Jamesthetaker
He/Him- 6,718
- 1,831
Yeah, because Edward is 9-A and the gun is weaker than him.Obi2cool4kenobi said:Also, by your logic a Browning M2 in real life wouldn't pierce or hurt Edward
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Yeah, because Edward is 9-A and the gun is weaker than him.Obi2cool4kenobi said:Also, by your logic a Browning M2 in real life wouldn't pierce or hurt Edward
Well, the same weapons in AC would likely harmed Edward but the real life one won't.Obi2cool4kenobi said:Yeah I think I'm done here. The fact a 50 caliber wouldn't hurt Edward at all is completely ludacris and NLF by all standards. Guns in AC are 9-A because they hurt 9-A characters, but a real life 50 caliber weapon that is extremely incomparable to any AC weapon we have ever seen in caliber size and damage output wouldn't harm him is beyond unreasonable.
If you want, you can create a thread to complain it. Debating it here probably won't get you anywhere.Obi2cool4kenobi said:This is taking tiering way too seriosly and throwing common sense out the window. MAny verses have very incosistent showings of many things, and this is another example.
Here you goMegaquake2012 said:Why are we assuming that guns are stronger than their irl counterparts without evidence to suggest that? You guys are assuming because an M1911 can kill a tier 6, means that M1911 is a tier 6. That's ludricous, the guy being shot clearly didn't have the regen or durability to take a pistol shot.
I know plenty of people who likely can't take gunshots but are far above guns in tiering because their skin can still be penetrated by bullets. Hell I even know a few who are outright harmed by them.
All in all, why are we assuming Edward can shrug off bullets from Arthur? AC guns have never been shown to have stronger than their irl counterparts, by all accounts they're the same as irl. Unless someone shows me scans where flintlocks are like, 40 kj or something.
Well I'd say firing a flintlock point blank at someone's face is gonna turn em unrecognizable. Plus that's just one potential feat which may just be hyperbole for all we know. Consistency is key.KLOL506 said:Here you goMegaquake2012 said:Why are we assuming that guns are stronger than their irl counterparts without evidence to suggest that? You guys are assuming because an M1911 can kill a tier 6, means that M1911 is a tier 6. That's ludricous, the guy being shot clearly didn't have the regen or durability to take a pistol shot.
I know plenty of people who likely can't take gunshots but are far above guns in tiering because their skin can still be penetrated by bullets. Hell I even know a few who are outright harmed by them.
All in all, why are we assuming Edward can shrug off bullets from Arthur? AC guns have never been shown to have stronger than their irl counterparts, by all accounts they're the same as irl. Unless someone shows me scans where flintlocks are like, 40 kj or something.
Black Lagoon is a verse filled with 9-B's out yer ass and yet guns are shown consistently to be the same as they are in irl. Without any special wall level feats. Guns simply don't scale unless shown othewise.Dante Demon Killah said:Yeah in a world of 9-Bs, guns need to be stronger than RL ones to be considered lethal
If you know that already then why are you keep arguring that Arthur could win?Obi2cool4kenobi said:Yet we are talking about Arthurs weapons harming AC characters, which apparently is impossible.
Nope, there was some distance between Cesare and Micheletto.Megaquake2012 said:Well I'd say firing a flintlock point blank at someone's face is gonna turn em unrecognizable. Plus that's just one potential feat which may just be hyperbole for all we know. Consistency is key.KLOL506 said:Here you goMegaquake2012 said:Why are we assuming that guns are stronger than their irl counterparts without evidence to suggest that? You guys are assuming because an M1911 can kill a tier 6, means that M1911 is a tier 6. That's ludricous, the guy being shot clearly didn't have the regen or durability to take a pistol shot.
I know plenty of people who likely can't take gunshots but are far above guns in tiering because their skin can still be penetrated by bullets. Hell I even know a few who are outright harmed by them.
All in all, why are we assuming Edward can shrug off bullets from Arthur? AC guns have never been shown to have stronger than their irl counterparts, by all accounts they're the same as irl. Unless someone shows me scans where flintlocks are like, 40 kj or something.
Even if, EVEN IF this feat was valid. It's the only feat avaliable. This is likely the author either not knowing firearms or having it obliterate the poor sod's face for effect.KLOL506 said:Nope, there was some distance between Cesare and Micheletto.Megaquake2012 said:Well I'd say firing a flintlock point blank at someone's face is gonna turn em unrecognizable. Plus that's just one potential feat which may just be hyperbole for all we know. Consistency is key.KLOL506 said:Here you goMegaquake2012 said:Why are we assuming that guns are stronger than their irl counterparts without evidence to suggest that? You guys are assuming because an M1911 can kill a tier 6, means that M1911 is a tier 6. That's ludricous, the guy being shot clearly didn't have the regen or durability to take a pistol shot.
I know plenty of people who likely can't take gunshots but are far above guns in tiering because their skin can still be penetrated by bullets. Hell I even know a few who are outright harmed by them.
All in all, why are we assuming Edward can shrug off bullets from Arthur? AC guns have never been shown to have stronger than their irl counterparts, by all accounts they're the same as irl. Unless someone shows me scans where flintlocks are like, 40 kj or something.
And the novel was explicit about Micheletto's face being obliterated, nothing hyperbolic about it minus the lightning thing.
Jamesthetaker said:Super Shotgu is a good example, it does function same as real world but in it own world, it was demonstration being stronger than real world counterpart.