• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Agnaa

Agnaa

VS Battles Super Moderator Administrator Calculation Group Translation Helper Human Resources Gold Supporter
From 👖👖👖👖👖👖
Joined
Last seen
Managing account details
Messages
15,932
Reaction score
14,308

Profile posts Latest activity Postings About

  • Currently in a nadir of interest. Not reading my profile or notifications. If there's anything important, DM me. ==================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================== Currently in a nadir of interest. Not reading my profile or notifications. If there's anything important, DM me.
    Deceived3596
    It's time you censor that naughty word in your pfp. It has been deemed wrong by our almighty fandom dictators benevolent leaders.
    Noneless21
    Noneless21
    Don't listen to him, he's secretly working under a dictator, if you abide then he have proof that you are guilty, I repeat, do not listen
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    No he's right. I've fixed my error.
    Rafi_BZ
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    I have no idea what you mean by that question.

    I currently have 43 threads in my "to-evaluate" backlog, I've added this to the list, and will get to it eventually.
    Rafi_BZ
    Rafi_BZ
    Thanks
    GoldenBooster445
    Hello.
    Can you evaluate this CRT? I've been unable to get proper CGM opinions on this one.
    vsbattles.com

    Karma cracks a wall: Ballistic Glass CRT

    In chapter 64 of Assassination Classroom, Karma picked up a pot and destroyed large sections of a glass window. The debate here is on whether said window used ballistic glass or regular glass. On the request of @Therefir in this blog, I am making this CRT to list down the points in favour and...
    vsbattles.com vsbattles.com
    Thank you.
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    I currently have 42 threads in my "to-evaluate" backlog, I've added this to the list, and will get to it eventually.
    Deagonx
    I know you've got a crazy backlog, but if you end up finding the time to evaluate this revision I'd appreciate it:

    vsbattles.com

    Nasuverse Dimensions Revision

    Following an earlier revision thread that was inconclusive -- partially due to attempting to cover several complicated subjects at the same time -- I am re-addressing what I think is the most important issue to revise so that the discussion is not too complicated to get more staff input. The...
    vsbattles.com vsbattles.com
    View previous comments…
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    You won't be able to make this go any faster unless you give me a time machine.
    Deagonx
    Deagonx
    There's no rush on this thread. Tohru didn't need to bump this. We're currently having a longer discussion between myself, Grath, and Ultima, and if the thread has not reached a satisfactory conclusion by the time you reach it, by that point at least the different sides will be more clear and you may be able to save yourself some time.
    GoldenBooster445
    GoldenBooster445
    Tanin_iver
    I had some questions regarding the current AP & Range separation thread particularly in regards to your current draft.

    Could you explain me the difference between when it is interdimensional and when extradimensional. I could not ascertain the exact difference and when do we have to consider one or the other, so maybe some examples could be better.

    Also, I'd like to know is when we are dealing with characters that can use Dimensional Travel like teleportation or portals etc for traversal and BFR between 4D and 5D realms, how should we index it.
    Also another case when character
    has Cosmic awareness and precog in that range, will it be different?

    Is something like "Low Complex Multiversal Interdimensional/Extradimensional range" appropriate or do we have to tier it differently.
    If not this then how else should we do it?
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    Could you explain me the difference between when it is interdimensional and when extradimensional. I could not ascertain the exact difference and when do we have to consider one or the other, so maybe some examples could be better.

    I felt like the draft was pretty clear. Interdimensional explicitly talks about many cases where it doesn't apply, and extradimensional doesn't have those restrictions.

    Also, I'd like to know is when we are dealing with characters that can use Dimensional Travel like teleportation or portals etc for traversal and BFR between 4D and 5D realms, how should we index it.

    Between 4-D realms, interdimensional. Between 5-D realms, extradimensional.

    Also another case when character has Cosmic awareness and precog in that range, will it be different?

