- 39,653
- 15,560
Well that just my guess since this Van Gogh are either Wilhelmina or Johanna, not the actual Vincent himself
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
For those who cant access reddit.WARNING : Including A LOT OF lores/spoilers of ~ Lostbelt 5 and Imaginary Scramble’s story (November 14th), so anyone who’s planning to fully enjoy the story PLZ WAIT FOR THE TRANSLATORS.
WARNING 2 : Since the event story is still not finished all of the info here are tentative to changes.
Source : 閑話3 (Secret Story 3)、第4幕 潮解する怪理(3/3)
About “Outer Gods”
About the Foreigner class
- Per Gilles Caster’s lecture, our newly introduced lore professor, there are 7 noteworthy characteristics about them
- 1. Absurdly large, GROSS and strong
- 2. Do not abide by physical or magical laws and thus making them normally impossible to interact or communicate with
- (IMPORTANT) 3. They claim themselves of “the rightful ownership of the planet earth” and as “the creator (written as “inventor” in the original Japanese text) of earth’s lifeforms”
- ...Isn’t there a familiar looking face claiming themselves as “the president of the earth” while dressing and acting like Kim-Jong-Un???
- Yep, according to this theory of Gilles all lifeforms, including humanity, are created/developed by these eldritch beings. BRETHREN MOON IS THAT YOU?
- 4. If we somehow decide to abide by their demands and leave the earth in their care, well, no one knows what exactly will happen but it’ll definitely become a VERY BAD NEW.
- (IMPORTANT) 5. Most of them are currently sealed.
- Maybe it’s time for me to reread EoR4. I suspect that I might find a lead that could tell me why the outer gods start appearing in FGO’s universe in the first place ‘cause I already forgot most details of this chapter…
- (IMPORTANT) 6. While they mostly act independently, some are allying themselves to other(s). Hostile relationships among them are also present.
- (IMPORTANT) 7. They are not conceptually invincible/immortal. They simply possess flesh bodies. The true nature of substances that made up their bodies are simply too incomprehensible/alien for us. That’s why they are TECHNICALLY KILLABLE AND possess LIMITED LIFESPAN.
About Van Gogh
- Gilles’ statement again, he thinks that, rather than describing them as a “priestess”, a “vessel”, an “avatar” or a “replica” of the gods, it’s more accurate to identify them as “(Anti) Hero”.
- Outer gods can only interfere with our world using “Throne of Heroes”. And using himself as an example, he tells us that madness and vice will eventually give birth to terrifying legends and eventually, Anti-Heroic Spirits like himself or Medusa etc.
- And Foreigners are in fact infancy Anti-Heroic Spirits, individuals who are on the process of getting engraved to the throne as Anti-Heroes. So basically outer gods exploit the birthing process of an Anti-Hero to create a proxy for themselves to interact with our world.…Isn’t there a certain being who has modified THREE heroic spirits saint graph to act as their emissaries…? (Their class aren’t foreigners though)
- BTW Gilles was totally silent and had no comment when asked about “Then what’s about her (XX)?” by Sion (LOL)
- All of the infobits here come from Xiang Yu’s predictions + Nemo’s and Skadi’s speculations so it’s still tentative atm (but imo they are almost 100% certain)
- There is an outer god who’s planning to invade our world through Imaginary Number Space. This being planned to use INS as it’s base of operations and some foreigners as it’s lackeys. So first they searched for an individual heroic spirit with suitable property/abilities to remodel IMS as the god’s new HQ for invading the earth. One of it’s required target is Hokusai since she has the potential to reshape INS and enable it to interact with our world (since our world is “real number”, which makes it theoretically impossible for INS to interact with us, in normal cases). However the problem is that Hokusai has the skill “Father-Daughter Bond” which prevents the corruption/maddening effect of the outer god from spreading, and her “Item Contruction” rank is also too low to enable her to reshape INS to fit the outer god’s objective.
