• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Status
Not open for further replies.

GarrixianXD

University Enthusiast
Any/All
VS Battles
Joke Battles
Administrator
Content Moderator
Translation Helper
4,397
10,699
The title may shock you and before I get gleamed with controversial hate comments messages on this thread I hope you considerately read my proposal concisely.
Warning: spoilers alert! Obviously...

The Realm of Clouds is a realm created by Guizhong with a star of its own

Banner_2_Hidden_Palace_of_Guizang_Formula_Domains_Genshin_Impact.jpg

5b4ca7d47828ca4ba351f9fbe371262f_6829569188822355917.png


^^The first image is from the Domain "Voyage of the Sanguine Sky" which directly mentions the Realm of Clouds in its lore description.
The second image is from the Domain "Travels of the Moonlit Venture" which does not directly mention the Realm of Clouds however it's stated to be a separate abode correlating to the Realm of Clouds; not to mention its a domain subsequential to the Voyage of the Sanguine Sky which could be accessed at the same location in-game.
Edit: the second image is the Heavy-Karma Cavern which is also a sub-space created by adepti (I changed it because the previous image links weren't working).

(0:10 displays both Voyage of the Sanguine Sky and Travels of the Moonlit Venture could be accessed through the same portal as whether or not they're the same dimension it's up to a debate. However, judging by appearance they seem to be separate from one another but that's for later future threads to be discussed)

The Chinese term for the abode is 云海洞天 and the term 洞天(Eng: Dongtian or Grotto-heavens) defines a place residue by Gods or Xian in Chinese mythology which could support the assumption that Guizhong's realm is a separate domain with it's own space and time. The term 云海 translates to Sea of Clouds and it's often regarded as an abode for immortals who created and manipulated reality, space, and time in Chinese mythology. The human world is separate from the world of God (or Xian) transcendent above all mortal worlds as a whole in Chinese mythology, as to be able to access the Realm of the Gods, one must attain some source of Godly power in ways of unconventional means.

More explanation of the Chinese mythology proposed Cosmos here: https://weibo.com/7549409992/MrbCeCKoj
Full Article Translated:

When it comes to multidimensional and parallel universes, these seemingly lofty and sci-fi concepts are also reflected in Chinese mythological stories; For the relationship between time and space, we often use the metaphor of river to describe time and space (as the saying goes in Kawaguchi, the passage of time is like a river), using boats to represent the location of our own existence.

The most wonderful aspect of this metaphor lies in the macro perspective, where countless different rivers converge into the sea for the same purpose, but their flow velocity and direction are different in terms of time and space; As a human being, like a boat, it flows in time and space. Compared to humans, a boat does not move and the water flows for a long time. In short, it is the source of clarity and turbidity, the base of stillness and stillness that move, and the change of all things is where the Heavenly Way lies.

What changes will happen when the river encounters problems and the world is observed with a stationary boat? In Chinese mythological stories, there is a saying that there is a day in the sky and a year underground, which means that the flow of time in the immortal world and the human world is different. In the human world, there are also different places where time passes, and the most famous one is the story of Lankeshan.

In the volume of the Southern Dynasty's "Shuyi Ji", it is said: "During the Jin Dynasty, Wang Zhi was logging at Shishi Mountain in Xin'an County. When he saw several children playing chess, he sang, and the quality was heard. The boy used a substance to match the substance, such as a jujube pit, and the substance contained it, without feeling hungry. In an instant, the boy predicted, 'Why not go?' When the substance rose, he saw that the axe had rotted away, and once he returned, there was no one left

The general meaning is that while Wang Zhi was chopping wood at Shishi Mountain, he saw several boys playing chess. He looked for a while, and the boy asked why he didn't go back. He got up and found that the handle of the axe had already rotted. When he returned home, he found that time had passed for a long time, and even his contemporaries had disappeared. It's heartbreaking.


The Langke people are caused by the immobility of themselves and the constant flow of time in different regions. In this story, the descendants of Shishi Mountain are called Langke Mountain, which is the eighth cave of the Qingxia in the Book of Taoism. This means that Langke Mountain is the place of immortals, and the differences in time flow rates seem to be understandable.

We often refer to Dongtian and Fudi together, but in fact, these are two completely different places. Dongtian is similar to today's context where there is another Dongtian, which means' tong '.

In the Taoist "Kongtong Q&A", the thirtieth question is: "What is Dongtian?" The answer is: "Dongzhe Tongye. It is said that this place can connect with the spiritual energy of the heavenly gods

Dongtian is a different dimension.


Here, we can see that there is a passage to the dwelling place of immortals in the world, from which one can reach Dongtian, which means that the place where immortals reside is Dongtian; Blessed land, on the other hand, is a place where people live, allowing them to avoid disasters and misfortunes without departing from the realm of humanity.

According to the Taoist Kongtong Q&A, "31 asked: What is a blessed land? The answer was: Five disasters do not stain the blessed land. 32 asked: What are the five disasters? The answer was: water, drought, sword soldiers, locusts, plague."

In mythology and legend, there are 36 Cave Heavens and 72 Blessed Places. We can understand that Cave Heavens are multidimensional spaces that have already been cultivated and separated from the human world. Blessed Places are suitable places for people to cultivate and become immortals. The time-passing speed of Cave Heavens is faster than that of the human world, and the time-passing speed of Blessed Places is the same as that of the human world.



