Rule Violation Reports (New forum)

[Lonkitt]

Eh, no. We are eager to fly off the handle at it because we don't like Chase. I'm sorry to rain on the parade, but the vast majority of these mistakes have no implications on scaling. For instance:

Chase's TL: Although, I will soon not be able discern how much time has passed in the future, however the fact that BB has already arrived at the Moon Cell is certainly something that can't be denied regardless.
My TL: Although I don't know how far off in the future it'd be, the point is that BB already reached the Moon Cell. That fact is absolutely unchangeable.
Judgment: What did you think that first clause meant??? It's an INCREDIBLY simple one too, how did you get "soon I won't be able to tell how much time will pass in the future"? What does that even mean? Why would Rin need to say that? You must have been tripped up by that "後かの" SO HARD if you seriously thought that was "how much time will have passed in the future" Like, seriously, take a step back and rework on your understanding of parsing grammar rules. Oh, and "動かせない/unchangeable" isn't exactly "can't be denied" but that's way smaller in comparisoon

Yeah, someone tell me what exactly we think Chase's goal was in altering this? I'm very familiar with this whole sequence and the scaling that Rin's statement is used for. None of the mistakes he made have any impact on how that scan is used.

You’re taking literally one example out of a pool of several scans. Posing this as what’s being used as the strongest evidence of Chase’s translation manipulation is twisting the argument

And again. It doesn’t explain why Chase would ignore advice from somebody who actually speaks Japanese

 

[Deagonx]

You’re taking literally one example out of a pool of several scans. Posing this as what’s being used as the strongest evidence of Chase’s translation manipulation is twisting the argument

Well, yes, because trying to go over each mistakes all at once would be needlessly lengthy, I'm just saying that's the impression I walk away with.

And again. It doesn’t explain why Chase would ignore advice from somebody who actually speaks Japanese

Salt? Pride?

Look I don't really care enough about Chase to try very hard to stop us from perma banning him for this so that we can avoid talking about whether his off-site statements are bannable but like, lets at least be transparent that we are making a mountain out of a molehill explicitly to avoid dealing with an actual mountain.

 

[KLOL506]

Eh, no. We are eager to fly off the handle at it because we don't like Chase. I'm sorry to rain on the parade, but the vast majority of these mistakes have no implications on scaling. For instance:

Chase's TL: Although, I will soon not be able discern how much time has passed in the future, however the fact that BB has already arrived at the Moon Cell is certainly something that can't be denied regardless.
My TL: Although I don't know how far off in the future it'd be, the point is that BB already reached the Moon Cell. That fact is absolutely unchangeable.
Judgment: What did you think that first clause meant??? It's an INCREDIBLY simple one too, how did you get "soon I won't be able to tell how much time will pass in the future"? What does that even mean? Why would Rin need to say that? You must have been tripped up by that "後かの" SO HARD if you seriously thought that was "how much time will have passed in the future" Like, seriously, take a step back and rework on your understanding of parsing grammar rules. Oh, and "動かせない/unchangeable" isn't exactly "can't be denied" but that's way smaller in comparisoon

Yeah, someone tell me what exactly we think Chase's goal was in altering this? I'm very familiar with this whole sequence and the scaling that Rin's statement is used for. None of the mistakes he made have any impact on how that scan is used.

Bro.

He translated the same piece of text. Thrice in a row. Each time more radically different than the last, the last one cutting out content from the original. Do you really want me to bring Red here to settle this grievous error?

Even ignoring that, what do you exactly have to say about your friend literally admitting he rushed the translations?

 

[Crabwhale]

Alright, as the senior staff member here, this is getting cluttered. I want my fellow admins and up to comment here. Anyone else, please cease arguing. Let the decision be made already. Anything beyond this will be going in circles.

 

[Tony_di_bugalu]

Not staff but just bringing to attention something, Chase tried to downgrade Fate/Nasu using his own translations (which were called out in the same thread from what I saw) and given he is being judged here by manipulating translations about Nasuverse.

You get my point.

 

[Antvasima]

I think that Chase can be permanently banned from our wiki and forum now. The consensus here seems to be strong. Thank you very much for helping out, Crabwhale.

 

[CloverDragon03]

Yeah, I definitely think he can now. The staff consensus is pretty overwhelmingly in favor of a permaban

Much thanks to everyone that contributed btw, it's appreciated

 

[GarrixianXD]

I blocked Chase on the wiki.

 

[Antvasima]

And I blocked him here in this forum.

 

[Antvasima]

No vulgar mock images please.

 

[Deagonx]

We should also act upon Marshadows ban now that the Chase matter appears to be settled

 

[GarrixianXD]

We should also act upon Marshadows ban now that the Chase matter appears to be settled

Have we reached a consensus for him?

 

[Damage3245]

Now that that is taken care of, was there a consensus on a temporary ban for @BasedNecoScaler69?

 

[CloverDragon03]

Now that that is taken care of, was there a consensus on a temporary ban for @BasedNecoScaler69?

I believe there were sentiments for either a couple of weeks, a month, or at least 2 months from different staff members

 

[KLOL506]

We should also act upon Marshadows ban now that the Chase matter appears to be settled

Didn't we already reach a consensus of a month minimum?

