• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Classroom Of The Elite - The Chair CRT

RoggerReggor said:
I literally didn't assume anything, I was saying "he can use it", and not "he will use it". It is like assuming that Fuuka would become a mid-tier without any kind of battle experience or fighting training upon their geniuses which is a mandatory thing in the verse for actual scaling.
Click to expand...
He fought Koji via striking so why would he switch to Judo all of a sudden? This doesn't really make sense to me no matter how I look at it.
 
Dinozxd said:
He fought Koji via striking so why would he switch to Judo all of a sudden? This doesn't really make sense to me no matter how I look at it.
Click to expand...
Ayanokouji legit said that Shiba was not fighting on the same spirit as he did with him. If we go by the statements, he legit said that he wasn't attacking Fuuka when he understood his obvious superiority (on the same level, that is). Secondly, people like Ichika know Judo. Shiba has a White Room history with her so it isn't like he cannot know Judo. Against Ayanokouji, he knows that Ayanokouji is a physical threat to him and not otherwise. Also, you never really proved how Fuuka can endure Shiba's punches. For one, it has been specifically mentioned that she was being only defensive. By holding him for 2 to 3 minutes, it can also mean that she was confident that she would avoid his punches for around that time. This is a lot of assuming honestly.
 
Why is this still being debated on ? Just ask calc group members to verify this and if it's accepted and Dinozxd still disagrees he can make a CRT detailing the problems with the calc.
 
Vzearr said:
Why is this still being debated on ? Just ask calc group members to verify this and if it's accepted and Dinozxd still disagrees he can make a CRT detailing the problems with the calc.
Click to expand...
We are debating the scaling chain tbh, and I believe it has been asked.
 
RoggerReggor said:
Ayanokouji legit said that Shiba was not fighting on the same spirit as he did with him.
Click to expand...
Yeah because he was holding back. Ayanokouji never stated that he switched his fighting style.
RoggerReggor said:
Secondly, people like Ichika know Judo. Shiba has a White Room history with her so it isn't like he cannot know Judo. Against Ayanokouji, he knows that Ayanokouji is a physical threat to him and not otherwise.
Click to expand...
I never said he didn't know Judo.
RoggerReggor said:
Also, you never really proved how Fuuka can endure Shiba's punches. For one, it has been specifically mentioned that she was being only defensive. By holding him for 2 to 3 minutes, it can also mean that she was confident that she would avoid his punches for around that time. This is a lot of assuming honestly.
Click to expand...
Bein able to fight someone for some minutes would mean that you can either damage the person, or endure their hits well. Fuuka would just get slammed by Shiba (when he was holding back) if she couldn't endure his punches.
 
Dinozxd said:
Yeah because he was holding back. Ayanokouji never stated that he switched his fighting style.
Click to expand...
Yo lol, if you aren't changing your fighting style against one opponent, how th does that mean you cannot do that against another? And hey, I know I am assuming as well, but it is to prevent overrating of a character who currently has nothing to be in the mid-tiers except for the fact that she once fought with a high tier. Suzune fought with a mid-tier (Housen) as well, but Housen was completely ruthless and wasn't like Shiba who was intentionally holding back at a degree. We can't just assume here.
Dinozxd said:
I never said he didn't know Judo.
Click to expand...
Neither did I, I am just saying that he knows Judo, and can use it if he wants to. Considering how versatile each person in the high tiers is, it isn't impossible, in fact, it's more possible than impossible.
Dinozxd said:
Bein able to fight someone for some minutes would mean that you can either damage the person, or endure their hits well. Fuuka would just get slammed by Shiba (when he was holding back) if she couldn't endure his punches.
Click to expand...
You didn't understand. To endure a hit, you will need to first get hit by it. Ayanokouji pointed out how Fuuka could have done much better if she had played only defensive, which means that Fuuka once tried to get a little offensive and took a hit from a Shiba who was holding back and learnt her place. Come on now, Fuuka isn't like Kouenji who can sense how much strength a person has just through the heat emitted by their body, or like Ayanokouji who can sense how much powers a person has. Man, I have overrated Fuuka to a high tier just off this and learnt my lessons as well.
 