From the perspective of Lankeshan being a cave, it can be seen that this mountain can communicate with the fairyland. Wang Zhi is likely to have accidentally entered the fairyland, standing next to the fairyland with a faster time flow, so after watching the boy play chess for a while, more than a hundred years have passed. If he entered a blessed land, then there should be no difference in time.

This idea is also reflected in the legend of Dongfang Shuo. "Dongming Ji" said that Dongfang Shuo went out for several months when he was young and was beaten by his mother when he came home. After some time, he went out again. This time, Dongfang Shuo came back after a year. This time, his mother asked him where he had gone, Dongfang Shuo said, "When I come to the Purple Mud Sea, there is purple water and dirty clothes. I still pass through Yu Yuanjian and return in the morning. How long has it been?" It means that I went out in the morning and came back at noon. Why do you say that I have been away for a year? It can be seen from here that the place where Dongfang Shuo went should be the location of Dongtian, which is very similar to Lanke Mountain in terms of time passing.



Regarding the issue of the rate of time passing, "The Book of the Underworld" also states: "The Ghost Says Three Years, and the Human World Three Days." This means that in traditional concepts, the three realms of heaven, earth, and man are likely to be countless parallel worlds. The fairyland will have different time flow rates due to different locations. The fastest time in the fairyland is only a short time, and the human world will pass a hundred years; In the underworld, time flows slowly, and in the human world, hundreds of years have passed in the underworld.

Regarding the record of a blessed land, in the "Records of the Blessed Land," it is stated that "a top twelve blessed land is rich and has a long appearance, and its descendants are prosperous. The bottom thirty-six blessed land is poor and humble, and its punishment and illness are combined. A middle twenty-four blessed land is not always blessed, and its wealth and wealth are uncertain. Some may have children when they are young or may have multiple illnesses due to its ugliness. The cycle of gain and loss is repeated, and if a person accumulates and acts, they will not be promoted. If a person commits iniquity, they will fall

With so many dimensions, it's dazzling.

As the saying goes, the seventy-two blessed areas are headed by Mount Zhongnan. Of course, the blessed areas also have another meaning:

If a person accumulates actions, they will not be promoted, but if a person commits iniquity, they will fall

That is to say, the true blessing lies in the accumulation of good deeds by everyone. A place where people are diligent and friendly will become a blessing. If everyone wants to gain something for nothing and harm others, then this place will fall into hell.

Now I think everyone should be clear about the difference between Dongtian Fudi and multi-dimensional space. The ancients also had their views on time and space. Due to the limitations of the times, they expressed this understanding using the concept of Dongtian Fudi, which is different from modern scientific cognition.

Let's fantasize a bit more. Perhaps it's not the different flow rates of time that led to the legend of the Rotten Ke Man, but rather Wang Zhi, who was directly transported through time and space by a fairy boy a hundred years later. Perhaps time and space are just so magical. So, even if we live in the present, we often have a sense of time and space transition, like a sense of separation from another world.
http://img1.gamersky.com/image2020/09/20200919_fbw_221_13/image007.jpg (Lore description of Voyage to the Sanguine Sky)
此处乃是云海洞天。旧主归终研究机关之学时,收纳了这几些古旧邪物。仙人们则造洞天收纳

Translation: "This is the Realm of Clouds. Guizhong, its former ruler, acquired several ancient and evil artifacts during her research into mechanics. The adepti created this realm to contain them." (Credits to Genshin wiki)
https://jingyan.baidu.com/article/6079ad0e84289769fe86db7d.html (Lore description of Travels of the Moonlit Venture)
“迷宫之下竟然是一片水月洞天,方壶宝地。”

Translation: "Beneath the labyrinth lies the unexplored Moonlit Wonderland, a trove of pots and kettles." (Credits to Genshin wiki)
The full translation might not be completely accurate but I might as well trust AI anyway since I'm too lazy to translate it all by my own.

Other evidence of Genshin's cosmology consisting of pocket dimensions could be shown by the Serenitea Pot and the Plane of Euthymia.
UNIVERSAL ENERGY SYSTEM

The Universal Energy System of Genshin is elementary energy wielded by allogenes and adepti energy is a variant of the UES.

As stated by the messages shown above, Qiqi's ability all has the term "Adepti Energy" in it and adding to the fact that Qiqi is also an adepti, we can confirm that adeptal power is a type of energy part of the Universal Energy System of Genshin. Waijing is a method of sub-space creation that allows the user to create pocket dimensions out of their imagination.



Sub-Space Creation or Waijing (Chinese: 外景 Wàijǐng, "Outdoor Scene")[1] is an adeptal ability used to create small, autonomous pocket worlds through imagination.[2][1]

This ability was a blessing from Rex Lapis and has been used during troubling times for some brief respite.[3] Even though it is a powerful adeptal ability, it does have limitations: one cannot build a whole city inside, since it is not a true world.[4]

From the description above, we can conclude that Waijing is an adeptal ability and therefore functions through the harness of adeptal energy.

The doubts about the legitimacy of this ability based on the concept of it being "imaginary" and the realm itself is not supposed to be real. However, I'm not arguing for the destruction of its space and time but for the star contained in the realm.


The Serenitea Pot is a pocket dimension created through "Waijing", and all of the materials contained in the realm is all real and tangible despite the realm itself being "fake".


As we see from that section of the article, the Traveler can create furnishing materials out of resources harvested from Teyvat (which is Genshin's main world, therefore it's real).



The Traveler can stand, run, and pretty much move freely around the realm and interact with the tangible matter in the realm.

