- 7,681
- 996
I haven't been in touch with MagiReco stuff since last month. Can anyone give me the TLDR version of what happens in the chapter 8 and 9 of possible?
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Puella Magi Discussion Thread VII: Waiting for Main Story Chapter 10
- Thread starter SomebodyData
- Start date
- Status
- 7,681
- 996
Aw....
- 39,668
- 15,591
Only SD who know :v
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #45
TL;DR everyone splits up to take on the Magius before they lure Walpugis into the city.
Yachiyo fights and takes off Holy Mami's Rumor clothes with the help of another Rumor, who just teleported from the main city after dumping a lot of witches to make sure Madoka doesnt ruin their plan.
The side characters realize that the Magius are usin the Rumors to amp up the Black Feathers and make them all target the soul gems.
Iroha gets kidnapped.
Chapter 9:
Yachiyo and Sana attack the Magius base where Iroha was kidnapped. The base is actually a massive rumor that has passive power null.
The Magius had sacrified Yachiyo's ex and the twins to Eve already. Kyoko helps Sana and Iroha escape. Now we wait for the translations
Yachiyo fights and takes off Holy Mami's Rumor clothes with the help of another Rumor, who just teleported from the main city after dumping a lot of witches to make sure Madoka doesnt ruin their plan.
The side characters realize that the Magius are usin the Rumors to amp up the Black Feathers and make them all target the soul gems.
Iroha gets kidnapped.
Chapter 9:
Yachiyo and Sana attack the Magius base where Iroha was kidnapped. The base is actually a massive rumor that has passive power null.
The Magius had sacrified Yachiyo's ex and the twins to Eve already. Kyoko helps Sana and Iroha escape. Now we wait for the translations
- 19,123
- 6,335
Neat.
Btw, all the god tiers (except AoC) should have Non-Physical Interaction.
Madoka can interact with nonexistents like UKG, UKG can interact with abstracts like Madoka, and Homura can also interact with abstracts like Madoka
Btw, all the god tiers (except AoC) should have Non-Physical Interaction.
Madoka can interact with nonexistents like UKG, UKG can interact with abstracts like Madoka, and Homura can also interact with abstracts like Madoka
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #48
Ye I could add it later since its a small update.
Momoko's part of Chapter 9 is out, not much happens other than Kaede, Momoko, and Rena fight off some pinked hair white feather's doppel, who then apparently joins them.
For the Magia Record, the next profiles I plan on making are Meru Anna, Kuro, and Kanae Yukino. Afterwards, I'll probably try finishing the Kazumi bunch and add the last two Tart Puella Magi, then maybe finally begin on Suzune and Portable.
Momoko's part of Chapter 9 is out, not much happens other than Kaede, Momoko, and Rena fight off some pinked hair white feather's doppel, who then apparently joins them.
For the Magia Record, the next profiles I plan on making are Meru Anna, Kuro, and Kanae Yukino. Afterwards, I'll probably try finishing the Kazumi bunch and add the last two Tart Puella Magi, then maybe finally begin on Suzune and Portable.
- 39,668
- 15,591
>Kazumi bunch
You mean the other Pleiades Saint?
You mean the other Pleiades Saint?
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #50
Yesssss
- 39,668
- 15,591
Sweet!
- 10,926
- 3,124
Puella Magi Oriko Magica Sadness Prayer Volume 4 Imgur
https://imgur.com/a/FsY8GZE PMOM SP Vol. 4 Ch. 20
https://imgur.com/a/xmirxtD PMOM SP Vol. 4 Ch. 21
https://imgur.com/a/1OWiTh PMOM SP Vol. 4 Ch. 22
https://imgur.com/a/OT0l70E PMOM SP Vol. 4 Ch. 23
https://imgur.com/a/h3qIfF6 PMOM SP Vol. 4 Ch. 24
https://imgur.com/a/FsY8GZE PMOM SP Vol. 4 Ch. 20
https://imgur.com/a/xmirxtD PMOM SP Vol. 4 Ch. 21
https://imgur.com/a/1OWiTh PMOM SP Vol. 4 Ch. 22
https://imgur.com/a/OT0l70E PMOM SP Vol. 4 Ch. 23
https://imgur.com/a/h3qIfF6 PMOM SP Vol. 4 Ch. 24
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #53
So cracking a soul gem isn't actually insta death, it first starts by removing your Healing powers and then begins a process.
I think a "Misc. Puella Magi Info blog" is going to be eventually needed at this point as I'm pretty sure we're going to forget everything sooner or later.
I think a "Misc. Puella Magi Info blog" is going to be eventually needed at this point as I'm pretty sure we're going to forget everything sooner or later.
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #55
That ending though it seems we finally got an eplanation on kure's power, jeez that's op.
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #57
Okay good night!
For when you wake up: She uses her fate manipulation to dramatically change herself, such as for example in this manga, she became witch willingly and retained her mind, and had amplified Oriko with her magic, kinda like Tart + Riz.