 

[BasedNecoScaler69]

I did not instigate anything, I posted a shitpost on his wall. If making fun of a user is instigating then you'd be sent to the dpeths for a lot of counts. I actually treated him with more respectt than he deserves, quite frankly.

bumping this for posterity.

Also, worth it.

 

[KLOL506]

bumping this for posterity.

Also, worth it.

That was unnecessary TBF.

 

[Damage3245]

That was unnecessary TBF.

Yeah, that is really not helping their case there.

I am in favor of a 1 month minimum ban for them. 2 months is also fine with me.

 

[Theglassman12]

A month or two ban is fine by me.

 

[Antvasima]

I think that two weeks to at most one month seems reasonable.

 

[KingNanaya]

Also, there has been an appeal to be able to participate in an upcoming Tokyo Revengers discussion thread that allegedly concerns an anime adaption of the series which clarifies the nature of a speed feat.

Antvasima

vsbattles.fandom.com

Also bumping this so it's not forgotten, seeing as the major dramas are concluded

 

[Deagonx]

Two months is fine with me.

 

[Emirp sumitpo]

I agree to a perma ban

 

[Lonkitt]

I also agree with perma ban

 

[UchihaSlayer96]

As do I.

 

[GarrixianXD]

I addressed it in the staff chat before. Phantom told me in DMs that he indeed has talked to the victim of Dread's grooming, which Dread denied in the first place judging by his side of the story sent by @Dereck03. Phantom told me that Dread knew she was underaged (which Dread denied that he didn't); there might be more to the story but I'm clueless about it. Dread claimed all those allegations were fake, but judging by those screenshots sent by BasedNecoScaler, I think it's safe to assume that Dread's side of the story is unreliable since he lied about such things. Permaban seems like a good precedent, I agree.

 

[M3X_2.0]

I also agree with a permaban but I think reports of this kind should be discussed on DM with staff and this specific staff member should bring it to the staff DM.

As much as I wish all the worst for these kind of people, I don’t think everyone should know about this, it’s even worse considering the sensitive themes the report has.

 

[M3X_2.0]

Or at least put those SS on spoiler tags please.

 

[BasedNecoScaler69]

I also agree with a permaban but I think reports of this kind should be discussed on DM with staff and this specific staff member should bring it to the staff DM.

As much as I wish all the worst for these kind of people, I don’t think everyone should know about this, it’s even worse considering the sensitive themes the report has.

Dread is not a staff member anymore, this is no longer a HR issue. But i can spoiler tag the images if absolutely needed

 

[M3X_2.0]

Dread is not a staff member anymore, this is no longer a HR issue. But i can spoiler tag the images if absolutely needed

IIRC HR still deals with retired members. But this isn’t a matter of being staff or not, the topic is sensitive enough to warrant a discussion in DMs, and you don’t need to expose all of this to everyone.

This is not a rule mind you, I just think this is what should be done.

 

[GarrixianXD]

IIRC HR still deals with retired members. But this isn’t a matter of being staff or not, the topic is sensitive enough to warrant a discussion in DMs, and you don’t need to expose all of this to everyone.

HR doesn't deal with retired members but yeah, I agree this topic is quite sensitive and very disturbing and more favorable in staff chat, hence why I didn't report it to the RVRT

 

[Abstractions]

Not that it's needed at this point (I also agree with a permaban fwiw), but Dread has also said a lot of racist shit and is apparently a believer in anti-semitic conspiracy theories. Zero redeeming qualities all around, keep them the hell away from this site.

Respectfully, could we not turn a very serious allegation into a situation where we throw every possible thing this person may have said at the wall? It's not appropriate, regardless of the validity of your concerns.

I'm not coming to Dread's defense and would hate for it to seem that way, this just should have been handled better and was not.

 

[CrimsonStarFallen]

Disgusting what some people are capable of. Agree with the perma ban, obviously. Painful to see him just admitting to this shit and being unable do to anything for his victim, though. That really, truly sucks.

 

[Abstractions]

I have applied BasedNecoScaler's 1 month ban, as has been agreed upon previously in this thread that has since been buried.

 

[Antvasima]

I also agree with a permaban but I think reports of this kind should be discussed on DM with staff and this specific staff member should bring it to the staff DM.

As much as I wish all the worst for these kind of people, I don’t think everyone should know about this, it’s even worse considering the sensitive themes the report has.

I very strongly agree with that these types of topics should consistently be handled via DMs, especially considering that our HR group is already supposed to evaluate the veracity of these claims in private. Let's constantly try to avoid as much community-destabilising panicked knee-jerk reaction inducing drama as possible please.

 

[Antvasima]

Respectfully, could we not turn a very serious allegation into a situation where we throw every possible thing this person may have said at the wall? It's not appropriate, regardless of the validity of your concerns.

I'm not coming to Dread's defense and would hate for it to seem that way, this just should have been handled better and was not.

Very strongly agreed. Thank you.

Should we delete the controversial post above?

 

[BreezeHM]

User Vandalized Cid's Profile

 

[DarkDragonMedeus]

I warned them and Dereck undid the vandalism.

 

[Antvasima]

Should we delete the controversial post above?

I have done so now.

 

[Antvasima]

I warned them and Dereck undid the vandalism.

Thank you very much to both of you for helping out.