Logically speaking, all of the furnishing material inside of the realm can be inferred as "tangible" and for it to interact with the Earth inside the realm, the ground has to be tangible as well. Therefore, if the Earth is tangible then the star of the realm has to be tangible as well.

Another doubt is that the "star" within the realm isn't an actual star, but rather a light source which well... I don't have much to counteract with that. Many people would juxtapose the "sun" in the realm and the light source in Enkanomiya. However, if you watch closely many parts of Enkanomiya are quite dark compared to many well-lightened places on Earth not to mention the entire territory is underground.



And not even the entirety of Enkanomiya is lightened. So we can conclude that the light source in Enkanomiya isn't entirely the same as the "sun" in the sub-space pocket dimensions, visually speaking. Logically speaking, we wouldn't consider a star that lights up a planet not to be a star which also applies to this case, where the "sun" of the realm not being the size of a star is less likely.

The Plane of Euthymia
The Plane of Euthymia is a realm created by the pure consciousness of Raiden Ei. A plane is defined as a level or layer of existence, thought, or development. As the Plane of Euthymia is not accessible through conventional means and is separated from the real world by Raiden's consciousness, it's practical to regard it as a separate pocket dimension from Teyvat. Since the wiki already accepted the Plane of Euthymia having their space-time and concept there's no need to explain deeper to prove it's a pocket reality.

Realm of Consciousness
A realm of consciousness is a domain built on a person's consciousness which is separate from the world of Teyvat; however, events that occur within a realm of consciousness can affect the outside world. Little is known about how realms of consciousness work, and Yae Miko describes them as a "very abstract concept" surrounded by chaos (Credits to Genshin wiki). A realm of consciousness is a realm consisting of a person's consciousness and deemed as an abstract concept of itself; a set of space-time warped by the owner's memories and unable to be accessed by conventional means. Only be accessed via an entrance which takes on the form of its owner and the entrant must have some sort of special connection to its owner (As how Ei was able to preserve and oversee Makoto's realm of consciousness since Makoto trusted Ei because they're sisters). Or if the character is powerful enough with some sort of hax, could access it (As Dottore tried to access Nahida's realm of consciousness via the Akasha but failed since she closed off her mind at the right timing). Anyways, since the wiki also accepts the Realm of Consciousness as an abstract dimension with its entirety own concept then no further explanation is needed.

Samsara Incident Caused by Akasha Terminal
The Samsara Incident was orchestrated by Sumeru Academica and the Fatui by the exploitation of the Akasha Terminal. It trapped the entirety of Sumeru under an endless time loop within a pocket hex dimension of subconsciousness and we of dreams. The time loop lasted for entire days and repeated the Sabseruz festival as every incident and everyone's memories all reset after twenty-four hours. The reality was manipulated during the story quests covering the samara as it affected both space and time within the particular area and everything around it. Eventually in the end, everything was fluctuating within the hex and created goddamn madness across the entirety of Sumeru thanks to Il Dottore messing with the Akasha Terminal to warp the shit outta the entirety of Sumeru and everyone residing there. I don't want to get to any more spoilers so hopefully, my somewhat vague explanation was helpful to prove that the Akasha Terminal was capable of warping reality and every abstract concept (e.g. every person's realm of consciousness) within the hex.

^^See more here

Serenitea Pot
The Serenitea Pot is a teapot given to the Traveller by Madame Ping and it's stated to contain an entire realm inside it in it's lore description.
"仙人以「尘歌壶」为媒介,凭借仙力化出了此方洞天境地(通过小道具尘歌壶进入)。作为此方洞天的主人,旅行者可以用各种方式修整洞天的环境,将其变成自己喜欢的样子。"

Translation: "The immortals used the "Dust Song Pot" as a medium and used their immortal power to transform this cave realm (entered through the small path with the Dust Song Pot). As the owner of this cave, travellers can use various methods to decorate the environment of the cave and turn it into the way they like."

“从萍姥姥那里得到的茶壶。里面似乎别有洞天…”

Translation: "A teapot obtained from Madame Ping. There seems to be a whole realm within it..." (Credits to Genshin wiki)
^^https://wiki.biligame.com/ys/尘歌壶世界

Td;lr: Top-tier Genshin characters are proven and stated to be capable of manipulating space-time, realities, and abstract concepts such as the minds and consciousness of beings (Characters such as Raiden Shogun and Il Dottore should have Reality Warping and Type 3 Conceptual Manipulation on their profiles; resistances to Reality Warping and Type 3 Conceptual Manipulation for Nahida's profile). Guizhong and other Xian (adepti) created realms such as the Realm of the Clouds and Serenitea Pot with it being its own dimension with its day and night (further proven in-game, as night in the Serenitea Pot could be a day in Teyvat). The Serenitea Pot and Realm of Clouds have been shown to have their star system in those images displayed on top of the thread.

In conclusion, characters that scale on par or above the adepti should have their tier upgraded to Star level (4-C) being in the same league as Guizhong and Madame Ping (adepti who created pocket realities with a star system). All characters who'd shown feats or been stated to be capable of manipulating Realms of Consciousness; and/or created hexes which drive people's concepts into insanity should attain Reality Warping and Type 3 Conceptual Manipulation listed on their profiles(Raiden Shogun, the Traveler, and possibly Yae Miko). Resistances also apply if a character manages to resist perpetrators tampering with their Realm of Consciousness (Nahida).

