So, been extremely busy and return to see 1-A Miraculous? Lol.
Kwamis Profiles
Whereas we have this unspoken rule of avoiding creating profiles for Kwamis, at this point seems kind of just avoiding creating them profiles for the sake of it, even thought they are characters with very specific differentiations from the characters we currently have indexed.
I would only be against the idea of creating profiles for Kwamis who haven’t used their powers without a holder, as the side effects that the uncontrolled use of their powers can have make any match attempt a bunch of speculation.
I’m not against a profile for Gimmi, when profiles like Shenron exist, and we’re given quite a lot of things Gimmi is capable of doing, as well as having his very own tier 2 feats within his two appearances in the series.
The idea of Gimmi just busting the universe at the beginning of every battle is also funny… and kind of a one pony trick character.
PD: I believe Kwamis are type two abstracts.
Chat Blanc.
There’s definitely more than one timeline involved.
Honestly, Chat Blanc is currently low-balled as of now. Like, even if we weren’t to change the view on the burrow, his feat was still, at the very least, one of the most blatant textbook definition of low 2-C destruction feats.
Tier 1 Miraculous.
Ok, no. Firstly, Tier 1 sucks.
Secondly, Tikki being "above the concept of Mathematics" (I mean, technically she is, but because the concept of creation, destruction and reality are above every other concept in-universe more than dimensionality being a factor. Like, concepts like Elation, Action, Jubilation, Derision and Determination are also placed above Mathematics as they are part of the most powerful Miracle Box, as stated by Su-Han) doesn’t makes her 1-A.
Pretty sure it’s not allowed to assume that a character cannot destroy anything above their cosmology, which is part of the reason why being 2x low 2-C cannot make you 2-C, among other reasons, like low 2-C already being infinite power.
First of all, its explicitly states that Tikki came into being WITH the creation of the universe, not before it, implying herself to be a abstract construct that is restricted to that of a single living universe (Low 2C at best).
Tikki exists in every space-time simultaneously. Marinette and Edgynette's Tikki is, quite literally, the same being existing twice simultaneously.
nothing suggests that her power has any sort of authority over any other Kwami and its concept (given that the Rooster Miraculous has been stated to not be able to copy any other miraculous power, even ones that assumingly are similar in power)
The power of pretension cannot replicate another Miraculous power because two concepts cannot exists simultaneously in the same universe without one becoming the concept of replication. That’s what you get from Xuppu’s analogy.
Since Tikki is creation, an creation as a concept can only exist once in the universe, creating another concept of creation would make said creation not creation, but replication; as such, it won’t be the power of creation.
I also believe the Kwamis were picking their words very carefully so Gabriel couldn’t really exploit the Rooster‘ s power without outright lying.