• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

ZillertheBucko said:
do-s doesn't scale to MA arc fubuki
Click to expand...
I'm not 100% sure if Fubuki's chapter 114 Hellstorm knocked out DO-S but she didn't get seriously injured by it either. I think it bears e
ZillertheBucko said:
Still using threat level scaling terminology in 2023 smh
Click to expand...
Just because you had a CRT doesn't mean I and others like me scale differently now, I don't know what your non vsbattle mates use but everybody on the block's using disaster levels on my side of things
LordTracer said:
Same tier =/= comparable in power.
Click to expand...
I say tier in this case because the gap is too big for them both to fight comfortably in mountain level or large mountain level together, since those are respectively x10 and x4.3 deviations from weakest to strongest- even Island is only a X20~ difference. This town ain't big enough for the two of them
 
Ourosboros said:
I'm not 100% sure if Fubuki's chapter 114 Hellstorm knocked out DO-S but she didn't get seriously injured by it either. I think it bears e
Click to expand...
we don't even know if she's alive or dead, she's never seen again after that
and base bang alone (which fubuki scales to) completely wiped out the entire squad and dealt with do-s without taking any damage

anyways lets think about this

At least high 7-A+ Fubuki> High 7-A+ Do-s < At least high 7-A+ amai mask << at most 6-C fuhrer ugly
At most 6-C fuhrer ugly > At least high 7-A+ gums = At least high 7-A+ tank top master.....
Tank top master and darkshine scaling to the same thing is kinda bad....
even if we make a monster raid arc ttm key (we know he constantly trains, so it's kinda plausible) it ends up like
At least high 7-A+ tank top master < at most 6-C Fuhrer Ugly < Base Bang
which leaves bang scaling to at most 6-C....in a chain where he's supposed to be at least high 7-A+
somehow we'd need to get him one half step lower before it was consistent
 
although the best I could do is saying that rover's blast is only = to bang's AP, and fubuki downscales from it
which would mean
At least high 7-A+ bang = Rover AP > High 7-A+ Fubuki > At most high 7-A+ do-s < High 7-A+ Amai Mask << At least high 7-A+ Fuhrer Ugly > High 7-A+ Gums = MA arc Tanktop Master
High 7-A+ MA Arc TTM = Gums < At least high 7-A+ Fuhrer Ugly < Base Bang

but also if do-s is at most high 7-A+
she's a monster association demon level which means Phoenix Man, Nyan, Drive Knight, evil water, brave giant, and Iaian would GET THE SCALING THEY ******* DESERVE
 
Ourosboros said:
Just because you had a CRT doesn't mean I and others like me scale differently now, I don't know what your non vsbattle mates use but everybody on the block's using disaster levels on my side of things
Click to expand...
btw disaster levels outside the monster association are an L, if you read the thread revising them you'd see why
 
Comparing the before and after, would you guys say that prisoner did "damage" to jet psykos here?
https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/1047992184210726993/1060760342877196358/IMG_0037.png
https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/1047992184210726993/1060760963055374366/IMG_0038.png
 
ZillertheBucko said:
Comparing the before and after, would you guys say that prisoner did "damage" to jet psykos here?
https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/1047992184210726993/1060760342877196358/IMG_0037.png
https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/1047992184210726993/1060760963055374366/IMG_0038.png
Click to expand...
ZillertheBucko said:
the one on the left is probably nothing but the one on the right looks more like damage
Click to expand...
I mean, the fact that he was causing indents on Jet Psykos should be enough to say he was dealing significant damage
 
because uh basically
heart orochi survives hits from bang, bomb, and darkshine
prisoner doing minor damage to psykos should downscale
prisoner has reactive evolution so it makes sense that he would go from getting one shot by garou to downscaling from dark shine

Bos prisoner high 7-C
Post DSK prisoner scales to double his previous value?
Post garou fight prisoner should be high 7-A+ for damaging jet psykos who survived hits from bang, bomb, and darkshine
 
https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/917231037757673472/917280809860354068/page_20.png
well I'll be damned
zombieman does scale after all
 
