• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

One Piece: Pre-Timeskip AP Revision

Status
Not open for further replies.
Stefano4444 said:
The energy released come from Luffy, it doesn't come from the giant gold ball.

Like if i throw a basket ball and destroy a skyscraper, are you going to argue that the power behind come from the basket ball?
Click to expand...
But a lot of the punching power came from the giant ball.

I mean, kinetic energy is mass * .5 * velocity^2, and that giant gold ball added a LOT of mass that Luffy didn't have otherwise pre-timeskip.

I mean, it's similar to how Gear 3rd works TBH
 
Eseseso said:
But a lot of the punching power came from the giant ball.

I mean, kinetic energy is mass * .5 * velocity^2, and that giant gold ball added a LOT of mass that Luffy didn't have otherwise pre-timeskip.
Click to expand...
If Luffy cannot match the force necessary to generate that much energy, he cannot employ enough velocity to the Golden Ball to utilize it's mass. Velocity is the greater factor here. His force without the mass is comparable. It has to be.
 
Eseseso said:
But a lot of the punching power came from the giant ball.

I mean, kinetic energy is mass * .5 * velocity^2, and that giant gold ball added a LOT of mass that Luffy didn't have otherwise pre-timeskip.
Click to expand...
And how was the ball moving? If the ball is moving via Luffy's own strength, it scales to him normally. You can't increase the weight of something you hold to increase your power output unless gravity is involved. If you throw a bowling ball upward at something, the energy it has going up will the same as if you threw a lighter object up as well.

The lighter object will go up farther. But all of that energy comes from the individual itself. If Luffy was taking advantage of gravity, yes this wouldn't scale to him normally. But if he was going up or horizontally/forward. Than he should scale to the feat in general. Because he creates the energy to move it and not gravity.

I don't know about the feat in question. But the question is. Did Luffy use gravity to assist him, or was it all himself? If it was all himself than that scales to him since he is the one generating that energy. If it was gravity than we cannot scale, since he was taking advantage of the energy generated by falling.

I don't know much about One-Piece, but just wanted to share my thoughts on that.
 
GodlyCharmander said:
If Luffy cannot match the force necessary to generate that much energy, he cannot employ enough velocity to the Golden Ball to utilize it's mass. Velocity is the greater factor here. His force without the mass is comparable. It has to be.
Click to expand...
TheRustyOne said:
And how was the ball moving? If the ball is moving via Luffy's own strength, it scales to him normally. You can't increase the weight of something you hold to increase your power output unless gravity is involved. If you throw a bowling ball upward at something, the energy it has going up will the same as if you threw a lighter object up as well.

The lighter object will go up farther. But all of that energy comes from the individual itself. If Luffy was taking advantage of gravity, yes this wouldn't scale to him normally. But if he was going up or horizontally/forward. Than he should scale to the feat in general. Because he creates the energy to move it and not gravity.

I don't know about the feat in question. But the question is. Did Luffy use gravity to assist him, or was it all himself? If it was all himself than that scales to him since he is the one generating that energy. If it was gravity than we cannot scale, since he was taking advantage of the energy generated by falling.

I don't know much about One-Piece, but just wanted to share my thoughts on that.
Click to expand...
Ok, those are some fair points.

I drop my issue, although we should wait for further input to see if the mods find it ok.
 
TheRustyOne said:
And how was the ball moving? If the ball is moving via Luffy's own strength, it scales to him normally. You can't increase the weight of something you hold to increase your power output unless gravity is involved. If you throw a bowling ball upward at something, the energy it has going up will the same as if you threw a lighter object up as well.

The lighter object will go up farther. But all of that energy comes from the individual itself. If Luffy was taking advantage of gravity, yes this wouldn't scale to him normally. But if he was going up or horizontally/forward. Than he should scale to the feat in general. Because he creates the energy to move it and not gravity.

I don't know about the feat in question. But the question is. Did Luffy use gravity to assist him, or was it all himself? If it was all himself than that scales to him since he is the one generating that energy. If it was gravity than we cannot scale, since he was taking advantage of the energy generated by falling.

