- 1,050
- 491
That's not a very specific use of Causality Manipulation, it's literally1. That's a very specific use of Causality Manip that we've never seen Sagume use before; we would need evidence that this was the method used before debunking the feat entirely.
Cause: I want it
Effect: An occult ball now exists
You seem to have a very limited conception of the potency of Causality Manipulation. Not that Sagume's is that good, but still.
Or it could just be replenishing itself endlessly through some magical means, although even otherwise I prefer the bolded interpretation.2. I'm not arguing against the alternative translation; it doesn't matter if its pouring out energy infinitely or endlessly, since somewhere infinite energy has to be involved, otherwise it'd just run out. Could be from Sagume or some other unknown source, but regardless of which interpretation you use, infinite energy needs to be a part of the equation.
Why are you assuming that Doremy can control dreams on a fundamental level? You're making it sound like she can control the very concept of dreams, which is a rather extreme claim that requires extremely good evidence.You're technically right, but if all dreams are connected on a fundamental level, then changing the fundamental nature of one would logically extend to all of them due to their inherent connection. So she's still technically 'controlling' a single dream, but that level of control extends to every other dream out there at the same time.
Again, why are you assuming that Doremy can control dreams on a fundamental level?Also, weren't you the one who argued that dreams as a collective are equal to reality? If that's the case, then controlling all of them could certainly get up to 2-C, which Doremy could likely do due to the whole "connected at the deepest levels" thing.
The Dream World itself is only Low 2-C.
Because, considering ZUN's statements on the matter, her fancy little title means nothing. She's literally just a random baku in "real" terms.And please tell me where you're getting 'random baku' from when she's literally the ruler of the Dream World. Are all baku rulers of the Dream World now? Can't imagine what kind of ****** up political system they have if that's the case.
Well, Prom's word is what matters most right now, and her reasoning seems quite good to me.Gonna need evidence beyond "a staff member agreed with me".
I don't need "proof" to back up the negation of your NLF concerning Doremy's dream manipulation. A generic "she can manipulate dreams" cannot be extrapolated into "she can manipulate all dreams regardless of size". Such "reasoning" is comparable to "this profile says that this guy can manipulate illusions, therefore he can blanket the entire universe in illusions".I don't know how to continue to argue this point when Doremy's profile makes it very clear she can manipulate all dreams. Maybe not all at once, depending on how you interpret the statement about dreams being connected, but assuming there are some dreams she can't control is something you would really need proof to back up.
And yes, it's still an NLF even if you slap a "Low 2-C" or "2-C" tier to it (especially given the natures of those tiers in question). If you had thought that the "proper" tier for the Dream World was 1-A or so, you would still be trying to scale Doremy to all of it using the same logic you're using here.
No. Any single dream could have any finite size, but very explicit proof needs to be given for an "infinitely" big dream.Few other points to note. If all dreams are just collectively equivalent to reality, as you've claimed in the past, then a single dream would still be infinite.
Or maybe the dream world is just far bigger than the sum of its parts.Reality as a whole is infinite (thanks to Hell and Higan), there are a finite number of dreams due to there being a finite number of people in the world, and an infinite number divided by a finite number is, well, infinite. A smaller degree of infinity, sure, but still infinite.
Hell as a "general" whole isn't "infinite" anyway. Only Avici is. And it's treated as special and completely distinct from any other Hell. Hell in general doesn't scale to Avici.
Nothing scales to Higan anyway, so its size doesn't matter.
An infinite world (spacetime continuum) contains an infinite number of people. This is simple logic. So infinity divided by infinity equals...one?
Wouldn't a "finite" number of dreams heavily contradict the Dream World being anything higher than 3-A at most anyway? Since most dreams are not at all confirmed to be infinite.