Kaidou isn’t one random strong ass villain compared to everyone else. Those guys have the feats to put them above him.

Marco flat out didn’t even fight since the payback war, and that’s when BB beat him.

Harming Kaido easily doesn’t mean you can fight him.
The people in the 30s can harm Kaido easily. They got smoked
This is not true, prime oden surpasses whitebeard because of his statement that no one can beat kaido except him and kaido got even stronger, and that's what marco scales to, this scaling chain looks like this.
Dragon kaido ~ marco > young dragon kaido > base kaido > whitebeard with gura > whitebeard < whitebeard with gura << CoC whitebeard. So marco has the AP advantage.
But I will still move marco down and whitebeard up because of the haki.

He doesn't get stronger in his prime and his haki doesn't get stronger, the only thing that changes is stamina and kizaru still has better hax.

King scales to zoro who can properly cut kaido's scales and scaling to law and kidd who can tank big moms punches and mom is stronger than whitebeard. Akainu got his organs turned into soup by an extremely fatigued almost dead whitebeard.
Killer is noticably weaker than the rest of the roof piece and his feats are like that of the scabbards while sanji is far above queen.
Marco is cracked.
Still kept up with him with conquerors haki which is insane.
Shiki fought both of them and got clapped silly.
That entire figbt is unknown and kaido was still young and was even stated to have gotten much stronger. This shouldn't be used in scaling whatsoever.
They don't, nobody (for now) can beat kaido except luffy.

I don't care, he's blatantly stronger, he's like android 17 lmao.

Even fodder marines harmed whitebeard, that is definitely not enough to scale. I'm talking about the dudes who can harm kaido like luffy did or the way oden did.

Can you please tell me why the ace novel is canon?
 
This is not true, prime oden surpasses whitebeard because of his statement that no one can beat kaido except him and kaido got even stronger
This is some basic headass crack scaling.

Oden did not say “nobody can beat him but me”. He said “If I can’t beat him, nobody here can”.
Kaido isn’t strong because of his AP only, he’s strong because of his stamina.
Everyone is acting like Luffy and Kaidou are Zeus and Chronos when Kaido is known to be a stamina tank, not an AP god
, and that's what marco scales to
Hell no
this scaling chain looks like this.
Dragon kaido ~ marco > young dragon kaido > base kaido > whitebeard with gura > whitebeard < whitebeard with gura << CoC whitebeard. So marco has the AP advantage.
But I will still move marco down and whitebeard up because of the haki.
How in the hell does Marco scale to Dragon Kaido.
How in the hell is young dragon Kaido superior to current base Kaido.
Base Kaidou has nothing that puts him above WhiteBeard with his DF.

Marco couldn’t put down Akainu with help. WhiteBeard 2 shot him.

Haki being a factor isn’t even realistic. “Stronger Haki puts him higher on the ladder” you know how Haki works?
WB without Haki has better feats than Marco with Haki.

Marco is not on that level.
He doesn't get stronger in his prime
Says who?
and his haki doesn't get stronger
Says who?
, the only thing that changes is stamina and kizaru still has better hax.
“Better hax” lasers and a light form?

Law has the best hax in the verse and he’s not even top 5 on your list.
King scales to zoro who can properly cut kaido's scales and scaling to law and kidd who can tank big moms punches and mom is stronger than whitebeard. Akainu got his organs turned into soup by an extremely fatigued almost dead whitebeard.
Killer is noticably weaker than the rest of the roof piece and his feats are like that of the scabbards while sanji is far above queen.
This is crack.

King scales to Zoro? Yes. Does King scale to Zoro with ridiculous Enma usage? Hell no.

Zoro and King have no scaling at all to Law and Kid. Kid 1v1’d big mom. Putting those guys there is hilarious.

Killer is comparable to Zoro and they both cut base Kaido alongside each other.

