- 4,141
- 419
at-least that give an idea how strong weakend jubi isRocker1189 said:Not that I think Juubito was 5-B.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
at-least that give an idea how strong weakend jubi isRocker1189 said:Not that I think Juubito was 5-B.
....Why I did not remember this is something i'll never know. Thanks for pointing this out.Adam of darkness said:Even assuming that was actually most of hagoromo's chakra concentrated around naruto's arm, it would actually be visible even normally like it is in kaguya's vision (Which obviously was not the case). Large concentration of chakra over certain area takes a physical form showcased throughout the series. Kid naruto releasing Kurama's chakra, Sasuke's/Kakashi's chidori, Rasengan, and many other examples. The more people reply in favor of Imade the more I realize they have not read the manga properly.
I suggest you to read the comment again. The opposition is exactly insinuating that most of the chakra hagoromo gave is present in the seal because it glowing brightly. The chakra pathway inside the arm is not glowing brightly, the area surrounding the arm is .RegisNex1232 said:Maybe because the examples being brought up are when they're actually releasing said chakra into the world? While the seals are just acting as a storage for the chakra from Hagoromo, untile they get used to seal Kaguya. Adam of darkness just brought up a different case without realising that it's different for a reason.
I don't think you understand burden of proof.Xerkser500 said:>You literally cannot prove that
Actually, this is the other way around. It's your burden of proof to prove that Naruto and Sasuke weren't being given even amounts of chakra from hagoromo. Which, in itself, makes no sense whatsoever in the situation they are in. Besides the fact that this is assuming Hagoromo has favortisim for one over the other, for some reason, why would Hagoromo not give them an even amount of power? He clearly gave them this power in the first place so that they can battle and seal Kaguya. Not giving them an even split amount would lower their chances of success instead of increase them. Hagoromo obviously doesnt want one or the other to struggle in their predicament, so there's no reason to believe he didnt give them an even amount of chakra.
https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/vsbattles/images/2/2d/Hagoromo_Power_2.png/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/180?cb=20190309223201[/IMG][/URL]
Kaguya's Byakugan Sees Immense Chakra in Their Seals
You'd be wrong if you think you countered this, the Byakugan sees Chakra and Chakra Pathways.
We get direct confirmation with her Byakugan that she sees the Chakra in their hands. The Byakugan can't see Jutsu, it can only see Chakra Pathways and she sees the large amount of Chakra in their dominant hands where Hagoromo bestowed the Moon and Sun seals.
Even worse, Hagoromo still had Chakra after granting Chakra to Naruto and Sasuke. Which means we can't even say he split his Chakra evenly onto them. Where was this actually proven? Because your scan at the end absolutely doesnt. Him saying "which I dont have right now" doesnt suddenly equate to "I have chakra, just not a lot".
Plus, if I remember correctly, Hagoromo in the war is supposed to be just a dead spirit right? If that is the case, why would he need chakra? Especially since it's been widley shown before that using up all your chakra doesnt mean anything except you cannot use jutsu. And for obvious reason.
Nothing here proves Hagoromo had chakra left. At all.
Spirits in Naruto have Chakra. This was already a CRT on VS Wiki that was accepted. Using up all Chakra means you die, we learned this in like in the early 20's chapters of Naruto.
Your point is moot.
Plus, Hagoromo helped re-summon Naruto, Sasuke, The Bijuu, Kakashi and Sakura with the help of the Gokages.
On top of that, Hagoromo is the one who brought the Gokages to help.
Even after that it's Hagoromo who undoes all the Edo-Tensei and desummons the Gokage.
Despite that, Hagoromo still had Chakra to remain in the world.
Mindovin"]
Sasuke naturally awakened the Rinnegan, he had his own Indra Chakra and received Ashura Chakra from Hashirama. This point is really up for debate: Rinnegan = Ashura Chakra + Indra Chakra.
Sasuke had both before meeting Hagoromo.
- Hashirama didn't give him chakra, he gave him a jutsu which we don't know what the heck it is, maybe it's a sealing jutsu. Maybe I'm the only one who doesn't know and someone tell me what it is if there is scan/statement.
- This scan also doesn't prove Sasuke awakened just he can/could if he have decades (if he is given chakra by Hashirama) if at all but we have databook statements tell he given by Hagoromo which is more reliable than any theory.
All we know about Ashura is what Hagoromo told us given that the anime isn't canon.https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/vsbattles/images/0/08/Ashura_and_Indra.png/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/180?cb=20190309221540[/IMG][/URL]
Ashura and Indra Never Received Power from Hagoromo
Ashura and Indra were never given power from Hagoromo and Hagoromo admits this himself when talking about their history.