LordTracer said:
It takes significant damage from them (especially Darkshine, his kick mutilated Orochi so much that Psykos said his body was useless now), just surviving doesn’t necessarily mean it scales.
Click to expand...
the infamous downscaling

psykos saying the body was useless isn't exactly a quantifiable metric for anything. After all, it was still alive after both bang and bomb attacked it too, and only died from the tatsumaki drill later on. We don't know how damaged it would have to be for it to be considered "bad" to be fused with anymore to psykos
after darkshine kicked it, it was still completely conscious as well. I suggest we just go with
At least high 7-A+ darkshine/Bang/Bomb > High 7-A+ Orochi heart durability = Post-Garou Prisoner AP
 
ZillertheBucko said:
the infamous downscaling
Click to expand...
No offense, but you say this a lot… and you really don’t understand how it works. Downscaling is done when a character is inferior, but still displays some degree of comparability. Getting severely damaged, but still surviving, isn’t grounds for durability downscaling. That’s a stamina feat, but not a durability feat.
ZillertheBucko said:
psykos saying the body was useless isn't exactly a quantifiable metric for anything. After all, it was still alive after both bang and bomb attacked it too, and only died from the tatsumaki drill later on.
Click to expand...
I reiterate: just surviving doesn’t necessarily mean durability. Let me remind you of the definition of durability:
Durability is the property which guarantees the ability to withstand a certain amount of force. Withstanding force consists of the measurement of the severity of damage from attacks. This is not to be confused with endurance; while durability is the ability to withstand damage, endurance is a measure of stamina.
Click to expand...
When Darkshine kicks Psykorochi, there’s a visible indent in Orochi’s body and blood is spurting from it. The next panel, they’re screaming in pain and still spewing blood. That’s not withstanding force, that’s just surviving an attack. And to quote from the durability page’s section on surviving attacks:
Many characters have been shown to survive attacks far above their durability, usually surviving with large injuries that others on their scale usually wouldn't survive. This is because of endurance, as they can endure a certain amount of pain regardless if the attack has burned them or sliced off limbs. This is not a durability factor, as this is a quality that is commonly attributed to willpower.
Click to expand...
Orochi’s heart doesn’t downscale from Darkshine because it didn’t withstand his attack. It was severely damaged and only survived the attack, which isn’t a metric to judge durability. It wouldn’t scale to Bang and Bomb for similar reasons.
 
ReusedOil said:
I just realized... seeing as how saitama's endurance is seemingly not dependent on biological functions, and more about his willpower, is it fair to assume that saitama has "infinite endurance"?

The only limit being saitama's desire wether to continue or not.
Click to expand...
ReusedOil said:
Can endurance still be considered finite if calculating the amount is basically estimated by "how much the person gives a ****"?

Usually it doesnt matter how much willpower you have if you run out of energy and so the body fails to work, but its shown saitama's willpower supersedes the needs of the body and its biological functions.

If saitama is motivated enough, could he theoretically have "infinite endurance"?
Click to expand...
Bump
 
LordTracer said:
No offense, but you say this a lot… and you really don’t understand how it works. Downscaling is done when a character is inferior, but still displays some degree of comparability. Getting severely damaged, but still surviving, isn’t grounds for durability downscaling. That’s a stamina feat, but not a durability feat.
Click to expand...
I'm done with arguing for the prisoner thing, but I do disagree with this methodology.
Being able to stay intact after being hit will always mean something. For example, if a baseline 3-B character with infinite stamina is punched by a 3-A character, they are going to be blown to piece and die instantly no matter what. You would have to be insanely far above baseline 3-B+ for it to not like atomize you or something. When it comes to sword cutting off limbs, that's just a case in which the victim didn't stay intact at all, so it doesn't really count, but if you take a non suppressed punch from someone and don't get a hole punched through you or blown up or your limbs fly off from it, then it does say something about your durability from being able to completely maintain your structure, even if it causes immense pain and damage. There are different kinds of one shots, which I think the wiki doesn't really make a good differentiation between.
1. Being able to punch someone and knock them out or cause them to cough big amounts of blood etc.
2. Being able to punch someone and crack their bones
3. being able to punch someone and completely shatter all of their bones
4. Being able to punch someone and instantly blow them up into a pile of meat

Personally I feel as though with case 1, the gap would be most accurately represented by the difference between "at most 7-B" and 7-B or "at least 7-B", or something like that
There needs to be a clear difference shown between being one shot to a much lesser degree than 3 and 4 and still staying intact.
Because again, stamina is literally never going to save you if an attack really is strong enough to actually be like a 50 times gap or something insane like that (which is even smaller of a gap than what high 7-C to high 7-A+ would suggest)
LordTracer said:
It wouldn’t scale to Bang and Bomb for similar reasons.
Click to expand...
honestly they did nowhere near the amount of damage that darkshine did anyways, and were using a rush attack from both sides.
 
