• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Naruto FTL+ Debunk

Status
Not open for further replies.
How come Isshiki only had 10% energy after defeating the Konoha duo even though he stomped them? It wasn't because of the wounds the Konoha duo gave him, but because Jigen used Isshiki's ability too much
yes
^ See Amado's statement, that chakra tank on Jigen's stomach indicates his chakra capacity and power. Amado said "his tank chakra will be full in 2 days". That means her chakra tank can hold Isshiki's full power, but only for a short time (less than an hour if used at full power). Now Amado who said that Isshiki's power was about 10% to Kashin Koji was referring to the context of Jigen trying to recover a few hours after fighting with the Konoha duo, not that he could only use 10% of Isshiki's power so far. The analogy is like having lava in a titanium bucket, the titanium can hold the lava, but it will erode and break down due to the temperature difference and eventually crumble due to the depletion of its strength.
Amado mentions that in his battle with Naruto and Sasuke, he used so much chakra that his own strength would be almost 0. but with a chakra filling that lasted for 1-2 hours, the crack was resolved and it reached 10% levels. he was also stressed many times by koji that he was weaker.
 
You are comparing plots that are important with plots that are obviously for comedy, that scene where Hima knocked Naruto out was clearly a gag scene and should not be taken seriously. Both of those situations are not the same
Actually with daemon's statements this could even be a good feat lol (j)
 
He didnt use Sukunahikona

this is head canon. i understand trying to reconcile the two things but it doesnt work. Ishikki's powers has varied depending on the body he is in. Jigen can shrink things without the need for physical Dojutsu, kawaki can seal organic things within that exact same pocket reality, something Ishikki was explicitly not able to do. off course we can think of some theories for why, but in terms of an indexing site we have to just go with what is shown.
In English, and with a stronger assertion:

If Jigen cannot use Sukunahikona, then he could not have produced this: https://gyazo.com/efdedc3b00580907aba38bbc1d55a5ab - He used a strategy of attacking by reducing the size of objects. Although Sukunahikona has not yet been introduced here, we can see its application in the manipulation of the size of inanimate objects. We know for sure that Kaguya was able to inflict fatal wounds on Isshiki until he was incapacitated.

At that time, the concept of Isshiki's dojutsu had not been introduced, and Jigen was attempting to minimize the use of his power. There is other evidence besides the identical size manipulation ability of Sukunahikona (besides using the black iron which was shrunk and enlarged during the Narusasu fight).

Jigen can use Isshiki's power to retrieve inanimate objects that he has restored in another dimension. Proof of this can be seen here: https://gyazo.com/06e25729e97fd23c6b98f05c9af8426e - where Delta damages a table, but Jigen immediately takes a similar table and set of utensils. This explanation makes sense if Jigen really does have Isshiki's ability.

Furthermore, Occam's Razor supports the idea that Kaguya is relative to Isshiki, which means that the 10x difference in power can be negated.
 
And just because his tank might be 100% doesnt mean he can use Ishiki's power to the fullest Edo tensei have infinite chakra but limited by the amount of the chakra reserves
 
I’m not gonna comment on the 10% Jigen stuff because my opinion in it currently is more or less the same as Shadows.

But the Kaguya argument is ass, trying to claim an inconsistency off of an event we never saw and is presented to us as an off guard is disingenuous.

Hokage Naruto who we currently have at 5B even in base can be knocked unconscious by his 7 year old daughter when he’s off guard.
How to tell if you not read the whole thread, without really tell it. Read the argument correctly, what we need to know that both of Isshiki and Kaguya was relative. And for Naruto case, that's an asinine analogy, because it's a comedic relief scene. REMEMBER GAG SCENE
 
im not arguing that theres a 10X gap between Kaguya or Ishikki. im arguing against the reasons your proposing for why there isnt by using Ishikki being caught off guard.

I already agree with the premise that Nard and sausage didnt fight a 10% Jigen. thats because as you said Jigen can still draw From Ishikki's strength via the karma at the cost of his body deteriorating and that i dont believe chakra amounts scale linearly.
 
Your use of Occam's razor is complete nonsense anyone can make up anything and assume its the simplest you are somehow saying that Ishiki was unable to react to Kaguya's attack that he was somehow aware it was going his way, lol my reason is simpler he was sleeping and got attacked.
What if Kaguya opened a portal in the middle of jigen's body and thats why he was cut in half?
 
You are comparing plots that are important with plots that are obviously for comedy, that scene where Hima knocked Naruto out was clearly a gag scene and should not be taken seriously. Both of those situations are not the same
Naruto isn’t a gag manga where things can be disregarded because of a comedic undertone. There’s not even a precedence of things illogical happening because it was intended for comedy. This isn’t One Piece.

Even if we did disregard that. We have Hiruzen being hurt by children, Juubi Madara being pierced by Zetsu and a dying Obito in two seperate off guards, etc.

Off guards happen, that’s how we already have it accepted too, saying the gap is too big for that is just incredulity.
 
Actually with daemon's statements this could even be a good feat lol (j)
What do you want to say explicitly? Say it and bring relevant point-by-point evidence, because what you've been discussing is in line with what I've been saying. It's as if you're saying I don't understand what I'm saying, but instead, you're doing a Self-Defeating Argument by supporting my premise. Because from the start, the 10% connotation that is only present in the context of Jigen is limited to Jigen recovering.
 
Occam's Razor doesn't support the idea that Kaguya's relative with Isshiki when it's directly stated/implied that she caught him off-guard.

Me coming behind Mike Tyson and slumping him with a straight right he didn't see coming wouldn't mean i'm relative with a full-power Mike Tyson, it means I'm relative with his baseline ability to tank shots he can't see coming, it wouldn't scale me relative with a full-power, aware Mike Tyson.

This is especially the case in Naruto where people amplify their durability with chakra, if Isshiki wasn't actively amplifying his durability when he was caught off-guard by Kaguya than that wouldn't be an anti-feat because Isshiki isn't 10x more durable than Kaguya's AP as a baseline, it's only when he's amplifying himself he's arguably on that level.
 
Your use of Occam's razor is complete nonsense anyone can make up anything and assume its the simplest you are somehow saying that Ishiki was unable to react to Kaguya's attack that he was somehow aware it was going his way, lol my reason is simpler he was sleeping and got attacked.
What if Kaguya opened a portal in the middle of jigen's body and thats why he was cut in half?
Your's is definitely nowhere near simpler, your assumptions are too bold and specific. Because those are not that likely to actually happen in the actual plot. Literally Hagoromo didn't need sleep to survive, and yet you are making up assumptions that Isshiki could've been sleeping?!
 
Say it and bring relevant point-by-point evidence, because what you've been discussing is in line with what I've been saying. It's as if you're saying I don't understand what I'm saying, but instead, you're doing a Self-Defeating Argument by supporting my premise. Because from the start, the 10% connotation that is only present in the context of Jigen is limited to Jigen recovering.
What I'm talking about is that jigen has increased to 10% due to healing. when his body cracks he almost reaches 0 points. ( bro didn't realize the himawari part was a joke)
 
I already agree with the premise that Nard and sausage didnt fight a 10% Jigen. thats because as you said Jigen can still draw From Ishikki's strength via the karma at the cost of his body deteriorating and that i dont believe chakra amounts scale linearly.
Fair enough. It is extremely difficult to take someone off guard who is 10 times faster and stronger than you infact, the reason for this is that Isshiki superior physical abilities enable for him to react more quickly and effectively to potential threats or attacks. Do you remember when Jigen able to deploy Sasuke who gonna execute his neck? For instance, if someone were to attempt to surprise attack such a person, they would likely be unable to do so because the person's heightened physical abilities would enable them to detect and evade the attack more quickly, leaving the attacker vulnerable and exposed. Furthermore, a person who is 10 times faster and stronger than you would likely have a much greater awareness of their surroundings, as well as a more acute sense of danger, allowing them to anticipate and avoid potential threats before they even materialize.

That means basically you understand that Kaguya and Isshiki is relative, that's why Kaguya can catch an off guard Isshiki.
 
