- 1,013
- 428
I think the best bet for finding EC's speed would be to compare it to Death Gatling's minigun. I can't think of any other way to find his speed that wouldn't be considered calc staking.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
- 24,475
- 25,521
Wait why the mini gun of all things?
- 1,013
- 428
Garou managed to react and block shots from the gun. Garou had trouble dodging Genos's attacks and EC outsped one of Genos's attacks. So we could find the speed of EC if we compare the beams speed to the minigun and base the speed of the gun off irl miniguns.
- 24,475
- 25,521
Maybe the GPE thing is just the best way to find his AP tbh
- 1,013
- 428
I'm not very good at calcing so I tried just pluging in the accepted values for EC for both KE and GPE and both were well below city level. I wonder if it would be possible to calc the ap for making something as big as EC stop suddenly with a punch like what Bang and Bomb did.
- 2,608
- 859
A quick survey shows that an M134 minigun has a bullet exit speed of 850m / s or supersonic, almost supersonic +
- 1,013
- 428
I tried that value with a KE calculator and only got 300 kilotons. EC would have to be going 3-5 times faster in order to get any kind of upgrades at least based of what I'm using.
- 24,475
- 25,521
Likely no, KING called EC with GPE at 7-A, I'm waiting for them to post the full calc
- 1,013
- 428
7-A with GPE? Shit there's another reason I don't do calcs.
- 24,475
- 25,521
I don't even know how GPE works heh
- 6,125
- 6,132
Guys Saitama is tier 0 and no one else is infinitely below him so everyone is tier 0 by extension.
- 3,996
- 2,789
I've already run some math through. EC would have small city AP scaling Genos's cannons to an GAU-12 Equalizer.
But basically: Garou was able to deflect several hundred, maybe thousands of bullets from death Gatling. He struggled to avoid individual blasts by Genos. Genos's blasts are obviously far faster than Death Gatling's guns and if we choose not to quantify that directly, then we can at least say they are as fast as individual minigun bullets (1040 m/s for HEI GAU-12 30 mm) and find EC's speed to be 1386 m/s, then we multiply that by a more realistic length of 2000 meters and boom, baseline 7-B.
But basically: Garou was able to deflect several hundred, maybe thousands of bullets from death Gatling. He struggled to avoid individual blasts by Genos. Genos's blasts are obviously far faster than Death Gatling's guns and if we choose not to quantify that directly, then we can at least say they are as fast as individual minigun bullets (1040 m/s for HEI GAU-12 30 mm) and find EC's speed to be 1386 m/s, then we multiply that by a more realistic length of 2000 meters and boom, baseline 7-B.
- 1,013
- 428
That's for his pre molt length right? His Post Molt length was calced at over 4000 meters what would that yield?
- 3,996
- 2,789
25 megatons
- 1,983
- 1,233
We could scale it to the meteor beam.
- 24,475
- 25,521
Maybe the GPE method is better? Because with KE, we likely won't get a satisfactory or accurate speed, and even if we do, it's a very low balled speed of EC's true speed, and if we use his actual speed, the ratings become wildly inflated
- 24,475
- 25,521
Is there a way to calculate Orochi's beam speed? I think that could potentially upgrade some as some had to react and defend against Orochi's beams. If they do end up scaling to his beam speed, then it allows Orochi to scale to his attack speed
- 360
- 239
- 24,475
- 25,521
We already use it
- 360
- 239
Okay thanks
- 2,608
- 859
Does anyone know how to convert reaction time to speed?
- 24,475
- 25,521
What do you mean by that?
- 2,608
- 859
In the calculation that USklaverei did, in the end there was something like this:
1.65670167e-9 seconds, or 2.01c (FTL)
1.65670167e-9 seconds, or 2.01c (FTL)
- 3,996
- 2,789
That is Saitama's speed. Or at least it was Saitama's speed until we downgraded Geryuganshoop over the Murata statement, now it's just a 'possibly'.
- 1,289
- 786
Geryuganshoop's relativistic look unreliable
(I'm not talking about the speed of the stones. That's okay. I'm talking about his personal speed of the tentacles in the profile).
I doubt he had time to move before the stones flew to Saitama. Most likely, these movements were performed before the stones were thrown.
(I'm not talking about the speed of the stones. That's okay. I'm talking about his personal speed of the tentacles in the profile).
I doubt he had time to move before the stones flew to Saitama. Most likely, these movements were performed before the stones were thrown.
- 3,996
- 2,789
I don't have a problem with relativistic Geryuganshoop, I see movement lines there and don't see why he couldn't be relativistic or close to it physically.