    If it covers one separate 4-D realm, interdimensional. If it covers multiple other 4-D realms, extradimensional. If it covers any part of 5-D realms, extradimensional.

    Is something like "Low Complex Multiversal Interdimensional/Extradimensional range" appropriate or do we have to tier it differently.

    Not really.

    If not this then how else should we do it?

    Just describe the appropriate construct, and link to somewhere that it's explained, like:
    Extradimensional (Can peer into parts of the [[Blind Eternities]])
    Click to expand...
    AThe1412
    Hi Agnaa! Can you give your opinion on this small CRT I made? You're one of the only staff members I have seen comment on the Roblox discussion thread so I feel more comfortable asking you than other people. I hope you don't mind.
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    I currently have 38 threads in my "to-evaluate" backlog, I've added this to the list, and will get to it eventually.
    AThe1412
    AThe1412
    Oh alright. Thank you!
    Kisaragi_Megumi
    Kisaragi and Chariot, refer to this part of the OP of this thread
    Regular members aren't allowed to post in this Rule Violation Reports thread, unless they are making a report here, have direct involvement in a report, or have relevant information about a report that has not been brought up yet, in order to not derail or delay the processing of the reports, or worse instigate further rule violations. Repeated violations will be followed with a strict warning, followed by a threadban for one week to a site ban for some duration, depending on the severity of their conduct.
    Click to expand...
    Your newest posts haven't been doing that.
    Click to expand...
    I called that as an dictactorship, thank you

    But in serious thought, i just wanted to add some points regarding Arto, especially i'm one of those peoples who has dealed with him for so long, but i guess the points that has been brought in RVR is already enough
    However, i also want to say that i feel that he's somehow is obsessed with me, like wanted to be like me who has many friends and respected due of my long presence on this site for almost 6 years and he said that some times whenever i told him to f*** off
    DaMonkeMan
    Sorry to bother you, but is it true that Pokemonfan wished death on a staff member?
    If you don't want to answer this, that's quite alright.
    I'm just curious.
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    Yes. I already said that and explained it in my second-most-recent post in the RVT.
    Omnificence
    Would really love your evaluation here, please.
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    I currently have 24 calcs in my "to-evaluate" backlog, I've added this to the list, and will get to it eventually.
    BestMGQScalerEver
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    I know, it's every mathematically possible universe, rather than every logically possible universe. I believe this runs into the same issue. And that both of those also run into the same issue as "every universe people can imagine" or "every piece of fiction ever written".

    In fact, given that modal realism is stronger and further reaching than type 4 multiverses, the latter shouldn't land higher than the former.
    BestMGQScalerEver
    BestMGQScalerEver
    Wouldn't it be atleast High 3-A instead of 3-A typically? If not nigh-typically since 99% of verses have a "concept" of infinity especially with verses that use said idea.
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    Typically, yeah. I was talking about the zero context case. Infinity existing would bump it up to High 3-A, those universes being separate space-times would bump it up to 2-B (2-A with infinity existing), etc.
    DaMonkeMan
    I don't know if this is required but I heard other people do it before making a Staff Discussion thread so I wanted to ask, may I make a thread based on the rule addressed in this comment?
    It made me think that it should likely be removed, and that type of thing usually goes in a SD thread, thus I'm asking you for permission.
    I want to remove/address a couple other problems as well.
    ByArrow
    hi, i am trying to calculate one bullet catch feat and i am stuck somewhere can you help?

    The character does not start running as soon as the gun fires, but after a short while, he starts running.

    The elapsed time is not given, but during this time, there is a short conversation between the character and his friend.

    feat.

    How long should I assume this elapsed time?
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    Blech, there's some weird stuff in fiction about time spent talking not counting. It seems like it's meant to in this case, but it's unclear exactly how long.

