...Right, to avoid this becoming a derail into infighting, here's my own list if any cares (This is all relative, with the og series ranking as a 10):
Magia Record (Event Stories / Side Stories): 9.9 / 10 (F4 is incredible when it comes to wholesome stories. I have a headcanon that they might have been doujin writers back in PMMM's golden age, because some elements really do show here. The darker event stories like Madoka / Homura's Valentines are incredible well done too, but its by Inu, which gives me hope for the anime, even the worst event story, Cross Connectio, is still hype and what Suzune Magica should have been.)
Cafe Grief Seed: 9.5 / 10 (Gave me diabetes and that artstyle, dear lord. A dramatic slice of life.)
Tart: 9.3/10 (The writer knows he's basically writing a shounen, but by adding historical elements and trying his own thing, he really made a good manga. I think this is shown best by Tart's reaction to the nature of the soul gem.)
Tamura: 8.9 / 10 (Really fun to read, expanding on material we already know and the writer definitely played the PSP game. Some timelines felt like filler tho. Queen Mami will probably be the best timeline, but that ending was just so heartbreaking. Especially the realization that Tamura and other important Homuras never managed to save Madoka...)
Wraith Arc (1st half): 8.8 / 10 (Incredible atmosphere and art, as well as worldbuilding. Honestly had a better beginning than the og series, and had the second half been done better, this could have been considered a superior sequel.)
PSP: 8.8 / 10 (Funny when it wants to be, and tragic when it needs to be. Aged like milk tho).
Adult Mami: 8.8 / 10 (ICONIC. I'm still planning on making a profile for Adult Mami. This story is kinda a mix between depressing and funny, because at the end, Mami is still alone...)
Magia Record (Anime): 8.7 / 10 (Still not done, so the potential is there. Chapter 3, 4, and 5 have been enhanced greatly through this adaption. Specifically character building for the latter two chapters, and the fight in chapter 3. Doppel Giovanna and Commoner's Horse became hype, despite having the shittest designs in-game).
Oriko Magica (Sadness Prayer): 8.6 / 10 (Remaking, because lets be clear, that's what this really was, a story like Oriko Magica must have been a hard feat. But the writer did it. They explained Oriko and Kirika much better this time, most of my gripes about the original are gone.)
Magia Record (Manga): 8.2 / 10 (A straightforward adaption of the game, but seeing it play out with minor changes for cohesion is really nice. Still, I think it really shows how the main story ain't quite Madoka enough).
Kazumi: 7.6 / 10 (Volume 2 and 5 are the low points of the series. Rereading it has helped me understand it better, but dang, I shouldn't have to reread it so many times to understand what's going on. Volume 2 should have been deleted from editing, and volume 5 split into two more volumes. This has almost as much potential as Wraith Arc if it had an anime adaptation or remake.)
Anti-Materials: 7.5 / 10 (Bruh who authorized this Mami x Homura fanfic. Because bless their soul. The plot is non-existant but the character dymanics are fantastic, I recommend anyone to read this.)
Different Story: 7.5 /10 (This may be blasphemous, but Different Story isn't as fun to read second time around. Feels like vol. 2 and 3 should have just been fused tbh).
Homura's Revenge: 7.3 / 10 (Kinda bland, but still a nice read. Have the same gripes as Different Story.)
Oriko (Manga and Extra Story): 7.2 / 10 (Alright story, Oriko carries this story. Kirkia seems a bit too obsessive and barely explained. Artwork haunts the verse to this very day. I did like how it tried to build on the moral dilemmas brought by the og series, but sadness prayer did it better.)
Pomu Magi: 7 / 10 (What was I even reading?)
Wraith Arc (2nd half): 6.8 / 10 (You know you got a problem when most of the fanbase doesn't even understand what happens here. The fact that AoC isn't given a real name is another problem as well. It really suffered from only having 3 volumes. If adapted, this would work incredible well. As a matter of fact, by simply explaining stuff and improving the pacing in the latter half, this could be on equal grounds with Rebellion and the og series easily.)
Comic Anthologies 6.5 / 10 (Does what its intended to be, the stories are a mixed bag. Madoka Magica GT should have been longer.)
Magia Record (Main Story / Another Story): 5.5 / 10 (I have a laundry list of issues, but honestly the biggest one is that its Madoka lite + fanservice. It's power scaling is shit too, lmao at Iroha oneshotting the Uwasa of Lucky Owl Water when three other magical girls including Yachiyo couldn't even scratch it. It breaks the very lore it builds upon, like how Uwasas work. Alina was what marked the beginning of the bad for me, read her side/event stories and then read the main story and tell me these aren't different characters.)
Suzune: 4.8 / 10 (You tried GAN, but I have hope that if you remade it, and got rid of the awful twist ending, you'd be able to do it justice. Imagine, each volume another girl goes down while debating whether magical girls should be forcefully prevented from becoming a witch, and each magical girl's death becoming harder to justify in Suzune's mind.)
I don't remeber Sute Ma! or Veranda enough to rate them unfortunately, but I remember the latter as good.
Rebellion Manga and Main series manga are both just 9s to me, for obvious reasons.
Haven't read Floating Madoka, Shoujobu Madoka, Kanameke, Bookstore, or Kindergarden. Yet. Haven't heard the drama CDs either.
Akemi Homura Will Try Harder Tomorrow scares me.