Staff Tally

Agree (1): DarkDragonMedeus

Disagree (0):

Neutral (1):
Qawsedf234
 
Last edited:
This borders on the "at least doubtful", numerous feats and declarations of characters not being capable of continental feats, Ei fighting his robot for (500 years?) hundreds of years using his Musou barely had enough energy to "drying seas" (she spent all these years fighting with Musou, which is her strongest technique, fighting a copy of herself as strong as she is), Azhdaha and Zhonglu fighting with all their power in 1v1 and not having any statement at this leve, etc.
Realms are a tricky thing, in Genshin, because even as it is stated in this CRT, it is not known for sure how they work, there are no declarations that you need to have great power (elemental energy) or anything like that to create them, there is some concrete proof that the creation of pocket realities scale to AP?
 
Last edited:
Tubby: Just commit the image of the objects to memory and prepare the necessary materials...
Tubby: Then, simply release the thought from your mind and the object in the blueprint shall appear within this teapot.

Tubby: He said that even though Sub-Space Creation is a product of adeptal power, even that has its limits.
Tubby: This world is not a true one, after all. It provides merely a moment of brief respite from the mortal realm, not a means of escaping it entirely.

All objects are made from the person's mind, Adepts use an ability to create them, objects according to what is said above, are made of pure someone's "thought", they (subspaces and objects) are not created by elemental energy or something that is usable in a fight (AP), so this does not seem to be escalated to AP, since it does not use elemental energy
 
Last edited:
1. I totally disagree with AP, realms created by adepts use a specific skill, and don't scale to AP, it has nothing to do with elemental energy or anything that scales to AP.
2. I disagree with type 1 concepts, the planes of consciousness only exist if the consciousness of the person who created the plane exists, Makoto's plan for example only remained because his consciousness still existed in Musou, after his consciousness ceased to exist in Musou, his realm also ceased to exist, and objects from the realms that adepts create are likely to disappear after the owner's death, as they are made from the owner's thoughts.
3. I don't know if this really counts as "reality warping", a plane of consciousness only has one form (the "form" of the plane of consciousness is reflected in the owner, if I'm not mistaken, and is reflected in things like personality), and the interior of the plane of consciousness is reflected to the owner's memories, and I don't remember anyone changing the shape or interior of the plane of consciousness whenever they want and however they want, neither EI nor Makoto have feats to control their plans in this way.
4. If there's no feat of Ei, Makoto or Nahida controlling (changing) their plans however they want or whenever they want, I disagree with everything about this CRT.
 
Last edited:
I don't think most of their pocket dimensional are scale to their statistic
Especially guizhong who was not really strong god just like makoto plus it's doesn't have any timeframe so it could be calcable.
But i believe there is possibly tier 5? feats for god tier from this
A crystalline substance taken from a Primo Geovishap. Within it is contained the potential to become a dragon.
These dull crystals are precipitated within the bodies of vishaps sleeping in the mountains. Liyue folklore holds that they will gather power over many years, after which this crystal will, at last, replace their original heart, and the vishap will become a true dragon — one that can shake the mountains and split the earth.
Scalling from azdaha as vishap true dragon
 
I don't think most of their pocket dimensional are scale to their statistic
Especially guizhong who was not really strong god just like makoto plus it's doesn't have any timeframe so it could be calcable.
It is even written in the skill description that this does not scale to AP, nor the realms created by adeptis, nor the plane of consciousness.
But i believe there is possibly tier 5? feats for god tier from this
Scalling from azdaha as vishap true dragon
I don't think this scales to tier 5, I think at best island or island+ level (dividing the land is possibly just talking about e.g. making a "gully" in the land, since Azhdaha who is the king of dragons in his fight against Prime Morax did nothing at this level).
And this would only escalate to characters that we are pretty sure are stronger than dragons (like Prime morax) since dragons are some of the oldest and most powerful beings in Teyvat, it's not to say that they are on the same level as gods or monsters that the archons faced.
 
Last edited:
I don't think this scales to level 5, I think at best island or island+ level (dividing the land is possibly just talking about e.g. making a "gully" in the land, since Azhdaha who is the king of dragons in his fight against Prime Morax did nothing at this level).
What does it even mean about gully thing?
Calculating "split earth" Even taking context "earth" as lowball only liyue area already give roughly H6-A feats
And this would only escalate to characters that we are pretty sure are stronger than dragons (like Prime morax) since dragons are some of the oldest and most powerful beings in Teyvat, it's not to say that they are on the same level as gods or monsters that the archons faced.
It doesn't directly said azdaha. It said about vishap race when they evolving to true dragon, but it also scale to azdaha, due azdaha also counted as true dragon. It scale to all archon atleast at their prime (except nahida)
 
What does it even mean about gully thing?
Calculating "split earth" Even taking context "earth" as lowball only liyue area already give roughly H6-A feats
Dude, there is nothing that proves that with "earth" you are talking about all of Lyue, let alone all of Teyvat, and that's why the calculation of dragons is more complicated, saying that dragons are tier 5 would be the same thing as saying that the fight between Azhdaha and Morax would destroy all of Teyvat, I'm sure the planet would have been destroyed a long time ago if the true dragons scaled to tier 5, first you have to know better the area where the dragons were.
It doesn't directly said azdaha. It said about vishap race when they evolving to true dragon, but it also scale to azdaha, due azdaha also counted as true dragon. It scale to all archon atleast at their prime (except nahida)
I'm also not specifically mentioning Azhdaha, but dragons in general.
Dragons are one of the oldest and most powerful beings in Teyvat, Azhdaha apparently being older than the mountains of Teyvat.
Nobody scales for dragons, unless beings who have faced them or are shown to be superior to them because dragons are extremely powerful and ancient, dragons are not "archon level" or "god level" (due to the fact that they are one of the most powerful and ancient beings in Teyvat, and we have few cases of beings facing dragons, they cannot scale to something specific, they draw their power from the realm of light, they do not have a specific scale like "level god" or "archon level"), almost no character besides Morax has faced a dragon .
 
