- 5,122
- 2,627
The translations I looked up for the anime and manga just said Hashiras with no adjectives. Could you give a link?Yea, when Muzan visits he's like you killed 7 strong hashira.
That's just the Hashira Training for all corps members. Hashira Training for the hashira happens a few times yearly through Yoriichi doll being used and is kind of confirmed by Shinobu saying she can't participate in the Hashira Training this time due to crafting poison and revenge planning.
I'm not certain about him considering Gyutaro the true UM6, he just talked about him more because he had more expectations of him and had more potential which is true cuz he's stronger, skilled and more analytical making him more valuable in a battle while also thinking Daki was a hindrance in comparison to someone as strong as Gyutaro, so this wouldn't really suggest she's that weak, just weaker and less valuable than Gyutaro. I don't think Muzan would lie about her defeating 7 strong hashira as he makes other statements that are truthful, an example would be him stating she ate more humans as well as that she's more beautiful than anyone else which is true as she's the only one who can make a grown man faint based off her beautiful appearance. So he doesn't really lie to her here.
Hashira also need to be able to fight UM's as Giyu states that damaging and keeping up with a UM is a sign of being equal to hashira tier, a drunk retired Shinjuro is capable of blitzing Tanjiro who had previously kept up with a Muzan blood amped LM1. Urokodaki in a far older and retired state keeping up with a constantly growing in strength EOS Nezuko who had somewhat kept up with Hantengu, Kanae fighting Douma a few years back and deducing some of his abilities while also being stated more talented than Shinobu/implied stronger than Shinobu.
He just saw Rengoku man-handle Sanemi but he didn't saw the fight with the kizuki. I'm not even sure if he received information about which demon he actually fought. Also idk why Rengoku's father would matter. Either way, this is a far weaker version than MT Rengoku.
This is still kinda ignoring how Daki was still affected by Nezuko's BDA and it kind of makes it easier to decapitate. It would still tie back into the Gyokko argument. I don't think Tengen ever makes a comment on how she's not UM lvl after she gets healed. He just says weaker sister which is true as she's weaker than Gyutaro.
Muzan probably knows how strong she is but it's not like it matters as he doesn't promote Rui despite the guy being his favorite among all demons and him being the strongest LM at that time. The existence of blood battle also kind of goes against this.
Wasn't the Hashira Training a suggestion by Gyomei with the Hashiras accepting and implementing it? That would indicate it being a new idea, so if there was previously some sort of training involving all of the Hashira, then it presumably happened in a different form. I'm not sure what the exact meaning or wording in this case is supposed to be but what I do know is that any other instance of a Hashira Training hasn't been mentioned, described or shown in any of the material I've seen as far as I remember. Kotetsu hasn't acted like as if he has regularly seen a Hashira fight the Yoriichi Type Zero either. The possibility of Tengen and Rengoku having been involved in training together would kinda go against your idea of Tengen not knowing how strong Rengoku is.
It's less about Muzan outright lying to her and more him acting like as if he likes and respects her far more than he actually does. We also have Gyutaro saying that she killed seven Hashiras as well with him having killed fifteen, so there is no ambiguity here with the statements. Muzan says after Gyutaro and Daki's deaths that Gyutaro could have won if he fought without Daki and it does look like as if that's in fact right, so it's not just her being a hindrance in comparison but actually being a hindrance in Gyutaro's fight against the demon slayers.
Enmu has said that he wasn't able to go all out yet at the end and Tanjiro needed the Hinokami Kagura and Inosuke's help to behead him. Tanjiro only started managing to use the Hinokami Kagura for more than a short burst in the Entertainment District arc. When Tanjiro fought that decoy body he even wondered if Enmu was weaker than Rui. If Hashiras were automatically within the vicinity of an Upper Moon's level of power, then those who qualify would quite easily deal with Lower Moons they fight. Rengoku did struggle for a bit with his Lower Moon immediately before becoming a Hashira and then worked his way up until the fight against Akaza, so that alone shows that there is a bit of variance with Hashiras. It should also be noted that both Shinjuro and Urokodaki had their entire demon slayer careers behind them which they spent getting stronger and survived all that time unlike many others, so them being quite strong because of that is rather obvious independently of their retirement or current status. It should also be noted that it doesn't look like as if any of the Hashiras from the current generation fought Upper Moons prior to encountering them in the manga and you said that you think that Tengen lacks knowledge of how strong an Upper Moon is supposed to be. Since defeating Lower Moons qualifies you for becoming a Hashira keeping up with the superior Upper Moons in any capacity kinda qualifies you by default.
This is to emphasize how he got to know Rengoku and that we see clear indicators of their relationship developing and therefore them having spent time together which are factors which decrease the chance of Tengen not knowing how strong Rengoku is. We've seen with Giyu and Shinobu and also with Iguro and Sanemi that Hashira can end up working together in missions which is also a factor against the idea. There is also that armwrestling ranking list and us knowing that they've been involved in group activities like trying to make Giyu smile. We also got Extraordinary Perception that allows characters to sense how strong someone is to a certain extent on all of the Kimetsu no Yaiba profiles, so if Tengen failed to get any idea of Rengoku's strength despite all of that, then that would be kind of stupid.
Didn't Gyutaro heal her? Hantengu's emotions weren't exactly permanently weakened by Nezuko's fire and Daki said that her with Gyutaro's eye was her true power which would indicate that she was at least at that time in peak condition or close to it. I recall that Rui was weaker than he could have been due to giving his fake family their powers and strength, so his potential was kind of compromised compared to Enmu. The Blood Battle can allow demons to showcase more than raw power and allow them to display what they can do when pushed into a corner, so that wouldn't necessarily imply that Muzan is entirely passive in regards to the ranking of his demons and he has been shown to take action with recruiting to or expelling demons from the Kizuki.
Last edited: