• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

ZillertheBucko said:
R.c7f056cd153dd25bf9292d596f0cabfe

And I found the limiters page!
Click to expand...
If you want it so badly, make it yourself lmao
 
Qawsedf234 said:
The second rule can be removed, but the first is something that has cropped up and won't go away, so it stays.
Click to expand...
Yeah it's kinda weird to say that in a rule page, that second rule fits more in a note on Saitama's actual page, but the absurd limitless arguments are an actual annoyance (especially now that it is objectively wrong but STILL argued) and I fully agree with prohibiting it.
 
Berserk discussion thread for any other fans (it's back btw):

www.vsbattles.com

Berserk General Discussion Thread

As the title says. Berserk has returned, and has already given numerous new chapters, but I don't see much talk about it, so I decided to make this, also because it's an ongoing thing again, even if the updates aren't very common (next one is over a month away). Imo, any series that is ongoing...
www.vsbattles.com www.vsbattles.com
 
Oi-, don't you think Saitama should gain some kind of Analytical Prediction?


Here Saitama evaded an attack which Garou transported with a portal, so he should've predicted Garou would use a portal to enlarge his punch



Here Saitama counterattacked Garou (who was behind Saitama) without looking at him.





But this is the most important feat imo. As you see, Saitama uses the omnidirectional serious punch with thousands of afterimages. And when Garou tries to evade them using a portal, at the other side of the just generated portal, there it was Saitama, who crossed the portal from the other side to punch Garou. To do so, Saitama should've predicted Garou would use a portal, and where he would put the other side of the gate so he (Saitama) could cross the gate from the other side.

And, well, you may also consider a feat that when Saitama and Garou where fighting, both with their full strength, Saitama could connect punches at Garou despite Garou's massive analytical prediction

What do you think?
 
JustANormalPerson01 said:
Oi-, don't you think Saitama should gain some kind of Analytical Prediction?


Here Saitama evaded an attack which Garou transported with a portal, so he should've predicted Garou would use a portal to enlarge his punch



Here Saitama counterattacked Garou (who was behind Saitama) without looking at him.





But this is the most important feat imo. As you see, Saitama uses the omnidirectional serious punch with thousands of afterimages. And when Garou tries to evade them using a portal, at the other side of the just generated portal, there it was Saitama, who crossed the portal from the other side to punch Garou. To do so, Saitama should've predicted Garou would use a portal, and where he would put the other side of the gate so he (Saitama) could cross the gate from the other side.

And, well, you may also consider a feat that when Saitama and Garou where fighting, both with their full strength, Saitama could connect punches at Garou despite Garou's massive analytical prediction

What do you think?
Click to expand...
The first one looks more like Garou's punch just knocked his head back.

Saitama doesn't need that to know that Garou was attacking behind him, he just threw a punch and hit Garou. The most that's added is instinctive reactions when someone responds to an attack they're not seeing, which is what the second feat would be considered.

Again, this is still a stretch to call it analytical prediction, Garou has spammed portals the entire fight, anyone could guess he might use a portal there and just prepare in case he does, analytical prediction is being able to actually tell an opponent's exact move through analysis of the way they fight, like Goku predicting when and where Hit would attack him in the future, just guessing an opponent using an ability (especially using a portal to escape an attack) simply requires intelligence. Vegeta could predict that Hit would use time-skip soon, and prepared for it so he could grab Hit, but he didn't actually predict when it would happen, or where Hit would attack, thus Vegeta does not possess analytical prediction on his profile, this is a similar case. Generally speaking, when analytical prediction is given, the evidence for it involves a scene where we clearly see or are even told that the character had accurately predicted an attack based on observation. I'd pretty safely say that if I were Saitama there, I would guess that Garou was gonna use a portal to avoid the attack.
 
