Because it isn’t an actual reason, unless ignoring 95% of presented evidence is something you find acceptable on this site.
The only “reason” given for disagreement is that fighting inside a realm doesn’t prove anything, which I already said from the beginning that it isn’t the main argument or reasons I used. Stronger evidence than this was given on top of that, and guess what? They weren’t addressed at all.
Following that was also literally nothing but asking questions, to stuff that my thread
already gave evidence for.
So no, these were not reasons. That response painfully ignored almost everything I brought forth, focused on on single point that I said from the start was only
supporting details to my whole argument, and used that as a blanket method of just disagreeing with the whole thing without actually addressing everything else. So unless we find quick hand wavy counter responses that
don’t address everything presented as acceptable responses, this is not a valid disagreement.
So no. And if you continue to accuse me of being dishonest, when I already counted your vote (so that accusation of me trying to make this an unanimous vote goes out the window), I will be reporting you to the Rule Violations Thread and Human Resources if necessary. You aren’t going to attack my character and make me appear to do something that I’m not doing.
Said dimension is suppose to lack spacetime (being above the conceptual incarnation thereof), so I consider that a contradiction.
Not when it’s Arceus himself allowing them to be inside the dimension, or otherwise creating them to use against the player which he also summoned there himself.
Regardless, it wouldn't matter, as the ability to just a hax in some Tier 1 space proves and supports nothing, unless it actually affects a Tier 1 character.
Where in our standards does it say haxing a tier 1 character is the only method of scaling a hax to tier 1? All that’s necessary is providing evidence that it works on a tier 1 scale.
Which would be relevant for power and irrelevant for hax potency. Since nothing in Pokémon has TIer 1 hax potency in these things, the totality of all of existence's hax potency would still not be Tier 1.
You are missing the point, and again, putting words that I didn’t say in my mouth.
This isn’t “all of existences hax potency”. This is about All of existence
itself being an aspect, which includes the said Low 1-C dimension.
Because All of Creation is an aspect of the plates, the plates that are also the origin of all Pokémon powers, there exists a correlation between these powers and Arceus’s dimension.
On top of that, we have found characters who are literally their own dimension as having their abilities scale to themselves. Why would All of creation, that includes Arceus’s Low 1-C realm, and is an aspect of the very thing where all Pokémon powers come from, not scale them to each other?
The hax page explicitely states that hax potency is unrelated to AP & Tier i.e. the characters capability to produce energy. Likewise, we don't consider character to have hax potency increases when they have power increases (Note 1) and we had threads in the past about how characters getting tier 1 power doesn't upgrade their hax potency correspondingly.
I understand that, but what happens when it becomes a case of a characters power having haxy components to them? This isn’t just about producing energy.
Arceus’s power given off was distorting his dimension and the cosmology, time and space. That shows that it was used in a manner of hax and not just a matter of pure power getting unleashed and destroying, and this said power is apart of his own plates.
And we obviously aren’t arguing the hax should be upgraded just because the tier was.
Power increase isn't hax potency increase. A poison doesn't become stronger because you have more biggatons and neither does spatial cutting. The entire idea of hax is that it is independent of raw power.
Already said that upgrading the hax because of a power increase is not what we are attempting here.