RoggerReggor said:
Yo lol, if you aren't changing your fighting style against one opponent, how th does that mean you cannot do that against another? And hey, I know I am assuming as well, but it is to prevent overrating of a character who currently has nothing to be in the mid-tiers except for the fact that she once fought with a high tier. Suzune fought with a mid-tier (Housen) as well, but Housen was completely ruthless and wasn't like Shiba who was intentionally holding back at a degree. We can't just assume here.
Click to expand...
I'm not saying he can't change his fighting style lol. I'm just saying that it's weird to assume he would change his fighting style when that isn't stated or shown in an another fight of Shiba.

Suzune fought Housen at full power while Fuuka fought Shiba who was holding back. That's the difference.
RoggerReggor said:
Neither did I, I am just saying that he knows Judo, and can use it if he wants to. Considering how versatile each person in the high tiers is, it isn't impossible, in fact, it's more possible than impossible.
Click to expand...
Like I said, assuming that doesn't make sense at all.
RoggerReggor said:
You didn't understand. To endure a hit, you will need to first get hit by it. Ayanokouji pointed out how Fuuka could have done much better if she had played only defensive, which means that Fuuka once tried to get a little offensive and took a hit from a Shiba who was holding back and learnt her place.
Click to expand...
It's not like she got injured or ended up getting knocked out in the end of the fight lol? That means she tanked Shiba's hits to some degree.
 
Dinozxd said:
I'm not saying he can't change his fighting style lol. I'm just saying that it's weird to assume he would change his fighting style when that isn't stated or shown in an another fight of Shiba.

Suzune fought Housen at full power while Fuuka fought Shiba who was holding back. That's the difference.

Like I said, assuming that doesn't make sense at all.
Click to expand...
I am not going to address any of this. Just remember that assumptions to overrate a character < assumptions which don't overrate the character. It's simply weird that despite everything, all Fuuka has is her athletics statements. The mid-tiers of the verse are there because they deserve to be there. Kouenji is there because he tied in a tug-of-war with Ayanokouji, he also has Chinese martial arts training and some insane survival abilities which he obtained by surviving into the forests. Housen of course, is a gifted and a beast, but he also has experience in street fighting, which is confirmed to be above Ryuuen, someone who fought for a good part of his life and could develop his own brawling fighting style. Albert was blessed with a giant body and has trained it to a good extent. Sudou is a hard-worker whose physique is feared even by Ryuuen, and not to mention his basketball experience which has trained his body as well.
Classroom of the Elite is surely an animanga/LN which has superhuman qualities, but the characters in respective tiers are there because they have trained for it. Unless you have good enough statements for Fuuka, there's no way to scale her.
Also, what will you do if you place her in the mid tiers? You get faced by another difficulty where you will need to find a spot to perfectly place her in the mid-tiers as well. If you place her between characters, that would give another set of assumptions, which is bad.
Dinozxd said:
It's not like she got injured or ended up getting knocked out in the end of the fight lol?
Click to expand...
Stop right there. The fight didn't even conclude, it ended before it could even pick up a good start. We don't know what could have even happened to Fuuka, when it has been revealed that Tsukishiro and Shiba are involving in even killing people. Tsukishiro mentioned that the amount of the punches he dealt could have killed even Ayanokouji, so that's enough to say how strong he is when Shiba simply is higher in AP than Tsukishiro.
Dinozxd said:
That means she tanked Shiba's hits to some degree.
Click to expand...
Thanks for admitting it yourself. The debate has ended. We don't know that "degree" you just mentioned. It can be that Shiba would be using only 10% of his power (again, don't start debating how I am assuming, I am just giving a hypothesis which wouldn't unnecessarily wank a character).