Your's is definitely nowhere near simpler, your assumptions are too bold and specific. Because those are not that likely to actually happen in the actual plot. Literally Hagoromo didn't need sleep to survive, and yet you are making up assumptions that Isshiki could've been sleeping?!
And assuming Îshiki was somehow aware that kaguya was attacking him and was anable to react anyways is the simplest assumption? Nowhere is stated that Hagoromo doesnt need to sleep having an enourmous stamina doesnt mean you dont need to sleep, and it doesnt matter what explanation is, anything can be said to be simple because Ishiki was unaware of whatever attack Kaguya made and thats what it counts.
 
Fair enough. It is extremely difficult to take someone off guard who is 10 times faster and stronger than you infact, the reason for this is that Isshiki superior physical abilities enable for him to react more quickly and effectively to potential threats or attacks. Do you remember when Jigen able to deploy Sasuke who gonna execute his neck? For instance, if someone were to attempt to surprise attack such a person, they would likely be unable to do so because the person's heightened physical abilities would enable them to detect and evade the attack more quickly, leaving the attacker vulnerable and exposed. Furthermore, a person who is 10 times faster and stronger than you would likely have a much greater awareness of their surroundings, as well as a more acute sense of danger, allowing them to anticipate and avoid potential threats before they even materialize.

That means basically you understand that Kaguya and Isshiki is relative, that's why Kaguya can catch an off guard Isshiki.
Byakugan
 
Occam's Razor doesn't support the idea that Kaguya's relative with Isshiki when it's directly stated/implied that she caught him off-guard.

Me coming behind Mike Tyson and slumping him with a straight right he didn't see coming wouldn't mean i'm relative with a full-power Mike Tyson, it means I'm relative with his baseline ability to tank shots he can't see coming, it wouldn't scale me relative with a full-power, aware Mike Tyson.

This is especially the case in Naruto where people amplify their durability with chakra, if Isshiki wasn't actively amplifying his durability when he was caught off-guard by Kaguya than that wouldn't be an anti-feat because Isshiki isn't 10x more durable than Kaguya's AP as a baseline, it's only when he's amplifying himself he's arguably on that level.
Your analogy does not provide any conclusive evidence, as hitting Mike Tyson would result in a reaction that could potentially push you back, and Isshiki has been repeatedly demonstrated as a careful and meticulous character, making it unlikely that he would be caught off-guard so easily.
 
Me coming behind Mike Tyson and slumping him with a straight right he didn't see coming
Different situations, Mike Tyson is a human being. Whilst Isshiki is an alien, a fictional character that have abilities. And this would depend on the context, because if i remember correctly, Isshiki and Kaguya are supposed to be allies since both of them are there to plant the God Tree. Isshiki could've simply thought of her as an ally, and then she just suddenly attacked him and caught him off guard. Which again, Isshiki would have been able to react since he is 10x stronger and faster than her.
 
Neutral on this. I find it very strange though how some of the agreements come from accounts w low ass reaction scores that afaik haven’t been seen in any other naruto threads 🤔
 
Your analogy does not provide any conclusive evidence, as hitting Mike Tyson would result in a reaction that could potentially push you back, and Isshiki has been repeatedly demonstrated as a careful and meticulous character, making it unlikely that he would be caught off-guard so easily.
This post doesn't address anything, it's stated/implied he was off-guarded by Kaguya. Trying to rationalize this just to provide a debunk against the 10x scaling isn't a good argument and it comes off as reachy.

Hitting someone with AP that's relative to their durability wouldn't cause your punches to be pushed back, there would be a level of recoil because of the transferal of energy happening but it wouldn't cause your punch to reverberate back like how you're arguing it would.
 
Fair enough. It is extremely difficult to take someone off guard who is 10 times faster and stronger than you infact, the reason for this is that Isshiki superior physical abilities enable for him to react more quickly and effectively to potential threats or attacks. Do you remember when Jigen able to deploy Sasuke who gonna execute his neck? For instance, if someone were to attempt to surprise attack such a person, they would likely be unable to do so because the person's heightened physical abilities would enable them to detect and evade the attack more quickly,
this is only true for people already engaging in combat, where even if your off guard or distracted your likely to still be more on guard than you would if you were asleep or not in a fight.

the issue with Kaguya and Ishikki is that we literally have no context other than he was off guard. if we ever get a flashback and we see Ishikki and kaguya actively fighting first then sure.
 
