• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
I’m aware,but not sure what you’re getting at.
You seemed to be affirming that Goetia not damaging Avalon is a big deal.
Do you think Tier 1 is not affected by this? Because every tier 1 scales to the destruction of Avalon, for some reason.
I think I would hard disagree on most of the scalings that are in the wikipage of VS Battles as far as Fate is concerned.
People are too concerned about Quantity and forget Quality.
And Fate (and other novels) care a lot more about Quality than Quantity.
 
It’s either 4-B, 3-A, or low 2-c, yea.

The people who disagree seem to be neglecting that Avalon was completely fine from Goetia’s attack that scales above all of extra.

That alone is a huge issue.
Ok first I was a bit skeptical of your takes but now you're just straight up lying

Avalon was fine?
Of course it was , you're confusing intent with weakness , since when did goetia's intent was to destroy the planet. He wanted to reshape the planet but first he needed to incinerate humanity for the fuel why would he destroy Avalon since, Avalons destruction would mean the end of the planet since Avalons is the planet's inner sea
He needed fuel so he only burned the upper layer of the planet
Just because he didn't doesn't mean he couldn't

Goetia even say's this himself that his np would pierce the planet, piercing includes Avalon
Goetia's words:

Grand temple of time(section 12):
"That hellish moment continues. As she(mash) continues to block the heat that would pierce the planet "

Why didn't he destroy Avalon or kill Merlin as you're saying, it's simple, without Solomon goetia had no reason to believe he would lose that's why he didn't stop Chaldea even in the 4th singularity

Also I'm seeing a pattern here your game here is just repeating the same points again and again until you're opponents get tired and then you claim that you've won the debate 😂
 
Also I'm seeing a pattern here your game here is just repeating the same points again and again until you're opponents get tired and then you claim that you've won the debate 😂
Not really. If anything, that statement resembles the tactic y'all are using. I've been observing this thread for a while, and Wankbreaker has been providing evidence to support their claims, with each piece of evidence logically following up with the claim and because of that making the argument valid and sound which ultimately leads to the truth.

I've noticed how the Nasu supporters are attempting to shut down the discussion and quickly end any downgrade thread, for obvious reasons. You seem more interested in lying and being disingenuous, viewing this as a matter of winning or losing rather than treating it as a meaningful discussion. Both parties should ideally view the discussion as an opportunity to challenge what's false and work together to reach a conclusion that makes both sides feel they've contributed to the argument and thus prune out anything that might be false.

Since many supporters here fit the former description, it’s clear why they would want to immediately kill any thread that might challenge their perspective.
 
I've noticed how the Nasu supporters are attempting to shut down the discussion and quickly end any downgrade thread, for obvious reasons.
I joined VS Battles ~4 years ago, and basically Nasuverse/Typemoon are the only topics I actually am active in.
While I can't compare with other verses in here, the wanking has been slowly, but surely, creeping in.

For example: You have literal pages talking about how the Quantum Time-Locks operate and why they are like that. Because of space / capacity.
In the original novel, Sakura / Rin says "infinite timeliens" (which isn't incorrect as a translation, but considering it could also mean "many"/big number) - infinite timelines confirmed.
 
Not really. If anything, that statement resembles the tactic y'all are using. I've been observing this thread for a while, and Wankbreaker has been providing evidence to support their claims, with each piece of evidence logically following up with the claim and because of that making the argument valid and sound which ultimately leads to the truth.

I've noticed how the Nasu supporters are attempting to shut down the discussion and quickly end any downgrade thread, for obvious reasons. You seem more interested in lying and being disingenuous, viewing this as a matter of winning or losing rather than treating it as a meaningful discussion.
Alright buddy calm down sure he's not lying and being unfair by nitpicking

In the current thread he uses bbs lines to make it seem like kiara sessyoin is solar system level

But koyanskaya of darkness says this about Kiara:
"
Many humans may have reached godhood, but I never imagined I would ever meet a human who surpassed gods.
Actually, hold on a minute...
Her mental structure can't even be expressed in hyper dimensions! What the heck...she's making an entire universe in her stomach!?
Many humans reached godhood, but I didn't think I'd see the day I'd meet a human who surpassed godhood. Wait, I have a bigger question. What the HELL is wrong with mental composition? Not even a 4D cube'd be enough to give us a good visual representation of that. Who had the big idea of letting her build a universe inside her belly?"


