• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Lady upgrade

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are just intentionally trying to make me look worse
No, I'm not. You have a serious paranoia problem dude.
Yeah, now for the love of god can you JUST DROP THIS
this is a crt. That's it.
Okay. If you want to focus on the CRT, then you should not make comments randomly accusing staff of scheming to close your thread because they asked what the votes were, or accusing them of trying to impact your reputation, et cetera. You keep claiming you want to drop this but you keep perpetuating it for some reason.
 
Could we all calm down here? It's definitely not wise to have bad blood between us, more-so if the other user is in the verses we like.
Now, going back to topic.
Well, DT Nero did stomp them on a much earlier state of game, he even goes as far as fighting an evolved one and beat him. Now, what is going on here? Is this some kind of magic trick that makes Nero go weaker as the game goes on?! Not exactly. I would like to call this, a PIS, why? Simple, now we see Kyrie in the fight there and it's clear Nero wants to save her. Now what would happen if Nero saved her right away because he beated up those knights and Agnus? Simple, Nero's plot ******* ends. Oh and Dante would get much faster to The Savior due to not having to deal with Agnus as well, killing the old man in diapers quickly and ending the game in less than 10 missions, nice!! I don't think i have to explain it any further.

The proof is the statement itself, and there is nothing directly going against the statement being true at that point in time. If dmc5 lady has evidence and dmc4 lady doesn’t, then the split is just going to be made rather than assuming the statement is false. That would only happen if it it was later stated that Nero would beat her or that her weapons have gotten weaker since dmc3/4 or something, but direct evidence like that does not exist. Given that the statement is true, it means dmc5 lady has a 4-C arsenal regardless. Either that or we just go with Nero not being a million times stronger than the angelos.
Oh, well alright. So you're saying we should only base Lady being Star Level (which mind you it's pretty inconsistent) just because of Dante saying a one-liner that should somehow be specific enough to consider Nero when he's not even there and that's not even the point of the liner?
Have we also seen Dante fight "CURRENT DMC 5 LADY" to say that she's stronger than Nero, the knights and basically anyone that lowscales? Or has he seen Lady fight any significant demon to warrant that? Further more, he doesn't even say that they're the strongest, only the most badass and he only says the liner to give the impression to the spectator that it is indeed Vergil.
 
Well, DT Nero did stomp them on a much earlier state of game, he even goes as far as fighting an evolved one and beat him. Now, what is going on here? Is this some kind of magic trick that makes Nero go weaker as the game goes on?! Not exactly. I would like to call this, a PIS, why? Simple, now we see Kyrie in the fight there and it's clear Nero wants to save her. Now what would happen if Nero saved her right away because he beated up those knights and Agnus? Simple, Nero's plot ******* ends. Oh and Dante would get much faster to The Savior due to not having to deal with Agnus as well, killing the old man in diapers quickly and ending the game in less than 10 missions, nice!! I don't think i have to explain it any further.
he only stomped them when he was pissed off and actually in devil trigger. Moments before he had just been stabbed and overpowered by them all.
base post DT Nero has never shown to do that, either.
So again, it's not proved to be PIS, the only time he stomps them is when he's enraged and/or using devil trigger, as made abundantly clear in the cutscene where he is overpowered by Bianco Angelos before his fully rage kicks in.
Let's not forget that even DT Nero never showed the ability to just straight up break the shields, which are what was giving Lady the most trouble.
Oh, well alright. So you're saying we should only base Lady being Star Level (which mind you it's pretty inconsistent) just because of Dante saying a one-liner that should somehow be specific enough to consider Nero when he's not even there and that's not even the point of the liner?
Have we also seen Dante fight "CURRENT DMC 5 LADY" to say that she's stronger than Nero, the knights and basically anyone that lowscales? Or has he seen Lady fight any significant demon to warrant that? Further more, he doesn't even say that they're the strongest, only the most badass and he only says the liner to give the impression to the spectator that it is indeed Vergil.
Well regardless of if he's the point or not, he's included in the statement. Especially since he's one of the only strong guys Dante knows at this point in the series to begin with besides Vergil, and every tier 2 guy or member of the order of the sword is dead, and he doesn't even really know V either. For the statement to even mean anything at all it would have to apply to like...the only guy left in the series who could fight demons at all.
Also he doesn't just say they're the most badass, he says that Vergil's the only one who can beat them. Of all the things he could have said to identify him as Vergil, he just throws out that he literally doesn't know anybody other than him who could beat them, which is how he supposedly knew it was Vergil in the first place.


I've been restraining myself from bringing up the fact that Lady specifically takes the place of Nero when you play as her in the alternate timeline, and is the one who beats Sanctus...
 
he only stomped them when he was pissed off and actually in devil trigger. Moments before he had just been stabbed and overpowered by them all.
base post DT Nero has never shown to do that, either.
So again, it's not proved to be PIS, the only time he stomps them is when he's enraged and/or using devil trigger, as made abundantly clear in the cutscene where he is overpowered by Bianco Angelos before his fully rage kicks in.
Let's not forget that even DT Nero never showed the ability to just straight up break the shields, which are what was giving Lady the most trouble.
This isn't replying my argument, it's just you stating what you said again. Nero defeated far more powerful beings than the knights and i proved it as a PIS for him to struggle with lower enemies, you now have to prove how that point is wrong.

Well regardless of if he's the point or not, he's included in the statement. Especially since he's one of the only strong guys Dante knows at this point in the series to begin with besides Vergil, and every tier 2 guy or member of the order of the sword is dead, and he doesn't even really know V either. For the statement to even mean anything at all it would have to apply to like...the only guy left in the series who could fight demons at all.
Also he doesn't just say they're the most badass, he says that Vergil's the only one who can beat them. Of all the things he could have said to identify him as Vergil, he just throws out that he literally doesn't know anybody other than him who could beat them, which is how he supposedly knew it was Vergil in the first place.
"THE ONLY GUY LEFT IN THE SERIES WHO COULD FIGHT DEMONS AT ALL" yeah bro, no cap definitely 100%
Anyways, if we take this statement at face value (which you're doing) then Lady has to scale above Lucia, someone that gave Arius-Argosax a beating, scaling far higher than Phantom or Griffon or even the Malphas and Cavaliere Angelo.
So not only you're saying that Lady scales above Mundus's Generals, you're also saying she scales above the likes of Cavaliere Angelo, whom is powered by HERSELF and Malphas or Gilgamesh who had V run like a coward, and would you look at that, the one who is supposed to be above Lady even says she's impressed after Dante killed one of Mundus's Generals.
 
This isn't replying my argument, it's just you stating what you said again. Nero defeated far more powerful beings than the knights and i proved it as a PIS for him to struggle with lower enemies, you now have to prove how that point is wrong.
I am not denying that he defeated stronger enemies, I am simply saying that it's shown on multiple occassions that he can't one shot them without a significant amp. Yes he has defeated stronger, but that just means that the gap between Bianco Angelos and his strongest enemies isn't to the point where they'd be completely stomped. It's not PIS when it happens more than once is my point.
Nero was indeed noticeably stronger, but he is unable to easily kill them regardless, that is my point. It is clear that they are capable of surviving hits from and briefly overpowering Nero on multiple occassions, therefore they should at least be downscaling from him to be at most 4-C or such.
"THE ONLY GUY LEFT IN THE SERIES WHO COULD FIGHT DEMONS AT ALL" yeah bro, no cap definitely 100%
They're not guys. That was deliberate on my end.
So not only you're saying that Lady scales above Mundus's Generals, you're also saying she scales above the likes of Cavaliere Angelo, whom is powered by HERSELF and Malphas or Gilgamesh who had V run like a coward, and would you look at that, the one who is supposed to be above Lady even says she's impressed after Dante killed one of Mundus's Generals.
nope, she just scales above Nero, that's it.
 
I am not denying that he defeated stronger enemies, I am simply saying that it's shown on multiple occassions that he can't one shot them without a significant amp. Yes he has defeated stronger, but that just means that the gap between Bianco Angelos and his strongest enemies isn't to the point where they'd be completely stomped. It's not PIS when it happens more than once is my point.
Nero was indeed noticeably stronger, but he is unable to easily kill them regardless, that is my point. It is clear that they are capable of surviving hits from and briefly overpowering Nero on multiple occassions, therefore they should at least be downscaling from him to be at most 4-C or such.
You know i can count the "multiple occassions" with my fingers. Worst part is you could say the first one is ANOTHER PIS because it was made to awaken Nero's DT with enraged, you can even see how Agnus gets flung across the room with the shockwave, whom scales far higher than the knights.
Second, it's important to note that their knight armor is their body, and everytime you kill them their body just disappears, what Lady did was pierce the body, negating the knight's durability in some way.
nope, she just scales above Nero, that's it.
Any why only Nero? You yourself said that the statement makes Lady scale above any other guy Dante knows is alive such as Nero, Lesser Demons and... LUCIA!
 
You know i can count the "multiple occassions" with my fingers. Worst part is you could say the first one is ANOTHER PIS because it was made to awaken Nero's DT with enraged, you can even see how Agnus gets flung across the room with the shockwave, whom scales far higher than the knights.
Everything that affects the plot isn’t automatically PIS, Jesus Christ dude, that’s an absolutely extraordinary fallacy. By this logic, literally everything is PIS because it has to happen in the story. You can’t just say everything you don’t like is PIS and everything you do like is perfectly fine.
Second, it's important to note that their knight armor is their body, and everytime you kill them their body just disappears, what Lady did was pierce the body, negating the knight's durability in some way.
….what???? Since when is literally just cutting through something dura neg, that’s called AP. I don’t even know where you’re getting this from at all.
Any why only Nero? You yourself said that the statement makes Lady scale above any other guy Dante knows is alive such as Nero, Lesser Demons and... LUCIA!
I told you why already, but you left it out of your reply for some reason
They're not guys. That was deliberate on my end.

nope, she just scales above Nero, that's it.
 
Like I said, it's just a one liner vs a ton of other shit
A “ton” of other shit which I just debunked above
Bianco is consistently able to contend with base Nero, and there is no evidence of it being outliers (the burden of proof would be heavily shifted to prove such)
there is actually little to no evidence to suggest that Lady being able to beat Nero contradicts anything
 
for one, I do not care in the slightest how trusted he is. Aside from being an asshole about it, his logic simply didn't hold up. Even though you're not staff, I'm still not going to just let you come in here and just FRA for something Tony said that I already responded to.
You may have responded, that doesn't mean anyone has to agree with you. If they agree more with Tony, it is what it is.
 
You may have responded, that doesn't mean anyone has to agree with you. If they agree more with Tony, it is what it is.
Why is this going to stop me from attempting to persuade them? It’s not like I can stop them from agreeing and then ditching the thread, all I was doing was saying that the argument they agree with doesn’t hold up
it’s not as though I’m a staff member or anything, so it doesn’t actually matter what I say. I don’t see the point in you replying to that with this.
 
Why is this going to stop me from attempting to persuade them? It’s not like I can stop them from agreeing and then ditching the thread, all I was doing was saying that the argument they agree with doesn’t hold up
it’s not as though I’m a staff member or anything, so it doesn’t actually matter what I say. I don’t see the point in you replying to that with this.
You can try. But to then go over and over the same thing t's a waste of time. Sometimes we have to learn to take no for an answer, you know.

You may think the argument doesn't hold up. He came to a different conclusion.

The point is that bit of your comment was something that needed to be addressed to me, so I took the liberty to address it.
 
You can try. But to then go over and over the same thing t's a waste of time. Sometimes we have to learn to take no for an answer, you know.
This doesn't seem to be one of those times at the moment.
Every rebuttal provided against me has presented a new flaw to create a counterargument against, so I am going to continue arguing until there someone's argument falls apart.
 
This doesn't seem to be one of those times at the moment.
Every rebuttal provided against me has presented a new flaw to create a counterargument against, so I am going to continue arguing until there someone's argument falls apart.
According to you.

3 staffs, 2 knowledgeable members disagree. You can choose the stonewalling route, but I advise you against it.
 
Everything that affects the plot isn’t automatically PIS, Jesus Christ dude, that’s an absolutely extraordinary fallacy. By this logic, literally everything is PIS because it has to happen in the story. You can’t just say everything you don’t like is PIS and everything you do like is perfectly fine.
You're completely ignoring that Nero got beaten up by beings weaker than him, but LET'S ASSUME THIS ISN'T PIS.
Okay, the scene can be explained because Nero was completely distracted and then pinned to a wall by 2 swords, quickly. You also have to take into account that this is PRE-DT Nero, so it doesn't really hold up. At best you could say Lady and Pre-DT Nero are comparable, but putting her in the leagues of Post-DT Nero is a bit too much.