The main issue to me is whether or not prisoner did damage, which I do believe he did a little bit but I don't feel is worth arguing at the moment
 
so how about this

  • 6-C Platinum Sperm > At most 6-C PD AB Garou = AB bang > at least high 7-A+ base PD Garou = Bomb = Base Bang = Rover AP > High 7-A+ Fubuki
  • At least high 7-A+ rover AP > high 7-A+ Half monster garou
  • Spiral Garou = At least high 7-A+ Darkshine > high 7-A+ Half Monster garou
  • 6-C Platinum Sperm > At most 6-C Golden Sperm > At least high 7-A+ Darkshine = base bang = bomb
  • at most 6-C AB Bang = Post Molt centipede > at least high 7-A+ Pre Molt centipede ~ Bomb = Base Bang
  • at most 6-C Post molt centipede > At least high 7-A+ Jet Drive arrow (genos durability, striking strength doesn't scale)
  • At least high 7-A+ Pre molt Centipede > High 7-A+ Metal Knight missiles
  • At least high 7-A+ Base Bang ~ Atomic Samurai > High 7-A+ Half Monster garou
  • At most 6-C Sun Blade atomic samurai = Golden Sperm > At least high 7-A+ Darkshine
  • Fubuki > At most High 7-A+ Do-s
  • At most high 7-A+ Drive Knight = Nyan > at most high 7-A+ Do-s
  • At least high 7-A+ Fuhrer Ugly > High 7-A+ Amai Mask > At most high 7-A+ Do-s
  • At least high 7-A+ Fuhrer Ugly > High 7-A+ Gums ~ MA raid arc Tanktop master
  • High 7-A+ Gums = Pig God > At most high 7-A+ Mercenaries = Disciples
  • high 7-A+ Evil natural water > mercenaries and disciples

It's also worth nothing that nyan thought he could damage saitama after he saw him one punch rover, so Nyan is possibly higher
 
https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/917231033714376734/917274862333067264/p_38.png
https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/917231032820973628/917274869903814707/p_39.png
Confidence scaling is an absolute blessing
 
ZillertheBucko said:
https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/917231033714376734/917274862333067264/p_38.png
https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/917231032820973628/917274869903814707/p_39.png
Confidence scaling is an absolute blessing
Click to expand...
Cap Scaling*

Nyan is off-the-chain for thinking he could harm a guy who could one-shot someone with high dragon durability like Rover- this is the fool who nearly died to Gearsper
 
Ourosboros said:
Cap Scaling*

Nyan is off-the-chain for thinking he could harm a guy who could one-shot someone with high dragon durability like Rover- this is the fool who nearly died to Gearsper
Click to expand...
The term “high dragon” still makes me cringe
Well gearsper literally never showed any kind of power before he fought nyan, and he literally escaped anyways when he knew it was dangerous so like
how does this have any relevance?
 
Anyways I honestly narratively prefer the new scaling web I made much mote
Rover being described as one of the strongest members of the association and then being like hundreds of times weaker than gale wind who wasn’t even a cadre yet, and platinum sperm being so much ridiculously superior compared to the rest of the monster association as well is kinda trash
So high 7-A+ nyan, phoenix man, natural water, rover, and fuhrer ugly makes way more sense to me
 
ZillertheBucko said:
https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/917231033714376734/917274862333067264/p_38.png
https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/917231032820973628/917274869903814707/p_39.png
Confidence scaling is an absolute blessing
Click to expand...
You’ve got to be ******** me.

Nyan is sweating and clearly scared after seeing Saitama one-shot Rover, to the point that he calls him a monster. Then he decides that he needs to go for a surprise attack, which shows that he isn’t even confident that he can beat Saitama to begin with.

There is no scaling here.
 
LordTracer said:
You’ve got to be ******** me.