Why don't point out where I'm wrong if according to wankbreaker providing correct evidence and not lying about both kiara and Goetia
 
I joined VS Battles ~4 years ago, and basically Nasuverse/Typemoon are the only topics I actually am active in.
While I can't compare with other verses in here, the wanking has been slowly, but surely, creeping in.

For example: You have literal pages talking about how the Quantum Time-Locks operate and why they are like that. Because of space / capacity.
In the original novel, Sakura / Rin says "infinite timeliens" (which isn't incorrect as a translation, but considering it could also mean "many"/big number) - infinite timelines confirmed.
Yes, it essentially comes down to people running home with the highest possible interpretation, even though, as you said, those statements are and could be fundamentally wrong from a narrative standpoint. They either know this and choose to lie about it, or they genuinely have no idea, most likely because they've never read the series and don't understand the context behind those statements, which could result in some people instead trying to spread secondhand knowledge, if not something even worse.

Why can't people just be honest with themselves and aim to make their arguments as flawless as possible with logical reasoning, without the need for exaggeration?
 
But koyanskaya of darkness says this about Kiara:
"
Many humans may have reached godhood, but I never imagined I would ever meet a human who surpassed gods.
Actually, hold on a minute...
Her mental structure can't even be expressed in hyper dimensions! What the heck...she's making an entire universe in her stomach!?
Many humans reached godhood, but I didn't think I'd see the day I'd meet a human who surpassed godhood. Wait, I have a bigger question. What the HELL is wrong with mental composition? Not even a 4D cube'd be enough to give us a good visual representation of that. Who had the big idea of letting her build a universe inside her belly?"
There's one detail I think you are forgetting - even a being surpassing a god would be between God-level and Planet-level.

In one of the games of Fate a version of "Arcueid" (as a Servant) has her powers "sealed"/weakened because her Masters though she was a God.

Also, what Kiara does is a "subversion" of the Third Magic + her transformation into a Demon/Beast. It's nothing new or "unique", even if it has never been properly explained.
 
Last edited:
Ok first I was a bit skeptical of your takes but now you're just straight up lying

Avalon was fine?
Of course it was , you're confusing intent with weakness , since when did goetia's intent was to destroy the planet. He wanted to reshape the planet but first he needed to incinerate humanity for the fuel why would he destroy Avalon since, Avalons destruction would mean the end of the planet since Avalons is the planet's inner sea
He needed fuel so he only burned the upper layer of the planet
Just because he didn't doesn't mean he couldn't

Goetia even say's this himself that his np would pierce the planet, piercing includes Avalon
Goetia's words:

Grand temple of time(section 12):
"That hellish moment continues. As she(mash) continues to block the heat that would pierce the planet "

Why didn't he destroy Avalon or kill Merlin as you're saying, it's simple, without Solomon goetia had no reason to believe he would lose that's why he didn't stop Chaldea even in the 4th singularity

Also I'm seeing a pattern here your game here is just repeating the same points again and again until you're opponents get tired and then you claim that you've won the debate 😂
Pierce what? The texture?

Mash blocked it with Lord Camelot,meaning that it is weaker than Avalon

Unleashing the true name of Avalon will deploy a Bound Field that provides the greatest defence. A Noble Phantasm that annuls the interference of True Magic; its existence is equivalent to True Magic.





If you’re arguing that AAS could affect the planet anyway, you just indirectly admitted the planet not scaling to Avalon.
 
Alright buddy calm down sure he's not lying and being unfair by nitpicking

In the current thread he uses bbs lines to make it seem like kiara sessyoin is solar system level

But koyanskaya of darkness says this about Kiara:
"
Many humans may have reached godhood, but I never imagined I would ever meet a human who surpassed gods.
Actually, hold on a minute...
Her mental structure can't even be expressed in hyper dimensions! What the heck...she's making an entire universe in her stomach!?
Many humans reached godhood, but I didn't think I'd see the day I'd meet a human who surpassed godhood. Wait, I have a bigger question. What the HELL is wrong with mental composition? Not even a 4D cube'd be enough to give us a good visual representation of that. Who had the big idea of letting her build a universe inside her belly?"