Marco is cracked.
Still kept up with him with conquerors haki which is insane.
While tired and holding up an island.
This is like comparing G2nd Luffy to Doflamingo while Doffy was holding up the birdcage and fighting Law at the same time after several fatal injuries
Shiki fought both of them and got clapped silly.
“Got clapped silly” you definitely don’t read one piece.
Shiki fought them so well to the point where even the narrator said Marineford was destroyed before they could put him down.
That entire figbt is unknown and kaido was still young and was even stated to have gotten much stronger. This shouldn't be used in scaling whatsoever.
Rocks is stated to be Roger’s strongest foe.
That means he’s above Shiki, WhiteBeard, Chinjao, and many more.
WhiteBeard in his sick self is capable of fighting Kaidou. Those guys in their primes can fight Rocks.
They don't, nobody (for now) can beat kaido except luffy.
You do know Kaidou is at the ends of his stamina?
Kaidou is weaker than he was beginning of the raid.
Luffy’s only having above an average chance right now cause Kaidou is at the ends of his stamina.
I don't care, he's blatantly stronger, he's like android 17 lmao.
I’m praying you’re not saying Marco is blatantly stronger than Blackbeard.
Even fodder marines harmed whitebeard, that is definitely not enough to scale. I'm talking about the dudes who can harm kaido like luffy did or the way oden did.
Fodder marines harmed WhiteBeard after he was dying. WB just a few years before was a tank.
Can you please tell me why the ace novel is canon?
Oda supervised it, the author used his notes for it, officially published by Shueisha, etc.

IMG_3293.jpg
 
This is some basic headass crack scaling.

Oden did not say “nobody can beat him but me”. He said “If I can’t beat him, nobody here can”.
Kaido isn’t strong because of his AP only, he’s strong because of his stamina.
Everyone is acting like Luffy and Kaidou are Zeus and Chronos when Kaido is known to be a stamina tank, not an AP god

Hell no

How in the hell does Marco scale to Dragon Kaido.
How in the hell is young dragon Kaido superior to current base Kaido.
Base Kaidou has nothing that puts him above WhiteBeard with his DF.

Marco couldn’t put down Akainu with help. WhiteBeard 2 shot him.

Haki being a factor isn’t even realistic. “Stronger Haki puts him higher on the ladder” you know how Haki works?
WB without Haki has better feats than Marco with Haki.

Marco is not on that level.

Says who?

Says who?

“Better hax” lasers and a light form?

Law has the best hax in the verse and he’s not even top 5 on your list.

This is crack.

King scales to Zoro? Yes. Does King scale to Zoro with ridiculous Enma usage? Hell no.

Zoro and King have no scaling at all to Law and Kid. Kid 1v1’d big mom. Putting those guys there is hilarious.

Killer is comparable to Zoro and they both cut base Kaido alongside each other.


While tired and holding up an island.
This is like comparing G2nd Luffy to Doflamingo while Doffy was holding up the birdcage and fighting Law at the same time after several fatal injuries

“Got clapped silly” you definitely don’t read one piece.
Shiki fought them so well to the point where even the narrator said Marineford was destroyed before they could put him down.

Rocks is stated to be Roger’s strongest foe.
That means he’s above Shiki, WhiteBeard, Chinjao, and many more.
WhiteBeard in his sick self is capable of fighting Kaidou. Those guys in their primes can fight Rocks.

You do know Kaidou is at the ends of his stamina?
Kaidou is weaker than he was beginning of the raid.
Luffy’s only having above an average chance right now cause Kaidou is at the ends of his stamina.

I’m praying you’re not saying Marco is blatantly stronger than Blackbeard.

Fodder marines harmed WhiteBeard after he was dying. WB just a few years before was a tank.

Oda supervised it, the author used his notes for it, officially published by Shueisha, etc.

IMG_3293.jpg
He literally did not say that. He stated verbatim "If I don't manage to knock down kaido, no one of our time will succeed". That clearly in ludes whitebeard.
Oh stop it, he's called "the strongest creature" not the "most stamina creature". I literally don't recall kaido ever being implied to be strong because of stamina, he's strong because he's strong.

Marco stopped kaido's boro breath and matched big mom with her homie and she's comparable to kaido.
That's a misunderstanding. It's current dragon kaido > young dragon kaido > young base kaido.
Prime conqueror oden > conqueror gura whitebeard. This means oden > Gura whitebeard. And young base kaido matched base oden.
Pre timeskip marco.
I brought haki up because marco and whitebeard scale to the roughly same level of AP but whitebeard has superior haki so he should win via regeneration negation.

Prime Rayleigh is physically the same as old rayleigh and his haki is already at it's best and hasn't declined, there's also no proof it did.
Don't bring up law he's unrelated. Kizaru's lazer durability negate people like whitebeard and has range while rayleigh doesn't.

Kidd only 1v1ed big mom with awakening which he can barely use without getting drained, normally he scales to base big mom who all the roof piece scale to. Zoro out of them all has the highest AP normally for cutting dragon kaido's scales. With enma and asura he scales above dragon kaido but those are 1 hit moves. Killer needed sound durability negation to harm kaido, he himself was surprised that zoro cut kaido's scales.