I may be reading to deep into it, but the room Oriko and Kirika are always in, seems to be some kinda astral plane, given how a dead Kirika somehow gave a dying Oriko the card to kill Madoka with.
For when you wake up: She uses her fate manipulation to dramatically change herself, such as for example in this manga, she became witch willingly and retained her mind, and had amplified Oriko with her magic, kinda like Tart + Riz.
I may be reading to deep into it, but the room Oriko and Kirika are always in, seems to be some kinda astral plane, given how a dead Kirika somehow gave a dying Oriko the card to kill Madoka with.
- 39,668
- 15,591
Kazumi Magica end without Godoka.
- 14,195
- 2,574
- 19,123
- 6,335
We need to talk about acausality bois.
Madokami has type 2 (Textbook example, really) and 4 (Transcendens causal laws). I could argue for type 5 as well.
Base Homu has type 1 (although wasn't CMG Homu the one that kept her memories.?) and CMG Homu has type 4 (due to her transcending causal laws)
UKG has types 2 and 4 scaling from Meguca.
I dunno if base Madoka should hava acausality now tbh
Madokami has type 2 (Textbook example, really) and 4 (Transcendens causal laws). I could argue for type 5 as well.
Base Homu has type 1 (although wasn't CMG Homu the one that kept her memories.?) and CMG Homu has type 4 (due to her transcending causal laws)
UKG has types 2 and 4 scaling from Meguca.
I dunno if base Madoka should hava acausality now tbh
- 7,681
- 996
Are you talking about the MagiRecord Madoka?
- 7,681
- 996
I mean, yeah, now that you mention it, Kyubey describes her as "Singularity Cause and Effect" does seems contradicting to what shown in the series.
- 7,681
- 996
Ah....I misunderstand.
What is it then? Some form of ability or something?
What is it then? Some form of ability or something?
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #67
We discover in Wraith Arc that the shield has type 1 acasuality, so yes even base Homura should have it.
I'mma see if Final Timeline Madoka has any more acauality feats, but just a reminder that she did dream about the previous timelind in the first episode before even becoming a magical girl.
I'mma see if Final Timeline Madoka has any more acauality feats, but just a reminder that she did dream about the previous timelind in the first episode before even becoming a magical girl.
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #69
ye, a weird one, but fate hax none the less.
- 10,926
- 3,124
The Puella Magi Verse loves to give Fate hax to magical girls. First Riz, than Yachiyo, and now Kirika. Although Kirika is technically the first Fate hax user since she appeared first although we never learned about her Fate hax until now. So she's also technically both the earliest and latest Fate hax user.
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #71
There is also another one in Magia Record, basically she manipulates fate to make her predictions accurate.
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #74
Understandable I guess, it should probably be removed from base Madoka. Though maybe on the same thread type 5 for ult madoka can be argued,
- 19,123
- 6,335
Sounds about right.
And given that we are talking about revisions, can I say that our justification for High 3-A Tart is weak, to say the least?
Like, she has an "infinite power" statement and that's kinda it.
Isabeau reacting to her also honestly disproves infinite speed.
Honestly i would feel more comfortable scaling her above Isabeau
And another thing. Why we assume that Tart's Doppel negates durability?
And given that we are talking about revisions, can I say that our justification for High 3-A Tart is weak, to say the least?
Like, she has an "infinite power" statement and that's kinda it.
Isabeau reacting to her also honestly disproves infinite speed.
Honestly i would feel more comfortable scaling her above Isabeau
And another thing. Why we assume that Tart's Doppel negates durability?
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #76
Well "infinite power", broke the inverse tiering system, and as you mentioned yourself, people with similar potential has reached such levels of power, and exceeded it.
The only time Isabeau reacted to her was when Tart was mid-air no? Every other time was Isabeau trying to attack Tart but getting blitzed every time.
Speaking of Isabeau though (Since I'm currently checking it to respond) Kyubey mentions that when she was born (So right off the bat this was at her weakest) she encompassed all of France, and then her daughter proceeds to mention: "As the Dark Age reached maturity, all of the people felt the darkness of their losses! It created (meaning it has already happened) an even larger witch, spreading farther and wider over the world!"
Isabeau's invulnerability also includes abilities, such as Melissa's Matter Destruction hax.
So we probably need to add Statistics Amplification (Grows more powerful and larger accordingly to the despair of men within her Barrier) alongside a more detailed Invulnerability and upgrade her accordingly.
As for Doppel tart, I believe it was because it of the entire "No matter who or what stands before this Doppel, it shall find sin within them and expose it before the light of day. In short, one has no choice but to accept the full brunt of its absurd purity."
Though "ceaselessly disgorge their sins", doesn't this mean the Doppel forces them to talk about their sins with her aura?
The only time Isabeau reacted to her was when Tart was mid-air no? Every other time was Isabeau trying to attack Tart but getting blitzed every time.