    I'd do 3 seconds for a high-end (based on me reciting those lines to myself), and "the bullet is just off-screen" as a low-end.
    ImmortalDread
    I apologize. I did not mean that in a serious tone, it was simply a side joke, to change the environment's flow.
    You are not obligated to forgive me or anything. But I never knew, that this has been quickly escalated to the point of blocking someone for that reason, specially given the fact, it is harmless childish joke.
    View previous comments…
    ImmortalDread
    ImmortalDread
    Shall we continue as always peaceful to each other and ignoring it completely, or you wish to block me forever?
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    Chill out. I said I'd block you for a day.

    No need to come trying to contact me publicly to bypass that, or to catastrophize things as if I'm blocking you forever.
    ImmortalDread
    ImmortalDread
    oh ok, I am chilled, but idk, u edited the message, made me worried. Alright, I will stop commenting here and in the Ant message wall.
    MrKerf
    Hey, Agnaa. Sorry to bother, but can you check this RWBY vs SAO vs thread. We are kinda stuck and you're the only staff member on both verses pages, although an opponent on one.
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    Lol, I'm an opponent on both. I haven't watched either of both to know enough about a match (I haven't actually watched any full RWBY episodes, and I haven't seen any full SAO episodes for about 8 years). I put myself down as an opponent since I dislike both series.
    MrKerf
    MrKerf
    Tbh I am probably an opponent too XD I just feel better about Volumes 1-3 and Aincrad arc, like most of the verses’ fans are, which is what we discussing, so I had to try.
    Thanks anyway.
    James_Plays_4_Games
    I have privately created a sequel to the Precognition update that happened in the following thread, because I thought of a good enhancement that can be made to the page. https://vsbattles.com/threads/analytical-prediction-should-have-its-own-page.151618/. When proposing the revision, should I make it a staff discussion thread or a content revision thread? The original thread was a staff discussion thread, but I'm not a staff member.
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    Non staff members can make staff discussion threads.

    I don't think it really matters much. You can post it as a content revision thread, and if people think it's getting too cluttered, it could be turned into a staff discussion thread.
    James_Plays_4_Games
    James_Plays_4_Games
    Thanks for your advice. 👍
    Gasper
    Hi, do you plan on updating unsong profiles in the future?
    View previous comments…
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    That doesn't sound like it establishes a different system of cause and effect, but idk the Acausality standards very well.

    I don't remember anything about God existing in Keter. From what I remember, God exists outside of the universe, and pours his Divine Light through the Tree of Life (including Keter), to sustain existence.

    I also don't remember anything about Keter being bigger than infinite timelines. Yetzirah, Briah, and Atziluth are all higher worlds, but they're simply more real/fundamental, not physically larger, and not containing multitudes of timelines.

    Given the similarity of Unsong's ending to an earlier short story of Scott's, Answer to Job, I wouldn't be surprised if God's vast garden of universes was intended to only have a finite number of timelines.
    Gasper
    Gasper
    I asked people if that qualities for Acausality type 5 and one of them said "that's half the requirements for type 5" and another said that does sound like possibly Acausality type 5.

    I meant to say he exists in Atziluth.
    And infinites i was referring to are from set theory mentioned in the verse. Which are accepted on his profile.
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    As I said, he seems to exist outside of the universe, with Atziluth being a part of the universe.

    Ah, I thought you said infinite timelines, not infinite infinities.
    Stryker861
    Sup Agnaa, in the incredibly likely chance that no other CGM gets to this first could you add this to your eval list?
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    Aight; I've chucked it in.
    Stryker861
    Stryker861
    yo congrats on becoming an admin, well deserved
    PowerToScale
    What did the blue name say to the CGM..? can you please evaluate these calcs.

    If you have time could I get get your evaluate on these calcs. Thank you in advance.
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    I like the cut of your jib, kid.

