• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
"Avengers Beyond" seemed to simply exist in order to completely depower and then give a fate far worse than death to The Beyonder, which didn't make sense considering his preceding evolution, and also added a pointless nonsense character that we will never hear from again to the origin story of his species, so I strongly disagree with your assessment here. I really despise the type of purely destructive hack writing that Derek did there.
 
I do agree with your take, but, it's pretty evident Avengers: Beyond took place before Defenders: Beyond. So, Beyonder is still ever as powerful when he left the House of Ideas.
 

Abstract:​


Since a recent revision pivots the Astral Plane as 1-A, it will remain 1-A. Meaning the Abstarct Universal True Forms remains a layer above baseline.

Omniverse:​

The changes to the Omniverse will adhere to just staying 1-A since we will not be using the dreams within dreams where reality is not real to the higher realms. Although, there's some interesting keys to it, the best for the Omniverse at the higher end is 1-A+. Which all the differences within worlds are in the same hierarchy and not a different one. So, the Multiversal/Omniversal form of the Abstracts will be reduced to 1-A.
Some abstract entities should be 1-A+, but the Omniverse itself should still be classified as H1-A, as Universal-Eternities (1-A+) are merely cells within the Omniverse/Eternity, which is too vast and varied to be scaled as 1-A+. The Omniverse should remain H1-A because it contains many distinct 1-A+ realms and entities within it.And those who could threaten the Omniverse should still be classified as H1-A.

The Outside:​

The Outside realms will all be reduced 1-A. However, the main difference is that each higher realms does not share the same relation of transcendence in the new wiki. So, the Far Shore, and the Beyond will just remain three layer.
Oblivion
The Void/Darkness/Outside


The Void should also be regarded as H1-A, as it is endless, even for Eternity (Omniverse) . Oblivion is also connected to primordial chaos and freedom, as his aspect, the Chaos King, embodies primordial chaos. In Chaos War, Oblivion was also called 'Chaos.' This connection might extend to The Abyss, the realm of pure chaos and freedom. Therefore, the Void may encompass nearly all planes of existence, except The House of Ideas, as the destination where the WHR returns when it dies and is reborn is darkness. The Handbook also states that the Void is the birthplace of the Phoenix (WHR).This means the Void is larger than the WHR and The Beyond.

The Mother of Horror also exists because of the Void.
The White Hot Room, Couldn’t-Be-Shouldn’t-Be/Could-Be-Shall-Be, and the House of Idea will be an additional layer.
The White Hot Room should still be H1-A, as it represents all things and all places. It is the plane where the creativity exists, and part of it functions as the 'White Paper' for the creations/stories. Even the Beyonder, a being of immense power, views the higher planes of existence (such as the White Hot Room and the Abyss) as a Multiverse.
The only realm and character to get High 1-A will be the One Above All and the House of Ideas.
The House of Ideas and TOAA should be considered H1-A+ rather than just H1-A , as he's above all plane of existence.
 
Last edited:
You're going to need to prove otherwise then.
Question the Definition of “Canon”
What exactly is your definition of 'Canon'? In Marvel Comics, the term 'Canon' is not rigidly defined by a single author or storyline. Marvel Multiverse operates on the concept of countless parallel universes and timelines, including Earth-616 (the main continuity) and infinite other realities. Saying something isn’t Canon requires clear criteria, which Marvel itself often leaves ambiguous.

Point Out DeMatteis’ Official Marvel Publications
J.M. DeMatteis’ works have been officially published by Marvel Comics, including stories that introduced concepts like The Far Shore and The White Hot Room. These ideas have expanded the Marvel Universe in significant ways. Claiming his works aren’t Canon disregards the fact that Marvel itself approved and published these stories as part of its universe.

Highlight His Contribution to Marvel Cosmology
J.M. DeMatteis played a pivotal role in expanding Marvel Cosmology, particularly in exploring philosophical and higher dimensional concepts. For instance, The Far Shore is described as a realm beyond all dimensions, a place that even beings like Eternity and Infinity acknowledge as superior. Dismissing these contributions undermines the depth they bring to Marvel narrative structure.

Use Examples from Marvel Supporting DeMatteis’ Ideas
Looking closely, DeMatteis’ ideas have been referenced by other Marvel writers, such as Jonathan Hickman and Al Ewing. For example, The House of Ideas was prominently featured in Immortal Hulk and described as the source of everything in the Marvel Universe. The fact that other authors incorporate these concepts proves their significance and validity as part of Canon.

Conclude with Suggestions
Therefore, saying J.M. DeMatteis’ works aren’t Canon appears to be a subjective judgment rather than an evidence-based conclusion. If you want to refute their importance, you need concrete evidence that Marvel officially disregards them as Canon. However, based on existing material, DeMatteis’ works are integral to Marvel Cosmology and add substantial depth to the Marvel Universe.

