The person who wrote those arguments is not me for one. Anyway, it is a bit rude to bash people for having a different interpretation which is weird from your stance, don't you think? Especially when those people want nothing to do with vs battles nor they actively and aggressively want to change any rating here.
I mean doesn't the guy first bash the people in vsb telling that they're wanker lol. And it's not about having different interpretation, it's for not even trying to debate about it when other show the wrong thing in his interpretation.
I do apologise, but it is anything new for people to be bashing vsb? Reddit, comic vine, wattpad, and even deviantart and youtube do it. Heck even the fate reddit bashes us.
Meh, his deal. He told me to test the waters and find counter arguments, so i did it.
Doesn't change that if he bash people, shouldn't have problem that we bash him too. Even more when he try to counter argument made here by having his own interpretation tell on an another platforms lol (which are pretty bad for some of them)
Guilty as charged. But no, the plan was if most people here had accepted the idea only then i might had tried. And he just asked me to show the blog around.
Well we have nikkitch litteraly talk with his wife in throne of heroes so i mean it's pretty clear that their not just data in throne of heroes.
hence "inconsistent". The knights of the round didn't talk, gilles didn't meet jeanne etc...
Well could be just we don't have info about it
Except they all had regrets and wanted to meet someone (another hero) again.
The avatar don't have memory of the throne of heroes if i recall so this could help
Again, except when they do, that's what I call an inconsistency
I call it Nasuverse /s
Depends... Saber, for example, never really went to the Throne "truely", as she never actually died before accepting her wish wasn't a good idea?
It's explicitly said that the reason Saber has Invisible Air is to conceal her identity, that is, her sword, not even herself, is so identifiable people would know her by looking at it. They don't necessarily know the specific form of the vessel the servant is in though, cause if they knew it would be useless to call themselves by their class instead of proper name.
In FGO they have a Watsonian explanation for why they have the same memories - they have a "copy" of the Saint Graph of the servant as data. (Don't know if you've played the chinese lost belt, but this detail plays a part in one event there) It was in a computer before, in Chaldea, now it is a suitcase. This isn't a "true/normal" summon in a proper sense, though. Normally, you don't have the Saint Graph itself, so you can't exactly choose the "SPECIFIC" servant to be summoned, so normally it wouldn't be like that.
Yes, they very much are.
Knowing Plot Monk, she will probably want to build a temple or something besides the white house
time [...] it's more than a linear path
Worst case scenario we still have a 6-C feat from Arc that I think scales to servants
We are
Doesn't she go to Avalon in one of the versions? I remember the scene more than the context, her in Avalon.
The Tier 6 vs Tier 7 is basically a discussion of consistency, at least that's how I see it. Servants are displayed too ******* inconsistently in each written work, and adapations tend to then add even more inconsistency, that's why I think it's a legit discussion really. But Arc does do some nice things, specially in Tsuki Remake
If you don't trust me why don't you debate him then? Feel free to change his mind.
For what? I would like to remind you that people are free to have their own personal stance. What you see as enough to reach a higher tier may not be enough for another person. Having a different way of seeing things which is shared by like countless people outside of vs battles wikia isn't a cause for disappointment unless you think that anyone with a different opinion is wrong and only you are correct.
see my comment about the throne and heaven, both aren't mutually exclusive. Avalon is a place for both the living and the dead, but she clearly died in her case.
sooooooooooooo spoiler question, did eresh show up?
