Unwritten, Fables, and DC Continuity Connection

[Confluctor]

in The DC Book: A Vast and Vibrant Multiverse Simply Explained,

Largely irrelevant

they treat creator owned stuff as part of the continuity.

Not all, just some.

Fables is also canon to unwritten if you read the last 4 issues,

They had a crossover, yes. But so what?

and Batman appears in this comic issue 4 with Fables characters and its stated he came from another dimension and Earth (obviously referring to Prime Earth) and the comic says that those are the characters from Fables

Again, so what? Crossovers happens. But you have to explain why they scale.

The evidence for it being non canon is that its creator owned, but there's evidence that being creator owned doesn't make it non canon. Only swerzye has attempted to refute it, you didn't

There is so much more evidence than just that.

 

[Armorchompy]

if we all naruto run he can't report us all fellow thread mods

 

[SamanPatou]

Characters crossing over to other series has never ever been enough to consider two continuities canon to each other, unless very strong and reliable evidences and arguments are brought on, and at most we consider crossover characters as alternate versions.

 

[XXKINGXX69]

Disagree with the premise.

care to explain?

What, that the evidence is enough? It isn't. At all. There.

If you don't want to elaborate, then don't comment

Largely irrelevant

Not all, just some.

They had a crossover, yes. But so what?

Again, so what? Crossovers happens. But you have to explain why they scale.

There is so much more evidence than just that.

I didn't say the guidebook states all creator owned comics are canon, I used that to prove being creator owned isn't enough

They had a crossover, yes. But so what?

Again, so what? Crossovers happens. But you have to explain why they scale.

Never said anything about scaling. The crossover is a reference, and its not just a "crossover", its characters that are the same as their Fables counterparts appearing in a DC comic

There is so much more evidence than just that.

This is a lie. There isn't any at all, and if there is, why can't you show it to me? Is it hard?

 

[Confluctor]

This is a lie. There isn't any at all, and if there is, why can't you show it to me? Is it hard?

If you show me why they go together - why they can be canon to each other, then sure. Go on, I am waiting

 

[Jibz]

Should we just lock this? Feels like a waste of time.

PLEASE DO SO. THIS MAN IS A MASSIVE TROLL, AND WILL DO NOTHING BUT WASTE TIME.

 

[Darksmash]

OP still didn't explain how exactly the cosmologies of Unwritten and DC will fit together.

 

[Xearsay]

I'll report you for mod abuse if you do, this thread isn't even complete and we are still in the middle of discussion

Wait, you can report the mods?

 

[Planck69]

Wait, you can report the mods?

Of course, no one is above the rules here. Granted, reports are made to Human Resources as I'm aware.

 

[Armorchompy]

I think for most staff you can just report us normally, you'd need human resources for a Sysop since other Sysops can't really punish them.

That said, besides the obvious, nobody minds if I close this, right?

 

[Setsuna_tenma]

I think for most staff you can just report us normally, you'd need human resources for a Sysop since other Sysops can't really punish them.

That said, besides the obvious, nobody minds if I close this, right?

No

 

[Armorchompy]

Yeah I'm just gonna, feel free to uh, report me for mod abuse I guess.