Vietthai96
He/Him- 9,303
- 12,434
and how are you suppose to correctly display him dodging a timeline falling via visual???, this isn't exactly a counter-argument.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Dragon Ball Heroes: Cosmological Review
- Thread starter Irineu
- Start date
- Status
- 3,168
- 3,324
How is a game supposed to visualize something that big?
- 12,956
- 5,051
It being a game doesn't justify things being this much incoherent.
Writers definitely know about the size of celestial/cosmic bodies, yet we get this cutscenes.
Not to mention that not even those on the background are portrayed as giants, they're still on comparable size as Demigra.
Writers definitely know about the size of celestial/cosmic bodies, yet we get this cutscenes.
Not to mention that not even those on the background are portrayed as giants, they're still on comparable size as Demigra.
- 3,168
- 3,324
Them knowing the size of the universe doesn't magically allow them to correctly portray the size of the universe along with a character in the same scene.
- 12,956
- 5,051
Doesn't matter, timelines are not supposed to fall like that and to be dodged like they're random objects.
If those were attacks used from a character who uses timelines as bullets/technique then okay, that could be ok. But here those crystals weren't manipulated from anything.
If those were attacks used from a character who uses timelines as bullets/technique then okay, that could be ok. But here those crystals weren't manipulated from anything.
- 3,168
- 3,324
People aren't supposed to exceed the SoL (shouldn't even reach it btw, they have mass) either, yet they do.
These people shouldn't be able to wield that kind of power in their bodies, let alone High 3-A and above, yet they do.
That isn't an argument whatsoever.
These people shouldn't be able to wield that kind of power in their bodies, let alone High 3-A and above, yet they do.
That isn't an argument whatsoever.
- 12,956
- 5,051
False equivalence to the maximum, we're not talking about speed omfg.
We're talking about size, something that was accurately portrayed before (and later) in the verse.
You're not supposed to literally dodge a timeline falling on you like is a regular object, this isn't just breaking the laws of physics but is literally saying that timelines can perfectly fall on people and be dodged as if they're common rocks. And you know that ain't really right.
- 5,683
- 3,208
You just can't apply that logic to a cartoon lol.
In fiction it happens more often than not.
In Instant Death there is a being called "Celestial fundation eater" a giant fish whose size dwarfs entire Timelines alone.
Or also beings holding an entire Space-time continoum in the palm of their hand
- 12,956
- 5,051
The fish uses Avatars to interact with what's inside the worlds and it being higher dimensional is not contradicted from anything, so that's not an argument.
That is heavily context dependent. In the cases I know about this (like Doremy from Touhou) she straight up manipulates those universes.
But here we talk about timelines being forcefully portrayed as comparable in size to 3D humans with no logical explanation.
- 5,683
- 3,208
What do Avatars have to do with the fact that the true form of the fish transcends Timelines's size itself?
Again, those are just Game mechanics, you know they don't always have to make sense, right?
You know a player can just grab Krilin and beat up Whis in the Game.....
Or for example, when you travel to Planet Namek from Conton city, to do Nail's quests.
You clearly see the planet portrayed as a floating Island, does that mean Planet Namek is only 6-C?
- 12,956
- 5,051
It just supports the fish being bigger, duh.
Are you seriously applying game mechanics to a cutscene? Game Mechanics is shit like HPs, taking turns or everyone having finite statistics. But this is a cutscene, game mechanics don't apply there.
- 5,683
- 3,208
It's more like the fish being Higher dimensional, since the "Sea" where he resides is. Rather than needing 3-D sockpuppets to interact with lower worlds.
Also the fact that he can interact with those Universes just fine, the dude literally eats Universes as breakfast
- 12,956
- 5,051
That doesn't really address what I said. Stop understanding what you want to understand, I'm perfectly aware why the fish is Higher D, the fact it uses 3D avatars to interact with said worlds only supports that notion.
Besides it's completely irrelevant with the topic at hand anyway.
- 5,683
- 3,208
He literally can eat those lower worlds lol. So interacts with Low D just fine.
Anyways, yep. Dropping this, just addresing the point that "is impossible to dodge" timelines tho.
Also, the fact there are beings in fiction Who can throw entire multiverses at will
- 12,956
- 5,051
That is because the fish is bigger than those timelines. FW has 0 proofs of that. You're climbing on mirrors now lol.