That calc is outdated, the new “pocket realm containing a sun” calc can be found on the References for Common Feats page at 4-C.
Oh, aight well thanks
Makoto’s realm of consciousness was listed with Raiden’s ability to warp pocket dimensions so I’d just assumed however if they took the Realm of Consciousness being abstract into detail I have no idea (it should be anyways as it was stated by Yae Miko).
I don't think most of their pocket dimensional are scale to their statistic
Especially guizhong who was not really strong god just like makoto plus it's doesn't have any timeframe so it could be calcable.
But i believe there is possibly tier 5? feats for god tier from this

Scalling from azdaha as vishap true dragon
that’ll only scale to island level at best, far from planetary. It’s been stated those realms were created by adepti including Guizhong. And your assertion about Guizhong “not being a strong adepti” wouldn’t debunk the possibility of her being star level.
This borders on the "at least doubtful", numerous feats and declarations of characters not being capable of continental feats, Ei fighting his robot for (500 years?) hundreds of years using his Musou barely had enough energy to "drying seas" (she spent all these years fighting with Musou, which is her strongest technique, fighting a copy of herself as strong as she is), Azhdaha and Zhonglu fighting with all their power in 1v1 and not having any statement at this leve, etc.
Realms are a tricky thing, in Genshin, because even as it is stated in this CRT, it is not known for sure how they work, there are no declarations that you need to have great power (elemental energy) or anything like that to create them, there is some concrete proof that the creation of pocket realities scale to AP?
Ei battling her puppet for 500 years, depriving her every speck of energy and still being able to withstand is already an impressive stamina feat. The term “seas” is a very vague verse according to miHoYo since in Honkai they have the “Sea of Quanta” which is a 11th dimensional complex multiversal structure; hence, the term “dying seas” shouldn’t be taken as literal. I don’t understand why Zhongli and Azhdaha fighting not having statements of being “on that level” debunk the postulation that Adepti are Star level. If Realms in Genshin wasn’t so interpreted officially and shrouded in mystery, it would be space-time continuums by default since we don’t know anything about it; thus, no evidence to debunk its existence. I’m sure a character doesn’t need elemental energy or vast strength by creating a realm to scale to that level of AP. I’m sure there are shit tons of other characters who created pocket dimensions that also mentioned the concept of “imagination”, yet, scale to that level.
It is even written in the skill description that this does not scale to AP, nor the realms created by adeptis, nor the plane of consciousness.
Can you show me the scan where it’s stated directly creating realms in Genshin doesn’t scale to AP?
1. I totally disagree with AP, realms created by adepts use a specific skill, and don't scale to AP, it has nothing to do with elemental energy or anything that scales to AP.
2. I disagree with type 1 concepts, the planes of consciousness only exist if the consciousness of the person who created the plane exists, Makoto's plan for example only remained because his consciousness still existed in Musou, after his consciousness ceased to exist in Musou, his realm also ceased to exist, and objects from the realms that adepts create are likely to disappear after the owner's death, as they are made from the owner's thoughts.
3. I don't know if this really counts as "reality warping", a plane of consciousness only has one form (the "form" of the plane of consciousness is reflected in the owner, if I'm not mistaken, and is reflected in things like personality), and the interior of the plane of consciousness is reflected to the owner's memories, and I don't remember anyone changing the shape or interior of the plane of consciousness whenever they want and however they want, neither EI nor Makoto have feats to control their plans in this way.
4. If there's no feat of Ei, Makoto or Nahida controlling (changing) their plans however they want or whenever they want, I disagree with everything about this CRT.
Your second argument I can agree since it’s either type 2, if not type 1, concept hax. And again, please show actual scans where it’s stated bluntly that realms don’t scale to AP and completely irrelevant to power and potency. For your third argument, I can somewhat agree since their reality warping abilities only engulf their sphere of influence (tho, could be considered a limited reality warping). Raiden already have Pocket Reality Warping listed in her profile so I guess it’s fair game (tho, not like she could summon entities and objects outta nowhere and created a plane of euthymia to seal her opponents). For your fourth argument, Ei and Makoto could manipulate and control practically everything in their own dimensions and realm of consciousness. Il Dottore managed to created a hex around Sumeru and warped everything around it (including abstract concepts) with the Akasha terminal (that’s not a feat for Nahida, she only resisted it therefore qualifying for a resistance feat).
Tubby: Just commit the image of the objects to memory and prepare the necessary materials...
Tubby: Then, simply release the thought from your mind and the object in the blueprint shall appear within this teapot.

Tubby: He said that even though Sub-Space Creation is a product of adeptal power, even that has its limits.
Tubby: This world is not a true one, after all. It provides merely a moment of brief respite from the mortal realm, not a means of escaping it entirely.

