n the heat of the battle you can get these sudden reflexes for defensive purposes. Real-life humans can lift cars or show very impressive reflexes, hell most of us if threatened knowingly in a high-adrenaline situation can likely replicate one or two of these otherwise high skill moves. What makes this kinda stuff special for martial artists is that they can replicate it with a degree of CONSISTENCY, while most of us can’t and have to rely on raw chance.
Can you demonstrate your character can do that consistently? If not they’re not getting it more than a regular person is.
The problem is most humans don't do it even if they have the physical capabilities. Plus, not all humans and in fact most humans can't do some of those latter feats on their own. By "Not on their own" it could be argued they can also walk/stand on water as if it was solid ground, raise people from the dead including themselves, ect. Heck, even I might be more physically fit than those two characters or some Breaking Bad characters and yet I still don't have anything against the profiles existing.
Still, just because a character is no more physically capable than a real world person especially if ancient historical examples are included. Otherwise even Superhuman feats policies would be getting too strict. Technically as far as "Powers and abilities" are concerned, there'd be nothing wrong with making profiles for real world people. The only reason it's not allowed is simply just from the fact that trying to pit two real worlders and asking "Who would win in a fight to the death" would be prone to immense controversy. But if it weren't for a rule against that, a lot of people actually would be interested in a RL Bruce Lee Vs RL Chuck Norris debate.
Unless you want to CRT in Martial Arts for a thousand files, we don’t consider “clever street fighting” as such. You’re arguing against wiki precedent, and honestly wiki opinion for most part, we never really give that out UNLESS the character is explicitly trained or performs extremely recognizable techniques with frequent consistency
I read the Martial Arts page.
Martial Arts is defined as
different techniques of attacking and self-defense, with the purpose of physical and/or spiritual self-improvement. At its core, martial arts can include any kind of creative/flexible physical body movement used for offensive and defensive purposes. Which would include blocking a shank at the perfect timing. The sand throwing feat may not be martial arts, but neither would simply having knowledge on pressure points, but even that's something
we have a page for and listed as an example of martial arts. Standard street smarts would still be worth indexing by that logic.
No. They’re entirely separate genres. There are MANY Crime Dramas AND Mystery Dramas that aren’t action, and throwing a few punches doesn’t make you action either. Death Note is an Action Manga by your definition
Also we do list sitcoms like How I Met Your Mother, Simpsons and iCarly, so you’re wrong demonstratively.
Death Note is literally a verse we have indexed on the platform despite no one being higher than 10-A. As well as a profile for the likes of
Near who is even more bare bones than various Squid Game profiles.
I did not find How I Met Your Mother which was deleted actually as was Two and a Half Men. Simpsons is a cartoon, and ICarly is full of 9-B feats actually. Which was something I literally brought up as Armor pointed out.
Because most humans aren’t 10-C, irrelevant argument.
Again we literally can just add anything by this logic, the shit you’re claiming is a “strawman” is demonstratively true while YOUR assertion is not.
This is just gonna result in wiki having no rules whatsoever, we’ve never allowed JUST 10-Bs with NOTHING ELSE on the file, until right now where you’re arguing against it. There needs to be a line SOMEWHERE, this wiki is about something is it not?
Armor already answered all of those. Also, the 10-B's each have one respective ability listed; knife user, social influencing, ect. But the problem is that I should make a content revision where they now have a few. And their abilities would be just as good as
Hank's or
Jesse's.
Nobody argued AP is necessary to that degree? Great job knocking down a strawman, non-standard AP is necessary when you have LITERALLY nothing else notable worth listing.
You're once again the one who literally said this.
You can keep the 9-Cs, no issue with that from me, but 10-Bs gotta go.
Pretty sure that counts as doing what you claimed you weren't doing even if it wasn't what you were intending
Throwing dust in someone’s eye and HAPPENING to catch a knife once, while doing nothing else significant throughout the series isn’t feats, hell if they’re the ONLY THING they’re outliers.
Consistent with taking three steps forward during a tug of war game to force the other team to knock themselves over when they lease expected to. That's another thing, Seong Gi-Hun actually has a few feats of sort of holding his own against a Peakhuman mobster. He shielded Kang Sae-Byuk from him in the 1st episode and also fought him with several others during Episode 4's midnight brawl. So there is consistency, no outliers.
...just because you had a couple of bright ideas doesn't mean you're now automatically a combat prodigy, mate. Unless you demonstrate he's consistently good at COMBAT, I'm not gonna presume his skills translate across EVERY FIELD.
Most of his anti-feats aren't even that bad of anti-feats. It was literally an entire group of Loan Sharks that kicked his ass. He got his ass kicked because he was outnumbered, but because he was a shitty fighter. And based on a conversation with his daughter, he gets into fights all the time. And the Salesman just happens to be a lot more skilled and stronger than he looks. Still, I brought up other consistencies. Also, you don't even need to be a grandmaster of martial arts to have a profile, you just need to be fairly decent in hand to hand combat to be considered a martial artists. And these are words coming from someone is a trained martial artist who has their share of crazy feats IRL.
No, they can't, unless they're peak of human intelligence.
Peakhuman intelligence is not really a thing. And you don't have to be a genius either. Anyone who is at least fairly decent and comes from a verse where conflict plays a good part is fine.
But yes, I will make a content revision to address the issues.
