- 12,385
- 19,586
Daredevil vs Nightwing comes to mind, but it’s debatable
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
DEATH BATTLE! Discussion Thread (All-time Death Battle Spoilers Alert)
- Thread starter TMaakkonen
- Start date
- 9,571
- 18,403
- Thread starter
- #24,962
It seems like a paradox, wrong verdict should automatically mean good reasoning is impossible. But going through a list, uhhhh
Maybe some earlier eps? Assuming we allow lenience from casual non-vs debater logic, stuff like "Roboenza makes Metal Sonic betray and go solo" is in casual way cute story idea that could happen.
Maybe some earlier eps? Assuming we allow lenience from casual non-vs debater logic, stuff like "Roboenza makes Metal Sonic betray and go solo" is in casual way cute story idea that could happen.
- 9,571
- 18,403
- Thread starter
- #24,964
Yeah like, it has to be old one to be wrong. If a modern ep is wrong, its like SasukeHiei & OmnimanBardock where its "please buy these calcs that dont fit with stories teehee". Unless you go for debatable ones, but they dont feel like point here.
Hell, this fits into Pokemon vs Lions logic. Just ignore VS shit. Think about it like casual. In fact, imagine that youd had to research & animate a fight in 2 weeks. And that was 14 years ago, not only was VS shit niche, no one really calced worth shit. So assuming casual leniency mode:
Rogue beating WW is funny. WW has a lot of bare skin in her outfit. Rogue absorbs powers by skin touch. Seems simple. Some guidebooks give low stats for WW even tho they look professional, and while its battle for death, WW is not gonna insta stomp. So Rogue has a shot to turn tables.
Nobody knows Bomber Man is Kirby. People back then didnt know Kirby was a Kirby. So play Bomber Man casually. What do his bombs do? Kill him. His main attack can be exploited so I dont think this is outlandish that Dig Dug can beat him.
Is looking things from casual mindset ok?
Hell, this fits into Pokemon vs Lions logic. Just ignore VS shit. Think about it like casual. In fact, imagine that youd had to research & animate a fight in 2 weeks. And that was 14 years ago, not only was VS shit niche, no one really calced worth shit. So assuming casual leniency mode:
Rogue beating WW is funny. WW has a lot of bare skin in her outfit. Rogue absorbs powers by skin touch. Seems simple. Some guidebooks give low stats for WW even tho they look professional, and while its battle for death, WW is not gonna insta stomp. So Rogue has a shot to turn tables.
Nobody knows Bomber Man is Kirby. People back then didnt know Kirby was a Kirby. So play Bomber Man casually. What do his bombs do? Kill him. His main attack can be exploited so I dont think this is outlandish that Dig Dug can beat him.
Is looking things from casual mindset ok?
Last edited:
- 3,103
- 3,544
Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't Archie Sonic get some buffs that allows him to 1-tap Wally semi-recently? If yes, that'd probably be my choice.We have a thread dedicated to evaluating Death Battle matches for such criteria by our VSBW standards:
DEATH BATTLE! Accuracy Scale [Part 10, The more things change, the more they stay the same]
Alright, since the previous one hasn't been updated for long despite new episodes and revisions for several characters, we're gonna update and put everything here... again :V Rules: This list is purely for the accuracy of the DB research. Video or animation quality does not play a factor...vsbattles.com
Looking at the OP, seems like the "Wrong, Decent" rating might be what you're interested in, no?
Hope this helps!
Scrooge vs Shovel Knight also kinda lands in this category, if only on a 'standards of the time' basis. I heard rumours about Uni SK though, if that's any food for thought.
ZeNoviceArtist
He/Him- 6,043
- 7,321
0ホルスファルコン将軍0
He/Him- 1,676
- 3,375
We have a thread dedicated to evaluating Death Battle matches for such criteria by our VSBW standards:
DEATH BATTLE! Accuracy Scale [Part 10, The more things change, the more they stay the same]
Alright, since the previous one hasn't been updated for long despite new episodes and revisions for several characters, we're gonna update and put everything here... again :V Rules: This list is purely for the accuracy of the DB research. Video or animation quality does not play a factor...
Looking at the OP, seems like the "Wrong, Decent" rating might be what you're interested in, no?
Hope this helps!
Looking through this thread reminds me of how many profiles on this wiki are out of date, barebones, suffering from severe citogenesis, or the standards of scaling being absolutely wack. WDYM that Infinite Frontiers Supes gets outhaxxed by Goku according to the standards of this wiki?
Speaking of which, I found this gem in the thread, a “debunk” of Goku VS Superman 3:
Dust_Collector
They/Them- 9,283
- 12,051
Nope
- 20,438
- 20,336
And funny how most franchises here get updated when death battle tackles them
- 27,321
- 61,040
Flash (Wally West) (Rebirth)
Wally West is The Flash, the fastest man in the multiverse.[1] Formerly the protégé and successor of Barry Allen, he was trapped in the Speed Force for years, with the world forgetting his history until his metaphorical "rebirth." Tier: Varies with speed, up to 2-C, higher with Speed Steal. High...
vsbattles.fandom.com
- 282
- 316
Maybe Omni-Man vs Bardock could've fit this if Bardock took strength and Nolan took speed but Nolan still won. If they had argued that the latter had better speed, adaptability, stamina, and experience, he could've outlasted Bardock's forms especially in space, which would've been way more plausible than what we got. I think Bardock should still win since in that case since he one-taps Nolan and still has a range advantage but the logic of Nolan winning that way could've made sense? It's hard to validate wrong verdicts logically so that's the best I can do.