All objects are made from the person's mind, Adepts use an ability to create them, objects according to what is said above, are made of pure someone's "thought", they (subspaces and objects) are not created by elemental energy or something that is usable in a fight (AP), so this does not seem to be escalated to AP, since it does not use elemental energy
That statement literal proved that the Serenitea Pot is a separate realm from the mortal world (it’s indicated as “not true one” and “brief respite from mortal realm” because it’s a pocket dimension created personally for the Traveller). The Traveller is still required to gather tangible materials to conjure objects with his imagination proving that the teapot is not imaginary (Traveler is the host of teapot, making it somewhat his realm of consciousness therefore he has the ability to create objects out of imagination). The theory of realms and teyvat being fake is really inconsistent because there is no official concrete evidence to prove that everything about and derived from Teyvat is fake. The reference that the realm still have its limits because it’s a pocket dimension, not a universe itself; therefore, it’ll have limits a part from the main Genshin universe. Tubby didn’t gave context to the term “limits” hence we could just assume it could be space and time whatsoever.
 
You need to prove that it's a literal star rather than a generic light source.
one that can shake the mountains and split the earth.
First of all, the Genshin planet is called Teyvat, not Earth, so this cannot be referring to splitting the entire planet in half. Second, "earth" simply refers to the ground and terrain, so this really refers to creating a crack or fissure in the ground of unknown size. It's an unquantifiable statement. Shaking mountains is good, though.
The term “seas” is a very vague verse according to miHoYo since in Honkai they have the “Sea of Quanta” which is a 11th dimensional complex multiversal structure; hence, the term “dying seas” shouldn’t be taken as literal.
The SOQ has nothing to do with Genshin. She was not referring to it.
 
You need to prove that it's a literal star rather than a generic light source.

First of all, the Genshin planet is called Teyvat, not Earth, so this cannot be referring to splitting the entire planet in half. Second, "earth" simply refers to the ground and terrain, so this really refers to creating a crack or fissure in the ground of unknown size. It's an unquantifiable statement. Shaking mountains is good, though.

The SOQ has nothing to do with Genshin. She was not referring to it.
First off, Teyvat is a continent of the Genshin world. Not a planet. That shine of light appearing like a sun could be inferred as a star with common knowledge and no-need to presume it's some light source whatever. And what "light source" could shine up an entire dimension? If it's not a star wtf would it be anyways lmao

I never referred the Sea of Quanta has anything to do with the Genshin world. I referred to it because Hoyoverse often utilize words as metaphors (such as "sea"), therefore not to be taken literally.
 
If Realms in Genshin wasn’t so interpreted officially and shrouded in mystery, it would be space-time continuums by default since we don’t know anything about it; thus, no evidence to debunk its existence. I’m sure a character doesn’t need elemental energy or vast strength by creating a realm to scale to that level of AP. I’m sure there are shit tons of other characters who created pocket dimensions that also mentioned the concept of “imagination”, yet, scale to that level.
Where do you think you don't need to prove that it scales to AP? Characters use energy completely different from any AP-related energy to create objects and the dimensions themselves, and of course you have to prove that this scales to AP, not counting the creation of dimensions, there is no other AP feat at this level in Genshin.
The Traveller is still required to gather tangible materials to conjure objects with his imagination proving that the teapot is not imaginary (Traveler is the host of teapot, making it somewhat his realm of consciousness therefore he has the ability to create objects out of imagination).
1. Where it says you need materials to conjure objects in lore?
2. This literally disproves nothing, the "energy" used to make objects or dimensions has nothing to do with AP, the main energy related to AP and elemental energy.

Besides the but, do you really think these are the only anti-feats in the entire lore? No Genshin character before or even after introducing this teapot has AP feats that come close to this.
Azhdaha and Morax fought in a cave and didn't destroy all of Teyvat how? How was teyvat not destroyed by the countless gods and aquatic monsters that existed years ago and still exist today? How did the adepts not destroy Teyvat in the fight against Osial? How is Osial itself not capable of destroying even Liyue? There are numerous anti-feats for this season.
Numerous characters from the Liyue arc upwards are already much stronger than all adeptis, and none of them have a feat that comes close to that.

The AP scale simply makes no sense, the "sea" excuse doesn't disprove all the other 92829 anti-feats that exist in lore besides the lack of feats, and there isn't a single proof that creating a subspace scales for AP.
 
Last edited:
That statement literal proved that the Serenitea Pot is a separate realm from the mortal world (it’s indicated as “not true one” and “brief respite from mortal realm” because it’s a pocket dimension created personally for the Traveller). The Traveller is still required to gather tangible materials to conjure objects with his imagination proving that the teapot is not imaginary (Traveler is the host of teapot, making it somewhat his realm of consciousness therefore he has the ability to create objects out of imagination). The theory of realms and teyvat being fake is really inconsistent because there is no official concrete evidence to prove that everything about and derived from Teyvat is fake. The reference that the realm still have its limits because it’s a pocket dimension, not a universe itself; therefore, it’ll have limits a part from the main Genshin universe. Tubby didn’t gave context to the term “limits” hence we could just assume it could be space and time whatsoever.
This goes against the lore in every way.
1. Is the very being that was made to take care of the dimension simply lying without reason?
2. Where does it say in the lore that materials are needed to create objects in the dimension?
3. None of this yet proves that this scales to AP, the subspace creations are done with an adeptis ability that Morax made known to the adeptis, but at no point is it said that it is done with anything AP related, and yes, proof is needed that this also counts as AP, as the numerous anrt-feats and lack of feats will complement against this AP.
 
