- 61,177
- 14,747
Neither do half of the enemies the Hunter visceral attacks, he can literally do it to ghosts and skeletons
Awesome, the Hunter can sever type 8 immortality of that nature as well
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Steal the crown from under their nose (The Hunter vs Stone Golem)
- Thread starter Peppersalt43
- Start date
- Status
- 10,116
- 11,488
Fairly sure that would be resisted either way, but I suppose it's specific enough that I can't answer confidently.
This, however, I can definitely say it's resisted, as said action would be effectively soul hax against the undead. That's how they are reliant to the plane, they are small pieces of it; the negative energies fuel them as analogs to souls.
- 61,177
- 14,747
The Hunter does have soul hax and the ability to kill souls yes, incuding disembodies spirits that exist on alternate planes of reality
- 10,116
- 11,488
Resisted with multiple layers.
- 61,177
- 14,747
They resist their souls being physically attacked and damaged? How many layers exactly?
- 10,116
- 11,488
Not only resisted, it exists on another plane entirely (Negative Energy Plane)
Normally undead are immune to said attacks overall (because of the nature of souls vs negative energy), but it also has 14 layers to those effects that would target said energy, on top of it's spell resistance, for an added 12* layers of protection
- 61,177
- 14,747
Yes, the Hunter can affect beings with that kind of existence
Its not a spell tho, its just his normal attacks
- 10,116
- 11,488
Doesn't have interdimensional range attacks on this key?
Mr. Bambu
Suffer-Not-Injustice Bambu
VS Battles
Joke Battles
Super Moderator
Administrator
Calculation Group
Silver Supporter
- 22,756
- 22,272
Yeah, necrotic/radiant damaging spells are pretty much exactly that. Pretty much anything with a page will have resistance (though a great deal of creatures in D&D, such as commoners, do not). Lephyr is also correct in that undead in D&D outright cannot be affected, regardless of their resistance, due to the special nature of their souls (i.e. being converted to negative energy and residing in a different plane)
- 10,116
- 11,488
We also have a debate on the Gaze attack of the Vitreous Drinker. The Gaze attacks overall in the SRD mentions it affects multiple targets as long as they look at the gaze.
However, the monsters statblock states they just need to be within range of the gaze. Which would apply there?
- 10,116
- 11,488
Oh yeah, and about the Deflection bonus to AC.
- 61,177
- 14,747
The ghosts in Cainhurst and the Chalice Dungeons as well as Kos' soul that you kill at the end of the DLC
- 61,177
- 14,747
Oh yeah
Since its undead The Drinker would be kinda screwed by the Hunter's holy weapons would it?
Since its undead The Drinker would be kinda screwed by the Hunter's holy weapons would it?
- 10,116
- 11,488
Not exactly. The reason holy stuff works in dnd is because they specifically counter the negative energies of the undead. Without interdimensional range, it shouldn't affect it imo.
Mr. Bambu
Suffer-Not-Injustice Bambu
VS Battles
Joke Battles
Super Moderator
Administrator
Calculation Group
Silver Supporter
- 22,756
- 22,272
If both can apply, apply both. Otherwise, the monster's specific statblock would take priority. For example, the Beholder's eyestalks function regardless of whether you look at it or not, despite being a "gaze attack".
For Drinker specifically I believe it's less a physical thing and more akin to a forcefield. Not exactly a visible one, but iirc it is dependent upon Charisma?
Man that's pretty weak. Non-physical interaction is not necessarily soul-destroying shit, Weekly. We have no idea what becomes of those guys after we take 'em out, even less with Kos given it's a dream (an abstraction of the already fucky reality we're inhabiting in-game).
Not really? Undead in D&D can have such weaknesses but most stronger ones just... don't. The exception is a good amount of more powerful undead have strengths that can typically only be overcome by holy stuff (e.g., radiant damage often negates regenerative properties).
I have knowledge on both verses, I don't think the Hunter has any great way of dealing with the Drinker besides just beating it to death (which it very well might before the Drinker successfully kills it). Finger of Death has been pretty largely misinterpreted in this thread, it cannot be dodged, nor is it only viable on targets that have been weakened- if you lack the proper resistance, Finger of Death is an instant kill.
All in all, I do consider the Vitreous Drinker the more likely victor in such a fight, but that more or less entirely hinges on its use of Finger of Death.
- 61,177
- 14,747
How good is it considered though? Because the Hunter can get through forcefields going by the fight with Logarius
Meh, fair
I mean, Finger of Death wouldnt permakill the Hunter, they would just resurrect and know to kill the Drinker before it can use Finger of Death again
- 10,116
- 11,488
Yes, based on charisma.
In my defense, I was going with the assumption it was resisted, that's why I brought up the fact the Drinker can just nerf the Hunter anyways.
Mr. Bambu
Suffer-Not-Injustice Bambu
VS Battles
Joke Battles
Super Moderator
Administrator
Calculation Group
Silver Supporter
- 22,756
- 22,272
To my knowledge the Hunter has no noteworthy resistance to Death or Soul manipulation, just good resurrection. That resurrection, also, has never shown the ability to repair soul shit such as Finger of Death. I believe it to be a perfectly valid wincon.