- 3,103
- 3,544
yikeshe dontFlash (Wally West) (Rebirth)
Wally West is The Flash, the fastest man in the multiverse.[1] Formerly the protégé and successor of Barry Allen, he was trapped in the Speed Force for years, with the world forgetting his history until his metaphorical "rebirth." Tier: Varies with speed, up to 2-C, higher with Speed Steal. High...
- 3,103
- 3,544
Anyway, I have to tap out for the night - but there's something I'd like to ask y'all for when I get up in the morning:
See, I've been thinking about my Xeno JRPG MU spreads, and one character I've been struggling to find a good main/alt for is Lin Lee Koo. For that, I'd like to hear some suggestions.
REQS:
For Bonus points:
I have Annette from 3H put down rn, and while that one is OK-ish, it's kinda a placeholder. The only other one I can think of is Clemont from the Pokemon XY anime, but that's not post-apoc, unless you count the attack on Lumiose for whatever reason.
See, I've been thinking about my Xeno JRPG MU spreads, and one character I've been struggling to find a good main/alt for is Lin Lee Koo. For that, I'd like to hear some suggestions.
REQS:
- Mechanically-minded genius prodigy at a young age (Lin is 13, before you ask). Make that an obsession or drive if you can.
- Post-apocalypse setting (I know NLA is still industrial/developed, but her planet still blew up).
- Have a strained but understanding relationship with someone in an adjacent circumstance (read: what happened with Lao).
- Be at least 7-C+ Physically, and 5-B+ when scaled.
For Bonus points:
- Have a portable shield as a weapon.
- Have a comic relief as a sidekick.
- Have dead parents, 'preferably' in an accident (I know that sounds f*cked, but you know what I mean)
- Can also cook (literally).
I have Annette from 3H put down rn, and while that one is OK-ish, it's kinda a placeholder. The only other one I can think of is Clemont from the Pokemon XY anime, but that's not post-apoc, unless you count the attack on Lumiose for whatever reason.
- 11,876
- 5,437
IDK Queen Tyr'ahnee, but I like her as an opponent for Lord Hater.
Same for Beat against Sora.
Dokuro Mitsukai vs Poemi Watanabe might be interesting.
What's the connection for Fleetway Sonic vs Kasen Ibaraki?
Moon Girl vs Hiro Hamada could be cool, especially with Devil Dinosaur & Baymax involved, though I'd fear for Hiro & Baymax.
Chucky vs M3GAN: Does M3GAN have a chance? I don't really know the franchise(s).
Sasaki Kojiro vs Roronoa Zoro might be neat, if he really could rival Zoro. (Skeptical.)
IDK Uryu Ishida, but I know Yuno Grinberryal, I think so I think it could be interesting.
Triple H vs Shao Kahn does sound like it'd be a stomp, but maybe not? John Cena versus could reptile coudl be neat, too, lol.
Next time is Medaka Kurokami is Superman... the heck?
- 12,385
- 19,586
Hey, thoughts on Jaden Yuki vs Makoto Yuki?
ZeNoviceArtist
He/Him- 6,043
- 7,321
I don't like it.
- 12,385
- 19,586
why not?
ZeNoviceArtist
He/Him- 6,043
- 7,321
Because I instinctively reject it.
- 12,385
- 19,586
Well that doesn’t seem very fair
- 5,602
- 6,640
Bobobo would understand the ability, he just wouldn't care.
- 1,570
- 2,186
that's the funniest outcome, henceforth it is also the canon and correct outcome
XSOULOFCINDERX
They/Them- 26,501
- 12,402
Man, Fleetway vs Kasen really exploded in popular overtime hasn't it?
- 27,321
- 61,040
Eh within the community def
- 2,575
- 4,394
Old news but Sweet Tooth was robbed.
- 1,570
- 2,186
For real for Real atleast they kind of rectified its ending with jinxharley
- 12,385
- 19,586
- 20,438
- 20,336
Stefano4444
He/Him- 6,807
- 6,055
- 20,438
- 20,336
Welp Ghost Rider vs Spawn can finally have the "welcome to hell motherf*cker" line now
- 9,571
- 18,403
- Thread starter
- #24,994
...Wait you actually need to subscribe to see archived videos.
oh
oh
Rayfire
Any/All- 3,937
- 2,903
- 282
- 316
I just saw that too. kind of funny that beerus vs galaxia went from copyright hell to behind a paywall but you can still watch it for free on the RT archive (I just rewatched the fight)
- 20,438
- 20,336
You know, even with alien x at the stats available here losing to green lantern herald scaling they hace DC and Marvel, the way they portrayed it in animation clearly didnt scream as such, could have done a better job back then
Last edited:
- 16,968
- 12,950
fun
i also like Zidane from FF9 vs makoto Yuki
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