Marvel Handbooks and Official Guides
Many concepts introduced by J.M. DeMatteis have been cited in official Marvel Handbooks and guides, reinforcing their status as part of the canon, at least within the context of the Multiverse.

"Referenced in Mainstream Storylines"

"Doctor Strange: Into Shamballa has been acknowledged as part of Doctor Strange history."

The Far Shore and the “Realm Beyond Dimensions” have been continuously utilized in Marvel broader Cosmology.

Editorial and Creative Intent
While Marvel has not directly stated that “everything” J.M. wrote is Canon, Marvel’s policy generally does not involve outright erasing Multiverse content. Officially published concepts remain canon unless explicitly retconned or removed, which has not happened with J.M. DeMatteis’ contributions.
 
Last edited:
I do agree with your take, but, it's pretty evident Avengers: Beyond took place before Defenders: Beyond. So, Beyonder is still ever as powerful when he left the House of Ideas.
Really? I thought that it happened afterwards, which did not make any thematic sense whatsoever, but I thought that it was just horrible quality and extremely biased writing. 🙏
 
Also, DeMatteis's stories are mostly canon, but they are cosmologically incompatible with the more official mainstream interpretation, much like Jim Starlin's latest series of Marvel Comics works, so we have to consider them separate for practical reasons. 🙏
 
Last edited:
Question the Definition of “Canon”
What exactly is your definition of 'Canon'? In Marvel Comics, the term 'Canon' is not rigidly defined by a single author or storyline. Marvel Multiverse operates on the concept of countless parallel universes and timelines, including Earth-616 (the main continuity) and infinite other realities. Saying something isn’t Canon requires clear criteria, which Marvel itself often leaves ambiguous.

Point Out DeMatteis’ Official Marvel Publications
J.M. DeMatteis’ works have been officially published by Marvel Comics, including stories that introduced concepts like The Far Shore and The White Hot Room. These ideas have expanded the Marvel Universe in significant ways. Claiming his works aren’t Canon disregards the fact that Marvel itself approved and published these stories as part of its universe.

Highlight His Contribution to Marvel Cosmology
J.M. DeMatteis played a pivotal role in expanding Marvel Cosmology, particularly in exploring philosophical and higher dimensional concepts. For instance, The Far Shore is described as a realm beyond all dimensions, a place that even beings like Eternity and Infinity acknowledge as superior. Dismissing these contributions undermines the depth they bring to Marvel narrative structure.

Use Examples from Marvel Supporting DeMatteis’ Ideas
Looking closely, DeMatteis’ ideas have been referenced by other Marvel writers, such as Jonathan Hickman and Al Ewing. For example, The House of Ideas was prominently featured in Immortal Hulk and described as the source of everything in the Marvel Universe. The fact that other authors incorporate these concepts proves their significance and validity as part of Canon.

Conclude with Suggestions
Therefore, saying J.M. DeMatteis’ works aren’t Canon appears to be a subjective judgment rather than an evidence-based conclusion. If you want to refute their importance, you need concrete evidence that Marvel officially disregards them as Canon. However, based on existing material, DeMatteis’ works are integral to Marvel Cosmology and add substantial depth to the Marvel Universe.

Marvel Handbooks and Official Guides
Many concepts introduced by J.M. DeMatteis have been cited in official Marvel Handbooks and guides, reinforcing their status as part of the canon, at least within the context of the Multiverse.

"Referenced in Mainstream Storylines"

"Doctor Strange: Into Shamballa has been acknowledged as part of Doctor Strange history."

The Far Shore and the “Realm Beyond Dimensions” have been continuously utilized in Marvel broader Cosmology.

Editorial and Creative Intent
While Marvel has not directly stated that “everything” J.M. wrote is Canon, Marvel’s policy generally does not involve outright erasing Multiverse content. Officially published concepts remain canon unless explicitly retconned or removed, which has not happened with J.M. DeMatteis’ contributions.
This place isn't to voice your concern about canon. If you think otherwise then make a CRT yourselves.
 
Some abstract entities should be 1-A+, but the Omniverse itself should still be classified as H1-A, as Universal-Eternities (1-A+) are merely cells within the Omniverse/Eternity, which is too vast and varied to be scaled as 1-A+. The Omniverse should remain H1-A because it contains many distinct 1-A+ realms and entities within it. And those who could threaten the Omniverse should still be classified as H1-A.
Being a “merely a cell” is quantitative. The comparison between 1-A to High 1-A isn't size-based. Anymore than how each layer of 1-A is more conceptualized or invoked R>F and High 1-A separate itself as an entirely different framework. None of those meet the qualifications.
Oblivion
The Void/Darkness/Outside