….what???? Since when is literally just cutting through something dura neg, that’s called AP. I don’t even know where you’re getting this from at all.
It is penetrating damage and serves as a virtual way of negating resistance due to it stretching the zone of impact, essentially crushing it and breaking the links between molecules which weakens the resistance to easily create an area of entry.
Of course, up in one point you just become immune to this if the AP difference is too high, but the difference between Pre-DT Nero and the Knight is enough to fit within this range.

I told you why already, but you left it out of your reply for some reason
Cuz i didn't see how it explained anything and it just acted like christmas decoration there, could you explain it further if it's important to the argument? I really didn't understand it.
 
According to you.

2 staffs, 2 knowledgeable members disagree. You can choose the stonewalling route, but I advise you against it.
coming up with counterarguments is not stonewalling, it's called discussing. You are using stonewall as a buzzword, which really just means "you are disagreeing with me too long, please stop"
and so what if 4 people disagree, there are 8 billion people on earth and I'm sure I someone could find 5 of them who believe the moon is made of cheese, the earth is flat, and we're living inside the matrix. Majority rule doesn't actually prove anything. I am just having a discussion, and there was no reason for you to come in and tell me that people can be wrong about things sometimes.
I just want a moment of having a discussion and going through the normal process of debating until we reach a conclusion without getting interrupted by these types of things. From here on out I'd recommend that every post in this crt be related to the crt.
 
You're completely ignoring that Nero got beaten up by beings weaker than him, but LET'S ASSUME THIS ISN'T PIS.
Okay, the scene can be explained because Nero was completely distracted and then pinned to a wall by 2 swords, quickly. You also have to take into account that this is PRE-DT Nero, so it doesn't really hold up. At best you could say Lady and Pre-DT Nero are comparable, but putting her in the leagues of Post-DT Nero is a bit too much.
The idea that post dt nero is stronger in base to begin with is shaky, especially considering that's not even his real devil trigger. I might actually get to that another time, but regardless, saying that post-dt nero is too much is something that you have to prove, and the burden of proof is heavily on you if you are claiming it's PIS for post dt nero to not be able to one shot Bianco Angelos. Simply saying that he fought someone stronger does not cut it, because that doesn't mean that it wouldn't just scale lower into the same tier.
It is penetrating damage and serves as a virtual way of negating resistance due to it stretching the zone of impact, essentially crushing it and breaking the links between molecules which weakens the resistance to easily create an area of entry.
Of course, up in one point you just become immune to this if the AP difference is too high, but the difference between Pre-DT Nero and the Knight is enough to fit within this range.
yes, piercing damage, but either way there is no justification for choosing to scale it to pre dt nero but not accepting the fact that it was able to tangle with post dt nero
piercing damage does not negate durability as you said yourself, and regardless lady's piercing would just be 4-C anyways, so it's not very meaningful.
That's 4 staff disagrees. Should we close this?
cutting this short to say I am still in the middle of typing my response. This is exactly what I talked about earlier.
 
cutting this short to say I am still in the middle of typing my response. This is exactly what I talked about earlier.
Cool, but you're always going to have more to say. Arguments can go on forever. The odds of you convincing 5 other staff to agree with you is unlikely.
 
Probably.
and you have not even begun to give me a chance to speak to you about your disagreement. Of course it is well within your rights to speed blitz a crt and not allow the opposition to respond (staff do whatever the hell they want) but I am just informing you that it would be in extremely poor taste.
Cool, but you're always going to have more to say. Arguments can go on forever. The odds of you convincing 5 other staff to agree with you is unlikely.
there have been worse odds before, just let me speak for christ sake. Lordgriffon didn't even reconfirm his vote, ping him or something and let him read through everything that has been said.
 
and you have not even begun to give me a chance to speak to you about your disagreement. Of course it is well within your rights to speed blitz a crt and not allow the opposition to respond (staff do whatever the hell they want) but I am just informing you that it would be in extremely poor taste.
Sorry, I've read your points. Unlikely you will convince me. Again, accept no for an answer, saves you time.

Edit: Also, continuously groaning about staff doing "whatever they want" doesn't help your case. The thread has been opened for close to three days. You have given plenty argumentation, and plenty have been given to you. Some better than others, truth be told (the piercing point recently brought up is irrelevant, we would still scale that to their AP).

You've been heard, you've been disagreed with. That's all.
 
