- 3,552
- 3,402
Yeah, it ends up with them thinking:
- Gilgamesh has no fighting skill
- Gilgamesh is one trick pony
- He's meh outside of EA
- SHIROU STRONK, WRITE FANFIC ABOUT STRONK SHIROU
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Nasuverse Discussion Board (New Forum)
- Thread starter DemonGodMitchAubin
- Start date
- 39,691
- 15,627
I'm surprised that you guys put Apocrypha at that high score, so many wasted potential everywhere, Sieg and Atalanta are f***ing trash, and the OST is just a glorified roman things zzzzz
- 231
- 101
I have heard that EA does not even pass Large Mountain.
- 4,524
- 2,242
I actually liked Apocrypha tbh. I didn't think it was nearly that bad. It was good. Of course, I've also only played it once and it was a while ago, so I could be missing something
- 4,524
- 2,242
Funny enough, Gil was one of the worst characters in FSN for me. He only really evolved into a chad in Fate Zero onwards
- 231
- 101
Gilgamesh became a chad to me at the end of Babylon, when he with his pierced chest mocks for Tiamat's laser.
- 3,552
- 3,402
Yeah, he was fun as an "invincible villain" character, but Babylonia was when me and my friends really liked him.
- 967
- 372
I tend to side with the argument that true name release Ea shouldn't have AP because it doesn't matter. World goes brrrr, if you are in said area, brrrr you go.
- 967
- 372
Fate games, for as bad as their gameplay is, is where Gil shines as a true chadlord.
Rakih_Elyan
He/Him- 4,485
- 3,096
- 5,415
- 6,222
I need Shirou x EMIYA fics
Rakih_Elyan
He/Him- 4,485
- 3,096
That shit is too many bro...
You underestimate the power of fujoshi fic writer's.
- 3,552
- 3,402
...huh?
Rakih_Elyan
He/Him- 4,485
- 3,096
Eye bleach material fic that recommended to me by my friend.
Tdjwo
He/Him- 3,180
- 1,299
I love Apocrypha ngl. I love the character like Karna, Jeanne, Sieg(not the MC), mordred, Amakusa Shirou and Chiron. The OSTS are one of the best in Fate. Atlanta was trash indeed.
Tdjwo
He/Him- 3,180
- 1,299
Tdjwo
He/Him- 3,180
- 1,299
Gil has always been a Chad from day 1
- 4,524
- 2,242
nah, he was pretty mid in FSN imo. He was okay in UBW but that’s about it. He becomes an easy 9/10 character after Fate Zero which not only makes him an interesting character but gives him actual depth
- 39,691
- 15,627
I know it's matter of taste but overall by the community Apocrypha is the worst albeit not the trash one like Last Encore, it still has many charming points like the many of servants there like you mentioned, but as said, it does has a lot's of missed and wasted potentials
The writting is also very mid too, characterization is all over the place with only Amakusa has the best one
OST is mid too, and if we see the best Fate's OST then i'll give it to Ufotable Stay Night and Zero, and likely Strange Fake will be on top of it as well with Sawano on the list
Heck, even FGO has a better OST than Apocrypha
As for Atalanta, while you have the same mindset, i have one factor that i hate Atalanta deeply due of Apocrypha bad writting, not even her Berserker version in LB1 is a saving grace for me, the fact that i used to hate Nero, Alcides, and Siegfried but now i'm very acknowledged the three (with Alcides and Draco as my faves) show how f***ed up Atalanta roles are
Semiramis is came to close but that's more of the reason of how FGO fanbase back then overhyped her (like "hurr durr her double class will be best gimmick", "Hanging Garden will be so good" etc) and when she's finally debuted, she's so low tier as heck and now peoples barely talk about her in present times, so rather than hate, it's more of pity instead, and combined with Apocrypha reputation, no wonder why
- 4,060
- 1,713
why ya all hate extra last encore so much. I just love it's animation
Tdjwo
He/Him- 3,180
- 1,299
Not only do I not really like Nero, but the plot, characters, and its very existence itself was so bad I couldn't believe I was watching Fate. The worst Nasuverse content of all time. It makes the first FGO movie look good.