Why don't point out where I'm wrong if according to wankbreaker providing correct evidence and not lying about both kiara and Goetia
"There are many who have reached the status of a god as a human... but to think there could be one who surpasses a god while still human. No, seriously... what is that?! Her mental structure can't even be represented by a hyperdimensional cube!! It's like she’s got a universe inside her belly!"

「人の身で神に至ったものは数あれど……人の身のまま神を凌駕するものがいようとは。いや、そもそも……何ですかアレ! 精神構造が超次元立方体でも表せねー!! 腹ん中に宇宙作ってんじゃねーですよ!」

Ah yes, mental structure. Aka flowery language.

MFW higher-D demon pillars get beat by normal servants
 
Yes, that’s the point. You said that she was purposefully not using it, while the reality was that she could not see the distortions.
Never said that, my statement was that she couldn't get close to fujino at the time cause she couldn't see the distortions. Which is not a problem anymore given that she can now.
She also moved to those buildings to hide between them to not get targeted. Shikis entire battle strategy was to get out of fujino’s sight.
At the beginning of the fight she hid behind the buildings because she couldn't see her attack, I'm sure you read when shiki fought her head on when she could see her attack lol.
Fujino is literally blind after chapter 3 lol, think the rest should be obvious.
She's blind meaning her spell is dead, like I said scans of fujino being said to be able to use her attack without sight.
Cool, she can cut it.
She had extreme diff dodging slower distortions. pretty sure the novel says she didnt completely avoid damage either.
What slower distortions? Lol you keep reiterating this without proof of her distortions being slower or faster. Also she didn't sustain any further damage when she could see the attack.
That is not said. This is why you don’t use the Cokesakto translation as a source. She also dodges shikis attack as it’s about to reach her.

"You really are ridiculous."

Shiki's voice echoes through the darkness. Fujino turns in the direction of the sound. The stack of materials Shiki is hiding behind is instantly smashed. At that instant... a white figure streaks out of the wreckage

"... There!!"

Fujino's eyes get a hold on Shiki. The girl in the white kimono and the red leather jacket runs toward Fujino, holding her left arm out.

"......!!"

Fujino hesitates a bit and then bends. With a cracking sound, Shiki's left arm breaks. Her neck is next; but when Fujino looks... Shiki is already within range. The path that the knife takes is like a flash of light. A bright swing that leaves a lingering trace in the darkness. The knife that strikes without hesitation, however, does not hit Fujino. She ducks, avoiding the swing that was aimed at her neck... no, it was just an accident. Asagami Fujino only looked away because she was scared of Shiki, who was running towards her with a broken arm.
This literally substantiate on my point in a more direct way, fujino dodging the attack was called an "accident".
The knife that strikes without hesitation, however, does not hit Fujino. She ducks, avoiding the swing that was aimed at her neck... no, it was just an accident. Asagami Fujino only looked away because she was scared of Shiki, who was running towards her with a broken arm.
I'm sure you read this part.
Addressed this above.


Shiki starts to run. Her speed is incredible, despite the pooling water and violent wind. It should not take more than three seconds to reduce the distance between them from ten meters to zero. Enough time to bring Fujino's frail body to the ground and stab her in her heart. But even that speed cannot match the speed of sight. Shiki has to close in on her target while Fujino only has to look at her target. For the two, that difference of three seconds is too long.
"The speed of sight" is completely disparate from the speed is dependent on sight, to elucidate on this, the distance between the two was to fujino's advantage as she only needs to look at her target while shiki has to cover a distance. Refer to my earlier point of fujino's ability being said to be higher than shiki's due to the way it works, shiki needs to be close while fujino just has to look at her target. And what you just sent solidifies that, the "speed" in context means she can kill things easily without taking into acount the distance between them as she just has to see her target. So you would need to prove that the distortions are faster without sight once again like I've asked.
"........."