Like always, I think it is futile to even argue over this anymore.
 
bro really close the subject of fuuka going head to head with shiba because this is something that was done for the continuity of the plot in this series, it is very obvious that fuuka can never be equal to shiba. under normal conditions, even if shiba does not use all his strength, he can easily take fuuka. as I said, this is just something done for the continuity of the story, fuuka cannot really be compared with shiba, in my opinion, he is a little stronger than ibuki, he is not that much more, in the verse low layer
 
Shyster said:
bro really close the subject of fuuka going head to head with shiba because this is something that was done for the continuity of the plot in this series, it is very obvious that fuuka can never be equal to shiba. under normal conditions, even if shiba does not use all his strength, he can easily take fuuka. as I said, this is just something done for the continuity of the story, fuuka cannot really be compared with shiba, in my opinion, he is a little stronger than ibuki, he is not that much more, in the verse low layer
Click to expand...
Yes, I share the same opinion as you. It's just that we cannot say Fuuka > Ibuki for now really as Ibuki basically has similar statements to Fuuka. Fuuka would have been killed if Shiba went a little serious, it's literally in the narratives.
 
Yeah my interest in this debate really ended right here. You're literally twisting my words to make them suit you and acting like I contradicted my words where I didn't even mean that.

I don't even know why I even debated about Fuuka's scaling in the first place when I never even agreed to the usage of this feat in the first place. Going back to watching this thread I guess...
 
DarkDragonMedeus agreed with this CRT especifically with Shiroyashaa proposal, Here's the proof

 
Last edited:
It's sad that Classroom of the Elite threads are becoming unlikeable by the staff as well (and I am a part of a reason for it due to my habit of replying to every thing which I am asked about). So, we need one more staff approval yeah.
 
RoggerReggor said:
It's sad that Classroom of the Elite threads are becoming unlikeable by the staff as well (and I am a part of a reason for it due to my habit of replying to every thing which I am asked about). So, we need one more staff approval yeah.
Click to expand...
;-;
 
Vzearr said:
The entire calc is flawed. This thread should be closed.
Click to expand...
You only talked about the fragmentation end tbh. While I agree that it is flawed, Shiroyashaaa's suggestion already said to ditch the fragmentation end and just use the splitting end and put "higher" ratings instead of a Wall level+ thing.


And yes, that's why I didn't improve the fragmentation end as well.
 
RoggerReggor said:
You only talked about the fragmentation end tbh. While I agree that it is flawed, Shiroyashaaa's suggestion already said to ditch the fragmentation end and just use the splitting end and put "higher" ratings instead of a Wall level+ thing.


And yes, that's why I didn't improve the fragmentation end as well.
Click to expand...
No, like the entire thing is wrong. Including the splitting end (Which I assume is the cutting end).

You assume the entire chair is made of steel, when, in no way is that the case.
 
Vzearr said:
No, like the entire thing is wrong. Including the splitting end (Which I assume is the cutting end).

You assume the entire chair is made of steel, when, in no way is that the case.
Click to expand...
Zetsu already listed the arguments of why the chair is made of steel using the illustrations and every thing, yet this is being debated uh. 😭
 
RoggerReggor said:
Zetsu already listed the arguments of why the chair is made of steel using the illustrations and every thing, yet this is being debated uh. 😭
Click to expand...
You assume the entire thing is made of steel, when, very clearly, in all images we see, the chair is only made out of a few bits of steel. A lot of the chair is just leather.
 
Vzearr said:
You assume the entire thing is made of steel, when, very clearly, in all images we see, the chair is only made out of a few bits of steel. A lot of the chair is just leather.
Click to expand...
It isn't leather, I sent how a leather part with cushion would be pushed inwards and how the anime animated a leather chair, both aren't even comparable.
 
RoggerReggor said:
I didn't, the part assumed to be splat for the lowball (the chair seat) is steel and I myself said that we ditched the fragmentation part, so I would really want you to stop debating about how the rest of the parts aren't steel.
Click to expand...
That is also, clearly, not made out of 100% steel.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Vzearr
Ayanokoji (Classroom Of The Elite) Downgrade
2 3
Replies
119
Views
6K
RoggerReggor
RoggerReggor
Clout5560
  • Locked
Classroom of the elite downgrade/Changes
Replies
28
Views
2K
Antvasima
Antvasima
XxZetsuxX
Classroom of the elite - Confirmed feats addition
2
Replies
60
Views
3K
XxZetsuxX
XxZetsuxX
Vzearr
Classroom of the elite downgrades/upgrade
2
Replies
76
Views
4K
Dinozxd
Dinozxd
XxZetsuxX
Classroom of the elite revision thread
2
Replies
72
Views
4K
Dinozxd
Dinozxd
Back
Top