Hitting someone with relative AP compared to their durability wouldn't cause your punches to be pushed back, there would be a level of recoil because of the transferal of energy happening but it wouldn't cause your punch to reverberate back like how you're arguing it would.
That's why it's more make sense for Kaguya to be relative to Isshiki. Because the 10% points is inconsistent. It will be make more sense for Kaguya to be able to harm him. If we use the logic that Isshiki is ten times stronger and faster, the reaction will get harder too. When you punch something, you will get an equal reaction of energy of your punch, as dictated by Newton's third law of motion, which states that for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.

When you punch an object, you are exerting a force on that object, which in turn exerts an equal force back on your hand. This force is what we feel as the impact of the punch. The amount of force that is exerted on your hand is equal to the amount of force that you exert on the object being punched, as the two forces are always equal and opposite.

Additionally, the amount of energy that is transferred during the punch is also equal and opposite, as energy is a scalar quantity that is proportional to the force applied and the distance over which that force is applied. This means that the energy of your punch is transferred to the object being punched, but an equal amount of energy is also transferred back to your hand, resulting in the impact that you feel.

Therefore, when you punch something, you will always get an equal reaction of energy of your punch, as dictated by the fundamental laws of physics. This is why it is important to consider the force and energy involved in any physical interaction, as they are always equal and opposite, and can have significant consequences for both the object being acted upon and the object doing the acting.
 
All of this back and forth arguments of "10X/10% this and that" due to the "likely FTL+" and "likely Large Planet level" ratings in Isshiki's profile :v
 
That's why it's more make sense for Kaguya to be relative to Isshiki. Because the 10% points is inconsistent. It will be make more sense for Kaguya to be able to harm him. If we use the logic that Isshiki is ten times stronger and faster, the reaction will get harder too. When you punch something, you will get an equal reaction of energy of your punch, as dictated by Newton's third law of motion, which states that for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.

When you punch an object, you are exerting a force on that object, which in turn exerts an equal force back on your hand. This force is what we feel as the impact of the punch. The amount of force that is exerted on your hand is equal to the amount of force that you exert on the object being punched, as the two forces are always equal and opposite.

Additionally, the amount of energy that is transferred during the punch is also equal and opposite, as energy is a scalar quantity that is proportional to the force applied and the distance over which that force is applied. This means that the energy of your punch is transferred to the object being punched, but an equal amount of energy is also transferred back to your hand, resulting in the impact that you feel.

Therefore, when you punch something, you will always get an equal reaction of energy of your punch, as dictated by the fundamental laws of physics. This is why it is important to consider the force and energy involved in any physical interaction, as they are always equal and opposite, and can have significant consequences for both the object being acted upon and the object doing the acting.
It wouldn't because Isshiki isn't 10x stronger, faster and more durable than Kaguya as a baseline, it's only when he has, and is using 100% of his chakra that he's arguably 10x above Kaguya. Literally nothing you have stated has debunked this fact nor have you debunked the idea of Kaguya off-guarding Isshiki being non-scalable to Isshiki's full-power.

I'm not addressing the rest because it's just conjecture.
 
Last edited:
It wouldn't because Isshiki isn't 10x stronger, faster and more durable than Kaguya as a baseline, it's only when he has, and is using 100% of his chakra that he's arguably 10x stronger than Kaguya. Literally nothing you have stated has debunked this fact nor has debunked the idea of Kaguya off-guarding Isshiki being non-scalable to Isshiki's full-power.

I'm not addressing the rest because it's just conjecture.
How about this:

Ishiki was caught off guard by Naruto base, a 10x gap shouldn't be like this.
 
What the hell is your ass talking about
Is it that hard to understand? just because the show doesn't resolves around comedy and gag, doesn't mean that gag scenes doesn't exist. A lot of Shonen Animes have their comedic relief scenes, and it is never meant to be taken seriously.
 
my bro really said "nothing strange" 💀💀
There's honestly nothing strange abt it, so what if random accounts agreed whilst barely being active? they are not important, VSB prioritize opinions from actual staff members. Not random members, it doesn't matter if they say agree or not. Unless they are also discussing the same topic
 
Honestly just ignore them, unless they are also trying to discuss this topic. Because most of the time they probably just want to see the end result of this discussion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top