- 1,289
- 786
The movements on the scan must have been done before throwing stones towards Saitama. After the stones went flying, he froze (in the context of the timeframe, while the stones flew towards Saitama, he froze, static).
At least there is no evidence that he made these movements while the stones flew 15 meters, and not before.
At least there is no evidence that he made these movements while the stones flew 15 meters, and not before.
- 3,996
- 2,789
He's talking in that same panel, I don't see where the implication he's static is coming from. We see him in one position, then in the middle of the rubble shower and the rocks fly at Saitama as he says "Die Earthling!" the fact that Murata put the text in the action panel is more conclusive evidence that Geryuganshoop was moving than anything I can see to the contrary here
Last edited:
- 1,289
- 786
What? How is the fact that his last body position before the throw was such a proof that Geryuganshoop was moving when the stones were thrown? It may well be a movement before the throw. His phrase could likewise be said before the stones were thrown. As evidence in favor of this - anime. In it, Geryuganshoop said this and only then threw stones towards Saitama.
- 1,289
- 786
Plus, doesn't that sound like an outlier to you? This would mean that almost all S-class heroes (except Flash, Genos and Tatsumaki) would be static (or very much slowed down) for him.
- 3,996
- 2,789
We can't see if he's moving before the panel because he's veiled inside the rubble tornado. If he said the line before the movement started, I don't understand why Murata would put the line in the movement panel.
I know you consider MHS and relativistic OPM calcs to be outlierish, but I see no indication he was static and the line is on the movement panel, it'd be simpler to assume he's saying it as he's throwing the stones.
- 3,996
- 2,789
No, I think the upper end heroes are MHS, MHS+ and sub-rel, plus there's no reason Geryuganshoop can't be faster than most of the s-class- many of the threats Saitama puts down would be serious challenges for the s-class and I think Geryuganshoop is in that category via his TK and speed.
- 1,289
- 786
I quite think that the calculations for MHS and MHS+ are correct, in the next update of the profiles (which will begin after solving the issue with relativistic octopus velocities (His name is difficult for the translator to spell, I will call him octopus)). His combat speed through scaling through characters is MHS+, but the speed of throwing stones is Relativistic+, which is the reason why he should be slowed down for stones. And there is no evidence in favor of the movements at the time of the throw. The conversation took place on the same scan, when he just started throwing stones. That is, he could first say this phrase, and then start throwing stones (Just like in the anime). Such moments with words before action are always found in Marvel comics or DS and other mangas.
Geryuganshoop is not the kind of monster that is positioned as a very fast physical. For him, the death of Gloribas and Melzalgald was already a reason to panic and believe that his enemy would be very dangerous for him. But other S-class heroes fought on equal terms with Melzalgald in speed.
The sub-relativistic speeds for the characters in the OPM have long been downgraded to the MHS. Because Garou's feat was calculated through wank method. This has already been accepted.
He would have no reason to panic about Saitama walking in his direction if he were more than 20 times faster than Melzagand and had much higher destructive power through telekinesis. But he could well have panicked that he might not have time to launch stones at Saitama in time, because he easily killed someone with whom the Octopus was comparable in reaction and combat speed.
- 10,497
- 9,053
Yeah, no.
- 1,289
- 786
As many of you know, about 3 weeks ago there was create discussion about downgrade the speed of OPM characters. It was accepted. Now, the updates will come into effect when the speed of Geryuganshoop is discussed. If anyone wants, then please take part in this discussion about the speed of Geryuganshoop.
Sandbox of changed profiles. The profiles of the characters MHS+ Tier have not been made, because they will be ready only if it is decided whether Geryuganshoop's relativistic velocities will be removed or not.
Sandbox of changed profiles. The profiles of the characters MHS+ Tier have not been made, because they will be ready only if it is decided whether Geryuganshoop's relativistic velocities will be removed or not.
- 7,214
- 3,688
Wouldn't Gery need to have comparable reaction time to continuously speed the rocks in a circle like he did and throw them?
- 3,996
- 2,789
Yes, his reaction time must be comparable. If Geryuganshoop is both talking and moving in that panel, it would only make sense if he were perceiving at a comparable speed. The only thing that probably wouldn't scale would be travel speed, since we haven't seen how well Geryuganshoop can transverse long distances.
- 20,026
- 16,595
Throwing something doesn't scale to your reaction speed. Neither does yelling while doing so.
- 3,996
- 2,789
Well if you're a regular sentient, you can't yell faster than you think and not much faster than you perceive. But let me guess, we'll have to list Geryuganshoop's reaction speed as unknown because we don't have any concrete feats in that field
- 24,475
- 25,521
Bumping this