Last edited:
RinneItachi said:
Again, this is still a stretch to call it analytical prediction, Garou has spammed portals the entire fight, anyone could guess he might use a portal there and just prepare in case he does, analytical prediction is being able to actually tell an opponent's exact move through analysis of the way they fight, like Goku predicting when and where Hit would attack him in the future, just guessing an opponent using an ability (especially using a portal to escape an attack) simply requires intelligence. Vegeta could predict that Hit would use time-skip soon, and prepared for it so he could grab Hit, but he didn't actually predict when it would happen, or where Hit would attack, thus Vegeta does not possess analytical prediction on his profile, this is a similar case. Generally speaking, when analytical prediction is given, the evidence for it involves a scene where we clearly see or are even told that the character had accurately predicted an attack based on observation. I'd pretty safely say that if I were Saitama there, I would guess that Garou was gonna use a portal to avoid the attack.
Click to expand...
I mean, even if Saitama knew Garou was going to use a portal to evade the omnidirectional Serious Punch, to punch Garou from the other side of the Portal, Saitama should've guessed where Garou would've opened the other gate and punch him from there.
 
But afterimages are only that, afterimages, not clones that can act by their own.

For Saitama to punch Garou from the other side of the Portal, he should've predicted where Garou was going to put the other side of such Portal.
 
JustANormalPerson01 said:
I mean, even if Saitama knew Garou was going to use a portal to evade the omnidirectional Serious Punch, to punch Garou from the other side of the Portal, Saitama should've guessed where Garou would've opened the other gate and punch him from there.
Click to expand...
Saitama was attacking omni-directionally, he was already positioned properly after the portal was made. If that was your argument I would've approached my response a bit differently.

zxMw2qG.png
qsUoDn8.png
LBTJuVI.png


I don't see this getting analytical prediction. Though maybe fear hax for making Garou say "Eek?!".
 
RinneItachi said:
Saitama was attacking omni-directionally, he was already positioned properly after the portal was made. If that was your argument I would've approached my response a bit differently.

zxMw2qG.png
qsUoDn8.png
LBTJuVI.png


I don't see this getting analytical prediction. Though maybe fear hax for making Garou say "Eek?!".
Click to expand...
My point is:

Garou created a portal. Such portal transports Garou to a completely different position away of all Saitama's afterimages (via common sense, if he's using a portal to evade omnidirectional serious punch, there is no reason for Garou to put the other gate of the portal somewhere where Saitama could just punch him)

But when he opened the portal, it is shown that the real Saitama, not an afterimage (which is not a real being, but a visual trick. Saitama's only in one position at the time, the other "Saitamas" are not clones, but afterimages left by his speef), but the real Saitama was already waiting him from the other side. So, Saitama should've been waiting Garou patientlly from the location where Garou would've put the other side of the Portal, to punch him when he opened such way.

If Saitama were below Garou, he wouldn't have been at the other side of the Portal (which he is), but below both Garou and the portal
 
Wait, I didn't even understand this scene until just now. So Garou was falling into a portal to come out of another one, which means Saitama would've needed to enter through Garou's alternate portal to attack him from there? I always interpreted it as Saitama following Garou through the portal and just punching him there.

Still, idk if it warrants analytical prediction, for the reasons I mentioned before.
 
JustANormalPerson01 said:
My point is:

Garou created a portal. Such portal transports Garou to a completely different position away of all Saitama's afterimages (via common sense, if he's using a portal to evade omnidirectional serious punch, there is no reason for Garou to put the other gate of the portal somewhere where Saitama could just punch him)

But when he opened the portal, it is shown that the real Saitama, not an afterimage (which is not a real being, but a visual trick. Saitama's only in one position at the time, the other "Saitamas" are not clones, but afterimages left by his speef), but the real Saitama was already waiting him from the other side. So, Saitama should've been waiting Garou patientlly from the location where Garou would've put the other side of the Portal, to punch him when he opened such way.

If Saitama were below Garou, he wouldn't have been at the other side of the Portal (which he is), but below both Garou and the portal
Click to expand...
I know that now.

I guess this could get a "likely analytical prediction" if given its own CRT, I'd be surprised if it got a full on analytical prediction for Saitama though, but that's not up to me.
 