The Void should also be regarded as H1-A, as it is endless, even for Eternity (Omniverse) . Oblivion is also connected to primordial chaos and freedom, as his aspect, the Chaos King, embodies primordial chaos. In Chaos War, Oblivion was also called 'Chaos.' This connection might extend to The Abyss, the realm of pure chaos and freedom. Therefore, the Void may encompass nearly all planes of existence, except The House of Ideas, as the destination where the WHR returns when it dies and is reborn is darkness. The Handbook also states that the Void is the birthplace of the Phoenix (WHR).This means the Void is larger than the WHR and The Beyond.
None of that is High 1-A. We don't use voids as a basis for High 1-A without any further context. What you said isn't really High 1-A since some Abstracts can survive in the Void for a short while instead of being inaccessible to them.
The White Hot Room should still be H1-A, as it represents all things and all places. It is the plane where the creativity exists, and part of it functions as the 'White Paper' for the creations/stories. Even the Beyonder, a being of immense power, views the higher planes of existence (such as the White Hot Room and the Abyss) as a Multiverse.
Still part of the same hierarchy.
The House of Ideas and TOAA should be considered H1-A+ rather than just H1-A , as he's above all plane of existence.
No.
 
Being a “merely a cell” is quantitative. The comparison between 1-A to High 1-A isn't size-based. Anymore than how each layer of 1-A is more conceptualized or invoked R>F and High 1-A separate itself as an entirely different framework. None of those meet the qualifications.
As I mentioned, the Omniverse encompasses many layers- many planes of existence, including Abstract Entities, Eternities, Mystic Realms, the Megaverse (Multiverses within Multiverses), the Far Shore, and the Neutral Zone. These are all aspects of the larger Omniverse, each existing within its own hierarchical layers, with various high-level layers. Therefore, I don't believe the Omniverse should be classified as Outerverse-level, as it contains all of these (1-A+) layers.

None of that is High 1-A. We don't use voids as a basis for High 1-A without any further context. What you said isn't really High 1-A since some Abstracts can survive in the Void for a short while instead of being inaccessible to them.
A high-level plane of existence like the House of Ideas is classified as H1-A, and yet any being can still enter it.
Ok, agree.
 
As I mentioned, the Omniverse encompasses many layers- many planes of existence, including Abstract Entities, Eternities, Mystic Realms, the Megaverse (Multiverses within Multiverses), the Far Shore, and the Neutral Zone. These are all aspects of the larger Omniverse, each existing within its own hierarchical layers, with various high-level layers. Therefore, I don't believe the Omniverse should be classified as Outerverse-level, as it contains all of these layers.
Yeah, that's not what makes them qualitative in nature unless you have some scans showing it.
A high-level plane of existence like the House of Ideas is classified as H1-A, and yet any being can still enter it.
That would be more of a disqualifier that the House isn't High 1-A then upgrading the previous realms. However, they weren't randomly just taken to any of those realms without reason.
 
Yeah, that's not what makes them qualitative in nature unless you have some scans showing it.
The concept of the Omniverse is far more complex than just being classified as 1-A+. In reality, it exists within a vast hierarchy of planes of existence, with each plane representing a different layer of reality. For instance, Earth-616 is a fictional universe within the larger construct of Eternity's eternal imagination with all realities being narratives and dreams of Eternity. The Astral Plane is a higher frequency of reality, unbound by time or space, representing the realm of Ideas, Thoughts, and Narratives, while serving as a foundational layer of Earth-616's existence. Furthermore, the World Pool is a realm containing various comic books, each representing different possibilities and realities that lie within the Nexus. These realms, including the Superflow and the Neutral Zone, are part of an even larger, interconnected structure that exists beneath the Omniverse. So the Omniverse should be considered as H1-A, not just 1-A+, reflecting its vastness and complexity within a greater, multi-layered hierarchy of existence.
 
Last edited:
The concept of the Omniverse is far more complex than just being classified as 1-A+. In reality, it exists within a vast hierarchy of planes of existence, with each plane representing a different layer of reality. For instance, Earth-616 is a fictional universe within the larger construct of Eternity's eternal imagination with all realities being narratives and dreams of Eternity. The Astral Plane is a higher frequency of reality, unbound by time or space, representing the realm of Ideas, Thoughts, and Narratives, while serving as a foundational layer of Earth-616's existence. Furthermore, the World Pool is a realm containing various comic books, each representing different possibilities and realities that lie within the Nexus. These realms, including the Superflow and the Natural Zone, are part of an even larger, interconnected structure that exists beneath the Omniverse. So the Omniverse should be considered as H1-A, not just 1-A+, reflecting its vastness and complexity within a greater, multi-layered hierarchy of existence.
No. Just no.

The second, third, and fourth links are broken.

The first scan is meant to entail some sort of R>F? Treating something as fictional as a metafictional joke isn’t 1-A.

As for the World Pool scans the only thing I could take from that is “our world is a dreamscape of a higher mind.” However, nothing of the a sort of “hierarchy” is involved. So that would just be one layer.
 