    I currently have 11 calcs in my "to-evaluate" backlog, I've added these to the list, and will get to them eventually.
    PowerToScale
    PowerToScale
    No worries
    Expectro2000xxx
    Since you have evaluated recent Tokyo Revengers calcs I want to consult you about this recently approved calc, specifically the KE part as it give a result of 11.26 Megajoules despite the complete lack of damage to the impacted superficie (neither the manga nor the anime show any destruction at all to begin with), so I believe it isn't a valid result that could be used considering the wiki policies about KE and visuals (which I detailed in length in the comments).
    View previous comments…
    Expectro2000xxx
    Expectro2000xxx
    I already mentioned it to @DMUA and he responded:
    Granted the KE rules also more talk about how a destruction calculation takes priority over a KE one if they contradict one another, and I don't care that much about disputing if this counts or not since it's very much the peak of the verse as far as I can tell
    Click to expand...
    Which come from this section of the Kinetic Energy page:
    • There is a destruction/AP calculation contradicting a kinetic energy calculation. The destruction/AP calculation would take priority over the kinetic energy calculation in this case as the AP calculation would be a better proof in regards to how much damage he/she is capable of in an attack.
      • For example, if a character launches a 200kg metal ball against a common wall at Mach 300, but the wall remains largely undamaged, the energy required to cause the minor damage on the wall would take priority over the kinetic energy derived from speed in this case.
    Click to expand...
    Problem be, in this case there is literally zero destruction so even if wanted it isn't possible to make a destruction calculation.

    The argument used by the creater of the calc to justificate the lack of visual damage is this:
    Mikey lifts Taiju by the head and slams it to the ground with his kick. That's a localized damage area the size of Taiju's head; you can't expect anything more than ground fractures hidden by the rug underneath his head this is not an explosion.
    Click to expand...
    No craters considering this isn't an explosion, also you can't expect the mangaka to draw fractures on the ground under a red carpet. He has drawn cracks for weaker characters in their younger days, so there is a reason why there won't be cracks on a carpet. The AOE fallacy does apply, especially when you are comparing a head to the size of a damn elephant. Yes that's 11.26 Megajoules on a couple of centimeters. The best that can be done given the circumstances is a massive bang.
    Click to expand...
    Which seems ridiculously because as I showed the calculated energy is x90 times the energy of an elephant tackle and x4 times the absolute high end of a cannonball, so the damage caused should be quite noticeable instead of have zero visual representation.
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    Yeah that's silly.

    Sounds like DMUA sees an argument, but doesn't care about fighting the supporters over it, or smth.
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    Okay, I've left a message rejecting it.
    HammerStrikes219
    https://vsbattles.com/threads/rule-violation-reports-new-forum.107529/post-5861404

    I just wake up too damn early, but here are my thoughts regarding topic bans should extend to sandboxes or blog posts.

    They should when they are complete and utter warranted.

    Also whatever it should been by default or not, I will think it typically varied as not all of us will use the sandboxs or you know actually know how to use it. Still that is not the case most of the time. Blog Posts are the other hand, if they still doing it in the verse they are topic banned from, then it completely still fairplay to assume the topic ban is in effect for that stuff.


    Regardless though, I also do think it is absolutely warranted in the case we have for Vapor over here.
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    Okay, I don't think that should be posted in the RVT though.
    HammerStrikes219
    HammerStrikes219
    Yeah, hence why I posted on your message wall given my non staff status (well obviously).

    Just want to formulate a opinion on the matter
    • Like
    Reactions: Agnaa
    Testarossa002
    Hi Agnaa

    I want to pick your brain on something calc related for a verse I'm working on

    There's this particular feat where "hundreds of miles around were turned to dust"
    But since it's a novel aka no visuals, I can't get anything regarding craters

    How do you suggest I should proceed?
    View previous comments…
    Testarossa002
    Testarossa002
    Ohh I get

    It's omnidirectional

    Given that the radius is at least 200 miles, what do you think the crater should be?
    Agnaa
    Agnaa
    I said the radius would be 100 miles, I'd assume that the crater would be a hemisphere with a radius of 100 miles.
    Testarossa002
    Testarossa002
    Alright

    Thanks
  • Loading…
  • Loading…
  • Loading…
Back
Top