Indra was born with immense power and never worked with others, he achieved greater heights by working alone and being born special.
Ashura was born a dunce and couldn't really utilize his powers. However, per Hagoromo's own words, Ashura gains power by working with others and Indra was born with his powers:
"Elder brother Indra possessed strong ocular powers and senses from birth... he always did everything by himself, leaning only on his own strength and came to understand that his powers were different and special... On the other hand, nothing ever went well for little brother Ashura from the time he was small and he couldn't do anything all on his own. In order to attain the same power as his older brother he always needed the cooperation of others in addition to his own effort."
"While struggling through training, the power of bodily Chakra awakened within him and he attained power rivaling his brother's."
Zzsax"]
@Imade
Ashura and Indra were never given power from Hagoromo and Hagoromo admits this himself when talking about their history.
Backpedalling implies I have gone back on my words, in case you've forgotten, my argument has multiple points, it's not a singular one.Adam of darkness said:I don't think you understand burden of proof.'''''I'm saying they aren't 5-B for not receiving 5-B Chakra from Hagoromo.
The burden of proof is on you to prove he gave them exactly 50% each of his Chakra
Getting desperate at this point. First it was "Hagoromo took back the seal in which most of his chakra was present!" and now its "Uhhhhh you cant prove he gave 50% of his chakra to each of them!!"
Back paddling is strong here. But anyways lets break this arguement too. We know for a fact that
No one is denying he gave them an even amount of Chakra, understand this.(1) Hagoromo gave equal chakra to both Naruto and Sasuke said:>The burden of proof is on you to prove he gave them exactly 50% each of his Chakra.
Except, it isnt. The burden of proof is on you to prove he didnt because it makes absolutely 0 sense to assume he didnt. Occams Razor, he gave them an even amount of chakra.
Hagoromo clearly doesnt want one of them to struggle or possibly die in their situation and hinder their chances of success. That, and he doesnt suddenly have favoritism for Naruto over Sasuke and vice versa. So why would you think he didnt give them an even amount in the first place? Everything points to him giving him an even amount unless explitly proven otherwise. Which you havent done.
Kep has a response coming in too, he's had issues with his internet though the past day.BlackeJan said:I think it's safe to say that at this point everyone is going to keep saying the same thing. @Shadow and @Taka would pretty much be the last say and then we move onto the end or else it's going to be repeated if we don't close the thread
Its not always like that, or else Rasengan, Rasengan Shuriken, Bijuu Dama , literally every technique made of concentration of chakra will have flames patternBMWFanboy said:Might I remind everyone that Chakra (concentrated) doesn't remotely resemble this , but looks like this , on more than one occasio , even as far back as Part 1 , or for that matter , even Boruto , so if the Seals were carrying heavy amounts of Chakra, they would looklike this to a Byakugan eye, hell to even a normal eye, a heavy concentration of chakra will be visible to the human eye , which makes no sense considering the fact that the chakra in question is one of the strongest Chakra in the verse. But they don't, Kaguya explicitly calls them Jutsu. Chakra resembles a flame, a light emanating from the seals doesn't make it chakra
That's incorrect, the calcs of the Chibaku Tensei done with Hagoromo and Hamura and the Chibaku Tensei done with Naruto and Sasuke have different yields and results, they aren't equivalent.Xerkser500 said:>What you need to prove is that Hagoromo gave them 50% of his Chakra each.Nothing proves he didnt lose all of his chakra to begin with so no I don't. Even with the benefit of the doubt, Adam already addressed why they would still be 5-B even if given as low as 30% of his chakra each with nitpicking. Also no, the 400 Zettaton feat Hagoromo did with his brother fully goes to him later on and his page even specifies this. Whether Naruto and Sasuke scale or not, Hagoromo gets the full value of the calc by giving them the capability of doing the same thing he and Hamura did on his lonesome.
https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/vsbattles/images/8/8b/ChakraBright.png/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/180?cb=20190310063122[/IMG][/URL]
Kaguya Sees the Chakra in the Seals
So you're going to literally ignore what the Byakugan does and provide a theory instead?
The Byakugan can see through objects, far distances, visualize Chakra and the Chakra Pathways.
She can't even see neither Sasuke nor Naruto's palms to see the physical distinction.
Her vision is what we see on the scan, it's why Kishimoto drew it.
What Kaguya sees is a lot of Chakra in their dominant hands.