Last edited:
For your fourth argument, Ei and Makoto could manipulate and control practically everything in their own dimensions and realm of consciousness. Il Dottore managed to created a hex around Sumeru and warped everything around it (including abstract concepts) with the Akasha terminal (that’s not a feat for Nahida, she only resisted it therefore qualifying for a resistance feat).
1. When did Ei and Makoto change their plan of their own free will? Changes in the realm such as changing the color of the sky, a greater amount of lightning in the plane or something like that is due to the feelings and memories of the owner of the plane of consciousness, I don't remember either of the two changing their planes because they want to, especially Makoto, since she is dead, and neither could change her plane of consciousness.
2. And how does this prove that Nahida is capable of changing the inside and outside of her plan as long as she wants to? I don't remember this happening since history, besides but, there is an interesting difference between Nahida's plan and Ei is Makoto's plan, one that is mainly related to her knowledge, but, this point is not important, it can show the moment in which Ei, Makoto or Nahida changed their kingdom of their own accord (having nothing to do with changes due to memory or feelings).
3. You would need better proof to say that plans are really conceptual frameworks, as Yea Miko only says that "from the outside looking in, the plan is a concept much abstract", not that the plan really is one. abstract concept, but, from the outside looking in, then what exactly are the plans? Whether you are outside or inside, what is the plan regardless of your point of view? This is a very specific mention, which does not speak directly to what a plane of consciousness IS.
 
1. When did Ei and Makoto change their plan of their own free will? Changes in the realm such as changing the color of the sky, a greater amount of lightning in the plane or something like that is due to the feelings and memories of the owner of the plane of consciousness, I don't remember either of the two changing their planes because they want to, especially Makoto, since she is dead, and neither could change her plane of consciousness.
2. And how does this prove that Nahida is capable of changing the inside and outside of her plan as long as she wants to? I don't remember this happening since history, besides but, there is an interesting difference between Nahida's plan and Ei is Makoto's plan, one that is mainly related to her knowledge, but, this point is not important, it can show the moment in which Ei, Makoto or Nahida changed their kingdom of their own accord (having nothing to do with changes due to memory or feelings).
3. You would need better proof to say that plans are really conceptual frameworks, as Yea Miko only says that "from the outside looking in, the plan is a concept much abstract", not that the plan really is one. abstract concept, but, from the outside looking in, then what exactly are the plans? Whether you are outside or inside, what is the plan regardless of your point of view? This is a very specific mention, which does not speak directly to what a plane of consciousness IS.
Nahida was imprisoned for over 500 years in her own realm of consciousness by the Sumeru Academia Sages with the exploitation of the Akasha Terminal. However, that’s not the case for Ei and Makoto. Makoto died before she was even introduced to the story so we wouldn’t know much about her. Ei managed to warp and sustain Makoto’s realm of consciousness by her own will. If Ei couldn’t alter the plane under her will then Makoto’s realm of consciousness couldn’t be sustained (description is listed with Pocket Reality Manipulation on her profile, hence no needed for further explanation). When a person dies their Realm of Consciousness eventually disappears over a period of time unless a foreign power seals and preserves it.

It was stated the Realm of Consciousness also influences from the person’s memories means that it could be warped from the person’s memories; however, that doesn’t prove it could only be altered with memories nor it disapproves they’re capable of abilities. Even if it’s only altered through memories that wouldn’t be the case with Ei who created her own plane of Euthymia.
The interior of a realm of consciousness is also influenced by its owner's memories.


As of your argument with Nahida…
Paimon: But now, we can at least confirm one thing: The Akasha definitely has something to do with whatever's trapping us in this cycle!

However, Dehya suddenly senses Dunyarzad's aura, feeling her regret and disappointment, so the Traveler begins to explain what was happening. Dehya agrees with their logic, believing that the sages were probably responsible for the samsara. Nahida then tells them that the Akasha uses the Gnosis to operate and that it gathers and compiles knowledge to the people

The Traveler then realizes the truth of the Akasha and the sages are actually stealing dreams from the people of Sumeru.

Nahida disappointingly informs them that Dunyarzad's consciousness disappeared, as it could no longer handle the Akasha harvesting. The Traveler and Paimon are also saddened by her apparent demise, but Nahida tells them how to break the samsara

The Akasha Terminal is powered up by the Dendro Archon’s gnosis. As said before, it manipulated everyone’s dreams and consciousness creating a time-loop across Sumeru and separating up space and time with a hex. Therefore, Nahida does have the will to bend the environment by modulating everyone’s dreams and consciousness with the Akasha Terminal (or her gnosis in general). I don’t understand how “feelings and memories” debunk my proposition they’re capable of bending concepts, they’ve been stated to be capable of such a feat thus why would feelings or memories be a hindrance? Il Dottore and Sages was capable of disheveling the hex around Sumeru to their accord towards anything they want. The reason we haven’t seen that with Nahida because she’s a good hearted person who cares about the people of Sumeru. Ei created her own plane and the wiki already confirmed she could warp it (you can post a thread to contest if you like). As for Makoto, she’s dead and featless hence we wouldn’t know anything about her (I only referred to her plane of consciousness because Ei was capitulating it). Nahida doesn’t even have a profile on this wiki yet so I doubt anyone who doesn’t know about Genshin could complain shit about Nahida.

As for your argument about planes not being abstract…
Yae Miko:To the outsider, the realm of consciousness is a very abstract concept. Luckily, I'm Ei's familiar, so I can sense her rough whereabouts.
Yae Miko: In other words, even though I can't pinpoint the exact spatial location of this realm, I can still send you to where Ei is.