That doesn't affect his combat ability, only his flame clouds, and you just said kaido has insane stamina, he can be fatigued but he still hits just as hard.
Garp and sengoku weren't even hurt, and destroying marineford does not mean he put up a fight. The fight was off screen but he's above them because he's portrayed to rival roger but they're all nigh equal.
Rocks is unknown, I'd rather leave him off the list for now.

He's reached his limit against gear 5 luffy only, at that point he was actually on his knees huffing and puffing.
No I'm saying marco is stronger than he was before. Revenge war black beard is just a guess honestly.
Thanks.
 
Someone would disagree with this statement. Someone like say, Rayleigh
He says he could do more if it weren't for hus age, I interpret that as him saying he can last longer fighting and it's consistent with the statements of him being as strong as he was in his prime.
 
He literally did not say that. He stated verbatim "If I don't manage to knock down kaido, no one of our time will succeed". That clearly in ludes whitebeard.
That's the same thing
Oh stop it, he's called "the strongest creature" not the "most stamina creature". I literally don't recall kaido ever being implied to be strong because of stamina, he's strong because he's strong.
I quote the vivre cards
The Strongest Creature that wish for the destruction of this boring world, "Kaido of the Beasts"!!
7 defeats, 18 times held captive...tortured over a thousand times and executed 40 times, and suicide from jumping down from the height of 10000 meters. Due to his unmatched vitality, none can kill him. Kaido lose hope in this world.
This is why he's called the strongest creature.

"He's strong because he's strong".
His introduction doesn't even say anything about that. He's up there cause he can't be killed. Not because of battle power, but because he's damn near invulnerable.
Chapter 795. I recommend you read that.
Marco stopped kaido's boro breath and matched big mom with her homie and she's comparable to kaido.
Marco stopped Kaido's boro breath with a technique that is meant for high dura.
That is durability.
Jozu stopped Mihawk's slash, I'm not saying Jozu > Shanks.

He matched Big Mom with a single homie who was using no Haki of any type in his absolute strongest form. Let's get this down.
Marco's strongest form ~ Big Mom's weakest form
That's a misunderstanding. It's current dragon kaido > young dragon kaido > young base kaido.
Prime conqueror oden > conqueror gura whitebeard. This means oden > Gura whitebeard. And young base kaido matched base oden.
This is not true at all. Haoshoku has different levels, which is why base Luffy would get murdered by Hybrid Kaidou but Hao Luffy can match Hao Kaido.
Your scaling is based off of AP when Kaidou isn't even like that. Kaidou isn't implied to be the guy who can easily overpower other Yonko.
Pre timeskip marco.
Marco.
Did.
Not.
Get.
Stronger.
I brought haki up because marco and whitebeard scale to the roughly same level of AP but whitebeard has superior haki so he should win via regeneration negation.
Whitebeard is superior to him in every category other than durability.
Prime Rayleigh is physically the same as old rayleigh and his haki is already at it's best and hasn't declined, there's also no proof it did.
Prime Rayleigh physically being the same as a rusty Rayleigh is a crazy statement.

Haki is based on stamina. If you admit his stamina declined, then you admit his Haki declined.
Don't bring up law he's unrelated. Kizaru's lazer durability negate people like whitebeard and has range while rayleigh doesn't.
Dura neg feats are dogshit. It's dura neg for a reason.

You put him high because he has RANGE??? Are you serious?
Kidd only 1v1ed big mom with awakening which he can barely use without getting drained,
You didn't read Wano.

Before Law even showed up, Kid went and saved Nami and Usopp from Big Mom. They fought offscreen for several
normally he scales to base big mom who all the roof piece scale to.
He 1v1'd her with 3 homies for several chapters
Zoro out of them all has the highest AP normally for cutting dragon kaido's scales.
This is not normally. Idk who is feeding you this information but it's very wrong.
He was specifically using Enma with ridiculous haki the moment he cut Kaidou's scales. Kaidou said so.
With enma and asura he scales above dragon kaido but those are 1 hit moves. Killer needed sound durability negation to harm kaido, he himself was surprised that zoro cut kaido's scales.
Prior to hit dura neg, he cut base Kaidou alongside Zoro, which Kaidou applauded him for.
That doesn't affect his combat ability, only his flame clouds, and you just said kaido has insane stamina, he can be fatigued but he still hits just as hard.
Yamato blatantly said Kaidou is weakening.
Before that, Kaidou fought
8 scabbards and Izou, getting hurt by every single one of them,
Getting minorly incapacitated by 4 scabbards while seething in pain.
Fought 5 supernovas who are all capable of hurting him.
Fought Luffy in a 1v1.
Garp and sengoku weren't even hurt, and destroying marineford does not mean he put up a fight. The fight was off screen but he's above them because he's portrayed to rival roger but they're all nigh equal.
You can fight people without hurting them. Marco vs Big Mom. Oden vs Whitebeard.
Rocks is unknown, I'd rather leave him off the list for now.
I'd take a statement of "Roger's greatest foe".
He's reached his limit against gear 5 luffy only, at that point he was actually on his knees huffing and puffing.
The dude was already losing his grip to Luffy before he even pulled out gears in 1027.