I don't know much about One-Piece, but just wanted to share my thoughts on that.
Click to expand...
The Golden Ball was quite literally stuck to this man's wrist. He did a punch forward.
 
TheRustyOne said:
And how was the ball moving? If the ball is moving via Luffy's own strength, it scales to him normally. You can't increase the weight of something you hold to increase your power output unless gravity is involved. If you throw a bowling ball upward at something, the energy it has going up will the same as if you threw a lighter object up as well.

The lighter object will go up farther. But all of that energy comes from the individual itself. If Luffy was taking advantage of gravity, yes this wouldn't scale to him normally. But if he was going up or horizontally/forward. Than he should scale to the feat in general. Because he creates the energy to move it and not gravity.

I don't know about the feat in question. But the question is. Did Luffy use gravity to assist him, or was it all himself? If it was all himself than that scales to him since he is the one generating that energy. If it was gravity than we cannot scale, since he was taking advantage of the energy generated by falling.

I don't know much about One-Piece, but just wanted to share my thoughts on that.
Click to expand...
Context
0298-009.png
0298-010.png
0298-011.png
0298-013.png


He threw the ball hard enough to break the ball, the entire force of the moving ball was caused directly by him
 
KingTempest said:
One shot territory is not 7.5x. One shot territory in Versus Threads is 7.5x. That isn't correlated into powerscaling.
Click to expand...
This was a shower thought I had earlier. Assuming 7.5x is a one-shot thing in every verse is definitely ffar fetched considering dudes in DBZ can't one shot each other with x50/100 multipliers. Other verses are like this as well.


KingTempest said:
He threw the ball hard enough to break the ball, the entire force of the moving ball was caused directly by him
Click to expand...
Adding to that, he was also going UPWARDS, meaning Gravity was a non-factor in aiding Luffy to swing easier or just carry it forward enough and let gravity do the rest. The entire feat was Luffy's strength through and through.
 
For further explanation.

This is the Luffy who one shot Enel.

As it stands I've been working on Skypiea scaling, and Luffy's reactive power level / accelerated development heavily is impacted towards the end of the arc.

End of Skypiea Luffy one shot Enel who did this to Wyper's skate, same skate that blocked hits from an earlier Luffy.

This scales probably to the likes of Foxy and the W7-EL and above people, but definitely not to anybody that resides in Skypiea like Wyper, Priests, Zoro, etc.
 
KingTempest said:
For further explanation.

This is the Luffy who one shot Enel.

As it stands I've been working on Skypiea scaling, and Luffy's reactive power level / accelerated development heavily is impacted towards the end of the arc.

End of Skypiea Luffy one shot Enel who did this to Wyper's skate, same skate that blocked hits from an earlier Luffy.

This scales probably to the likes of Foxy and the W7-EL and above people, but definitely not to anybody that resides in Skypiea like Wyper, Priests, Zoro, etc.
Click to expand...
Are there other examples for such a massive evolution?
 
I am late to this, but I only want to say that I kinda Agree with everything except scaling CP9 to Golden Rifle

In my opinion, that attack should be his own thing, like Nightmare Luffy, no one should scale to either of those things

Edit: And the Sabaody keys sounds iffy for me, but that is my opinion
 
If the golden rifle is being argued to be luffy's AP, then does that mean we can get a result for the raigo cloud split since I've seen that feat get to absolutely insane results like multi-continental?
 
Kazuma_kuwabara said:
In my opinion, that attack should be his own thing, like Nightmare Luffy, no one should scale to either of those things
Click to expand...
What???? Literally why do you think both things are comparable scenarios in any shape, way or form? Nightmare Luffy is literally Luffy using 100 people's strength on top of his own.
Golden Rifle is him, generating X force, and translating that into Kinetic Energy
 
Kazuma_kuwabara said:
In my opinion, that attack should be his own thing, like Nightmare Luffy, no one should scale to either of those things

Edit: And the Sabaody keys sounds iffy for me, but that is my opinion
Click to expand...
KingTempest said:
Sorry but I request that everyone who keeps filling up the thread with "I don't think we should use the Golden Rifle calc" should go away unless I see genuine reasons.
Click to expand...
 