- That problem lead the god to shift it’s first priority towards Vincent Van Gogh, an artist who was approached by an outer god through his artworks. Not only that he’s one of the Foreigner who can live within INS without any help, his NP as an heroic spirit “De Sterrennacht (The Starry Night” also has the ability to modify and enhance Foreigners, and also forcefully “deific” them (deification of a Foreigner = amplifying the intensity of their “Insanity” skill, ascending their Saint Graph and making them closer to the outer god they represent).
- With this reason Vincent became an essential part for it’s invasion plan but the problem is Vincent was a brave and noble individual who denies and rejects the approach of the outer god until the end of his life (his suicide in FGO is interpreted as his final attempt to not fall under the god’s influence). These traits of “absolute denial of any outer god” and “I will definitely suicide if I see any prospect of myself getting controlled by an outer god” is deeply engraved in his Spirit Origin’s record in the throne so he won’t succumb to the outer god’s control and use his NP for his sake even if he was summoned normally…
- This forced the outer god to improvise Vincent and artificially fused him with another Heroic Spirit, Cyltia, the water nymph daughter of Oceanus and Tethys in Greek Mythology. She faced with immense sadness and regret after Helios rejected her “but she didn’t suicide=refused to die” and instead turned into a heliotrope, which would become a modern day Sunflower. By utilizing Vincent’s strong connection with Sunflowers and their similar personalities (Vincent’s depression and Cyltia’s broken love), the outer god managed to successfully “stitch” them together : The newly made Foreigner has the memory and abilities from Vincent Van Gogh but was also implanted with many significant traits from Cyltia, including her personality, motif as a sunflower (hence her strong emphasis on the flower in both 1st and 2nd ascension and her jumpscare flower-face) and also her divinity.
- While surely Vincent’s memory won’t allow the servant to submit without question it certainly softened the resistance, allow it to exploit Vincent’s ability to some extent, the more important thing that this fusion managed to achieve is the trait of Cyltia, “refusal to suicide” was successfully implanted. Therefore it guaranteed that the new servant won’t be able to suicide even if the Vincent’s part of her strongly urges her to do so.
- As a bonus, since Vincent is also a huge Hokusai’s weeb the outer god exploited this connection to “call” Hokusai to the INS, and put her under the influence of Gogh’s NP. After hearing the “call” and receiving the effect of the NP (around the moment she approached Guda in the prologue of this event), her Item Contruction rank got increased dramatically while her “Father-Daughter Bond” was also severely weakened (signifying as Toto-sama being rendered completely catatonic for the entire period of Oei being under the NP’s effect). This started the process of slowly corrupting her into the outer god’s lackey, granted her the ability to modify INS to suit the god’s objectives, and also the ability to perfectly infiltrate Nautilus by morphing into one of the Nemo Marines.
- The servant Van Gogh (in the story they called her “Cyltia=Van Gogh” so I’ll called her “C=Gogh” from now on) regular showing of symptoms of depression, bipolar, uncontrollable giggles (reminds me of Joaquin Phoenix’s Joker), self-loathe and self-harm tendencies are the result of her personality, identity and existential crisis that stems from the constant clash between the elements of Vincent and Cyltia within her. This is why she and Frankenstein feel strong similarity between them : they’re both pathetic abominations forcefully stitched together by a horrid experiment. While Fran, per her own statement, has already fulfilled her wish by being together with her “Papa”, “Babbage”, Chaldean’s crews and Guda (she initially seeked an individual to be her soulmate (Adam) but later found that being together with these people also satisfied her), C=Gogh obviously still can’t get over her issues and accept herself like Fran did. This is why Fran immediately sympathized with and opened up to her when they first met.
- In a sense C=Gogh’s existence is quite similar to Nemo, Moriarty and Hessian Lobo that all of them are fused existences who are closer to “Phantoms” than a heroic spirit. However unlike the other Phantoms the clash and friction between her fusion materials are so intense thanks to her creator’s complete lack of concern towards her well-being, resulted in this sad girl who is constantly tormented by severe mental issues.
