- 9,253
- 2,731
Everyone should calm the heck down.
1) People have stated their own opinions. Deciding the result is up to debate, and accusing others of being fanboys or haters isn't a debate.
2) " the Everlasting said in the old thread that he didn't 'knew' about Sonic Shuffle, so he's not the most knowledgeable person on the subject"
Yeah, that was in an older thread. Right now his opinion is different. And besides, watching all of Shuffle's cutscenes pretty much gives you enough knowl├▓edge to have an opinion about its tiering.
To be fair though, while Ever has been very helpful to the wiki, and he still is, I can't really say that he can actually have an open debate if he's outside of the wiki. The best he can do is just stating his opinion, which, however, while he may be knowledgeable on Multiversal tiering, doesn't move the thread forward that much.
3) Shuffle's canonicity issue has already been debated and concluded. If anyone disagrees should rather make another thread entirely rather than shifting this one's discussion, as even if Shuffle was non-canon, this thread is still about and would still effect Illumina's Tier and Abilities.
With that said, while I'm still overall unsure, I'm somewhat leaning towards Cal's arguments.
1) People have stated their own opinions. Deciding the result is up to debate, and accusing others of being fanboys or haters isn't a debate.
2) " the Everlasting said in the old thread that he didn't 'knew' about Sonic Shuffle, so he's not the most knowledgeable person on the subject"
Yeah, that was in an older thread. Right now his opinion is different. And besides, watching all of Shuffle's cutscenes pretty much gives you enough knowl├▓edge to have an opinion about its tiering.
To be fair though, while Ever has been very helpful to the wiki, and he still is, I can't really say that he can actually have an open debate if he's outside of the wiki. The best he can do is just stating his opinion, which, however, while he may be knowledgeable on Multiversal tiering, doesn't move the thread forward that much.
3) Shuffle's canonicity issue has already been debated and concluded. If anyone disagrees should rather make another thread entirely rather than shifting this one's discussion, as even if Shuffle was non-canon, this thread is still about and would still effect Illumina's Tier and Abilities.
With that said, while I'm still overall unsure, I'm somewhat leaning towards Cal's arguments.