- 18,642
- 5,851
We shouldn't be policing what people do on other sites, unless it directly impacts what happens here.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I should also point out that, under the current rules regarding off-site behavior, I haven't done anything actually punishment-worthy. If I'm to be punished anyway, so be it, but first someone will have to devise a new set of guidelines regarding this sort of thing, and then get approval to implement.
That's sort of the headline here, and I believe that was Darksmash's point in bringing it up in the first place. Our site rules don't cover this, no more for Crabwhale than for Chase, and while the two are of a distinctly different character, the commonality is that it's offsite discord behavior that isn't currently addressed by any of our rules. So it's not about the moral assessment that it's awful to make r--- jokes or to use slurs in an ironic context, but whether or not our rules address this or if they should address it.nothing Crabwhale has done has broken any site rules.
Yeah and honestly, what chase did was on the AFBW server, nothing he does there has to do with VSBW at all, if he should be punished then the AFBW admins should do it not the entirely unrelated VSBWe shouldn't be policing what people do on other sites, unless it directly impacts what happens here.
I think the argument here from the opposing side is less "jokes don't hurt anyone" and more "jokes that I make in the privacy of my own friend group don't hurt anyone".“Jokes don’t hurt anyone” is probably one of the most blatantly incorrect things said in this entire debacle, if I’m being honest
Keep in mind this, are any of you moderators or administrators at AFBW? What right do you have to ban a user who makes jokes with his friends (and they do not mind) on another wiki's server on this wiki?Yeah and honestly, what chase did was on the AFBW server, nothing he does there has to do with VSBW at all, if he should be punished then the AFBW admins should do it not the entirely unrelated VSB
I think it'd be prudent to cease this discussion for the time being as it's clear thatI’m honestly opposed to that because that tells me you could be an absolute piece of shit and suffer no consequences.
That’s fair enough. In addition, I think it was already said that only staff should continue to speak on this matter, as anything more would cause a ton of clutterI think it'd be prudent to cease this discussion for the time being as it's clear that
A) Our current rules do not cover this behavior and
B) The RVRT is not the ideal place to have a staff-referendum on whether or not they ought to.
Being toxic, edgy or bigoted off-site isn't something we really do (or should) police. What you say or do in other forums only counts when those things effect this forum (such as raiding or something).Anyway, I would prefer if we stop this extremely controversial argument immediately, and let our Human Resources group evaluate these issues in private. They will likely need to have a very serious talk with Crabwhale as well.
Bunch of crying as usual, you can never stop being so pitiful, only you were emotional when your waifu alucard argued back then to lose and threw a fit, keep it to yourself the wank and shut up
Reply back proves how mature you are little kid
Coming from a wanker of alucard as you, that made a scene last time, you are the last one i wanna hear anything from
Keep it to yourself and shut up, also vs wiki ratings aren't accurate with all their stuff so zip it again
I think people just say "joke" as a catch-all term for "friendly interaction within a closed circle of acquaintances".Regarding the previous issue of discord behavior, I think the sentiment that a lot of people act far more unprofessionally off-site and would absolutely be banned if judged by their casual banter is more than true. As someone with a strong presence in VSBW's community off-site and on discord, it is hard for me to agree with a ban for this individual given what other people, including staff members, have said and done.
However I want to make it very clear that I do not believe the comments made were jokes. There was no punchline. There was no subversion, no clever irony, no unexpected one-two kick. The evidence provides shows only repeatedly processed love for underage girls.
I think the argument of "do not judge people off of jokes" is an abysmally horrible one. There's no joke here, not even a bad one. There's not even an attempt at a joke. If we are to make a ruling, it should solely be based off of our rules regarding off-site behavior and have absolutely nothing to do with the statements being ironic or joking, as they very obviously were not. Doing otherwise only sets a horribly low bar for going "it's just a prank bro" towards literally any offense.
People using a word incorrectly isn't really any of my concern. Casual conversation is still conversation.I think people just say "joke" as a catch-all term for "friendly interaction within a closed circle of acquaintances".
Otherwise, I agree with you.
Just a possible clarification, is all.People using a word incorrectly isn't really any of my concern.
I would like to (briefly, I apologize) speak on this.So him calling people the hard-r offsite, and saying he wants to rape them is not a violation? At what point does off-site standards become protecting legitimate racists and degenerates?
First of all, back in summer 2020, the Bureaucrats and Super Mod were given a list of duplicate accounts with an Email Address overlap. It is very reliable, and whether or not ZaStando, Blitz, and Red are different people or not. It does not change the fact that they had a shared Email Address back then. And anyone could easily log to their accounts to change their Email Address. Also, I'm not saying he "Needs to talk over people all the time." But people talk over each other by accident when there is more than one person in the discussion. Now if someone had a conversation like like this just for fun, I could see merit.
Remember, to try to invalidate the reliable Fandom spreadsheet is to make arguing cases for Sera Ex's family members being legit family members, or about LordAizenSama making 5 socks to get around his permaban to troll the wiki and denying those obvious facts. Which I am pretty sure @AKM sama @Promestein and @Ryukama can vouch out Spreadsheet on our long list of Email address overlaps are very reliable. Although, since @Mr._Bambu is a Super Mod now, I suppose he also can see the Google Doc if I give it to him in PM.
As for Imagine Breaker, I will it admit I don't have the hardest cases, but I do remember a time when ZaStando make an alt, accidently posted on his wall warning himself not to be making alt accounts, but later Imagine Breaker posted the exact same post word for word mere seconds after ZaStando posted it on his own wall by accident and removed it. Plus, I'm sure @Maverick_Zero_X @ShadowWarrior1999 @ShakeResounding @The_Axiom_of_Virgo and @Theuser789 have better experiences than I do and can make cases about how too similar they are.
Had not caught that, though the response does seem as though it would create... bickering. Best to move on regardless, given a verdict does seem as though it was reached.In fairness Chase was asked to give a defense for himself a while ago, but I agree that it's unnecessary at this point and we should just move on.