• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

A consistent feat in the SMB franchise

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dino_Ranger_Black

VS Battles
Retired
2,031
989
So....this is our new layout, huh? Anyway, good day everyone. Dino Ranger Black here. I've been thinking just recently about this topic that user named Peach chan have made about how odd and incoherent Mario's page is, suggesting of making separate tiers by the games he appeared due to his variable statistics, as well as, questionable reasons for their stats as well. The main issue seems to stem from gaps between the feats Mario achieved. Consistency and continuity in the series is a major issue as well, which many believe not to be there. However, I actually do believe we have a consistent feat to use to scale Mario. In at least 4 of his 3D games:

SM64 and

the DS versio

SMG1

SMG2 and

3D World via Green Stars,

Mario have fought bosses and Bowser, who are powered up by Power Stars, making this a realiable feat to scale him from.

What are the statistics of the Power Stars?

In Super Mario 64, Power Stars have shown to be At least Star level by Bowser using them, to create realms which shown to contain at least star in them. In fact, Wiggler (more on him later), who lives in Tiny Huge Island (One of the worlds Bowser made), noted that he doesn't need the Power Star anymore since he sees the stars at night after beating him. This means these realms are large enough to contain mutiple stars. This is back-up in a later 3D game, Super Mario Galaxy, viastatement by Rosalina, who has an extensive knowledge of the cosmos. According to her, lumas can turn into power stars, which can turn into planets, stars, and entire galaxies. Lastly, we have some calculations for the Power Stars due to being capable into turning in black holes. Three calculations where made in this blog: One made by The real cal howard, Lina Shields, and Executor N0 each. While they all have different results, they all are somewhere around Tier 4, with two out of three of them being around Star level. All this information constantly have the Power Stars somewhere around Tier 4 with Star-related feats being prominent, so the most appropriate rating would be At least Star level. We will include At least, due to the fact they can also form galaxies and being able to create a realm with mutiple stars in the background.


Are bosses really amped up by Power Stars?

They are indeed. In SM64, Bowser gave his minions Power Stars. He threatens Mario to return the Power Stars he managed to retrieved from the enemies he defeated since they need them and stated that he gave them power via the Power Stars, noting it's fading away but not being over yet if the player didn't obtain all of the Power Stars. Another example is Wiggler in SM64. He noted that ever since he held a Power Star, he felt strange. This is obviously the Power Star's doing, which made him drastically bigger and alot more powerful but couldn't seem to handle it's power. Finally, in SMG, Bowser Jr also instructed Megaleg to attack Mario with the power of the Grand Star. With this being said, the bosses are indeed empowered by these celestial artifacts.


Green Stars are Power Stars?

Correct. Different colored Power Stars debuted in Super Mario Galaxy (Or Super Mario 64, if you want to count the start screen). They are treated same as Yellow Power Stars, being added to the over all counter in the game and it's sequel. Infact, Red Power Stars also exists. There's no indication about the difference in power in any of them either. It's just purely for aesthetics.

What about Mario's higher end feats?

We can simply label them with a Possibly rating, using his most notable high end feat. Whether it's his battle against Grand Star powered Bowser or other.


With this knowledge, it would be more neat, organised, and more importantly, consistent if we include a, At least Star level rating for Mario (And everyone else who scales from him) based on these facts. Not only we can finally remove the confusing variable tier, it will make the page alot more logical and so much easier to scale possible future characters in the franchise.

Edit: Forget about what I said about the Possibly rating. We believe it would be better to exclude it since other characters such as Sonic and Kirby are also facing a similar situation. Thus the rating should be: At least Large Star level+ (Capable of defeating people empowered by the Power Stars, which can create realms that contain at least a star and vast space around it. Along with producing this level of power and being stated by Rosalina to be comparable to the Lumas, who can transform into actual stars), likely Multi-Solar System level (Power Stars create realms large enough to contain multiple stars and capable of fighting Antasma, even when amped by Dreamy Luigi.)
 
Hallelujah at last! Mario's profile can finally be coherent now. Thank you very much, Dino.

One thing though I can agree to the higher ends being a "possibly higher." But I've been thinking, wouldn't Mario beating Grand Star powered Bowser even within that game be PIS? I mean it doesn't make much sense for Mario unamped to beat someone who's already a match for him when their power was vastly greatened. Unless I am missing something or mistaken.
 
Shouldn't it be Multi-Solar System instead of Star because of Wiggler's statement to see stars at night? I think 4-A is possibly more certain than 4-C.
 
Darn, this seems pretty solid. It has my support.

However if we want to get rid of the variable tier, we're probably better off just leaving him at just straight up High 4-C, using these 4-C feats to support it in consistency.
 
Kevyn Souza said:
Shouldn't it be Multi-Solar System instead of Star because of Wiggler's claim to see stars at night? I think 4-A is possibly more certain than 4-C.
I think "At least 4-C, possibly 4-A" is alright.
 
Also, considering that the star in the background is about the same distance away our sun is from the Earth, wouldn't the entire realm be far higher than Star level in size?
 
@Ryu

You have a point but it's becoming a trend in the franchise. Whether he's amped up by Kamek's magic, Grand Stars, the Dreamstone, his paper counterpart, black paint, Royal Crown sticker, etc Bowser always seems to fall to Mario in the end of the battle, usually ranting about how he is unable to beat him even with his new found power and it's more often that not that Mario doesn't have any enhancements of his own, the only exception being the Peach Beam when he used the Star Rod from the top of my head.
 