Paimon: So it's abstract, but has a location, but you don't know where it is, but you can still send us there... what?

Yae Miko: Yes, no need to try and understand it. Let me put this simply: Right now, she is surrounded by chaos.
Yae stated it’s abstract from the perspective of an outsider but never stated its not abstract “on the outside”. Paimon asked for clarity and Yae seems to confirm it’s both an abstract concept and a space-time continuum. She didn’t specify much onwards but we could comprehend it as the Realm of Consciousness serving as a separate space-time continuum and an abstract notion of itself at the same time. May sound contradictory but conventional logic doesn’t work in the Genshin world after all… I’m sure countless other verses is also like that on this wiki yet scalings and qualifications still apply.
After reading Dog3352's post, I can't help but agree with him.
A mod or admin is needed for this CRT to even be viable. Voting won’t start unless I get a Genshin expert (like Solaris) and a staff to contribute to this CRT. Because I’m not the most apt in Genshin so we need coherent analysis of arguments from both sides.
 
Yae stated it’s abstract from the perspective of an outsider but never stated its not abstract “on the outside”. Paimon asked for clarity and Yae seems to confirm it’s both an abstract concept and a space-time continuum. She didn’t specify much onwards but we could comprehend it as the Realm of Consciousness serving as a separate space-time continuum and an abstract notion of itself at the same time. May sound contradictory but conventional logic doesn’t work in the Genshin world after all… I’m sure countless other verses is also like that on this wiki yet scalings and qualifications still apply.
Yae said that looking from the outside the plan is a very abstract concept, and Paimon didn't ask that, she asked if it was abstract, and Yae confirms it, but, she never confirmed it as being a concept, she just confirms it as being abstract, which is not makes it a concept, the plane of consciousness definitely is abstract, but, no confirmation of it actually being a concept or an abstract concept.
A mod or admin is needed for this CRT to even be viable. Voting won’t start unless I get a Genshin expert (like Solaris) and a staff to contribute to this CRT. Because I’m not the most apt in Genshin so we need coherent analysis of arguments from both sides.
He's talking about the 4C scale, which doesn't make any sense.
 
Yae said that looking from the outside the plan is a very abstract concept, and Paimon didn't ask that, she asked if it was abstract, and Yae confirms it, but, she never confirmed it as being a concept, she just confirms it as being abstract, which is not makes it a concept, the plane of consciousness definitely is abstract, but, no confirmation of it actually being a concept or an abstract concept.

He's talking about the 4C scale, which doesn't make any sense.
I thought being abstract is kinda being a notion… couldn’t it just be a notion of consciousness or dreams? I’ll gotta contact a mod about the 4-C scale
 
I'm going to speak my opinion on the things covered in this CRT.

1. I disagree with AP for the reasons I mentioned above, plus this: https://genshin-impact.fandom.com/wiki/Mist_Veiled_Mercury_Elixir

A kingdom is created by combining Waijing (skill used to create the realm) + "mind power" (thoughts, imagination) + Material (Ping used materials to finish the teapot), and none of them scale to AP, in addition to the numerous anti-feats and lack of feats.

2. I disagree with CM type 1, since it needs to have the "mind" of the owner of the plan for it to continue existing.

3. I'm neutral on reality warping, as I don't know how hax works.

4. The CM depends on the wiki (I'm neutral on this one too), I don't know if this statement is enough to give CM, but if it is enough, I propose CM type 3, the plane of consciousness don't govern (in this case, they're not like CM type 2, which govern is more fundamental than what they govern) and are not more fundamental than anything (as far as I've read), besides not being very well specified, they look more like CM type 3.
 
Last edited:
I thought being abstract is kinda being a notion… couldn’t it just be a notion of consciousness or dreams? I’ll gotta contact a mod about the 4-C scale
I don't know about CM, would have to see if someone with better knowledge would accept that statement as enough to get CM.
About the AP, honestly, I doubt very much that it will be accepted.
 
The statement about realm of consciousness being abstract concept from the outside is extremely strange, it is too metaphorical and isnt well define, so even if we go lenient and accept it is concept hax, at best it is type 3, idk where type 1 come from. Anyway i disagree with CM hax
 
I'm going to speak my opinion on the things covered in this CRT.

1. I disagree with AP for the reasons I mentioned above, plus this: https://genshin-impact.fandom.com/wiki/Mist_Veiled_Mercury_Elixir

A kingdom is created by combining Waijing (skill used to create the realm) + "mind power" (thoughts, imagination) + Material (Ping used materials to finish the teapot), and none of them scale to AP, in addition to the numerous anti-feats and lack of feats.

2. I disagree with CM type 1, since it needs to have the "mind" of the owner of the plan for it to continue existing.

3. I'm neutral on reality warping, as I don't know how hax works.

4. The CM depends on the wiki (I'm neutral on this one too), I don't know if this statement is enough to give CM, but if it is enough, I propose CM type 3, the plane of consciousness don't govern (in this case, they're not like CM type 2, which govern is more fundamental than what they govern) and are not more fundamental than anything (as far as I've read), besides not being very well specified, they look more like CM type 3.
The sub space creation having limits of not capable of creating cities is quite suspicious because the Traveler could fit anything into the serenitea pot

Even if those spaces can’t fit cities, the star’s still there… Honestly, shit tons of statements about teyvat and subspaces being fake is inconsistent in general. Scaramouche stated everything in Teyvat is fake even the entirety of Teyvat itself, not just the “sky and stars“

Anyways, you got a point
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top