Some thoughts on the Harry Potter profiles

[NatzuX]

Make seperate book and movie profiles
Agree: (3) Gendolfgg1, Lord_Farquaad69420, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree:
Neutral: (1) LightMoonWizard

Neutral

Downgrade Dumbledore, Voldemort and Grindelwald to High 8-C
Agree: (2) Lord_Farquaad69420, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree: (2) LightMoonWizard, Gendolfgg1
Neutral:

Neutral

Remove anything stating Grindelwald to be superior to Voldemort
Agree: (4) LightMoonWizard, Gendolfgg1, Lord_Farquaad69420, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree:
Neutral:

Agree

Remove anything stating old Dumbledore to be weaker than before
Agree: (3) Gendolfgg1, Lord_Farquaad69420, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree:
Neutral: (1) LightMoonWizard

Agree

Upgrade old Dumbledore to 9-B physically with subsonic reactions
Agree: (4) LightMoonWizard, Gendolfgg1, Lord_Farquaad69420, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree:
Neutral:

Agree

Remove "higher in her prime" from McGonagall's profile
Agree: (2) Gendolfgg1, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree:
Neutral: (2) LightMoonWizard, Lord_Farquaad69420

Neutral

Add something like "The verse generally ranges from Wall level to Large Building level, though there have been instances of accidental or unconventional use of magic reaching [whatever tier Alderton's feat is] or even [whatever tier Innocenti's feat is]." to the Wizarding World verse page.
Agree: (3) LightMoonWizard (Disagrees with the verse ranging from Wall level to Large Building Level, rest is fine), Lord_Farquaad69420, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree:
Neutral: (1) Gendolfgg1

Agree

 

[Jamesthetaker]

Make seperate book and movie profiles
Agree: (3) Gendolfgg1, Lord_Farquaad69420, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree:
Neutral: (1) LightMoonWizard

Agree. I recall seeing a dozen posts on the internet about the differences between books and movies, which are significant enough to separate them into distinct profiles.

Downgrade Dumbledore, Voldemort and Grindelwald to High 8-C
Agree: (2) Lord_Farquaad69420, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree: (2) LightMoonWizard, Gendolfgg1
Neutral:

Agree. They can be "High 8-C with magic, Low 7-C with Enviromental Destruction" via the fog creation feat, until better feats come up.

Remove anything stating Grindelwald to be superior to Voldemort
Agree: (4) LightMoonWizard, Gendolfgg1, Lord_Farquaad69420, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree:
Neutral:

I can agree with this, since nothing implies that Grindelwald is superior to Voldemort; if anything, it's more of the opposite.

Remove anything stating old Dumbledore to be weaker than before
Agree: (3) Gendolfgg1, Lord_Farquaad69420, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree:
Neutral: (1) LightMoonWizard

Agree. I am not sure how age affects magic, but nothing I know suggests that old Dumbledore is less powerful than his younger self.

Upgrade old Dumbledore to 9-B physically with subsonic reactions
Agree: (4) LightMoonWizard, Gendolfgg1, Lord_Farquaad69420, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree:
Neutral:

Agree. If an eleven-year-old child can achieve 9-B feats, most wizards should be able to scale from them.

Remove "higher in her prime" from McGonagall's profile
Agree: (2) Gendolfgg1, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree:
Neutral: (2) LightMoonWizard, Lord_Farquaad69420

I guess the argument makes sense. Like Dumbledore, I don't see why age would have any effect on their magic.

Add something like "The verse generally ranges from Wall level to Large Building level, though there have been instances of accidental or unconventional use of magic reaching [whatever tier Alderton's feat is] or even [whatever tier Innocenti's feat is]." to the Wizarding World verse page.
Agree: (3) LightMoonWizard (Disagrees with the verse ranging from Wall level to Large Building Level, rest is fine), Lord_Farquaad69420, DarkDragonMedeus
Disagree:
Neutral: (1) Gendolfgg1

Agree.

 

[Jason_Courne]

Make seperate book and movie profiles

Yeah this is obviously something that needed to happen for a while now

Downgrade Dumbledore, Voldemort and Grindelwald to High 8-C

Disagree since Credence's feat has the possibility to get higher due to either the screenplay version, or simply a recalc of the feat

Remove anything stating Grindelwald to be superior to Voldemort

Makes sense

Remove anything stating old Dumbledore to be weaker than before

Upgrade old Dumbledore to 9-B physically with subsonic reactions

Remove "higher in her prime" from McGonagall's profile

Age scaling was always weird so yeah agree with all three

Add something like "The verse generally ranges from Wall level to Large Building level, though there have been instances of accidental or unconventional use of magic reaching [whatever tier Alderton's feat is] or even [whatever tier Innocenti's feat is]." to the Wizarding World verse page.

I agree? I'm a bit conflicted since some characters are outrighted to be >>> magic wise

 

[The_Fiend888]

Bump

 

[The_Fiend888]

Bump