- 4,524
- 2,242
Nero's fine, but yeah everything else is dogwater. The only reason I don't think it's garbage is because it's better than garbage tier stories that I've read. It's like a 3, which is still bad.
- 10,984
- 4,945
don`t forget spacebattles as well.
it got nuked but there is a thread to recreate it. They are getting back to 1A-High 1A tier it just that there is too much tier 1 threads for other verses that staff barely even enter that thread its been sitting there for months with just a few staff input
- 4,524
- 2,242
spacebattles doesn't even believe in dimensional tiering so that's not really fair to begin with
It seems like there's basically universal agreement for it being High 1A iirc
- 10,984
- 4,945
its more the lowballing part
- 967
- 372
Mooncell isn't even confirmed to exist in FGO timelines. Even if she did, whatever she does as a Servant isn't the real thing itself.
I don't even wanna go into the continuity shit show that is Mooncell + Archetype: Earth/Arcueid being in the same "universe", but I think it's obvious none of the things BB does as a Servant are directly derived from Mooncell existing and acting.
- 967
- 372
And I can bet you I understand the math/physics part better than most.
- 5,415
- 6,222
Mooncell is literally stated to exist in another parallel world or timeline in FGO though.
- 967
- 372
I mean in the timeline the story is taking place. The problem is that either answers (FGO is a Mooncell timeline or FGO is a Crimson Moon timeline) results in some degree of non-sense.
And isn't it an Adjacent World? I can never remember for my life which one is it in these cases.
- 6,045
- 3,071
Quoting her BB in game profile
Not to mention all the other events where the Mooncell gang get involved, the thing exist in FGO and is brought all the time so objetively speaking it exist, because we are quite literally told so. This isn't something open to debate, is a fact, so I'm not going to argue over it.
- 967
- 372
You do understand EITHER WAY the answer makes something make no sense, right?
Okay, Mooncell exists. - Archetype: EARTH/Arcueid
No, Crimson Moon exists. - B.B.
It's not even a question of which one is right or wrong. Unless you wanna argue that there's two Moons. Your answer is simplistic at best and completely denies the real problem.
Okay, Mooncell exists. - Archetype: EARTH/Arcueid
No, Crimson Moon exists. - B.B.
It's not even a question of which one is right or wrong. Unless you wanna argue that there's two Moons. Your answer is simplistic at best and completely denies the real problem.
- 6,045
- 3,071
My answer is literally what the game itself state.
- 6,045
- 3,071
If you want a more in-depth answer then our BB (and Mooncell gang) are from another timeline (as showed for example by the surprise of everyone about the existence of a not cursed Kiara, though at the end she still ended as ****** up as the original one, or by how Hakuno affected our timelines from his/her own). And the Arcueid we summon is from our timeline (except the second ascension which is basically stated to be just for fan-service, like how Mash was added to the fighting game).
- 967
- 372
Where in the game exactly is that stated that Arch: EARTH is from out timeline?
"basically stated to be fan-service" doesn't change much, as you could say the exact same thing for the cross references and re-use of characters from Fate games.
Maxeez
He/Him- 499
- 197
Thing is, the characters outside of Shiki are just there to add layers to her own character. It was always meant to be like that from the beginning and it's also why she's such a goated character fr
.I've read Monster and Johan is honestly amazing, but that's one huge stretch if you ask me.
- 4,524
- 2,242
Oh I know. Shiki's goated, but the rest aren't that good. Hence why I don't like it that muchThing is, the characters outside of Shiki are just there to add layers to her own character. It was always meant to be like that from the beginning and it's also why she's such a goated character fr
- 4,524
- 2,242
I said arguably. But I can't really think of a single Nasuverse character that's even remotely as good as him