Fujino's eyes glimmer. The left eye for a rotation to the left. The right eye for a rotation to the right. Taking Shiki's head and left leg as the fulcrums, she twists. A strange sensation occurs instantaneously. The moment Shiki feels the invisible power upon her, she jumps explosively to one side. But the power on Shiki does not weaken. Fujino's power is not a projectile weapon. Even if one gets away from one round, it is impossible to get completely away from it whilst in her vision.

Shikis whole battle strat is to not get in Fujinos line of sight.
Because at that point she couldn't see her attack, and fighting head on without being able to see her attack would be detrimental.
There is a very short delay between fujino recognizing the target, and the distortion. this would be eliminated.
Nope there isn't, you just sent the scan yourself "fujino's ability actiavtes once you're in her line of sight.
Substantiate that she would be able to dispel faster ones when she had trouble reacting to them before.
Show scans of "faster" ones lol. Like I've asked for this numerous times already
Are you saying... shes not capable of targeting the knife and bending it?
Nope, I'm saying shiki would cut the spell before it does anything
The novel and side materials calling her stronger lol
I've explained why the ability of fujino would be rated higher than shiki's. The novel never stated she was stronger than shiki explicitly lol, send the side material scan. I can't trust something you say without looking at the context of what was written
Yes... but she could still detect and target shiki while she is falling.
What tha hell dawg. Do you thrive off head canon scenarios just to make it look like you're right?
If her clarivoyance already has a form of seeing through obstacles, how is this any different?
Just saw
well, she's no where near the top, i can tell you that much.
Not my problem.
coping doesnt eliminate its existence
Its existence is something that only a hater would use as a point on why shiki isn't top tier
see above.

Determined not to give up the knife, I glared back at Azaka as she approached. I wasn't carrying it around just for fun. I hadn't told her about it, but I had a strange feeling when I woke up this morning. Something had assimilated with my consciousness while I was asleep, though I wasn't sure if it was a fairy or not. But if it dared come back again, I wasn't letting it get away. That's why I needed the knife as a weapon.
Yes we all know the scene, and she did not want to give up the knife because it was the only weapon she could use to fight the faeries as stated here. And azaka only took the knife was because she was ontop of her bed and she climbed ontop of her. Let's not forget and derail from the premise which is "shiki never lets go of her own knife" amd she claimed the knife wasn't hers and only needed it to fight.
?

Laying down, or sitting? either way, she is still capable of movement, and if she had Archetype Earth level of speed, she would be millions of times faster than azaka, and be able to react with ease.
She was laying down and she could not react, she didn't even know azaka was coming to meet her until she actually did it. How would she jump from the bed when she was pinned down?
not cokesaktos fanfic, thats for sure.

Muttering those words in a chilling voice, she lunged at me. Stuck on the bed, I couldn't dodge her sudden attack. We ended up tangled together, crashing onto the mattress. In the end, Azaka managed to pry the knife away from me. Despite her cute looks, she was easily enraged. When she got really mad, she would go ballistic, like a wounded bear. Judging that words and counterattacks were pointless against this beast, I reluctantly handed over one of my hidden knives to end the silly scuffle. Azaka took the knife and walked over to her desk. I, on the other hand, remained lying on the bed. "You muscle head... Look at my arm, it's covered in bruises. What do you even eat?"
?? "STUCK ON THE BED" Are you reading things well or you just don't understand them.
Im "nitpicking" direct statements, alright.

I've already proven MEODP doesnt work. No concept of death, which means they are immune, via ORT's profile. Arc and Nero had a concept of death at this point.

She said "attempt", calling it an action based on emotion, which leads us back to the facts. She has no wincondition.
She never said "attempt", she said "You're simply here to kill that which cannot die". Which shiki then proceeds to say "as long as it is even alive even gods fall under my knife"
the only other ending where AE appears (Roa's), he explicitly gets killed easily,lol.
So you see the difference "he was explicitly killed" whereas that isn't the case for shiki
 
She never said "attempt", she said "You're simply here to kill that which cannot die". Which shiki then proceeds to say "as long as it is even alive even gods fall under my knife"
Okay, cool, character hyping herself up.

We know from ORT’s material profile that MEODP is useless….and know from KnK she gets injured by tree felling and concrete crushing attacks.
 
Okay, cool, character hyping herself up.