Edit: Added infos
About the credibility of Gilles' statements regarding Outer Gods
- Per his own admission, the 7 points about Outer Gods I wrote in this post were only results from him tapping into the unknown (thanks to his Prelati's Spellbook) "only for a little bit". And he couldn't accurately describe these points to DaVinci and Sion either, so he chose to simplify them instead. Yes, these points I posted are the already oversimplified versions (and thus are NOT 100% accurate. Don't believe these stuffs to every letter). Basically every bit of info we've gotten about Outer Gods up until now was all from 2nd hand sources so take them with a grain of salt. Let's hope that we will have a chance to confront an Outer God directly in the future so that we can get more concrete info about them
Normally any stuff relating to Outer Gods aren't supposed to be comprehensible to any being originated from the earth so Gilles couldn't just delve into the abyss of eldritch beings carelessly because even him will get consumed by madness from witnessing things that men ain't suppose to look at.
Looks so coolThis is just a really badass poster
New Info from today (Nov 15th) event story
- There’s still an epilogue on Nov 18th left so this info is still tentative
The identity of Gogh’s host/creator
- In game boss name : “The Outer God of Flower” (花の邪神). It’s the big green Ifrit Foreigner class boss.
- Skills name :
- “Thousand Years Slumber” (千年の眠り)
- “Sleep”-Induction skill on self and applying a 2-turns delayed “sleep” onto a target that attacked it.
- “Thousand Years Insanity” (千年の狂気)
- “Allure of the Fairy” (妖精の誘惑)
- Instant “Charm” with a ton of offensive debuffs
- “Fleeting Form” (仮初めの実像)
- It’s plan, after it finished it’s descent onto Imaginary Number Space, was to put us into a “thousand years slumber” while making us to experience a “pleasant dream” without any physical harm to us (Pretty similar to Summer BB’s plan…).
- In 閑話2 (Secret Talk 2), the reason Gilles came to speak up with Sion and DaVinci in the first place is that he had a “premonition” that “Two stars that are besides Mars are shining violently in dark green” —signifying that there’s an upcoming invasion from an outer god.
- I haven’t read a single piece of Lovecraftian work so I don’t have any confidence on my own speculation but I think that the identity of the god is “Vulthoom”, not the color as many might expect. (https://lovecraft.fandom.com/wiki/Vulthoom ; https://lovecraft.fandom.com/wiki/Aihai)
- The initial plan of it was of course to abuse Hokusai’s abilities. If Oei wasn’t restored to her sense in time she would eventually turned INS into a “shrine” that will welcome it’s descent.
- However we rendered the plan moot by detecting that Oei was hiding in and infiltrating our ship, trying her best to trap us here and buy time for her evolution to completely deify her.
- With this the god was forced into using it’s contingency plan : Activating a fail-safe program that will override Gogh’s personality, isolate her and forcing her to undergo the process of turning into a suitable vessel for it’s descent. If the descent is complete then it’ll ofc have control over Gogh’s NP and can use it without any restriction to brainwash and modify other Foreigners (mainly Hokusai for her abilities to modify INS to become it’s new HQ). The risk is of course, it needs to openly declare it’s presence as the enemy so it’s enemies (Chaldean) will surely try to sabotage it’s descent.
Screenshots of the scenes/dialogues I extracted my info from :
WARNING : This is basically SPOILERS OF EVERYTHING IN THIS EVENT so proceed with cautions.
WARNING2: Discussions in the comment section may easily include spoilers FROM THE OTHER TYPE-MOON WORKS (especially the ongoing ones). In my previous thread someone surprisingly didn't know about this and actually caused a little fight to happen, make sure that you don't do the same silly mistake.
