- 20,597
- 17,590
We'll list it at MHS+ since that's what scales to.
The rocks are thrown with a superpower that negates friction. He doesn't move with said power or react to a attack with a similar speed, so why should we scale him to the rocks?
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
The rocks are thrown with a superpower that negates friction. He doesn't move with said power or react to a attack with a similar speed, so why should we scale him to the rocks?
- 2,938
- 1,400
Where does MHS + come from?
- 25,061
- 27,173
Him being superior to demons like bug god
- 2,938
- 1,400
There is, but now it is being denied and it will be HS / MHS
- 11,559
- 10,996
Samurai Atomic
- 2,938
- 1,400
It was not accepted and only scale your attack speed with a sword
- 25,061
- 27,173
Why attack speed tho? Why not combat speed? I don't see any indication that it would only be attack speed
- 4,037
- 2,842
Ah I get you now. We've just been making the case that Geryuganshoop is not only moving rocks at rel+ speeds, but also that Geryuganshoop is moving his own tentacles and talking within a relativistic timeframe. If you can notably move and talk at relativistic speeds, wouldn't it be more likely that you could perceive at those speeds as opposed to MHS+? I don't see why his reaction time would be magnitudes slower than his attack speed when it is presented in this way and there's nothing narratively suggested he thinks and perceives that much slower than he is acting
- 2,938
- 1,400
Because Atomic has a lot more speed moving your arm than your whole body and that is evident, you know that yourself.
- 20,597
- 17,590
The Black Sperm fight is the best indication that AS can attack much faster than he can move. In the timespan it takes BS to throw a punch, AS can cut him hundreds if not thousands of times. But is still unable to physically avoid the incoming punch. So AS can swing his sword to a far greater degree than he can move his body.
The possibility of him not scaling to his TK speed is why there's no hard confirmation on his speed. I'm not against the rating existing, but making it his base rating is questionable in my view.
- 25,061
- 27,173
Fair I guess
- 25,061
- 27,173
Also any thoughts on this?
- 2,938
- 1,400
I tried to look for something to calculate it, but I didn't find something that is relevant
- 25,061
- 27,173
Well that's an oof
- 11,559
- 10,996
Does Elder Centipede have any size in phase 1 and 2 calculated?
- 1,013
- 428
As far as I could find no. The only size calc for him is for his post molt form. Also why does EC have unknown range? Shouldn't his range be at least hundreds of meters via large size type 3?
- 25,061
- 27,173
Wasn't there a calc for Post Molt EC?
- 12,316
- 11,261
Yo, what'd I miss?
- 25,061
- 27,173
Not much honestly, we're very slow with calcs and speed thus far. I need to compile all the things we need to calc.
- 25,061
- 27,173
Also would psykorochi vs Godzilla earth be a good idea?
- 11,559
- 10,996
Yes. But EC has 3 transformations
- 25,061
- 27,173
Really? I only recall 2. Which is the 3rd?
- 2,975
- 928
What is the Psykorochi AP? As far as I’ve checked, it’s a stomp
- 25,061
- 27,173
It ain't. Psykorochi is 254 petatons
- 25,061
- 27,173
- 4,037
- 2,842
I feel like I scaled his length somewhere... I will look for it. Do you have the updated EC GPE calc they were talking about earlier?
- 11,559
- 10,996
Not yet. Just to be sure. I'll only be able to use a computer on Monday.
- 4,037
- 2,842
There is no image of pre-molt EC fully above ground, the clearest image of pre-molt's body is here and only a fraction of it is above ground: .
Above Ground+ on screen length is 1229.7 meters, I got similar results pixel scaling another image. I would guess the whole body would be 2-3 km long, since at least half would be A) underground or just B) offscreen.
Don't think the CGMs would like a partial length though, it's tricky.
Above Ground+ on screen length is 1229.7 meters, I got similar results pixel scaling another image. I would guess the whole body would be 2-3 km long, since at least half would be A) underground or just B) offscreen.
Don't think the CGMs would like a partial length though, it's tricky.
- 25,061
- 27,173
I hope that we eventually get an official length, but I get the feeling it'll be listed as something like 100 meters lol
- 4,037
- 2,842
Probably would be something like that. They really seem to like nice, even numbers like 50 meters, 100 meters, 1000 meters
I doubt we ever will, given how much time has elapsed since then.
- 25,061
- 27,173
Anyways, do you have suggestions for this?
- 4,037
- 2,842
I wish I did...
- 1,289
- 786
Someone above asked why Hero MHS +. He scales up to the rest of his companions, and Melzagand can be caught with Bang, which scales up to the Atomic Samurai, which deflected the beams of the weakened Psykorochi. This was approved by 3 calk members in the discussion.
- 25,061
- 27,173
- 1,289
- 786
Why does everyone say that Geru shouted the phrase after throwing stones? He could scream a moment before throwing stones, this is even confirmed by the anime.
- 1,289
- 786
the translator translated the name Gelgan (Octopus subordinate of Boros) as "HERO".
- 25,061
- 27,173
1. The Anime scene is pretty different than the Manga, and should not be compared
2, I'm pretty Geryu was shouting when he was attacking
2, I'm pretty Geryu was shouting when he was attacking
- 25,061
- 27,173
I thought he scales to MHS only?
EDIT: Actually no, he seems to scale to HH+, my bad
- 1,289
- 786
The only difference is that in the anime it was with the computers, in a special room. In the manga, it was in Boros' throne room. The moment of the throw is exactly the same.
Okay, even so. He would not be afraid of a fight with Saitama because he killed Gloribas, if Gelganshp himself was 23 times faster than Gloribas. After all, it is obvious that his destructive power is much higher than that of Gloribas. And the speed is apparently comparable to him, which is why he was afraid that Saitama would have time to attack and kill him earlier.
In addition. Genos in 10 second mode does not get faster than he was. Kuseno drove all his skill points in 10 second mode only into destructive power, as he himself said. He didn't improve defense or speed. That is why it was dangerous for Genos to use this mode, because his body would not stand it. That is, he reacted well to the rays of Psykorochi thanks to his own speed. The weakened Psykorochi, although much weaker than her original form, can still run away from Genos, making her equal in speed. The Atomic Samurai easily reflects her beams and attacks her with the Beeline Atomic Slash faster than she reacts. Bang scales to Atomic Samurai.
Would you like to say that all the above-named characters are "possibly relativistic"?
- 25,061
- 27,173
Hm, I might just wait for what the others think, but if this all gets accepted, I'll make a seperate thread on possibly relativistic and who scales