Speaking of Isabeau though (Since I'm currently checking it to respond) Kyubey mentions that when she was born (So right off the bat this was at her weakest) she encompassed all of France, and then her daughter proceeds to mention: "As the Dark Age reached maturity, all of the people felt the darkness of their losses! It created (meaning it has already happened) an even larger witch, spreading farther and wider over the world!"
Isabeau's invulnerability also includes abilities, such as Melissa's Matter Destruction hax.
So we probably need to add Statistics Amplification (Grows more powerful and larger accordingly to the despair of men within her Barrier) alongside a more detailed Invulnerability and upgrade her accordingly.
As for Doppel tart, I believe it was because it of the entire "No matter who or what stands before this Doppel, it shall find sin within them and expose it before the light of day. In short, one has no choice but to accept the full brunt of its absurd purity."
Though "ceaselessly disgorge their sins", doesn't this mean the Doppel forces them to talk about their sins with her aura?
- 19,123
- 6,335
I'm not saying that it would be an outlier. More that Tart doesn't really have anything else backing it up.
She blasted Tart with an energy beam at one point (did nothing but still managed to hit her). Minou reacted to her as well (albeit barely)
"Far higher over time" or something like that could work? She can grow in power over time, but we don't know how strong she was when she was defeated. To me Minou's statement looks like "it's still spreading, it will encompass everything eventually", not "it already covers the world"
Probably warrants an "at least 6-B" as well. Kyubey is legitimately worried by the idea of Isabeau's power spreading over the entire planet, so there is that as well.
Agreed for the invulnerability.
I don't think that "no matter who or what" = durability negation.
It does. I do believe that the fire part also applies, but I don't think that it would negate durability
She blasted Tart with an energy beam at one point (did nothing but still managed to hit her). Minou reacted to her as well (albeit barely)
"Far higher over time" or something like that could work? She can grow in power over time, but we don't know how strong she was when she was defeated. To me Minou's statement looks like "it's still spreading, it will encompass everything eventually", not "it already covers the world"
Probably warrants an "at least 6-B" as well. Kyubey is legitimately worried by the idea of Isabeau's power spreading over the entire planet, so there is that as well.
Agreed for the invulnerability.
I don't think that "no matter who or what" = durability negation.
It does. I do believe that the fire part also applies, but I don't think that it would negate durability
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #78
I never said you were? I'm saying that generally we don't accept infinite power statements as they tend to be hyperbolic and innaccurate, I was just pointing out that neither of these apply given what we already know. And like I said above, the infinite power statement is backed by the in-verse tiering system.
The only time I found her being blasted was when she was mid-air (in which case she couldn't dodge due to her lack of flight or pseudo flight), can you give me a page number?
I guess? Minou was using past tense the entire time, so I'm not sure if that's accurate. But alright I guess.
I don't know, that sounds like its ignoring how durable her enemies are. But alright I guess, unless Doppel Tart, UKG, or Ult Madoka get paired against someone more durable with them, the results are basically the same,
The only time I found her being blasted was when she was mid-air (in which case she couldn't dodge due to her lack of flight or pseudo flight), can you give me a page number?
I guess? Minou was using past tense the entire time, so I'm not sure if that's accurate. But alright I guess.
I don't know, that sounds like its ignoring how durable her enemies are. But alright I guess, unless Doppel Tart, UKG, or Ult Madoka get paired against someone more durable with them, the results are basically the same,
- 19,123
- 6,335
What I meant is, "fate allows that" only proves that it wouldn't be an outlier.
It doesn't add legitimacy to the feat on its own.
Also, it's backed up only by the databook and tiering system. There are no feats close to that in the manga.
I'm going by memory (reread it yesterday) so I can't. Either way Minou reacted to her too.
The meaning seems "she created an OP witch, which started spreading her influence and is still doing so". Kyubey also confirms that she can still grow in power
It doesn't add legitimacy to the feat on its own.
Also, it's backed up only by the databook and tiering system. There are no feats close to that in the manga.
I'm going by memory (reread it yesterday) so I can't. Either way Minou reacted to her too.
The meaning seems "she created an OP witch, which started spreading her influence and is still doing so". Kyubey also confirms that she can still grow in power
- 14,195
- 2,574
- Thread starter
- #80
I guess? Though both the databook and tiering system are from the manga (making it a direct source).
Tart reacted to Minou actually, looking at the manga each time they struck blows Tart was simply blocking her attack. The only exceptions are two times, when Tart attacked her back and when Tart pushed Minou back, but Minou was struck both times without being able to do anything. It should also probably be mentioned she didn't even want to kill her, rather she left her alone to faint.
Well yeah, humans are a constant producer of despair, she would grow more powerful regardless.
Tart reacted to Minou actually, looking at the manga each time they struck blows Tart was simply blocking her attack. The only exceptions are two times, when Tart attacked her back and when Tart pushed Minou back, but Minou was struck both times without being able to do anything. It should also probably be mentioned she didn't even want to kill her, rather she left her alone to faint.
Well yeah, humans are a constant producer of despair, she would grow more powerful regardless.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