Nyan is sweating and clearly scared after seeing Saitama one-shot Rover, to the point that he calls him a monster. Then he decides that he needs to go for a surprise attack, which shows that he isn’t even confident that he can beat Saitama to begin with.

There is no scaling here.
Click to expand...
See scaling chain instead then, since I don’t really care enough to convince people about this route
 
ZillertheBucko said:
so how about this

  • 6-C Platinum Sperm > At most 6-C PD AB Garou = AB bang > at least high 7-A+ base PD Garou = Bomb = Base Bang = Rover AP > High 7-A+ Fubuki
  • At least high 7-A+ rover AP > high 7-A+ Half monster garou
  • Spiral Garou = At least high 7-A+ Darkshine > high 7-A+ Half Monster garou
  • 6-C Platinum Sperm > At most 6-C Golden Sperm > At least high 7-A+ Darkshine = base bang = bomb
  • at most 6-C AB Bang = Post Molt centipede > at least high 7-A+ Pre Molt centipede ~ Bomb = Base Bang
  • at most 6-C Post molt centipede > At least high 7-A+ Jet Drive arrow (genos durability, striking strength doesn't scale)
  • At least high 7-A+ Pre molt Centipede > High 7-A+ Metal Knight missiles
  • At least high 7-A+ Base Bang ~ Atomic Samurai > High 7-A+ Half Monster garou
  • At most 6-C Sun Blade atomic samurai = Golden Sperm > At least high 7-A+ Darkshine
  • Fubuki > At most High 7-A+ Do-s
  • At most high 7-A+ Drive Knight = Nyan > at most high 7-A+ Do-s
  • At least high 7-A+ Fuhrer Ugly > High 7-A+ Amai Mask > At most high 7-A+ Do-s
  • At least high 7-A+ Fuhrer Ugly > High 7-A+ Gums ~ MA raid arc Tanktop master
  • High 7-A+ Gums = Pig God > At most high 7-A+ Mercenaries = Disciples
  • high 7-A+ Evil natural water > mercenaries and disciples

It's also worth nothing that nyan thought he could damage saitama after he saw him one punch rover, so Nyan is possibly higher
Click to expand...
Is nobody gonna comment on the scaling chain at all
 
LordTracer said:
Fubuki doesn’t scale unless she’s at her peak, which means Do-S doesn’t scale either.
Click to expand...
The wording of fubuki’s “peak” on her profile is a weird special treatment that shouldn’t be there. When a character is able to block and attack but with high effort and gets injuries, we downscale them. It’s kind of silly to make fubuki the exception just because you feel like doing it this one particular time?
 
Dual_Binoculars said:
This is like the 10th scaling chain you've posted just make the CRT already. We can sort out the scaling there.
Click to expand...
Of course I’m not making the crt yet. I want to make sure that all the logic connects beforehand so I don’t have a sloppy shitty crt where everything gets decided there
I’ve just been asking for a little cooperation so that I can sort things out beforehand and have an easier time knowing what I actually want my proposal to be
If I had gone in without doing this, I would’ve had a crt where human Garou scales directly to his stronger selves and fuhrer ugly scales to the monster Garou that one shot him
So I really do need people to bring their counterpoints beforehand so I can see 1. Which ones I agree with that I should change my scaling chain for
and 2. Which ones are disagreed with too much that I probably would have a smaller chance of getting accepted regardless of if I believe it’s true or not. Otherwise instead of things being “sorted out” there, it would just get rejected and probably just closed. I’m making as much preparation beforehand so I have the facts right and can actually get it accepted.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

EnderLord8
STRONGEST One-Punch Man (Anime version) Discussion Thread
2
Replies
64
Views
8K
Anonymous_Learner
Anonymous_Learner
Recon1511
One Punch Man: Major Timeframe Upgrade
2
Replies
61
Views
8K
Raiden38
Raiden38
Lightning_XXI
Flash Vs Psykos & Gouketsu (OPM)
Replies
2
Views
1K
Recon1511
Recon1511
Farfetchedx
One Punch Man: Mid Tiers Scaling Revision
Replies
29
Views
5K
XSOULOFCINDERX
XSOULOFCINDERX
LIFE_OF_KING
  • Locked
One Punch Man - Willpower is weird
2
Replies
66
Views
8K
LephyrTheRevanchist
LephyrTheRevanchist
Back
Top