About what actually happened in the event
- Gogh’s deity (let’s assume that it’s actually Vulthoom) dragged us into the dream world that this event happens (hence the reason why masters who only finished Lostbelt 1 (= far before we actually meet Sion and Nemo, let alone the completion of Nautilus) can participate in this story). Gogh then called out to Hokusai and altered her Saint Graph to make her susceptible to becoming a proxy/vessel for her own outer god (Cthulu). The now insane Hokusai then infiltrated Nautilus and used her ability to repaint Imaginary Number Space onto a suitable ground for outer gods to collect/farm their “eldritch power” (can be obtained by feeding on fears and madness, much like how Pennywise does in the IT series, but for Hokusai case only, she can also farm this power by the continued usage of her repainting power). Vulthoom, through Gogh, then sought out cooperation from Cthulu but got refused (it thought that, with Gogh’s NP modifying Hokusai and both of them (kinda) belonging to the same faction of the outer gods, the propose of alliance would succeed and they could’ve farmed/collected “eldritch power” and descended together). With no other option left Vulthoom was forced into trying to collect the “eldritch power” and descend before Cthulu manages to do so, and that’s why it sent Gogh to infiltrate our ship, not only to sabotage and delay Hokusai/Cthulu’s progress, but also since the only source of “eldritch power” left for Vulthoom were fears and madness of Nautilus crew so it can’t afford to let us die until it can fully descend.
- However another unexpected event happened : the summoning of Yang Guifei, a proxy for another god (prob 99% Cthugha at this point). She took advantage of the vacant seat in the summoning, interrupted it and enabled herself to be summoned, thus becoming another participant in the “eldritch power” farming/grinding race. Similar as Vulthoom’s case, she must rely on Nautilus’s crews to farm so she allied herself with us and became Guda’s temporary servant (in fact, she can ignore the effect of command spells at any time so she doesn’t have to worry about Guda using them to stop her after she reveals herself and betrays them). With no one noticing (including the other two gods’ factions), she continued posing as Nautilus’ ally and had been secretly waiting for her chance to strike…
- After that we managed to expose and neutralize Hokusai immediately, effectively removing Cthulu from the race. Vulthoom’s victory seems to be certain at this point but, not so surprising, we also managed to expose it too and forced it to immediately begin the descent (despite the fact that the amount of “eldritch power” collected wasn’t yet enough for it to immediately descend to it’s true form). Thanks to it’s power still being pretty far from the optimal condition, we managed to take it down too.
- We then tried to get out from INS and go back to Chaldea, using Gogh’s ability to assimilate the remnant of powers left floating in INS after all the fightings and condense them into a holy grail, and use it’s power to undo the rewriting/modification of INS back to it’s original state. This is the chance that Yang had been waiting for, she snatched the grail and forced us (as the master) to command her onto using the grail’s wish for her goal. She managed to do this through those creepy cursed dolls she gave to us, Nemo Marines and Bakery. Her wish was to summon as many female foreigners as possible here to initiate her “Grand Foreigner Festival”, a battle royale among foreigners (including herself) to consume each others, gain more powers and grasp the chance of world domination. With the power of the grail she forcefully woke up the negative aspects of every Foreigner’s personality, enhanced them alongside their insanity, effectively turned them hostile and forced them to become the participants. This “Grand Foreigner Festival” was, for Yang, a “rear palace” (the building where concubines of Chinese emperors reside ; the royal harem) for Guda, since she came to saw him as “my beloved emperor” (much like how Kiyo sees us as her Anchin-sama). All of Guda brave actions she saw and their natural charisma made her into believing that they’re her beloved emperor. This delusion was actually the side effect from all of those “eldritch powers” that she had been collecting : It accidentally magnified her Insanity passive.
- Actually Yang could’ve just used the power from the grail to complete the descent of Cthugha right then and there and grilled everyone into teriyakis but the delusion stated above caused her to add the totally unnecessary step of “Grand Foreigner Festival” and basically **** Cthugha’s plan up to the point of no return just by giving us the chance to counter attack.