Again, context dependent. Most of the time these characters can manipulate said structures, so that's a reasoning, but in this case it lacks a reasoning.Also, the fact there are beings in fiction Who can throw entire multiverses at will
- 5,683
- 3,208
Yeah, just wanted to address the part about "being imposible to dodge timelines", becouse it can certainly happen in fiction
Anyways, I remain neutral for now, will wait for more arguments.
- 7,017
- 6,840
Can someone reiterate the proposal of qualitative superiority?
- 12,956
- 5,051
Is about CoT seeing timelines as crystals, but I countered that here
CraigTucker
He/Him- 494
- 266
I'll explain why your arguments doesn't work later gotta do some cleaning
- 12,956
- 5,051
Good luck dealing with the other 4 staff agreeing with me too.
- 3,368
- 4,525
I don’t like double standards so if being a timeline (you can see a fight happening inside the crystal) or universe/space time is invalidated because when people are in the Crack of Time look small even though when Fu held the universe in the CoT you could see Goku in it then you might as well downgrade Fu’s LS too and any verse that does anything similar but whatever this logic apparently makes sense
- 12,956
- 5,051
This is so random lmao.
Seeds are very different from the crystals, and the tree explicitly is not universe sized, but galaxy sized. So at best the Seeds work like Alien X, who is technically a living universe with lots of galaxies inside, but is not that big in the actual universe.
If anything the Universe tree size should be downgraded to Type 7 from Type 9.
- 3,368
- 4,525
Didn’t even realize but the op addressed this point there’s the Universe Tree and the Copy Universe I’ll quote the op word for word “Perhaps some argue that this is actually the seed of the universe, not the universe itself. But this is actually wrong, as this was actually the universe after the universe tree hatched. When he hatched from the tree, a light sucked the warriors out of the time rift and sent them into this universe.
In addition to the tree seed being different visually when we see it in the universal conflict saga. ” but yeah Fu never held the Universe Tree in his hand
CraigTucker
He/Him- 494
- 266
The hole anology here seems bad because The stuff that is acquired to make the tree grow is not based on the size, it's solely vitality we literally see vegeta make a blast just as big as the universe tree yet when it absorbs the energy it does not grow further Even here we see the universe tree is not as big as a galaxy which utterly decimates the idea that the energy inputted = size output as well.
Braking
He/Him- 3,801
- 2,209
why same thumbnail
CraigTucker
He/Him- 494
- 266
Same video but provide different stamps my bad these are arguments my friend and I point out against ppl who use these type of arguments
CraigTucker
He/Him- 494
- 266
Sorry bout that
- 4,716
- 4,176
I'd so I read through the basis of this thread and I see it's at kinda an impasse
So this is my view as a person who does not care whether the verse gets Upgraded or Downgraded
From what I can see the Crack of Time portrays entire 4D Infinite Universes as finite in size
The main argument against this is that since they're small in comparison to other regular sized people that inhabit that space
Them suddenly growing bigger than an infinite sized universe obviously makes no sense (but could be the case idn)
HOWEVER
That really doesn't even matter if the Infinite Universe in question is of a certain size, fiction does this all the time
What matters in my opinion is if these Universes in question still take the same amount of energy to destroy in the crack of time and are equivalent to there normal universe selves
What I mean by this is if a normal human was somehow transferred to the crack of time would they be able to say destroy a crystal and the universe itself?
Or is this only treated as something that can be done by characters hat have already been established as Universal in tier?
If the later is the case and they still retain there properties of requiring infinite energy to create or destroy then this would be a case of a 4 dimensional multiverse being dwarfed infinitely by a larger space
Which is literally the definition of Low 1-C
"Characters or objects that can affect, create and/or destroy the entirety of spaces whose size corresponds to one to two higher levels of infinity greater than a standard universal model (Low 2-C structures, in plain English.)"
This is assuming that there are characters the have destroyed the Crack of Time as well and not just the universes in it
If this is the case then put me down for Agree
So this is my view as a person who does not care whether the verse gets Upgraded or Downgraded
From what I can see the Crack of Time portrays entire 4D Infinite Universes as finite in size
The main argument against this is that since they're small in comparison to other regular sized people that inhabit that space
Them suddenly growing bigger than an infinite sized universe obviously makes no sense (but could be the case idn)
HOWEVER
That really doesn't even matter if the Infinite Universe in question is of a certain size, fiction does this all the time
What matters in my opinion is if these Universes in question still take the same amount of energy to destroy in the crack of time and are equivalent to there normal universe selves
What I mean by this is if a normal human was somehow transferred to the crack of time would they be able to say destroy a crystal and the universe itself?