He was already huffing and puffing back in 1010.
No I'm saying marco is stronger than he was before. Revenge war black beard is just a guess honestly.
Payback War Teach absolutely washed Marco, and that same Teach thinks of Kaidou as a dreaded monster.

You have this apparent claim that Marco was stronger than he was before the timeskip, which is ridiculously unproven.
Marco did not train.
Marco isn't one of those people who are implied to get stronger by doing nothing, because that's mainly for the young characters.
Marco didn't do anything of the sort to get stronger or weaker. He's still in his peak age.

Marco getting stronger is founded on absolutely nothing.
 
"Skull said that Kaidou had the highest sheer battle power out of all the Yonko he was aware of"

Checking Kaidou's profile again, I just realized this isn't listed in the source. Anyone know where this is stated?
 
That's the same thing
I quote the vivre cards
This is why he's called the strongest creature.

"He's strong because he's strong".
His introduction doesn't even say anything about that. He's up there cause he can't be killed. Not because of battle power, but because he's damn near invulnerable.
Chapter 795. I recommend you read that.
Marco stopped Kaido's boro breath with a technique that is meant for high dura.
That is durability.
Jozu stopped Mihawk's slash, I'm not saying Jozu > Shanks.

He matched Big Mom with a single homie who was using no Haki of any type in his absolute strongest form. Let's get this down.
Marco's strongest form ~ Big Mom's weakest form
This is not true at all. Haoshoku has different levels, which is why base Luffy would get murdered by Hybrid Kaidou but Hao Luffy can match Hao Kaido.
Your scaling is based off of AP when Kaidou isn't even like that. Kaidou isn't implied to be the guy who can easily overpower other Yonko.
Marco.
Did.
Not.
Get.
Stronger.
Whitebeard is superior to him in every category other than durability.
Prime Rayleigh physically being the same as a rusty Rayleigh is a crazy statement.

Haki is based on stamina. If you admit his stamina declined, then you admit his Haki declined.
Dura neg feats are dogshit. It's dura neg for a reason.

You put him high because he has RANGE??? Are you serious?
You didn't read Wano.

Before Law even showed up, Kid went and saved Nami and Usopp from Big Mom. They fought offscreen for several
He 1v1'd her with 3 homies for several chapters
This is not normally. Idk who is feeding you this information but it's very wrong.
He was specifically using Enma with ridiculous haki the moment he cut Kaidou's scales. Kaidou said so.
Prior to hit dura neg, he cut base Kaidou alongside Zoro, which Kaidou applauded him for.
Yamato blatantly said Kaidou is weakening.
Before that, Kaidou fought
8 scabbards and Izou, getting hurt by every single one of them,
Getting minorly incapacitated by 4 scabbards while seething in pain.
Fought 5 supernovas who are all capable of hurting him.
Fought Luffy in a 1v1.
You can fight people without hurting them. Marco vs Big Mom. Oden vs Whitebeard.
I'd take a statement of "Roger's greatest foe".
The dude was already losing his grip to Luffy before he even pulled out gears in 1027.

He was already huffing and puffing back in 1010.
Payback War Teach absolutely washed Marco, and that same Teach thinks of Kaidou as a dreaded monster.

You have this apparent claim that Marco was stronger than he was before the timeskip, which is ridiculously unproven.
Marco did not train.
Marco isn't one of those people who are implied to get stronger by doing nothing, because that's mainly for the young characters.
Marco didn't do anything of the sort to get stronger or weaker. He's still in his peak age.

Marco getting stronger is founded on absolutely nothing.
It's literally not. He's specifying their era, and emphasizing later that the pirates who will appear 20 years later are the ones who will beat kaido.

Cool. Not only does he have insane vitality, he's also the physiaclly strongest character too. What is this point even? He can harm fight those who can harm him so it'd still scale to his AP.

