• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Cosmology rating and possible Conceptual Manipulation upgrade - Maou Gakuin

Status
Not open for further replies.
What this means is that if you completely erase a certain concept in a shallow layer, that same concept in a deeper layer would be unaffected.
I thought we have a two type of people who had understand it two different way.

1.Concept should have only one not multiple in each layers and govern all reality ,affecting concept would changed all object of all layers

2.who had see each layers have conceptual on it own but each of it not relate on each other , like we treated low-2C and 2-A , you can be type 2 or 3 on low-2 just destroyed one's concept in low-2-C would not have any consequence to another universe.
 
Right , that already refutes the CM type 2, after all it is not affecting the whole reality of the Silver Sea, but only one layer
Incorrect. Every order affects all of reality. Order from deeper layers just affects the Silver Sea more than order from a shallow layer.
 
Each God* in the MG-verse represents a concept that upholds that aspect of the world. Naturally, if that concept was disturbed or destroyed, it would have some type of effect on the world, whether that be negative or positive. All worlds have Gods that represent these concepts. However, for example, the God of Destruction of one world has nothing to do with the God of Destruction of another world. If the God of Destruction of a deep world was destroyed, that wouldn't have an effect on any world outside of it's own. So while all worlds have Gods that represent the same concepts, they are essentially completely unrelated to each other.

Another thing, all fully-developed worlds have what is called a Lord God. The Lord God is the most powerful God of that world, and their Order is what dictates the path that their world as a whole follows. For example, the Lord God of Balandias-- the Tiger King Maytilen, possesses the Order of a Castle that has the power of ignoring cause to reach the desired effect. Because his Order is that of a Castle, the inhabitants of that world possess the attributes of a Castle. Another example of this is the Lord God of the Holy Sword World Hyphoria-- the Holy Consecrated Eife. Because Eife is a God of the Holy attribute, all weapons from that world are of the Holy attribute.

A few of the Gods that were introduced (I don't remember all of them)
-The God of Creation
-The God of Destruction
-The Heavenly Father God AKA the God that begets Order
-The God of Birth
-The Abortion God
-The God of Demise
-The God of Deepening

*Guardian Gods represent a concept, but (as far as I'm aware of) their deaths won't affect the world whatsoever.
 
Incorrect. Every order affects all of reality. Order from deeper layers just affects the Silver Sea more than order from a shallow layer.
You are the one who's incorrect. If, let's say, a God of Birth for example-- if they were from a deep world and they were disturbed or destroyed, and that lead to new life being unable to be born, that wouldn't affect the rest of the Silver Sea whatsoever. Only in that world in particular would new life be unable to be born. New life could still be born in the rest of the Silver Sea.
 
I'm not very knowledgeable about concept manipulation, but if any knowledgeable members have a question regarding how order in the Silver Sea works, feel free to ask me.

Also, please consider my second suggestion regarding concept manipulation:
Anyways, if Conceptual Manipulation Type 2 is not accepted, I have another suggestion.

Characters with the "Post-Silver Sea" key that can manipulate concepts in a deep layer would be able to negate 21 layers of resistance, while Venuzdonoa and "True Power" Anos would be able to negate 100 (99+) layers of resistance to Conceptual Manipulation Type 3.
 
Last edited:
You are the one who's incorrect. If, let's say, a God of Birth for example-- if they were from a deep world and they were disturbed or destroyed, that wouldn't affect the rest of the Silver Sea whatsoever. Only their world would be affected.
Yeah, you're proving I'm correct here... The Gods only control order, they aren't the order themselves (Excluding Guardian Gods). What happens with a God's destruction is completely irrelevant in this thread.

Also, there has never once been mention of multiple "alike orders" existing in the Silver Sea. Statements from the WN state that order (singular) is "stronger" in deeper layers, implying it's the same order in different layers, with the first layer being the "base type 3 concepts" and concepts in deeper layers being uncountably greater, causing deeper order to be unaffected by the destruction of shallow order.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, you're proving I'm correct here... The Gods only control order, they aren't the order themselves (Excluding Guardian Gods). What happens with a God's destruction is completely irrelevant in this thread.

Also, there has never once been mention of multiple "alike orders" existing in the Silver Sea. Statements from the WN state that order (singular) is "stronger" in deeper layers, implying it's the same order in different layers, with the first layer being the "base type 3 concepts" and concepts in deeper layers being uncountably greater.
The Gods are directly linked to their Order. That's why when that God is removed from the world, so is that Order. And even when Order from one world is removed, it just affects that world, not the entire Silver Sea.
 
When Anos disturbed the Order of Destruction in his world, that didn't affect any other world but his.
This proves that he can disturb the order of the worlds and that each order is separate from the other worlds or are different, And he can still affect the order of the deep worlds. But not in general scale
 
I know nothing about this verse and I'm not knowledgeable on the Conceptual Manipulation stuff so there isn't much I can do here, sorry.
 
