I could formulate an opinion if someone can give me a summary of the current proposals.
vsbattles.fandom.com
Why tho? I just think this approach is obviously motivated in bad faith and biased against DC Comics. Several other long-running series, including ******* Marvel, are not receiving a similar treatment, so why should DC be singled out? That's all there is to it.
I disagree, everyone else more knowledgeable than me in the matter has already told you why the whole reason of "Supes won't be 1-A" is just short-sighted and disingenuous. Hell, I was one of the few people who agreed that this wasn't an outlier and was actually usable if Supes had those specific suns amping him to that level 24/7. That's the premise it was ended on, that it wasn't added to his tier because of outside help shenanigans. Not because it was Tier 1.
I literally gave reasons that have nothing to do with "1-A Superman" in the post you're quoting. You're the one who's bringing it up again.
What the hell is this then?
That's it? That's your best argument? Care to explain how this approach has been made to be motivated in bad faith and biased against DC Comics? Any feats that have become neutered? Or is it your conflict with which author's interpretation lines up the most accurately for the verse?
Because it takes a LOT of work, and I assume no Marvel fans have had the time. A lot of people who worked on this are DC fans, so I don't understand claims of bias against it
"You're all just biased" is not a reason.
Yes, that's understood. In a perfect world, those who oppose the project could likewise explain their reasoning, and staff like yourself could make an unbiased assessment of both arguments, but so far no one has provided that, all I've seen is agreement or neutrality with one exception above.
Yes, I would personally prefer if we can eventually divide Marvel Comics by a few editorial direction eras, preferably pre-Quesada and post-Quesada, which is where the most drastic cosmological and thematic changes occurred, but these types of projects take massive amounts of time to properly investigate and figure out the most factually and logically accurate approach for.
No it isn't. Not everything in this world is (thankfully) motivated by completely partisan manipulative hatred of one thing or another.
Go on.
Keep going. Elaborate further.
BTW, this is not me instigating anything.
Just because they’re “DC fans” doesn’t mean they can’t hold certain biases against the verse. Literally one of the guys working on this revision thinks CAS and Mandrakk are star or galaxy level, thinks Mxy is below universal, thinks True Form Darkseid didn’t cast a shadow over the Multiverse, etc.
This is not the venue for you to air out your personal grievances against me (and strawman me in the process). This kind of toxic derailing is why your participation warranted the degree of skepticism that it did.
Pretty sure that even Marvel Comics will gets the same treatment as DC Comics but let's focus on the current thread. And this approach is not driven by bad faith and biased against DC Comics, but is rather motivated by inconsistent tierings of the DC characters, especially the god tiers, because of an attempt to create a composite cosmology with things that don't fit together. This approach is just to create to coherent that are more accurate to what the comics shows.
****, you beat me to it.
I managed to convince Deagonx to go along with the rest of our project group's conclusions rather than go overboard. You can read the suggested tiering that our project members concluded seem most logical in the blog post that I linked to in my first post in this thread.
Considering those who were interested already replied, Everyone except Matt.
In that regard, yes. Ultima is kind of busy due to schoolwork, and in consideration for him I think it should be left open until next week.
Ultima agrees with the split. One of the reasons we separated the thread into "split concept" and "specific splits" was because he agreed with the former but disagreed with one of the cosmology divisions, which is a conversation we intend to have on the next thread.
I edited away the information in question.
I should note, Impress is pretty much done with the community based on the reaction of her most recent posts. So asking her to come back might not be a good idea, Confluctor I do not have his Discord, but he may be of help.
