Yeah, they're the video game characters that feel the most powerful, but for whatever reason, people were always skeptical of their stats.
Granted, back then, video game characters' stats were always looked at with a lot of skepticism; as a Final Fantasy fan (especially a Final Fantasy VII fan), you are probably very well aware of that. It's just that, while opinions shifted for most other series, the skeptism around Devil May Cry, Bayonetta, God of War, and Doom's stats never went away (well, Bayonetta's stats have been pretty well established with Bayonetta 3, so maybe not that series). Though, for whatever reason, God of War seems to get the most pushback. Maybe because it's the most popular?
That is true, and it was true even on this site. The days of the Devil May Cry universal upgrades will live in infamy (no joke, they went on for seven threads before they were concluded, and each thread was 500 posts long).