- 6,774
- 3,686
That's Reverse Burden of Proof, actually
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
- 8,132
- 4,129
Ok then what's the evidence that he peaked and can't grow?
- 6,774
- 3,686
This whole discussion made me think on a scenario where we didn't scaled Boros to Orochi + Saitama getting stronger by breathing
He would have a High 6-A key and a Low 5-B key lol
He would have a High 6-A key and a Low 5-B key lol
- 7,196
- 7,580
Where's the evidence that he's grown. And you don't need to reach a literal peak to be unable to grow. All it would mean is that his growth has slowed down, not because he's reached a peak or even getting close to one, but because the training itself doesn't actually do anything for him. He's a surface-level character bare minimum and far beyond the speed of light. The reason the old workout for him was working originally is cause Saitama started off as a normal man. And because he was having so much trouble with what is now an effortless workout, that struggle allowed him to break his limiter, because the limits placed on him were absurdly low due to his average potential. There's no reason to assume the training actually has an effect on him.
- 22,686
- 23,270
On this site the current accepted point about Saitama's strength is that he's reached his peak but we don't know what that peak is besides being vastly superior to everyone else.
- 26,415
- 30,724
Low 5-B doesn't exist anymore owo
- 6,774
- 3,686
- 8,132
- 4,129
I think we're just seeing things differently because I tend to look at everything narratively rather than consistency like this site and what's generally accepted like what Q said. My argument, and the latter it's all theory until further notice.
- 26,415
- 30,724
- 8,132
- 4,129
Protecting people is more important to him than his depression lol so idek why you even made that argument.
- 26,415
- 30,724
His depression comes from him being too strong so he can't have a good challenge, how is saving people related to his sadness?
- 8,132
- 4,129
I thought you were implying he stopped training due to his depression, mybad.
- 3,397
- 2,450
Can someone post the translations, please?
- 8,132
- 4,129
Is there anyways we can reopen a crt for Csrc? Because both of these databooks Japanese and spanish have it at planet busting level.
- 8,132
- 4,129
- 26,415
- 30,724
The manga states it to be only High 6-A. The Manga (the main source material) > the databooks
Plus show the scan for Spanish and Japanese
- 8,132
- 4,129
- 26,415
- 30,724
Wasn't that a mistranslation? I remember most translation resulting in planet surface. Preferably I'd say we try translate it from the Japanese raw. Plus the manga established the CSRC as a surface level attack, not a planet busting one.
- 8,132
- 4,129
That's just the thing, vib translates all the manga for us and he told me he works with a professional translator. So why would it be wrong?
Also in spanish the sentence says
"un ataque desalmado que destuira la tierra"
Which translates to "a soulless attack that will destroy the earth"
Can also translate to "a soulless attack that will destroy the planet" but tierra is typically used to describe the earth.
- 26,415
- 30,724
To be safe I guess. Plus again, the manga describes the attack as High 6-A, and we should prioritize manga info over databook.
- 23,381
- 21,117
- 8,132
- 4,129
This is one redraw man though lol could easily be a retcon tbh.
- 16,286
- 17,800
Sorry to burst your bubble, that exact page has already been discussed and it was accepted that it being planet surface level is more accurate.
- 8,132
- 4,129
I mean it's officially planet in two databooks. Much more credibility in them.
Nullflowerblush
He/Him- 10,777
- 9,664
It's officially planet surface in both the manga and the original webcomic.
Also, there is only one databook, unless you are referring to the anime-only Compus guide.
Also, there is only one databook, unless you are referring to the anime-only Compus guide.
- 8,132
- 4,129
Could have easily downplayed himself.
- 26,415
- 30,724
That's dumb, with your logic, we can highball Boros to 4-C.
- 26,415
- 30,724
The anime campus guide actually has 4-C instead of 5-B, but High 6-Q made way more sense in context
- 8,132
- 4,129
That's silly, that's nothing to base 4-C on.
- 8,132
- 4,129
The anime is a separate canon.
- 26,415
- 30,724
Most of our translation including the main source material establish the CSRC as a High 6-A attack. Most of raw translations refer to CSRC as High 6-aa
We are not going with 5-B CSRC
We are not going with 5-B CSRC
- 26,415
- 30,724
But according to you, Boros could just be easily done playing himself, so he's probably 3-A
- 8,132
- 4,129
Herms, vib, and official sources translate it to planet but you guys translate it to surface and it's not even up for debate?
- 8,132
- 4,129
I think you're confused as that's not the logic I used.
- 26,415
- 30,724
The anime compus chose to turn a kanji that can mean several things but chose star, when that doesn't match with the original context or the proper Japanese sentence. So just because it's official doesn't mean it's 100 percent right
And again, Manga > The Databook. The Databook is there to provide additional informationinformation, not out main source
- 8,132
- 4,129
The compus is only canon to the anime. There's nothing really contradicting star but we're not talking about that rn.
Manga is > Databook but the attack never landed, the databook is showing additional information showing its stronger than he thought it was.
- 23,381
- 21,117
I kinda agree with this ngl.
- 16,286
- 17,800
No, it’s not lmao, the thread I linked literally goes over the databook page you’re talking about and came to the conclusion of it being planet surface destruction and not entire planet destruction.
- 8,132
- 4,129
The thread is 3 years old, which is why I think we should revisit it with the new information.
Similar threads
