- 26,436
- 30,769
Ew what lmao
I'd assume replaced the mass in the calc with Saitama's normal mass, which is like 75 KG IIRC.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
- 656
- 664
Is 12yo Saitama bulletproof?
- 10,201
- 9,957
Not necessarily, bullets in fiction tend to hurt characters far stronger than wall level.
Is 12yo Saitama bulletproof?
Btw why is Mumen Rider not scaling from this?
Nullflowerblush
He/Him- 10,785
- 9,672
saitama barely survived it and he was rendered unconscious for an hour
we don't usually scale characters to attacks that knocked them out, do we?
we don't usually scale characters to attacks that knocked them out, do we?
- 22,728
- 23,369
He used to be, is he not anymore?
- 22,728
- 23,369
@Ourosboros committed the cardinal sin of not linking the CRT in his changes
- 1,984
- 1,235
He should definitely scale. Even the lowest C class hero is stronger than a regular human.
- 274
- 190
I was actually planning on asking the same thing. Even Gearsper scales from kid Saitama, and the reason is that he's a trained hero. Mumen Rider is a trained hero all the same, and ranked even higher, so he should too.
- 3,389
- 3,809
Soon ima make an CRT to update the Notable Attacks/Techniques: area for the monsters and hero's because those sections are outdated
- 9,316
- 3,439
Can u explain it to me pls since idk anything about calcs
- 22,728
- 23,369
Saitama moved some rocks on the Moon's outer surface. There's no way for him to possibly move 8% of the moon's total mass with his kick. The calc's attempt to find volume was so off because it's mathematically suggesting Saitama moved a solid mass of moon rock that was over 1,000 kilometers long and 103 kilometers tall. He didn't move that much rock, just moved the amount carried with him and generated a shockwave that moved the lunar topsoil.
- 9,316
- 3,439
Thank you
- 9,316
- 3,439
i've talked with the guy who made the calc and his answer is this:
"since the calc worked with what happens it means the AOE was limited to just that and the rest of the moon was unaffected. (or in other words, since we can measure it we can argue that's all that happened and Saitama is just lucky) "
he also argued that since god made the moon its stronger than the average irl one
Last edited:
- 177,535
- 90,478
A Fandom SOAP member, who regularly helps me out with our censorship list, mentioned it.
- 22,728
- 23,369
Then he's misunderstanding the issue with his calc. His volume formula assumes a solid mass that uniformly moved at the same speed, when that isn't what happened. Saitama didn't effect 8% of the moon's total mass. His jump fragmented an area of the moon, carried some amount of rock with him and generated a shockwave that moved lunar topsoil. There's actual craters on the moon with the exact same effects as Saitama's jump but aren't as big.
There's zero indication that the OPM moon is any tougher than the IRL moon. The fact he used the IRL moon's statistics means the original calc acknowledged that they're the same.
- 9,316
- 3,439
he said this
"the other part is that umm when things go up they come down, so when this shockwave lifts lunar soil in the air and it doesn't show a crack of the same magnitude (the crack is large country level from another calc I've done) its because the soil came down and filled parts of the crack. Also, the measurements I used were not for some shockwave effect but for the lunar soil itself that we can see in both anime and manga"
"ignoring GOD on the moon?, his his showing was literally coming out of it so he logically would've prevented it from being destroyed"
also he doesn't wanna go back and fourth anymore so ill stop after this
- 22,728
- 23,369
Yeah, it's just a fundamental misunderstanding of how to get mass. The calc would only work if Saitama fragmented a significant fraction of the Moon's crust and carried it along with him, which isn't what happened.
Also no amount of soil would be able to cover cracks that would be over 100 kilometers deep like the volume calc implies.
God didn't come out of the moon. It appeared on the darkside of the moon and crawled upwards. Besides making large footprints God also wouldn't cause significant damage to the moon based on its actions.
That doesn't address any of the issues I brought up. The volume calc is fundamentally wrong. The lunar top soil was solely to explain were the small rock fragments and the dust came from after Saitama jumped.
Also no amount of soil would be able to cover cracks that would be over 100 kilometers deep like the volume calc implies.
- 26,436
- 30,769
That is just headcanon
- 8,154
- 4,141
I wish he did get evidence the moon survived the big bang or something
- 23,411
- 21,149
Shouldn't Genos have Extrasensory Perception? He was shown to be able to sense energy signals here, here, here, here (there are probably much more, these are the few that came up in my head), and even in the guidebook.
- 7,199
- 7,583
Wait, he doesn't? Yeah, he would 100% undeniably have it, I'm shocked that it was never added.
- 3,474
- 2,127
Probably because people thought it was covered by "Enhanced Senses" which he already has on his profile.
- 3,474
- 2,127
Also I'm surprised Garou doesn't have Supernatural Willpower added to his profile yet, lol.
- 7,199
- 7,583
Bruh how. That's literally one of his main powers lol.
- 7,199
- 7,583
So should a CRT be done on these or something? Would we even need one?
- 16,286
- 17,801
Yes, you always need a CRT if you’re adding new stuff on a profile
- 7,199
- 7,583
I remember seeing people add stuff without one because of how straightforward it is on multiple occasions but alright.
Anyways I don't plan on doing it cause I stopped being active and I'm rusty on making CRT's.
- 16,286
- 17,801
Yeah, people do that, but technically they’re not supposed to.
- 2,500
- 1,248
It should probably be limited though since the god beam is when things become unreadable for him, so ig he should be limited to only being able to sense up to 5-C+ energy
- 7,199
- 7,583
Honestly the fact that Boros has it because of one feat that a lot of people forget but Genos who has shown it on several occasions does not is insane to me.
- 4,406
- 1,334
I thought ESP was supernatural shit, Genos's energy sensing is mechanical. Would that still count?
- 7,199
- 7,583
I don't think that's inherently what it is, just that most versions of it are supernatural. It also doesn't necessarily need to be energy sensing in specific according to the wiki's official page. I'd say that it perfectly fits into what the page says for Power Reading.
https://media.**********.net/attachments/815059415178543127/925619922397200414/unknown.png?width=859&height=644
- 3,389
- 3,809
https://vsbattles.com/threads/one-punch-man-skill-issues.129630/ comment on this to add stuff and to which character and I'll put it
- 7,199
- 7,583
https://media.**********.net/attachments/815059415178543127/925620435037601842/unknown.png
Bro even Carnage Kabuto has it but this ability is mentioned nowhere on Genos' page.
Bro even Carnage Kabuto has it but this ability is mentioned nowhere on Genos' page.
- 4,406
- 1,334
Ah
Similar threads
