""Yes, Sasuke naturally awakened the Rinnegan. You need Indra and Ashura Chakra to do it, Sasuke had both before meeting Hagoromo."
Yes the databook has it's inconsistencies but Sasuke got Hashirama's chakra FAR before meeting Hagoromo and yet only got the rinnegan after receiving Hagoromo's power AND the databook tells us Hagoromo gave him the rinnegan? Yes let's go with what you say and not Kishimoto
Except having Hashirama's power doesn't instantly give you a rinnegan, it takes decades as it did with Madara, not sure why i need to repeat this but
"" From the Rikudou Sennin, he awakened the Rinnegan and the key to the seal…""
From the sage of six paths is where Sasuke got the rinnegan from, the fact that he got it instantly makes more sense this way since we know Hashirama's method takes decades, whereas directly from Hagoromo is instant.
You Need Ashura and Indra Chakra to Awaken the Rinnega
Your point here is in denial. Hagoromo is the one who reveals to us how the Rinnegan is naturally awakened:
"He was so obsessed with power that he stole some of Hashirama's. Which in short, caused the merging of part of Ashura's Chakra with Indra's Chakra and result in the derivation of my own Chakra's power. That's right, the awakening of the Rinnegan."
Sasuke naturally awakened the Rinnegan, he had his own Indra Chakra and
received Ashura Chakra from Hashirama.
This point is really up for debate: Rinnegan = Ashura Chakra + Indra Chakra.
Sasuke had both before meeting Hagoromo.
Something that can Hagoromo could have done is mutate Sasuke's natural Rinnegan. Sasuke met the requirements for a natural Rinnegan, but his was a unique Rinnegan as he had one Rinnegan instead of two that looked like a Rinne-Sharingan.
So Hagoromo could have changed the Rinnegan, but he did not grant Sasuke a Rinnegan.
""Your point falls apart at the start since we know Naruto awakened Six Paths Senjutsu naturally and Sasuke awakened the Rinnegan naturally."
Why do you keep repeating this? We have databook statements that say they didn't awaken it naturally, you cannot
Naruto Awakened Six Paths Senjutsu (Something Madara Had)
The Awakened Rinnegan and Awakened Six Paths Senjutsu are Needed
I'm talking about Six Paths Senjutsu, you brought a databook statement about Six Paths Sage Mode. Understand that those aren't the same things.
Six Paths Senjutsu is awakened via having the Chakra of the 9 Bijuu,
it's why Madara literally says he also has Six Paths Senjutsu like Naruto as Madara had the 9 Bijuu Chakra.
You keep linking Six Paths Sage Mode's Databook Entry when I'm talking about Six Paths Senjutsu.
Six Paths Senjutsu =/= Six Paths Sage Mode.
No one except Hagoromo and Naruto have Six Paths Sage Mode. Madara, Obito, Hagoromo and Naruto all had Six Paths Senjutsu since the requirements for Six Paths Senjutsu is the Chakra of the 9 Bijuu as Hagoromo reveals.
So yes, Naruto naturally awakened Six Paths Senjutsu. He had the Chakra of the 9 Bijuu and continued to have the Chakra of the 9 Bijuu even in the future during Boruto.
""however, what's in contention is what Hagoromo distributed to them, what was naturally awakened and what Chakra was meant for what."
Again, Hagoromo repeateadly says the power isn't only meant for the Chibaku tensei, UNLESS you want to propose the headcanon that he also gave Ashura only power to perform a chibaku tensei when he makes a direct comparison to his distrubution of power between naruto and sasuke and ashura and indra
Please read this specific scan carefully since you don't seem to understand the exact meaning of Hagoromo's distrubution of power.
This was all after the sealing by the way, so the Seal argument doesn't work here.
Ashura and Indra Never Received Power from Hagoromo
This scan you linked doesn't tell us anything given what we know.
For starters, Hagoromo didn't bequeath power to Indra nor Ashura in the past.
Ashura and Indra were never given power from Hagoromo and Hagoromo admits this himself when talking about their history.
Indra was born with immense power and never worked with others, he achieved greater heights by working alone and being born special.
Ashura was born a dunce and couldn't really utilize his powers. However, per Hagoromo's own words, Ashura gains power by working with others and Indra was born with his powers:
"Elder brother Indra possessed strong ocular powers and senses from birth... he always did everything by himself, leaning only on his own strength and came to understand that his powers were different and special... On the other hand, nothing ever went well for little brother Ashura from the time he was small and he couldn't do anything all on his own. In order to attain the same power as his older brother he always needed the cooperation of others in addition to his own effort."
Kaguya's Byakugan Sees Immense Chakra in Their Seals
Black Zetsu Reveals That Hagoromo Bequeathed a Powerful Seal
That Power is Located in their Hands in their Seals
"While struggling through training, the power of bodily Chakra awakened within him and he attained power rivaling his brother's."
Also, it is revealed to us what Hagoromo had given to Naruto and Sasuke throughout their fight with Kaguya:
- Kaguya reveals to us that they have immense Chakra in their dominant hands where the seal is located.
- Black Zetsu reveals to us that the reincarnation of Ashura and Indra (Naruto and Sasuke) received a powerful seal from Hagoromo.
- This seal is revealed to be the ones located in their hands and the seal is a powerful version of the Six Paths Chibaku Tensei.
The main power that Naruto and Sasuke received was the Six Paths Chibaku Tensei, the mass amount of Chakra given to them was revealed by Kaguya to be in their hands holding the seals.
No one is denying that Naruto and Sasuke came back from Hagoromo with additional powerups, but this was due to naturally awakening the Rinnegan for Sasuke and Six Paths Senjutsu for Naruto.
What you can't prove and provide evidence for is that Hagoromo evenly split his 200zt amount of Chakra into Naruto and Sasuke evenly for anything besides the Six Paths Chibaku Tensei.
There is not a single piece of evidence that Hagoromo split his Chakra in half for Naruto and Sasuke to use. The only thing we have is that Hagoromo gave Chakra to Naruto and Sasuke and that the massive amount of Chakra is located in their hands. That's it.
""
Also in chapter 690, as soon as Naruto and Sasuke use the seals on Kaguya, the seals disappear from their hands and immediately return back to Hagoromo. The seals given to Naruto and Sasuke by Hagoromo meant for the Chibaku Tensei returned back to Hagoromo after the Chakra for the seal was used on Kaguya."'''If Hagoromo's chakra disappeared after the seal then why does Naruto still have SOSP mode? It was GIVEN to him by Hagoromo via giving Naruto his power, if Hagoromo ONLY gave chakra to Naruto for the seal then why didn't the power disappear once the chakra giving him the power did? It literally makes no sense
, unless Naruto kept the chakra from Hagoromo beyond the fight which literally everything including Hagoromo's words himself state.
Sage of Six Paths Mode was given to him by Hagoromo, it's a mode of heightened awareness and better Chakra control. It increases his speed to a level that matches Madara as stated in the databook.
That's it.
Naruto maintains Six Paths powers due to still retaining Six Paths Senjutsu, to retain that he must have the Chakra of the 9 Bijuu, which he still does and it's further extrapolated upon in Shikamaru Hiden:
"The Nine Tails was still living inside Naruto. There were also remnants of the other 8 bijuu inside him as well. In that way, you could say he was a human pillar for the power of the Ten Tails. In the last war, Obito had become a human pillar for the Ten Tails and gained chakra rivalling that of the Sage of the Six Paths.
Naruto, who'd taken the bijuu into him as well, had some of the Sage's power even now."
Naruto and Sasuke both kept their Six Path powers and the Rinnegan respectively as they awakened their powers naturally.
""The issue was the incorrect belief that Hagoromo evenly split his 200zt Chakra into Sasuke and Naruto. That was false, most of Hagoromo's Chakra went into the seals as it's shown, stated and proven to us,"
Except Hagoromo himself says he gave them half his powers, absolutely nothing indicates "most" of it went to the seal, you are literally going off 1 page where their hands are glowing and that's it whereas i've given tons of scans AFTER the sealing where hagoromo says he gave them half his chakra each, the fact that Hagoromo says
"I too want to make the future better, this time i gave both of them the power" is literally the biggest indicator that the power isn't solely for the seal, but far beyond that which again is proven by Naruto keeping the SOSP Mode
This is literally false.
Hagoromo never says he gave each of them half of his entire Chakra.
You literally can't prove that. That alone is why the 5-B ratings are false.
Hagoromo Doesn't Have a lot of Chakra At the Moment
All we know is that he gave them a lot of Chakra as Hagoromo himself admits he doesn't have massive Chakra after talking to Naruto and Sasuke.
Plus the fact that Kaguya reveals to us that Naruto and Sasuke have massive amounts of Chakra located in their seals.
Even worse, Hagoromo still had Chakra after granting Chakra to Naruto and Sasuke. Which means we can't even say he split his Chakra evenly onto them.
This is already enough information to prove that Hagoromo didn't distribute his 200zt Chakra directly into them evenly. He distributed a lot of it into the seals as Kaguya saw and he didn't distribute all of his own Chakra as he still had Chakra leftover.