- Thanks to the now insane Yang completely trolling herself and her god, we got the chance to retaliate and potentially save everyone. It was even luckier for us since Gogh wasn’t affected by Yang’s usage of grail : the incomplete Vulthoom we destroyed there was, in fact, the “proxy/receiver” part of Gogh that physically separated itself from her to proceed with it’s plan of descending into Vulthoom (since obviously doing it without any mental resistance from Gogh was the surest and fastest way for it, and it totally believed that it’s power by that point was more than enough to take us on). With the proxy/receiver part inside her gone, she’s now much less prone to descend into uncontrollable insanity and the influence of the outer gods on her is also greatly weakened so she managed to shrug off Yang’s mental modification.
- Skadi proposed that we used Gogh’s NP to surgically remove the “proxy/receiver” part from every foreigner too since, without the influence/direction from Vulthoom, she should have much more control over it’s effect. We then proceeded to defeat all of the mind-controlled foreigners and turned them back to their usual selves thanks to this.
- Of course we also tried to expel Cthugha’s influence on Yang and turned her back to good too but, unfortunately, 90% of her saint graph has already been modified and corrupted so it was not possible to remove only the outer god parts without destroying her existence. With all hopes gone and we seemingly forced into a situation where we must kill Yang, Wu Zetian proposed an idea of doing a temporary fusion dance with both Fran and Gogh to use the latter’s NP (if Wu only fuses with Gogh her nature as a foreigner will crush Wu’s sanity so having Fran, a similar existence to Gogh as a patched abomination, as a mediator was necessary). Wu is Yang’s grandmother-in-law so her usage of Gogh’s NP will naturally have much better effect on Yang. Even so, the most Wu managed to do was to impose a geas on Yang, “You’ll only be able to be with your beloved emperor (Guda) only if your human side continues to grow”. This was to make the 10% human side of Yang to gradually increase it’s influence and control over the 90% outer god side so when the time that it has grown enough we’ll be able to extract and remove it safely like how we did to the other foreigners.
- Afterward we then succeeded in opening an exit from the INS. But during the time of departure, we suddenly fell asleep and this was the time when Gogh reveals that this was actually a dream. While the content of Vulthoom’s plan is still the same as stated above, the method it used to contact us in the first place was our dream (Vulthoom used it’s power to make all events in this dream “real”), somewhat similar how Douman pulled us to Shimousa (makes sense due to Vulthoom’s heavy association with sleeps and dreams). Gogh then tells her goodbye to us, thanking us for freeing and saving her and said that she’ll wait for the day we can meet again here, at INS, “the reverse side of the world” before giving us one final handshake…or so.
Gogh :
“For the last thing, let me give you one final handshake…”
“…wai- what!? My tentacle!? IT'S STUCK! I CAN’T PULL IT OUT!”
“WAI- NOOOOOOOOooooooo………” (and that final scene you saw happens, she got herself accidentally dragged with us back to the real world’s Chaldea LOL)
- Just before our return to the real world, BB (on the moon) was alert of the already weakened and suppressed outer god’s side of Yang and dragged her to the moon. She then used the power of the moon’s grail (Moon Cell?) to extract ONLY the human/rational side of Yang to basically, well interrogate her and she spilled out everything stated above (except the “actually this event was a dream” part). BB said that she learnt many valuable lessons from this incident and that her plan will succeed. She then said that “let’s meet again at the time of swimsuits on the next year”, heavily indicating that BB will eventually receive another form. Nyarlathotep BB is apparently not the final nightmare we’ll have to face…
How Yang came to be a foreigner
- Apparently Yang wasn’t a person who showed any interest or insanity that made her to contact with an outer god in the first place. But Xiang Yu speculated that, from the fact that “her body went missing”, after her death implied that it was stolen and the outer god modified her to change her immense love and loyalty towards her emperor into her worship towards the outer god (before she went further into insanity and started seeing Guda as her beloved emperor, she had been believing that her beloved emperor “is on Fomalhaut”). So in the other word, she’s a successful attempt of modifying/recreating a servant into a proxy/vessel for an outer god, quite unlike Gogh’s case.