RinneItachi said:
Wait, I didn't even understand this scene until just now. So Garou was falling into a portal to come out of another one, which means Saitama would've needed to enter through Garou's alternate portal to attack him from there?
Click to expand...
Basically yeah
RinneItachi said:
I always interpreted it as Saitama following Garou through the portal and just punching him there.
Click to expand...
Nah. Saitama was already there when Garou tried to escape, which is why Garou got scared when crossing the portal. And Saitama, in fact, punched Garou out of the portal Garou was trying to cross, not to the other side.
RinneItachi said:
Still, idk if it warrants analytical prediction, for the reasons I mentioned before.
Click to expand...
Which reasons?
 
JustANormalPerson01 said:
Basically yeah

Nah. Saitama was already there when Garou tried to escape, which is why Garou got scared when crossing the portal. And Saitama, in fact, punched Garou out of the portal Garou was trying to cross, not to the other side.

Which reasons?
Click to expand...
Because Saitama still could've just guessed Garou was gonna used a portal and prepared for it ahead of time. Preparing for an opponent to use an ability is not analytical prediction, as I mentioned. Vegeta could guess that Hit was gonna use time-skip, so he prepared to take the next attack and grab him the moment he felt the blow, but he didn't predict when Hit would attack, let alone how or where. It's still a reach to say that Saitama knew when and where the portal would be made when we don't have context, not to mention he was still a lot faster than Garou at the time, enough to borderline blitz him.
 
Recon1511 said:
think it should be added that Saitama doesn't have infinite power/strength or that he is just a gag character because it now has been directly contradicted by the manga.

That being said, he is limitless but he needs time for his AD to kick in.
Click to expand...
Saitama is confirmed to not be limitless. The most he theoretically has is the ability to grow stronger by a theoretical infinite degree but at best it makes him 3-A and we have zero supporting evidence for that.
 
RinneItachi said:
Because Saitama still could've just guessed Garou was gonna used a portal and prepared for it ahead of time.
Click to expand...
i mean, even if he guessed Garou would've used a portal, there is no way Saitama guessed where the other side of the Portal would be to instantly appear there when Garou was just starting to cross it. Considering the countless amount of possible places Garou could've put the other side.
RinneItachi said:
Preparing for an opponent to use an ability is not analytical prediction, as I mentioned. Vegeta could guess that Hit was gonna use time-skip, so he prepared to take the next attack and grab him the moment he felt the blow, but he didn't predict when Hit would attack, let alone how or where. It's still a reach to say that Saitama knew when and where the portal would be made when we don't have context, not to mention he was still a lot faster than Garou at the time, enough to borderline blitz him.
Click to expand...
Fair ig
 
Again, I'd go for a "likely analytical prediction", I would agree that he probably did accurately and precisely predict where the second portal would be made, but we don't actually know that, thus I wouldn't word it as a definitive truth.
 
Qawsedf234 said:
Saitama is confirmed to not be limitless. The most he theoretically has is the ability to grow stronger by a theoretical infinite degree but at best it makes him 3-A and we have zero supporting evidence for that.
Click to expand...
Well, that's what I mean by limitless, there isn't a cap to how strong he can get.

Anyway, the ruling should be updated regardless.
 
We don't need a rule for that lol.

As long as Saitama doesn't have Toon Force ability nor High 3-A AP, anyone who argues for him being that strong/having that ability should do a CRT to get it added instead of arguing something that there isn't on Saitama's profile
 
JustANormalPerson01 said:
We don't need a rule for that lol.

As long as Saitama doesn't have Toon Force ability nor High 3-A AP, anyone who argues for him being that strong/having that ability should do a CRT to get it added instead of arguing something that there isn't on Saitama's profile
Click to expand...
It's about discussion rules lol, it's outdated
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

TyranoDoom30
OPM profiles possible renaming
Replies
5
Views
3K
Recon1511
Recon1511
Kachon123
One-Punch Man: Genos Profile Rework
2
Replies
44
Views
6K
WizardPowers101
Kachon123
One-Punch Man: Adding Willpower to Some Profiles
Replies
12
Views
2K
Kachon123
Kachon123
Phoenks
  • Locked
"Possibly" 3-C Saitama
2 3 4
Replies
149
Views
17K
Phoenks
Phoenks
Marvel_Champion_07
Low 7-B Puri-Puri Prisoner
Replies
23
Views
2K
Marvel_Champion_07
Marvel_Champion_07
Back
Top