Or is this only treated as something that can be done by characters hat have already been established as Universal in tier?
If the later is the case and they still retain there properties of requiring infinite energy to create or destroy then this would be a case of a 4 dimensional multiverse being dwarfed infinitely by a larger space
Which is literally the definition of Low 1-C
"Characters or objects that can affect, create and/or destroy the entirety of spaces whose size corresponds to one to two higher levels of infinity greater than a standard universal model (Low 2-C structures, in plain English.)"
This is assuming that there are characters the have destroyed the Crack of Time as well and not just the universes in it
If this is the case then put me down for Agree
- 3,368
- 4,525
No people are small when they’re in the actual timelines or universes and they’re only comparable to size to the universe/timeline when they‘re not in the actual universe or timeline which now makes me wonder doesn’t that just mean when someone is in the perspective of the crack of time they become comparable to universes/timelines in size since even someone like Goku was literally in one of the universes Fu
To put this in simple terms ”humans” are small when they‘re actually inside the universe or timeline and should be that small comparable to the space time which makes sense ofc but they’re only comparable when they’re outside of said space time and seems like its similar to a boomtube affect since Fu literally holds a universe with Goku inside of it and we’ve been shown fights of events occurring inside a crystal timeline
- 3,368
- 4,525
XV2
vsbattles.fandom.com
Short Summary: CoT is a Space stated to be a “Super Space-Time” and “Beyond Space-Time” which mean nothing by itself but this makes sense when you realize its a space that dwarfs and is outside of infinite histories but interconnecting and housing these timelines and universes
Counterargument for this so far: Crystals seem too small and why are humans comparable to a timeline in size?
The counter arguments for the counter arguments is that it’s a perspective thing
My scans justifying this we see events happening inside the crystals and they’re called histories we also see Fu holding a universe which is stated to be a space-time many times and we actually see things within this universe and Goku is inside a universe Fu is holding further justifying that this is a perspective thing like how The Writer views the Monitor Overvoid as a sheet of paper which doenst mean that monitor a HDB is only as big as a sheet of paper
- 7,017
- 6,840
Can someone clarify if the time crystal shards are entire universes/timelines?
In order to enter them, there is some form of shrinking from the Crack of Time to the Time Shard?
In order to enter them, there is some form of shrinking from the Crack of Time to the Time Shard?
- 12,956
- 5,051
- 12,956
- 5,051
- 7,017
- 6,840
This is a rule violation thread post.
- 2,127
- 1,726
I was also wondering the same.
- 12,956
- 5,051
- 12,956
- 5,051
Alright, I'm in break time, so here's the thing.
Strawman af, I never said that is not an universe, just that it works like Alien X who is not universe sized on the outside but only inside. A bit like Mechikabura in his TPU as well.
Strawman af, I never said that is not an universe, just that it works like Alien X who is not universe sized on the outside but only inside. A bit like Mechikabura in his TPU as well.
Another false equivalence. It's a feat for the Writer in this case.
This ain't Gurren Lagann chief. You need explicit statements about this, not "maybe is like this".
Fuu literally says it.
This thing you said just damages your point. Fuu said that the tree will eventually reach galaxy size, meaning that it is not of that size yet. Aka your argument is literally saying that the tree is still much smaller than a galaxy.
CraigTucker
He/Him- 494
- 266
Fuu said this but the context and narritive disapprove this, I don't see why would x character say something with the context dismissed it.
That's completely assuming things and no fuu verbatemly said the tree was already complete, your going against your hole source and I already explain how the tree isn't really the size of a galaxy no refute here. The fact it’s supposed to be an object of absorption-> creation, the size has no intent on the use of said object, no one is arguing that it should be the size of a universe, no one is saying it should be 6-D physically, they are saying it has the power to create a new universe which in itself is already several galaxies and on multiple occasions was called infinite. You’re using an arbitrary format of words to try to say it’s only the size of a galaxy when the living world on its own was confirmed to be separated in 4, which innumerable galaxies and nebulae that exist in an endlessly expansive universe. Even if I agreed to saying it was an endlessly expanding 3-D space, it’s still bigger than a galaxy such as the milky way. Honestly i find you dishonest here and was referring to the tree without root, thus it doesn't damage any points of mine
- Status
Similar threads