>Do you realize how much Chakra in takes to invade an alternate time-space that is not you own?Yes and? Hagoromo isnt exactly the ruler of the afterlife. So he'd have no better chances of summoning a greater number of others from the afterlife than he would re-summoning T7 from one of Kaguya's time-spaces. So you cannot assume Hagoromo used any technique to summon them as opposed to him just requesting them to the living world for a short period of time.
Chakra Teleportation
The size of an object accounts for how much Chakra it takes to summon and resummon.
Hagoromo was dealing with 9 Bijuu and all of Team 7, that's a lot of mass.
So not only does he have to deal with invading another Space-Time, he has to account for the sizes of the Bijuu.
It's a lot of Chakra, more so than the Gokage from the past given the sizes of them.
Again, this point holds no ground.
>On top of that, you're now assuming that Hagoromo somehow invaded the afterlife to search for spirits to ask them to come back like it was a favor. That's a large assumption and numerous assumptions.You...do realize spirits in Naruto can freely travel between the living and afterworlds right? Hagoromo actively came to the living from the spirit world so why assume he cannot freely go back, request help, and come back again? This doesnt take as much assumption as assuming Hagoromo did this with a technique which would be impossible for him to do at that moment. Plus, Hagoromo wouldnt be the first one to do this anyway. Obito did this the moment Kaguya killed him. He went to the afterlife, came back to possess Kakashi, and then left again once T7 stopped her. Blatant evidence of spirits traveling between the worlds at will. There's no reason to assume Hagoromo cannot if Obito can.
Spirits can't freely travel between worlds, otherwise we'd have a lot more spirits around.
There is a large instance that debunks this theory of your's:
The Edo-Tensei of the War. They weren't traveling around freely after their spirits were released. Your theory that spirits can travel freely holds no ground.
Again, it's a huge assumption to assume that Hagoromo went and asked each Gokage to help him, plus I already proved that Hagoromo desummoned the Gokage, thus he had summoned them.
This point of your's is bunk and you have no argument.
>This is wrong, Hagoromo literally said it himself that he would undo it.And yet, we don't actively see this on-panel whatsoever. The Kage literally just up and vanish on their own while Hagoromo sits and watches the entire time. So either Hagoromo didnt need to actively send them back afterall or he used a seperate method that wasnt a jutsu.
No, Hagoromo literally said so himself that he summoned them via this. It obviously happened off-panel since we are told by Hagoromo himself that he is the cause.
This isn't even an argument, you're being desperate.
>If he didn't need Chakra then why was he on a time limit? What is limiting his time? Because spirits from the afterlife cannot remain in the living world forever? Either way, there's nothing said whatsoever that Hagoromo's time in the living world was based on his chakra resevoir so you cannot assume it had anything to do with him running out of time in the living world.
You literally just said two points above that spirits can move freely as they choose.
I am not going to keep arguing with you when you're now contradicting yourself and saying things against canon.
>It disproves this false narrative you made that Chakra has to be visible if there is a lot of it.It disproves absolutely nothing because it's not a false narrative. It's a blatant fact that the entire course of the series has given to us and anyone who actually knows Naruto would know this.
Kurama's chakra, Naruto's rasengan, Sasuke/Kakashi's chidori and many others are all examples of chakra being clearly visible when concentrated at one point. So if tis narrative of these sun and moon seals having the chakra embeded into them on Naruto and Sasuke's dominant hands was remotely plausible, the chakra concentrated there would be visible and not only seeable to the Byakugan eye (if you take the "glowing around their hands" bit as chakra). It wasnt visible period. Not before the technique was used or when it was used. So that disproves any claim that there was chakra gathered there.
Using the "one tailed Naruto being superior to Base Adult Naruto" point had absolutely nothing to do with this and was just completely unrelated. Hence why I had 0 idea why you even brought this up in the first place.
Seals don't have visible Chakra, they've never have had visible Chakra.
Ninjutsu has visible Chakra because it's creating something physicals.
Fuinjutsu does not, it's literally a seal.
Your point is moot. The theory was that Chakra concetrated in a spot is visible, it's why Adam of Darkness brought up One Tail Naruto having visible Chakra around him.
However, that's obviously false when characters like Hashirama or Adult Naruto don't have visible Chakra around them in their base forms despite being superior and having a lot of Chakra.
Adam of darkness"]
Yes, the byakugan indeed only sees chakra, due to which we see chakra anodes over entire body having constant flow, it is not concentrated at singular point. The colored panel which was ironically posted to favor opposite notion proves it.As visible, the chakra flow in his arms is just as normal as flow in his entire body . The brigthened part is just to put emphasis on what kaguya is looking at, idk how many times I have repeated this already