Marco stopped the attack the same way he stopped kizaru's attack which he actually scales to. He's also capable to harming those who can harm him. And that's not true, big mom was using her homie which is above her own AP, this is a higher caliber than what the roof piece are capable of.

Haoshoku does seem to have different levels, you gave a valid point. I was treating it as a static amp, shit I don't know how this affects the scaling but I feel like it makes it 1000x more confusing. But kaido has feats that put him above the other yonko in terms of AP.

That's impossible, he definitely got stronger, the feats he performed in wano couldn't be done by him in marine ford.

I changed their spots.

Crazy in your opinion. How? Haki is based on spiritual power, that's what your haki page says. How come it's tied to stamina? Characters can run out of busoshoku and not die. This isn't ki this is haki bro.

This list is based off who'd win in a fight, these things do matter.

So how do you know what happened if they fought off screen? You're gonna scale kidd to big mom because of an event we have no idea how it took place? They could've fought without kidd scaling to her max power, and he already scales to her base and homies.

Okay that's actually fair. Zoro is not normally that strong.

That scales to base kaido so not different from what I already scale them to.

okay that statement is fair, but it wouldn't change her ranking any drastically. She would be at the same level as oden.

So he didn't hurt them okay so why should he scale above them drastically like that? Seems like he did indeed just get clapped.

Oh but he had definitely not reached his limit and was still fighting at near max power. He was only at the ends of his stamina when he got on his knees against gear 5 luffy.

Of course teach would be scared of kaido if his best feat is clapping pre time skip marco. Marco literally has better feats after the time skip, just how do you explain that?
 
Here's my take:

1. Prime Roger
2. Prime Whitebeard
3. Prime Garp
4. Kaido
5. Shiki
6. G5 Luffy
7. Mihawk & Shanks
8. Sakazuki
9. Kuzan
10. Big Mom
11. Blackbeard
12. Oden
13. Prime Sengoku
14. Kizaru
15. Prime Rayleigh
16. Fujitora
17. Yamato
18. Law & Kidd
19. Zoro
20. Marco


Some placements are based of speculations (especially about some admirals i mentioned like Fuji who's feats are casual) i didn't include Rocks for now since we dont know anything about his power and abilities.
 
Last edited:
Here's my take:

1. Prime Roger
2. Prime Whitebeard
3. Prime Garp
4. Kaido
5. Shiki
6. G5 Luffy
7. Mihawk
8. Sakazuki
9. Kuzan
10. Big Mom
11. Blackbeard
12. Oden
13. Prime Sengoku
14. Kizaru
15. Prime Rayleigh
16. Yamato
17. Law/Kidd
18. Zoro
19. Marco
20. King


Some placements are based of speculations (especially about some admirals i mentioned like Fuji who's feats are casual) i didn't include Rocks for now since we dont know anything about his power and abilities.
Shiki above Luffy makes me wanna hurl
 
List for me, Joyboy, Benbeckman (and most of RH pirates), Imu, Greenbull, Blackbeard and Dragon are exempted because they are too vague to scale especially right now.

1) Rocks. D Xebec
2) Prime Roger = Prime Whitebeard
4) Monkey D. Luffy
5) Kaidou
6) Prime Shiki
7) Prime Garp
8) Shanks
9) Mihawk
10) Big Mom
11) Akainu
12) Prime Sengoku
13) Prime Oden
14) Prime Rayleigh
15) Kizaru
16) Aokiji
17) Fujitora
18) Law
19) Kidd
20) Zoro
21) Yamato
22) Marco
23) Sanji
24) Katakuri
25) King
26) Queen / Smoothie
27) Denjiro
28) Sulong Inu / Neko
29) Jack / Cracker
30) Doflamingo
 
List for me, Joyboy, Benbeckman (and most of RH pirates), Imu, Greenbull, Blackbeard and Dragon are exempted because they are too vague to scale especially right now.

1) Rocks. D Xebec
2) Prime Roger = Prime Whitebeard
4) Monkey D. Luffy
5) Kaidou
6) Prime Shiki
7) Prime Garp
8) Shanks
9) Mihawk
10) Big Mom
11) Akainu
12) Prime Sengoku
13) Prime Oden
14) Prime Rayleigh
15) Kizaru
16) Aokiji
17) Fujitora
18) Law
19) Kidd
20) Zoro
21) Yamato
22) Marco
23) Sanji
24) Katakuri
25) King
26) Queen / Smoothie
27) Denjiro
28) Sulong Inu / Neko
29) Jack / Cracker
30) Doflamingo
Good job
 
Back
Top