Yeah, Diasagree

None of this suggest type 2 concepts. The blog said orders, laws, concepts exist in each world. Just because deeper layer didn't affected doesn't mean anything, in the first place each universe didn't connected to each other and have their own order, laws, and concepts.

Just like destroying concepts in shallow layer wouldn't affected deeper layer, destroying concepts in deeper layer wouldn't affect shallow layer either.

By your logic any 2-B character would have type 2 conceptual manipulation.
Type 2 concepts is the root while type 3 is the branch. Destroying a branch wouldn't affect the other branch, let alone the root, but if you destroyed the root, all branch is effectively destroyed.

You just prove the root of all of this concepts exist in Maou Gakuin verse, but i don't see any.

So yeah again diasagree.
 
When a God is destroyed, their order isn't destroyed. This is proved when the God of Creation was destroyed yet her order wasn't. If you read the blog, you'd also know that disturbing order only takes that order out of the natural cycle of the universe.
 
When a God is destroyed, their order isn't destroyed. This is proved when the God of Creation was destroyed yet her order wasn't. If you read the blog, you'd also know that disturbing order only takes that order out of the natural cycle of the universe.
??? I know that disturbing order only takes it out of its natural cycle within the universe. I apologize if I worded something in a way that would make you assume that I didn't.

As for the God of Creation being destroyed, I presume what you're talking about is when the Creator God Elenesia died. Soon before she died, she gave birth to a new Creator God, that being Militia, and the Order of Creation was passed on to her. If Elenesia had been destroyed before she gave birth to Miltia, then the Order of Creation within that bubble would've been completely gone.
 
I'm not entirely sure about what classifies a concept as type 2, but the reasons for type 2 isn't because it's a multiverse.

The "strength" of order, meaning the amount of influence the order has on the Silver Sea, is uncountably greater in deeper layer when compared to a shallow layer. That difference means that if the shallow order is destroyed, it would have no affect on the deeper order. If the deeper order was brought together with the shallow order, the shallow order would seem to participate in the deeper order due to the uncountable difference in "strength".

Also:
Anyways, if Conceptual Manipulation Type 2 is not accepted, I have another suggestion.

Characters with the "Post-Silver Sea" key that can manipulate concepts in a deep layer would be able to negate 21 layers of resistance, while Venuzdonoa and "True Power" Anos would be able to negate 100 (99+) layers of resistance to Conceptual Manipulation Type 3.
 
Last edited:
I'm not entirely sure about what classifies a concept as type 2, but the reasons for type 2 isn't because it's a multiverse.

The "strength" of order, meaning the amount of influence the order has on the Silver Sea, is uncountably greater in deeper layer when compared to a shallow layer. That difference means that if the shallow order is destroyed, it would have no affect on the deeper order. If the deeper order was brought together with the shallow order, the shallow order would seem to participate in the deeper order due to the uncountable difference in "strength".

Also:
Just as a shallow order being destroyed has no effect on a deeper order, a deeper order being destroyed has no effect on a shallow order. There is actually proof of this. The Silver Water World Listeria was approaching the Abyss of the Silver Sea, meaning that it was one of the deepest worlds at the time. And it was destroyed. So all the Orders of that world were destroyed with it. Yet the Orders in worlds below it were perfectly fine.
 
Just as a shallow order being destroyed has no effect on a deeper order, a deeper order being destroyed has no effect on a shallow order. There is actually proof of this. The Silver Water World Listeria was approaching the Abyss of the Silver Sea, meaning that it was one of the deepest worlds at the time. And it was destroyed. So all the Orders of that world were destroyed with it. Yet the Orders in worlds below it were perfectly fine.
I get what you're saying, but there is actually no proof that the order was destroyed together with the world.

Still, I can only provide info on how order works, and I'm not knowledgeable enough about concept manipulation to make accurate arguments, so:
Anyways, if Conceptual Manipulation Type 2 is not accepted, I have another suggestion.

Characters with the "Post-Silver Sea" key that can manipulate concepts in a deep layer would be able to negate 21 layers of resistance, while Venuzdonoa and "True Power" Anos would be able to negate 100 (99+) layers of resistance to Conceptual Manipulation Type 3.
 
Last edited:
The deeper concept bring Weight from the lower concept

The lower world & concept get destroyed but not for the deeper concept

Type 2 should be fine since it's mostly transcended the concept in the shallow world

Also consdering how dal had type 2 concept because sw and mw concept are different makes mgkf type 2 concept justification seems better
 
Last edited:
if the deeper concept is destroyed, does the shallow(i'll use "shallow" instead of "lower")concept also destroyed?
Theoretically, it's possible. The "shallow concept" and the "deeper concept" are both the same concept. The shallow concept could be considered as the "base type 3 concept", while the deeper concept has an uncountably greater affect on reality. Destroying the shallow concept would have no affect on the deeper concept, since the shallow concept is uncountably lesser than the deeper concept.

