They definitely could use more work, but these profiles have had
plenty of discussion in the thread before being added, and are still being discussed to be improved and refined. In fact, we're discussing Pillar John's tiering right now. It's alright if you just found it.
The striking strength being inapplicable is for the same reason provided as attack potency... they just can't as a pillar. Inapplicable.
As for the other profiles, I've been saying it in the thread, and I'll say it here to save you time since you just found the thread: I've encourage others to edit, and improve them. We've discussed them a lot, and I made many changes to improve them as I was working on them, but they are the first pages I've worked on from the ground up. Others have been editing and improving them since they were uploaded. No need to go scorched earth if it's just a matter of improving/fixing things with edits.