The idea that post dt nero is stronger in base to begin with is shaky, especially considering that's not even his real devil trigger. I might actually get to that another time, but regardless, saying that post-dt nero is too much is something that you have to prove, and the burden of proof is heavily on you if you are claiming it's PIS for post dt nero to not be able to one shot Bianco Angelos. Simply saying that he fought someone stronger does not cut it, because that doesn't mean that it wouldn't just scale lower into the same tier.
Wym Post-DT Nero is not stronger that's literally ACCEPTED on the wiki.

yes, piercing damage, but either way there is no justification for choosing to scale it to pre dt nero but not accepting the fact that it was able to tangle with post dt nero
piercing damage does not negate durability as you said yourself, and regardless lady's piercing would just be 4-C anyways, so it's not very meaningful.
I said it's limited, not that it doesn't negate durability and that much lower guys can **** you up with piercing damage. And how would Lady's piercing be 4-C?? That doesn't even make sense. If you're talking about the Knight then no, those don't scale from Post-DT Nero, i already explained why that is PIS, your argument to debunk me was holding up because you think: Nero (Post-DT) >= Nero (Pre-DT) which is not accepted in the wiki as i said earlier.
 
Let's give him the benefit of the doubt.

@CrimsonStarFallen @Theglassman12 @DarkGrath @DarkDragonMedeus

Thoughts on the OP? Armor's, Tony's and KLOL points are also worth reading.
you pinged everyone except for lordgriffon
I was specifically asking for someone who has already participated in here and is more willing to read through everything, and you pinged a bunch of busy people who realistically have better things to do than put all their thought into this thread.
Sorry, I've read your points. Unlikely you will convince me. Again, accept no for an answer, saves you time.
typical debating etiquette includes listing all your reasoning, as I have done every. singe. post.
It gives the opponent a chance to either be convinced, or to understand why you disagree and make a counterargument in case you had a misunderstanding. I always show my thought process because it helps out both me and you.
You're clearly not making any effort to debate for the sake of the debate itself, and instead to just assert your opinion and not participate any further. It is perfectly reasonable for me to request that I actually get something to work with so we can actually discuss. If you were too busy to discuss or didn't want to or something, that would be perfectly fine, but you don't have to screw over my thread in the process.
The entire reason that the voting system is supposed to work is that as long as there's someone in the crowd with a good point being made, other people would in theory either convince them otherwise or have their minds changed. Putting your foot in the ground and giving a vote with no offer of being open minded and allowing your opinion to potentially changed, turns the debate into "I disagree and here's why, let's talk about it" into "I disagree, therefore you are not allowed to talk."
Majority rule works because people give all their reasoning and sway eachother, so we can easily clear up every loose end. And it is clear that it is not working that way. I am 100% willing to change my mind about things, and it doesn't seem you are returning the favor.
 
you pinged everyone except for lordgriffon
I was specifically asking for someone who has already participated in here and is more willing to read through everything, and you pinged a bunch of busy people who realistically have better things to do than put all their thought into this thread.
I pinged supporters of the verse and a neutral staff. Fresh opinions that may provide something new that may have not been considered yet. If you have a problem with that, the rest of your post becomes humorous to me. Also, I did not see the comment about asking for @LordGriffin1000 again. But go off, I suppose.
 
in that case, the OP is outdated, since the majority of the issues I've addressed since then have used evidence not present there, it would be easy for them to miss all the discussion they hadn't participated in.
In a past crt I had to update it with every counterargument and rebuttal to ensure that new people could jump in and know what's going on and avoid repeats of the first page, but in this case there's a lot to cover
I think we would agree that repeating the page one arguments would waste time, and time is not very abundant here at the moment, so I'm not really sure what you want me to do...
 
Wym Post-DT Nero is not stronger that's literally ACCEPTED on the wiki.
yeah ik, that's something that this crt (or I guess another one, if this dies) would have to change, since Bianco angelo downscales from both his base forms and there's no justification for saying that his base got stronger from him getting a new transformation.
 
yeah ik, that's something that this crt (or I guess another one, if this dies) would have to change, since Bianco angelo downscales from both his base forms and there's no justification for saying that his base got stronger from him getting a new transformation.
I see.
Well you could ask a knowledgeable member what's the reason for that and see if you think it's valid cuz i forgot lmao
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top