We know from ORT’s material profile that MEODP is useless….and know from KnK she gets injured by tree felling and concrete crushing attacks.
That statement was made from AE referring to shiki, so how is shiki hyping herself up?

Doesn't defeat the fact that she indeed kill AE, and her meodp is several levels higher than normal meodp, so she's capable of doing such.
Also according to your logic every character should get downgraded if they're injured with a kitchen knife or rocks. Heck no character surpasses tier 8 with your logic.
 
That statement was made from AE referring to shiki, so how is shiki hyping herself up?

Doesn't defeat the fact that she indeed kill AE, and her meodp is several levels higher than normal meodp, so she's capable of doing such.

“The Mystic Eyes of death perception are useless on it”
isnt
“Um these MEODP work on it and this one doesn’t”

Also according to your logic every character should get downgraded if they're injured with a kitchen knife or rocks. Heck no character surpasses tier 8 with your logic.

Not the same thing at all, but alright, lmao.
 
Not really. If anything, that statement resembles the tactic y'all are using. I've been observing this thread for a while, and Wankbreaker has been providing evidence to support their claims, with each piece of evidence logically following up with the claim and because of that making the argument valid and sound which ultimately leads to the truth.

I've noticed how the Nasu supporters are attempting to shut down the discussion and quickly end any downgrade thread, for obvious reasons. You seem more interested in lying and being disingenuous, viewing this as a matter of winning or losing rather than treating it as a meaningful discussion. Both parties should ideally view the discussion as an opportunity to challenge what's false and work together to reach a conclusion that makes both sides feel they've contributed to the argument and thus prune out anything that might be false.

Since many supporters here fit the former description, it’s clear why they would want to immediately kill any thread that might challenge their perspective.
Now this is just me admittedly, but if someone named "Wankbreaker" came in randomly trying to overhaul the verse I've been working on, my first gut instinct would probably be to think they're not interested in a meaningful discussion. I mean, it sounds like they've already decided that the supporters are just wankers and that they're the only one that's actually correct, so I wouldn't really entertain that kind of thing to begin with

It's not as if I don't get where you're coming from, but my issue is that it's not just one side or another. It feels like neither side is acting in good faith here

This is just what happens when scaling turns into a contest and people are more interested in trying to be right than actually having a meaningful discussion
 
Last edited:
Now this is just me admittedly, but if someone named "Wankbreaker" came in randomly trying to overhaul the verse I've been working on, my first gut instinct would probably be to think they're not interested in a meaningful discussion. I mean, it sounds like they've already decided that the supporters are just wankers and that they're the only one that's actually correct, so I wouldn't really entertain that kind of thing to begin with

It's not as if I don't get where you're coming from, but my issue is that it's not just one side or another. It feels like neither side is acting in good faith here

I feel like im very open to discussion, actually (hell, i even have a discord server revolving around the topic, with no major issue). I havent tried to silence the other party either.

"How dare you not think the nasuverse is outer-mega-hyperversal boundless, you downplayer!!!" doesnt seem like anything in good faith either.
 
I feel like im very open to discussion, actually (hell, i even have a discord server revolving around the topic, with no major issue). I havent tried to silence the other party either.
I'm trying to understand things from both perspectives. It's true you haven't tried to silence anyone, I just don't think anyone's gonna take too kindly to having their verse's ratings contested by someone whose whole profile is "I'm here to fix your wank." But hey, that could just be me since I've admittedly made no secret of the fact that I'm not a fan of that myself. I got zero issues with you yourself, I just tend to hyperfixate on stuff like that

And I mean for all I know, it could be because the server's an echo chamber. I'm onto you you filthy downplayer smh 🗿
"How dare you not think the nasuverse is outer-mega-hyperversal boundless, you downplayer!!!" doesnt seem like anything in good faith either.
Brother I wasn't saying they were acting in good faith either, I thought I made that clear. I said "neither side" for a reason 🗿

I just don't think "you're a wanker if you think Nasuverse is Tier 1 and that's the end of it" is the best mentality either. Personally, I think the verse (with my limited knowledge on it) is super up to interpretation in terms of scaling, more than most verses, because of just how much stuff there is saying so many things all at once
 
Back
Top