- 550
- 203
So, the profiles of Obanai Iguro, Muichiro Tokito, Gyomei Himejima, and Kokushibo all have resistance to Enhanced Senses, Analytical Prediction, and Extrasensory Perception (With Transparent World, his intent becomes completely concealed and impossible to detect)
However, this is not true at all. What grants this "intent concealing" is the Selfless State. Not Transparent World. They have never used these nor have been shown to use the ability, so these resistances on the profiles are false. Only Yoriichi, Tanjiro's Father, and Tanjiro himself are confirmed to be Selfless State users.
The abilities are connected, but they don't come together.
Even in the selfless state wiki itself, states;
"However, it is still unclear whether one has to be marked or possess mastery of Sun Breathing in order to achieve this state, though it is implied to be the case."
No one else achieves Selfless State ever, saying they can conceal it, is completely headcanon. The people I listed all have statements from other people confirming it, the others don't.
Another prime example pointing to this is
Only Tanjiro's hair color changes, his eyes lose detail, and his mark grows when he's in the Selfless State. (The state of Anatta.) He loses all emotion on his face and more.
Before:
After:
No other hashira showcases this when they unlock their Transparent world.
Gyomei Examples
Before:
After:
Muichiro Before And After:
Obanai Before & After:
No hair color change, no mark expanding, eyes aren't clear, and there's still an emotion on their faces. I don't even know why I have to argue for this since they aren't even confirmed users, they're just put there with headcanon.
Now you may say;
"But Gyomei and Muichiro threw off Kokushibo by using TPW! That means they concealed themselves."
Well, this would be wrong. Because the manga says they disrupted their blood flow to achieve this; And even then, Kokushibo doesn't detect Battle Spirit, So this wouldn't be proof.
Here are our options.
A) Either remove them from their resistance tab. (The most likely one.)
B) Or point out they cannot conceal their battle spirit/intent.
Of course, these would only apply to Gyomei, Obanai, Muichiro, and Kokushibo.
Yoriichi and Tanjiro would keep these since they are confirmed users of Selfless State.
Agree: 10/1:9 (@SaberPhantasy9, @Dread, @VladTheImmortal, @Naitodesu, @Kin201, @SuperStar, @Ruenas, @wwereymy235, @Milly_Rocking_Bandit- person who made the profiles lol, @CloverDragon03 )
Neutral: 0/0:0 ()
Disagree: 0/0:0 ()
However, this is not true at all. What grants this "intent concealing" is the Selfless State. Not Transparent World. They have never used these nor have been shown to use the ability, so these resistances on the profiles are false. Only Yoriichi, Tanjiro's Father, and Tanjiro himself are confirmed to be Selfless State users.
The abilities are connected, but they don't come together.
Even in the selfless state wiki itself, states;
"However, it is still unclear whether one has to be marked or possess mastery of Sun Breathing in order to achieve this state, though it is implied to be the case."
No one else achieves Selfless State ever, saying they can conceal it, is completely headcanon. The people I listed all have statements from other people confirming it, the others don't.
Another prime example pointing to this is
Only Tanjiro's hair color changes, his eyes lose detail, and his mark grows when he's in the Selfless State. (The state of Anatta.) He loses all emotion on his face and more.
Before:
After:
No other hashira showcases this when they unlock their Transparent world.
Gyomei Examples
Before:
After:
Muichiro Before And After:
Obanai Before & After:
No hair color change, no mark expanding, eyes aren't clear, and there's still an emotion on their faces. I don't even know why I have to argue for this since they aren't even confirmed users, they're just put there with headcanon.
Now you may say;
"But Gyomei and Muichiro threw off Kokushibo by using TPW! That means they concealed themselves."
Well, this would be wrong. Because the manga says they disrupted their blood flow to achieve this; And even then, Kokushibo doesn't detect Battle Spirit, So this wouldn't be proof.
Here are our options.
A) Either remove them from their resistance tab. (The most likely one.)
B) Or point out they cannot conceal their battle spirit/intent.
Of course, these would only apply to Gyomei, Obanai, Muichiro, and Kokushibo.
Yoriichi and Tanjiro would keep these since they are confirmed users of Selfless State.
Agree: 10/1:9 (@SaberPhantasy9, @Dread, @VladTheImmortal, @Naitodesu, @Kin201, @SuperStar, @Ruenas, @wwereymy235, @Milly_Rocking_Bandit- person who made the profiles lol, @CloverDragon03 )
Neutral: 0/0:0 ()
Disagree: 0/0:0 ()
Last edited:
