-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Metal Gear Solid Massive CRT. "Kept you waiting, uh?"
- Thread starter Twellas
- Start date
- Status
- 10,462
- 1,521
There's no way we are reaching final conlusion "soon", not only this discussion is not at its end but there's also the OP to analyze
- 10,462
- 1,521
Someone just decided to downgrade MGS and supporters just decided to stand their ground, that's what was going on in this thread.
- 2,672
- 776
- Thread starter
- #806
Actually 4, 5 or even 6 pages were dedicated to the OP. then Weekly brought up the fact that the 8-B calc wasn't valid, and the focus shifted
- 16,061
- 12,534
I still don't agree with secondary canon Twin Snakes, it shows up in MGS4 while AC!D or Ghost Babel don't because MGS4, especially that one chapter, is a celebration of the series, and by the series, I mean Metal Gear Solid. There's an actual statement that it isn't canon, acknowledging a game's existance doesn't mean canonizing it. The cutscenes are purposefully not meant to be faithful to the original, Kojima outright asked the cutscene director to do them in his style, which kind of further implies they should not be given much weight, especially since Snake rides on a ******* missile at one point. It's also worth mentioning that in MGS4 itself, Mantis himself specifically shows the PS1 and not the Gamecube, and that the voices are the same between MGS1 and MGSTTS in Japan, so that doesn't count anyway.
- 16,061
- 12,534
And the same group that said it isn't canon also wrote Rising, so if we discount them as not being able to say what's canon and what isn't then we can't consider Rising canon either.
- 16,061
- 12,534
Also, what is the "more than one instance"?
- 2,672
- 776
- Thread starter
- #810
flimsy argument really, it's a celebration of the Metal Gear series as a whole, which is why the NSX games are there, and Ghost Babel, being a Metal Gear game, should have been there by this logic
The statement wasn't from Kojima himself, but from Sean Eyestone, who merely works at Kojima Productions. And yes, being shown in a canon game, in a scene that almost directly refers to "canon" is if not an outright canonization, a very very strong hint
The fact that Kojima himself was ok with what's shown in the cutscene kinda defeats your whole point; the creator was ok with it=it's part of the creator's vision
Yeah, Rising isn't canon. THE OTHER GAMES are canon to Rising, but Rising isn't canon to the other games, so I don't know what your point is
- 16,061
- 12,534
I don't see how appearing in a game outranks an official statement, even if not made by the person who wrote the games, that's still someone with authority, and it seems to follow the logic for canonicity of other games (Written by Kojima - Canon, Not written by Kojima - Not canon).
You can't look at fanservice in the fanservice chapter and say "Yes, that is good enough proof." It just ain't.
(TTS also has some parts that downright clash with future entries, such as Shadow Moses' remains in MGS4 clearly being inspired SOLELY by MGS1, and especially Ocelot not being able to twirl guns with his left hand, now of course MGS3 was written after TTS, but Kojima knew of that cutscene in it, yet had Ocelot be ambidextrous or at least skilled enough with both hands, almost as if he did not consider that scene canon at all, what a mindblowing idea.)
You can't look at fanservice in the fanservice chapter and say "Yes, that is good enough proof." It just ain't.
(TTS also has some parts that downright clash with future entries, such as Shadow Moses' remains in MGS4 clearly being inspired SOLELY by MGS1, and especially Ocelot not being able to twirl guns with his left hand, now of course MGS3 was written after TTS, but Kojima knew of that cutscene in it, yet had Ocelot be ambidextrous or at least skilled enough with both hands, almost as if he did not consider that scene canon at all, what a mindblowing idea.)
- 16,061
- 12,534
I also just disagree with this idea of "selective canon", if you look at a game where 95% of the cutscenes are expressedly not canon, you can't look at the remaining 5% and say "yup, those are fine, no problem here", especially since the game is a huge tonal shift from the rest of the series.
- 2,672
- 776
- Thread starter
- #814
You don't see how appearing in a game made by the creator of the series outranks a statement from someone who isn't the creator?
The chapter is still a chapter, you can't discredit it because it's "fanservice", what kind of argument is that? The game is there, the reason behind why it's there is completely irrelevant
It's not selective canon tho, it's just "the og takes priority, but TTS still gets taken into account". When there are contradictions or significant shifts we take the og, but for additional stuff there is no reason not to take it, and as a rule of thumb, it's commonly accepted that stuff that happens in secondary canon can canonically happen.
The tonal shift is irrelevant, it was approved by the creator, so it's part of the creator's vision, simple as that
- 16,061
- 12,534
There's also an official timeline picture that excludes TTS
And here's an interview in which Kojima himself, wowie, says what he believes is part of the MG series, and does not mention TTS
www.ign.com
"I always say 'this will be my last Metal Gear,'" Kojima said, "but the games in the series that I've personally designed and produced -- Metal Gear on MSX, MG2, MGS1, 2, 3, 4, Peace Walker, and now MGSV -- are what constitute a single 'Metal Gear Saga.' With MGSV, I'm finally closing the loop on that saga."
Wowie, the man with an ego the size of the moon only believes the games he's directed to be canon? Crazy
Deja Vu, you erase all the MG and MGS logos, and The Twin Snakes is nowhere to be found. The mission also ends with you creating the KojiPro symbol, signifying that yes, KojiPro games are the actually canon ones. (He doesn't get Peace Walker, but that's on the helicopter)
And here's an interview in which Kojima himself, wowie, says what he believes is part of the MG series, and does not mention TTS
Kojima Says Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain Is the Last 'Metal Gear Solid' - IGN
Kojima: Even if the 'Metal Gear' franchise continues, this is the last 'Metal Gear.'
"I always say 'this will be my last Metal Gear,'" Kojima said, "but the games in the series that I've personally designed and produced -- Metal Gear on MSX, MG2, MGS1, 2, 3, 4, Peace Walker, and now MGSV -- are what constitute a single 'Metal Gear Saga.' With MGSV, I'm finally closing the loop on that saga."
Wowie, the man with an ego the size of the moon only believes the games he's directed to be canon? Crazy
Deja Vu, you erase all the MG and MGS logos, and The Twin Snakes is nowhere to be found. The mission also ends with you creating the KojiPro symbol, signifying that yes, KojiPro games are the actually canon ones. (He doesn't get Peace Walker, but that's on the helicopter)
- 20,391
- 17,254
As a question, when does it show up in MGS4?
- 16,061
- 12,534
It's also worth mentioning, a MGSV guidebook with a pretty detailed timeline does not mention the San Hieronimo incident. This isn't related to TTS, but I thought it should be brought up since Portable Ops is dubiously canon as well, the other stuff I showed also decanonices it.
- 2,672
- 776
- Thread starter
- #818
Doesn't matter, it's in MGS4 when refering directly to canon, all of this doesn't change this fact, unless you wanna say that Kojima had a stroke and accidentally added TTS to MGS4, none of this matters.There's also an official timeline picture that excludes TTS
http://i3.endoftheinter.net/i/n/26035f588b83cd7ea3bf78078e0c9c4f/Metal-Gear-Snake-Timeline.jpg
And here's an interview in which Kojima himself, wowie, says what he believes is part of the MG series, and does not mention TTS
"I always say 'this will be my last Metal Gear,'" Kojima said, "but the games in the series that I've personally designed and produced -- Metal Gear on MSX, MG2, MGS1, 2, 3, 4, Peace Walker, and now MGSV -- are what constitute a single 'Metal Gear Saga.' With MGSV, I'm finally closing the loop on that saga."Kojima Says Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain Is the Last 'Metal Gear Solid' - IGN
Kojima: Even if the 'Metal Gear' franchise continues, this is the last 'Metal Gear.'
Wowie, the man with an ego the size of the moon only believes the games he's directed to be canon? Crazy
And of course it's not on the timeline, it's the same event as MGS1, and obviously the og takes precedence.
Vague statements about "the game's i've produced constitute the saga" don't change the fact that those same "games that constitute the saga" directly show other games as "part of the saga".
Cool, doesn't matter, the og obviously takes precedence; it's a fun easter egg tho
- 2,672
- 776
- Thread starter
- #819
And then you wonder why this thread is 9 pages, you get hung on every single thing and start page-long discussion over something as simple as "it's shown in a canon game while basically talking about canonicity, it's canon".
Your lengthy argument would make sense if I was trying to say that Twin Snakes takes priority over the og, but I'm not, I'm just saying "hey, maybe this should be considered".
And btw, the wiki already lists Twin Snakes as a secondary and valid canon in the Verse page, so if anything, a discussion about this should be reserved to another thread
Your lengthy argument would make sense if I was trying to say that Twin Snakes takes priority over the og, but I'm not, I'm just saying "hey, maybe this should be considered".
And btw, the wiki already lists Twin Snakes as a secondary and valid canon in the Verse page, so if anything, a discussion about this should be reserved to another thread
Last edited:
- 16,061
- 12,534
Dude, Kojima literally lists the games that he considers canon, multiple times, and you ignore all of that because one time he did, one that came before these, he did not exclude it.
I don't get hung on every single thing, you say something wrong, and I explain to you why you're ******* wrong, and you keep clinging on to outnumbered and awkward "proof" claiming that everything I say is less impactful. There are FOUR direct statements that TTS isn't canon, three of which from Kojima himself, and ONE, older one that says it is, that the game itself contradicts.
But saying Kojima had three consecutive strokes and "accidentally" excluded TTS from multiple listings of what he considers the true MG saga, AKA canon, is perfectly acceptable?
I don't get hung on every single thing, you say something wrong, and I explain to you why you're ******* wrong, and you keep clinging on to outnumbered and awkward "proof" claiming that everything I say is less impactful. There are FOUR direct statements that TTS isn't canon, three of which from Kojima himself, and ONE, older one that says it is, that the game itself contradicts.