No. Just no.
Whyy
The second, third, and fourth links are broken.
Sorry- I've already fixed that.
The first scan is meant to entail some sort of R>F? Treating something as fictional as a metafictional joke isn’t 1-A.
My point is the concept of the Omniverse is far more intricate than simply being categorized as 1-A+. The realities within the Omniverse form a vast hierarchy of planes of existence, where each plane represents a distinct layer of reality , dream and narrative . As such, the Omniverse should be classified as H1-A, rather than 1-A+, to better reflect its immense complexity and its position within a greater, multi-tiered hierarchy of 1-A existence.
As for the World Pool scans the only thing I could take from that is “our world is a dreamscape of a higher mind.” However, nothing of the a sort of “hierarchy” is involved. So that would just be one layer.
These comic books represent entire realities, and my point is that these exist within a larger and higher plane of existence “ the Omniverse ”.
 
Last edited:
My point is the concept of the Omniverse is far more intricate than simply being categorized as 1-A+. Reality- It exists within a vast hierarchy of planes of existence, where each plane represents a distinct layer of reality , dream and narrative . As such, the Omniverse should be classified as H1-A, rather than 1-A+, to better reflect its immense complexity and its position within a greater, multi-tiered hierarchy of 1-A existence.
Yeah, I've checked the scans, and only the “dream” things seem like a case. However, I said it before that's all the same transcendence which would only gain a few layers as oppose to grant an entirely different tier.
These comic books represent entire realities, and my point is that these exist within a larger and higher plane of existence “ the Omniverse ”.
A reality being smaller than another higher one without any R>F isn't 1-A.
 
Yeah, I've checked the scans, and only the “dream” things seem like a case. However, I said it before that's all the same transcendence which would only gain a few layers as oppose to grant an entirely different tier.
A reality being smaller than another higher one without any R>F isn't 1-A.
The first scan is meant to entail some sort of R>F? Treating something as fictional as a metafictional joke isn’t 1-A.
Realities are Eternities.

Note:Characters like Gwenpool, who possess power comparable to the Scarlet Witch, have stated that they can manipulate reality beyond the panel. This suggests that Earth-616 is much like a 'panel'—a fictional construct—since the Scarlet Witch's power allows her to alter the very fabric of Earth-616.

When traveling beyond Earth-616, it can be perceived as a mere panel, a fictional construct. The universe becomes just one layer among countless other boundless Eternities within the greater Omniverse, where multiple dimensions, realms, and realities coexist and interact, each existing simultaneously but on different planes.

And there are realms that exist beyond space-time, above the Eternities. Existence within the Omniverse has different layered structures of 1-A, which is why the Omniverse should be H1-A.
 
Realities are Eternities.

Note:Characters like Gwenpool, who possess power comparable to the Scarlet Witch, have stated that they can manipulate reality beyond the panel. This suggests that Earth-616 is much like a 'panel'—a fictional construct—since the Scarlet Witch's power allows her to alter the very fabric of Earth-616.
Earth-616 I recall is 1-A due to containing the Astral Plane. Which at that point I don't know where the baseline level of existence comes from, but in other instances this could catapult someone to High 1-A. In this instance, it is not an entirely different plane beyond the notion of quality transendence which Gwenpool follows as well. Unless, you're telling me Gwen scales to the One Above All which cannot suffice everyone to go up in tier because there's no logical coherence in that.
When traveling beyond Earth-616, it can be perceived as a mere panel, a fictional construct. The universe becomes just one layer among countless other boundless Eternities within the greater Omniverse, where multiple dimensions, realms, and realities coexist and interact, each existing simultaneously but on different planes.
Didn't we discuss this? That's only granting an additional layer. You would provide all of the higher realms share the same quality.
And there are realms that exist beyond space-time, above the Eternities. Existence within the Omniverse has different layered structures of 1-A, which is why the Omniverse should be H1-A.
Beyond space-time only with qualitative transcendence whether through conceptuality or R>F is 1-A. Being “layered” isn't indicative of that.
 
Earth-616 I recall is 1-A due to containing the Astral Plane. Which at that point I don't know where the baseline level of existence comes from, but in other instances this could catapult someone to High 1-A. In this instance, it is not an entirely different plane beyond the notion of quality transendence which Gwenpool follows as well. Unless, you're telling me Gwen scales to the One Above All which cannot suffice everyone to go up int tier because there's no logical coherence in that.
I thought that a 1-A reality, which is perceived as fictional by higher-dimensional beings, would make Omniverse H1-A.
Didn't we discuss this? That's only granting an additional layer. You would provide all of the higher realms share the same quality.
Beyond space-time only with qualitative transcendence whether through conceptuality or R>F is 1-A. Being “layered” isn't indicative of that.
Ok 🏳️.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top