• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Your guns against my lightning-flamming fists: Natsu Dragneel vs Mami Tomoe

Status
Not open for further replies.
Homu_Sweet_Homu

Homu_Sweet_Homu

7,681
996
I was actually gonna make this another Homura vs X thread, but the very character I wanted to use somehow Mindscrew me into making this fight instead. Magical Girl Mami and Post-Second Origin LFD Mode Natsu. Both in characters and starts from 10 meters apart. Speed was equalized....otherwise, Natsu would blizts Mami to oblivion.

Natsu Postcard From Fairy Box
This Mofo is hot.....literally.

Mami Tomoe1
Kal has decent taste for his waifu, too bad she often to lose her head.

Natsu Dragneel: 9 (Scarlet, Byakushiki, Captain, Monarch, Zack, Blanked, Burning, COB, Scarletmoon)

Mami Tomoe:

Inconclusive: 5 (Kaltias, Elione, Gargoyle, Knight, Theglassman12)
 
1. Does Gun of Aegis reflect all attack, or just projectiles? If it's the latter, Natsu has the edge since he's more of the physical fighter

2. Are her ribbons resistant to heat? If not Natsu burns them

3. I don't see any explanation for her power disable. How does that work?
 
Anyway, I don't think it will works on physical attack. So yeah Natsu isn't completely helpless here.

Not sure about that, but it got destroyed by Homura's gun. The thing is, if a ribbon has been destroyed, another one will appears to replace it. Getting rid of it would be a pain for Natsu.

Her power disable works by using ribbon trap. Mmi created a clone made of her ribbon and it will ensnare her enemy leaving them unable to move and and disables the use of their powers. Even Homura cannot used her timestop power once she fell for this trap.

Edit: I wore a helmet, thank you very much. :p
 
As for the matchup, I'm not really decided but I'm leaning towards Natsu.

Mami's bullet spam will prove challenging and dangerous but Natsu's large AoE attacks will cover a lot of them in a single strike so he can likely open up a path in front of himself. I don't think Mami's ribbons will have much use here. Natsu has monstrous strength and is not a stranger to immobilizing techniques having broken out of Gray's flash freezing and Sting's paralyzing mark.

If he manages to close the distance to Mami, he has a large advantage in CQC as Mami doesn't really fight in that range at all. The best she can do is try and run away or use ribbons to restrain him.

As for her reflecting attack, I don't know the full extent of it's capabilites so can't say much on it. If Natsu's attack gets reflected, I don't think it will harm him due to his extreme resistance to heat.
 
Natsu won't get hurt from reflected attacks as he even tanked his own attack without recieving relevant damage.

For the ribbon problem Natsu can engulf his entire body in flames so i doubt that's a problem as they would get burned upon contact.

Also, @Homu good match-up. Heads up!.
 
The thing is, unlike Gray and Sting, Mami's immobilizing technique has some form of Power Null element. And Natsu broke off from both Gray's flashfreez and Sting's mark by using his magic.

Edit: Once Mami caught Natsu, he is screwed.
 
Considering his AOE thou I doubt her ribbons will ever have a chance to restrain him in the first place.
 
When I Saenz Lightning I honestly thought it was going to be Cole Macgrath, I got a bit excited.

Anyway, I'm going to wait for some more input, but Scarlet.

"Mami doesn't really fight at that range at all"

Yet she tied and outsmarted Homura in Rebellion despite the latter part being entirely CQC and Homura being someone who's learned knowledge from multiple time loops
 
Homu Sweet Homu said:
The thing is, unlike Gray and Sting, Mami's immobilizing technique has some form of Power Null element. And Natsu broke off from both Gray's flashfreez and Sting's mark by using his magic.
Click to expand...
I don't remember it having power nulling properties, if that's something happening in Rebellion, don't spoil me, haven't watched it yet.

But even if it does have that property, as I mentioned Natsu has immense physical force so freeing himself with pure force isn't out of the question at all. And his passive aura gives off great heat as well, so it could burn them.
 
Blanked said:
Natsu won't get hurt from reflected attacks as he even tanked his own attack without recieving relevant damage.

For the ribbon problem Natsu can engulf his entire body in flames so i doubt that's a problem as they would get burned upon contact.

Also, @Homu good match-up. Heads up!.
Click to expand...
I almost forgot. I vote inconclusive cause Mami always have some range advanatge and attack reflection can turn useful at least to block his attacks as reflecting them for damage purposes won't help.
 
Burning the ribbons is unlikely to work because Kyoko was unable to do it during Different Story. Plus the ribbons themselves are Low 7-B+.

Power null comes from the fact that across 100 timelines Homura never managed to break free once, and the same goes for Kyoko

Guns of Aegis reflect projectiles iirc.
 
Natsu's flames as well are power null just saying. Plus restraining him would only make him angrier and thus more powerful.
 
Also yeah, Mami absolutely abuses her range in character. But she isn't bad in CQC.
 
Battle starts at 10 meters and Natsu has several hundreds of meters range. Doubt she will have the opportunity to run away from his range. And she also doesn't fight on kilometer range from what I know. Several kilometers with breath attacks for Natsu as well.
 
I know, was just clarifying the range thing. She also fought Kyoko in close range as well.

She literally fired a bullet across a city during Rebellion though.

Anyway inconclusive for reasons above
 
If Natsu won this fight, it would be quite funny considering a jaxed character like sans failed to defeat her while a straight forward fighter like Natsu can.
 
If Natsu won this fight, it would be quite funny considering a haxed character like sans failed to defeat her while a straight forward fighter like Natsu can.
 
You need to consider fan voting thou. Sans can just causally teleport to her and soul manipulate for life or just use her own attacks against her by switching his place with her when the attack is about to hit him.

It's just fan voting.
 
I think the reason Mami bested Sans was because of her being a semi-soulless being. Her body doesn't actually has a soul.
 
Well, that kinda solves that problem. You didn't give necessary information for me to judge which is another thing i dislike about vs threads.

That said enough derail.
 
^Anime of course. I can tell the difference between real life and fiction.

Anyway, enough derailing. Mami mind manip resistance comes from resisting a witch kiss. A very weakened witch kiss can controls hundreds of people into commiting mass suicide....and Mami resisted it on daily basis.
 
Btw, anyone can see Natsu's Low 7-B calc? Mami is stronger because hers is Low 7-B+, but idk the extent
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Leafbladie
Mami Tomoe vs Nanoha Takamachi
2
Replies
44
Views
4K
Leafbladie
Leafbladie
Beast_Zero_Gudako
  • Locked
Dragon Slayer vs Magical Girl
Replies
32
Views
1K
The_Calaca
The_Calaca
Overlord775
Monica Pinkston vs Mami Tomoe
2 3 4
Replies
154
Views
2K
Kaltias
Kaltias
Starter_Pack
  • Locked
Rukia Kuchiki vs. Mami Tomoe (It's Time To Settle This) (Voting Completed)
2 3
Replies
119
Views
3K
Starter_Pack
Starter_Pack
Starter_Pack
  • Locked
Quote vs. Mami Tomoe (A Good Old-Fashioned Shoot Off) (Voting Completed)
2
Replies
48
Views
2K
ShiroEinzbern
ShiroEinzbern
Back
Top