- After she was sent back from the moon by BB, her memory about this event disappeared (but the geas is still intact) so this explains her attitude towards Guda when summoned onto Chaldea.
The foreshadow that indicates the possibility the real Vincent Van Gogh will be implemented eventually
- Actually, Vincent has another NP “Portrait of Père Tanguy”which is stated to be unusable by “The 「Foreigner」 Clytie Van Gogh” since this is a NP of the “rather pure and innocent” side of Vincent Van Gogh, an ability which is unadulterated by the influence of outer gods. Mashu said this word out, she thought that this was the “another NP” that Clytie Van Gogh used to buff Frankenstein during the fight with Vulthoom. The first time Gogh used her NP to save herself, Mashu, Raikou and Yang and bring all of them back to Nautilus safely, everyone forgot what her NP really was but Yang said to Guda and Mashu that she remembered that it was named “Portrait of Père Tanguy” : This is the reason why Mashu misunderstood this as Gogh’s alternate NP. The moment Gogh denied this being her NP was exactly the moment we realized, albeit too late, that Yang has been, in fact, a traitor all along.
- The word “rather pure and innocent side” was clearly highlighted in the actual scene. So the possibility of us eventually having the real Van Gogh in the future is pretty high IMO. → This one : https://imgur.com/a/nY2g2PT
- EDITED 2 : The reason I speculated that there'll definitely be AT LEAST 1 another story about Foreigners is from Gilles' premonition (Screenshots : ) (again, Prof. Gilles has been doing A LOT of works here lately). He said about outer gods who are associated with the planet Mars, Hokusai's patron deity AND IT'S OTHER 2 SIBLINGS.Hokusai's patron is currently having an enmity with it's brother (if the patron is actually Cthulu then is this "brother" Hastur?). But the problem Gilles is worrying about is the other sibling, stated to be the "youngest sister", who's associated with Mars. The details of this deity is, comparing to her elder brothers, mostly unknown and that his premonition speculates that she's trying to be an arbitrator between her brothers, unites them together, form an alliance of triple eldritch deities and plans an invasion. At first I thought that the part "A binary stars that shines violently besides the mars" was a premonition connecting to Vulthoom (due to it's connection to the mars) but Gilles stated that this binary stars system is supposed to represent Hokusai's patron deity and it's brother homeland. He also mentioned Fomalhaut entirely separately from this topic so it's pretty clear that this premonition of the mars isn't about the story in this event.
- This should make an interesting plot development too : Vulthoom "tried" to form an alliance with Hokusai's patron but failed so it's plan got delayed, not to mention Cthugha's further intervention, and as a result, we're being given more space to counter attack and deal with them one by one. Even with this advantage on our side, plus we acquiring Gogh's NP to use on the second half of the event, we still only managed to survive "barely" through a lucky string of multiple events (for example, 1. Gogh's "Starry Nights", when used properly, is basically a hard counter to outer gods' descent upon foreigners 2. Yang's insanity became too unstable and ruined Cthugha's plan). Now if the next event is not "the gods contesting among each other" but "the gods banding together" instead, we'll need to have more reliable new allies to have any chance to survive, and that would be a perfect opportunity to implement the real Vincent, who should have more access to his abilities and would be obviously much more stable as a servant than Clytie (he would prob still be the depressed/gloomy person he was but at least he won't have any of identity crisis Clytie has).
"Actually XX-san has an outer god inside her..." but immediately followed by "...you still don't know ? it's a wicked god named C A P I T A L I S M.”
C A P I T A L I S M
That moment when a meme is actually very apt and accurate...Do I like posting Fate memes? Yes, yes I do.