Jiraiya
Jiraiya initially wasn't even trying to kill anybody. He went to go gather intel and he was
talking to Konan. When he met Nagato again he
tried to have conversation. Even when half dead he
wanted to go confirm if the dudes he were fighting were the real ones.
WHILE HE'S DYING he's thinking about getting info out.
Whole time, they wanted to kill Jiraiya.
Against Jiraiya they completely countered him. He states that they
know his weaknesses.
The one minute they confirm that
they don't know something about Jiraiya, the Jutsu
kills three of them.
While he's injured,
he kills one of them.
And his props?
And can we remember that Jiraiya went in there alone? Summoned 3 people and that's it?
Naruto
Pain was far away from the source body and he used a
life axing jutsu in the beginning of the fight. Konan states that
the other paths recover slower after Nagato focused all their chakra on Tendo.
Pain was not trying to kill Naruto.
- We see on several occasions that Akatsuki fight Jinchuriki and don't intend to kill them.
- We see this in the fight as well.
- The pains didn't try any lethal techniques.
- So Pain wasn't trying to kill him.
And for every Naruto thread I've witnessed, not trying to kill = holding back pretty much. So Pain was holding back on Naruto.
Naruto came in the fight
with help. He had Fukasaku, Shima, Gamabunta, Gamaken, and Gamahiro come help him. Unlike Jiraiya who came alone.
Naruto had a way to bypass all of Jiraiya's issues.
- Jiraiya's taijutsu couldn't work because the Pain would just dodge/block his attacks, and ninjutsu didn't work on him either because he would've absorbed it.
- Jiraiya struggled with overcoming the sight of the Paths.
- Jiraiya was on his own most of the time
- Jiraiya needed prior knowledge to win.
In Conclusion
Using these statements for strength when in a powerscaling perspective, Jiraiya is superior, is an issue.
It'd be unfair to take the other statements into strict evaluation but to allow this statement to be 100% for AP.
The most it'd be for is for the rasenshuriken.