- 10,116
- 11,488
The thing is, this doesn't matter. Adventurers at these levels are expected to spam prep, clairvoyance and all manner of spells to gain knowledge on their targets. The Vitreous Drinker can still provide a challenge and even win.
- 61,177
- 14,747
Being able to shift back and forth between a human and a Keeper of the Old Lords with no issue would be soul resistance yeah?
- 10,116
- 11,488
They more than likely can reach that via magical attacks and/or bypass it through layers.
- 61,177
- 14,747
I mean, Keepers of the Old Lords straight up have no soul, theres nothing to affect
- 10,116
- 11,488
Finger of Death can affect soulless beings.
What's considered soulless
As creatures with null Int, Oozes don't have souls. They aren't immune to death effects, so Finger of Death affects them regardless.
- 61,177
- 14,747
Mkay, so this would be incon then going by Bambu's points, literally just comes down to a tossup of the Hunter shredding the Drinker vs the Drinker using Finger of Death
- 10,116
- 11,488
Which I argue the Drinker has enough skill by virtue of it's challenge rating to be able to survive and use it.
Bambu also agreed the Drinker is the most likely victor.
- 61,177
- 14,747
CR =/= skill though, CR only measures power
He also said it can go either way, which i agree with
He also said it can go either way, which i agree with
- 10,116
- 11,488
That's incorrect. It measures challenge. It includes power, but also a creature's skills, feats, resistances, special abilities and how hard they are to be dealt with by an adventuring group of at least 4 from that level.
- 10,116
- 11,488
- 61,177
- 14,747
I mean thats great and all but the Drinker doesnt have anything in its arsenal that suggests a high degree of skill in direct combat, its more built around spying and intelligence gathering, its intelligent in the conventional sense, not necessarily the combat sense. Hell the only weapon specialization is has is with its tongue lol
You'd be hard pressed to argue that the Drinker is more skilled than the Hunter in a direct contest of combat skill
Unless you want to argue that the Tarrasqueis secretly a supergenius
- 10,116
- 11,488
Also incorrect. As per a CR 11 creature, it can reasonably challenge people with high degree of martial arts like Monks, Fighters and Paladins. It is able to fight through Danmaku from a Sorcerer, it is able to give a run for its money to reasonably prepared Wizards. It can fight range spam from Rangers.
All manner of abilities, specialities and combination of feats and abilities, it can challenge and win.
At these levels, a Wizard is expected to know defensive spells to counter all manner of demons, undead, fey, aberration, etc etc etc. They are expected to be fighting creatures that are quite capable of spamming stealth since even level 1. Clerics are expected to commune with their deities to gain precog and knowledge: hell, they are expected to know the lore and abilities of a Vitreous Drinker outright.
The monster can still beat them.
- 61,177
- 14,747
Again, unless you want to argue that the Tarrasque is secretly an absurdly intelligent supergenius, its not a 1-1 scale
Their lore and abilities need to be taken into account when judging this
- 10,116
- 11,488
Still canon that they can. Hell, it is even notable that the Drinker is able to weaponize its tongue (a feat comparable to being proficient if not masterful with virtually any other weapon) Literally means it can hold itself quite well at cqc (in fact, majority of its feats are precisely for close quarters combat)
And considering what adventurers have access to at the level to be able to challenge the Terrasque? Yeah, lol. The Tarrasque itself can very reasonably weaponize its body in ways to give a run for its money to other fighters.
- 10,116
- 11,488
The Drinker would be considered a Genius-Supra Genius
And can also fight people like that (if not higher)
- 61,177
- 14,747
Having natural weaponry and being strong does not make them a skill god without actual feats of martial skill backing it up
The Drinker has no weapon proficiency other than with its tongue, with is Weapon Finesse also applying to its tongue as it has no other weapons, literally all of its skills are intelligence or charisma based, its lore is that its a spy, not a warrior or even an assassin, their canon go-to combat method is hit and run implying they arent able to hold their own in a cqc fight against someone actually good at cqc, and all of their abilities are spell-like or saves.
Cool, its intelligent, that doesnt make it skilled in cqc by default, thats like saying Albert Einstein beats Mike Tyson in CQC because he's smarter conventionally
- 10,116
- 11,488
Read the page. It's measuring combat intelligence. Combatants of below intelligence to it are said to be able to use all attack options from that book, which even includes stuff like wrestling.
That's the point. It can back it up against actual cqc combatants.
- 61,177
- 14,747
The Drinker has nothing indicating good cqc skill
Mr. Bambu
Suffer-Not-Injustice Bambu
VS Battles
Joke Battles
Super Moderator
Administrator
Calculation Group
Silver Supporter
- 22,756
- 22,272
I believe he isn't arguing skill in melee combat so much as arguing skill in using his abilities to great effect in melee combat.
No? I realize it mentioned a ritual but that was for the boss the Keeper of the Old Lords, the Hunter isn't that boss lol.
- 61,177
- 14,747
This thread has been a rollercoaster lol, went from the hunter beating the drinker to stalemating the stone golem to the hunter being DQed to the hunter being unDQed to stalemating the Drinker to the Drinker being DQed
- 10,116
- 11,488
As all debates should be. Explore every option to come to an agreeable conclusion.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