If you were to completely destroy the concept on Layer 1, it wouldn't affect the concept on Layer 2, but if you completely destroy the concept on Layer 2, it would theoretically destroy the concept on all layers up to Layer 2, but wouldn't affect the concept on Layer 3, and so on...
 
Last edited:
Theoretically, yes. The "shallow concept" and the "deeper concept" are both the same concept. The shallow concept could be considered as the "base type 3 concept", while the deeper concept has an uncountably greater affect on reality. Destroying the shallow concept would have no affect on the deeper concept, since the shallow concept is uncountably lesser than the deeper concept.

If you were to completely destroy the concept on Layer 1, it wouldn't affect the concept on Layer 2, but if you completely destroy the concept on Layer 2, it would theoretically destroy the concept on all layers up to Layer 2, but wouldn't affect the concept on Layer 3, and so on...
No, if you destroy the concept on Layer 2, it simply wouldn't destroy the same concept on Layer 1. There is nothing theoretical about it.
 
No, if you destroy the concept on Layer 2, it simply wouldn't destroy the same concept on Layer 1. There is nothing theoretical about it.
It's called a theory for a reason...
Also, you say this, but what proof do you have?

**Erasing the order from the world would destroy the world, but it's never once been stated that destroying the world would destroy the order.
 
Last edited:
Till I know about those abilities and certain ratings then I will not reply. Though I will look at this thread.
 
I get what you're saying, but there is actually no proof that the order was destroyed together with the world.

Still, I can only provide info on how order works, and I'm not knowledgeable enough about concept manipulation to make accurate arguments, so:
Nousgalia himself said that if he, the God that begets Order were to perish, there would be no Order left in the world(https://tempusinfinitumblog.com/2020/11/15/113-gods-lesson/). Meaning that if a God is destroyed, so is their Order AKA concept. Now, on to my main point: Gods normally reside in the world that they originate from. That is confirmed. Whatever happens to a God happens to their Order (in most cases-- for example, if the Order of a God is transferred to a different person, like when Nousgalia's Order was transferred to Eldemade, then whatever happened to Nousgalia was irrelevant to his Order). That is also confirmed. With that cleared out of the way, its safe to say that if an entire world is destroyed, all of if not at least most of the Gods residing in that world would also be destroyed. Since its confirmed that Gods are directly linked to their Orders, those Orders would perish along with their Gods. And the Silver Water World Listeria which resided in an extremely deep layer was destroyed. Do you see where I'm going with this?
 
That's almost completely false tho... Gods only control order.

Nousgalia controls the order that maintains all other order in that world. If he were to perish, then he could no longer control that order, meaning the other orders could no longer be maintained in that world. Order is not destroyed when the god that controls it is destroyed, but it is rather disturbed.
 
The deeper concept bring Weight from the lower concept

The lower world & concept get destroyed but not for the deeper concept

Type 2 should be fine since it's mostly transcended the concept in the shallow world

Also consdering how dal had type 2 concept because sw and mw concept are different makes mgkf type 2 concept justification seems better
Dude, you clearly don't know how concepts type 2 works. What's people said above are already enough to disprove the concepts manip type 2.
 
If I'm not mistaken, Nousgalia controls the "Order of Order".
Without his order, no other orders can exist.
If his order is destroyed, all orders would be destroyed.

Doesn't that somewhat qualify as a Type 2 concept? Or would it rather be something along the lines of, "Concepts cannot exist without the concept of concepts", and thus remain a Type 3 concept?
 
That's almost completely false tho... Gods only control order.

Nousgalia controls the order that maintains all other order in that world. If he were to perish, then he could no longer control that order, meaning the other orders could no longer be maintained in that world. Order is not destroyed when the god that controls it is destroyed, but it is rather disturbed.
Sasha literally says in this chapter(https://ncode.syosetu.com/n1578dx/479/) that the Order would not only disappear but collapse as well if Eques was destroyed. So yes, back to my earlier Nousgalia example, its not just that all Orders within the world would disappear from and be unable to be maintained in that world if he were to die, it would perish along with him.
 
If I'm not mistaken, Nousgalia controls the "Order of Order".
Without his order, no other orders can exist.
If his order is destroyed, all orders would be destroyed.

Doesn't that somewhat qualify as a Type 2 concept? Or would it rather be something along the lines of, "Concepts cannot exist without the concept of concepts", and thus remain a Type 3 concept?
Possibly, but that has nothing to do with how Order from deeper layers affect Order from more shallow layers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top