- 2,672
- 776
- Thread starter
- #821
He didn't outright say that it wasn't canon, that's the thing, but again, you are taking as "DIRECT statements that TTS isn't canon" simple cases of Kojima not mentioning it, when it could merely be that the og has priority over it, which doesn't change or inder the idea of TTS being a sort of "canon retelling"
- 2,672
- 776
- Thread starter
- #822
Also
- 16,061
- 12,534
If it showing up in MGS4 is a direct statement that it's canon, then it not showing up in GZ is a direct statement that it isn't.
And ******' fine we can do it on any threat you want, I don't care, make it right now, or if you prefer I will.
And ******' fine we can do it on any threat you want, I don't care, make it right now, or if you prefer I will.
- 10,462
- 1,521
chill dude lol
- 16,061
- 12,534
No I won't, I've been treated like an idiot for arguments far less insane than this, if I'm being offensive I apologize but I think this is an incredibly stupid argument.
- 16,061
- 12,534
I am aware of that, but it might just be to follow up on the new voicelines. Still, if you want me to make a new thread I'll mention it there too. Though, the japanese version still uses the OG voices, so that doesn't really matter.
- 16,061
- 12,534
Fair enough, still not enough to counter my points, but I'll recognize that.
- 2,672
- 776
- Thread starter
- #830
But I don't really have to counter your points, because you're talking as if I'm trying to present TTS as full canon that overtakes MGS1, but I'm not, I'm merely presenting it as valid secondary canon, and for that, the proof I've shown is more than enough. it not being "part of the timeline" makes sense because it's simply a retelling of a more canonically relevant game in the series.
And the stuff I'm presenting isn't even new, wholly different stuff, it still happens in the og, it's just that TTS gives us more info about it: in the og Mantis still moves the controller and still does the hand-push-thingy at Snake, but we don't see what this does to him, in TTS THE SAME THING happens, but we're given more info that in no way contradicts what's shown in the og, and if anything completes it, giving an in-game dimension to Mantis' meta action that was lacking in the og.
And the stuff I'm presenting isn't even new, wholly different stuff, it still happens in the og, it's just that TTS gives us more info about it: in the og Mantis still moves the controller and still does the hand-push-thingy at Snake, but we don't see what this does to him, in TTS THE SAME THING happens, but we're given more info that in no way contradicts what's shown in the og, and if anything completes it, giving an in-game dimension to Mantis' meta action that was lacking in the og.
- 16,061
- 12,534
It's not, there is not enough evidence to consider it secondary canon, because nothing I've shown is a direct statement about canonicity except for Kojima's statement. The timeline up until MGSV and Deja Vu are not necessarily about canon itself, they are simply about the MG series. There was absolutely no reason for Kojima not to include TTS in either of them, especially Deja Vu as it is simply a celebration of the series, yet he did indeed exclude them. All of this counters one appearance in MGS4 that once again doesn't say anything about canonicity outright.
- 2,672
- 776
- Thread starter
- #832
There... is.. tho.
You know what? Enough. The wiki considers it valid as of now, so we're gonna consider it valid until that changes, end of story; you can make all the threads you want later on, but as of now, Twin Snakes is canon and its feats are ok to use, so we're gonna use them. If we keep at it we'll never get anywhere
You know what? Enough. The wiki considers it valid as of now, so we're gonna consider it valid until that changes, end of story; you can make all the threads you want later on, but as of now, Twin Snakes is canon and its feats are ok to use, so we're gonna use them. If we keep at it we'll never get anywhere
- 16,061
- 12,534
Fine by me, if you somehow manage to get Class M approved now, it won't matter since that CRT will remove justifications for it.
- 16,061
- 12,534
If TTS is considered not canon at all, which is what I'm shooting for, it won't be usable at all.
- 2,672
- 776
- Thread starter
- #836
Again, it will, because the SAME EXACT SCENE is in the og. Mantis moves the controller, and if "reading the memory card" correlates in-game to "reading Snake's mind" it logically follows that "moving the controller" would mean "moving Snake". Since we never see Snake get ragdolled or anything of the sort, the logical conclusion is that Snake resisted the TK. The TTS scene does NOTHING but make the feat explicit and blatant.
- 16,061
- 12,534
Uh, that is one hell of a reach. The only thing that hints at this is a non-canon game, nothing within MGS1 implies that happened. It makes sense, sure, but it's still complete speculation.
- 16,061
- 12,534
Anyway, we've still got a lot more votes and opinions against the Class M than those in favor of it.
- 2,672
- 776
- Thread starter
- #839
it's... absolutely not tho: we know for a fact that Mantis' meta stuff actually effects the game universe, if reading the memory card translates to reading Snake's mind it's barely even an assumption to say that the controller would move him.
No not really, you don't
- Status