IMO most video games that have a certain series with continuity (like Mario and Luigi series,other nintendo characters video game series etc.) Should be qualified since it has some sort of continuity in the series. At least 4-c possibly4-A possibly far higher defeated bowser with several artifacts is fine
 
So more often than not, unamped Bowser really isn't on par with Mario?
 
I agree since Raphael the Raven was turned in a costellation by Yoshi and in Paper Mario another one helped Mario.
 
I'm unsure about this because the Grand Stars have much higher feats:

  • Quote on Bowser's profile: "The Grand Star is more powerful than Power Stars. The Lumas that turn into Power Stars can also turn into galaxies. Bowser also absorbed many Power Stars in the SMG2 final battle and was going to create galaxies via a reactor in SMG1"
  • Super Mario Galaxy feat via Galaxy Reactor: The Grand Star also collapsed and gave rebirth to the universe, making it Universe level+.
I don't know about the regular Power Stars, but the Grand Star's ratings should probably stay the same.
 
@Ryu

More like Bowser is willing to use different means to gain a victory over him. Considering he boasts greater strength and power in base form and beaten his dark counterpart in BIS, he's obviously on par. That or just because the good guys always win cliche.
 
@Palemario

That's not the point though. My main point is that Power Stars can be used to power Bowser's underlings.
 
Well if Bowser's base is "obviously on par" with Mario I think him beating Grand Star amped Bowser should be PIS. Regardless if similar things have also happened in other games.

And since with Mario it's often brought up that we should be fair and treat it like we treat others. Erza's feat was discarded as PIS since she previously couldn't stand a chance against a super restrained Irene, then went on to overpower her greatest attack.

Or Sonic's Tier 2 feat in the Rush games being considered PIS since Super Sonic beat a force explicitly far superior to the Chaos Emeralds and Sol Emeralds.

So I think Mario without any power increase defeating someone on par with him who got amped by orders of maginude should be seen as PIS.
 
Ryukama said:
Well if Bowser's base is "obviously on par" with Mario I think him beating Grand Star amped Bowser should be PIS. Regardless if similar things have also happened in other games.
And since with Mario it's often brought up that we should be fair and treat it like we treat others. Erza's feat was discarded as PIS since she previously couldn't stand a chance against a super restrained Irene, then went on to overpower her greatest attack.

Or Sonic's Tier 2 feat in the Rush games being considered PIS since Super Sonic beat a force explicitly far superior to the Chaos Emeralds and Sol Emeralds.

So I think Mario without any power increase defeating someone on par with him who got amped by orders of maginude should be seen as PIS.
I agree.
 
@Ryu

But that's why I suggested a Possibly. We aren't going to outright scale him or anything. We are just going to note it.
 
I feel that he should keep his 7-B tier due to his weaker appearences, like most of the 2D platformers, though I do agree with this.
 
I don't think Mario beating Grand Star Bowser should even be put as a possibility since it's kinda clearly PIS. We wouldn't make Sonic "At least ___ possibly higher" and include his Rush feats or have Erza be "At least ___ possibly higher" and include her Irene feat.

Other Mario high ends I'm fine with being put into that "possibly higher" conglomerate.
 
@Paleomario

In fact, Wiggler (more on him later), who lives in Tiny Huge Island (One of the worlds Bowser made), noted that he doesn't need the Power Star since he sees the stars at night.

Shouldn't it be Multi-Solar System instead of Star because of Wiggler's statement to see stars at night? I think 4-A is possibly more certain than 4-C.

^^
 
@Ryu

It happened 3 in a single game and it's not even the strongest artifact Bowser used but I rather not argue since I'm abit tired after making this. I'll agree with your Possibly higher suggestion since you reminded me about how Sonic and Kirby are in a similar situation and I used a similar arguement for why I'm against making seperate tiers for Mario.

So based on what everyone is saying, are we ok with this rating?:

At least Star level, likely Multi Solar System level (Fought bosses and enemies powered up by Power Stars), possibly higher ( Capable of fighting Bowser being powered by different powerful artifacts and other beings)
 
He didn't say Mario defeating bowser is PIS, he simply said Mario defeating a Galaxy level Grand Star powered Bowser was PIS.
 
Dino Ranger Black said:
@Ryu
It happened 3 in a single game and it's not even the strongest artifact Bowser used but I rather not argue since I'm abit tired after making this. Possibly higher it is since you reminded me about how Sonic and Kirby is in a similar situation and I used a similar arguement for why I'm against making seperate tiers for Mario.

So based on what everyone is saying, are we ok with this rating:

At least Star level, likely Multi Solar System level (Fought bosses and enemies powered up by Power Stars), possibly higher ( Capable of fighting Bowser being powered by different powerful artifacts and other beings)
That should work, but two things:

1. Where did the MSS rating for the Power Stars come from? Wouldn't it be Large Star level, or is there something I'm missing?

2. Also, we could make a note about Bowser's durability feat in Super Mario Galaxy (unless you're fine with it just being mentioned in the possibly higher on Bowser's durability).
 
Dino Ranger Black said:
At least Star level, likely Multi Solar System level (Fought bosses and enemies powered up by Power Stars), possibly higher ( Capable of fighting Bowser being powered by different powerful artifacts and other beings)
I agree with this
 
@Dino

You mentioned how the Wiggler stated that it could always see stars in the night sky.

If it's a starry sky, then the realm is likely 4-A in size. But that should be kept as a possibility.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top