I am not talking about whether Luffy evolves or not, that I know. What I am asking is if there is such a massive evolution during a battle, which lasts few minutes
 
LIFE_OF_KING said:
I am not talking about whether Luffy evolves or not, that I know. What I am asking is if there is such a massive evolution during a battle, which lasts few minutes
Click to expand...
Doesn’t last a few minutes, it’s just his regular overall growth, and the link I sent shows the growth, especially the Kuro section
 
Okay, can't get into the big stuff tonight but I can clarify that what I'm fine with so far is:

For this one:

Wyper bust through a tree: 1.98 Megatons (Low 7-B)
Click to expand...

I don't think we need to use the scaled average tree width of 140+ meters, since Luffy is actually quite close to the tree in the same panel and could be used for more direct scaling.

I'm going to need to take a closer look at the Chessmarimo stuff and some of the other scaling proposals in the OP, and will comment on them tomorrow in greater detail.
 
LIFE_OF_KING said:
I am not talking about whether Luffy evolves or not, that I know. What I am asking is if there is such a massive evolution during a battle, which lasts few minutes
Click to expand...
While this isn't pre timeskip, Luffy goes from getting one shot and blitzed by Kaido to unlocking CoC infusion and going toe to toe with him in less than 5 minutes (according to the time it was taking for Onigashima to reach Wano capital)
Of the top of my head for pre-TS
Pre timeskip Luffy also took poison that downed him quickly and shrugged off a greater dose during his fight with Crocodile to the point where he wasn't reacting to it at all. Another evolution in a extremely short amount of time.
Those are the first two ones that came to mind when talking about Luffy PHYSICALLY evolving in an absurdly short amount of time.
I'm sure there are other examples but ome likely relate to post-TS, which this thread has nothing to do with.
 
SnookB said:
While this isn't pre timeskip, Luffy goes from getting one shot and blitzed by Kaido to unlocking CoC infusion and going toe to toe with him in less than 5 minutes (according to the time it was taking for Onigashima to reach Wano capital)
Of the top of my head for pre-TS
Pre timeskip Luffy also took poison that downed him quickly and shrugged off a greater dose during his fight with Crocodile to the point where he wasn't reacting to it at all. Another evolution in a extremely short amount of time.
Those are the first two ones that came to mind when talking about Luffy PHYSICALLY evolving in an absurdly short amount of time.
I'm sure there are other examples but ome likely relate to post-TS, which this thread has nothing to do with.
Click to expand...
There is also Water 7/Enies lobby... Where Luffy couldn't react to blueno's soru or match him where in enies lobby could react to him and overpower him in base plus the statement from zoro as well
0383-012.png
0383-013.png
0383-014.png
0383-015.png
0385-008.png
 
MonkeyOfLife said:
There is also Water 7/Enies lobby... Where Luffy couldn't react to blueno's soru or match him where in enies lobby could react to him and overpower him in base plus the statement from zoro as well
0383-012.png
0383-013.png
0383-014.png
0383-015.png
0385-008.png
Click to expand...
He said "in minutes". Between W7 and Enies lobby was a bit, no?
Either way- yeah. Another time he went from not keeping up at all to just dominating his opponent on the next encounter
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

KingTempest
  • Locked
Enies Lobby and Thriller Bark Merge
2
Replies
47
Views
3K
KingTempest
KingTempest
Brogeefrong
You can cut through steel but can you cut through a wall? | Zoro vs The Wall | 1-0-0
Replies
1
Views
1K
That_moron2
That_moron2
RanaProGamer
Adventuring Swordsman Battle |Zoro vs Finn
Replies
5
Views
397
RanaProGamer
RanaProGamer
Eseseso
  • Locked
Pre-TS Base Luffy revision.
Replies
26
Views
2K
LordGriffin1000
LordGriffin1000
Ryuga21
  • Locked
Gear 5th Luffy: Time-Stop ability addition.
Replies
25
Views
5K
Damage3245
Damage3245
Back
Top