Bump.
The situation I see with Arceus here is a gamer with a low end pc and 100 games on his hard drive. Now
1. He has all games, sure but that doesn't mean he can play all games for the simple reason that his pc is low end and thus, many games simply aren't compatible with it
2. Now let's take it that he has all the upgradable parts, so he can swap in and out, so technically, he can play any and all games he wants
Note: The fact his pc isn't compatible with all games doesn't take away the fact that
he has the games.
The Typing is not the power of Pokémon, No. The Typings refers to the Aspect of the Pokemon reality a Pokémon is given command over.
1. We already know that the Plates are the essence of the Type. So the plates is what makes the Type what it is. Literally the meaning of Essence
2. Let's use the Earth Plate as an example. It is imbued with the
Essence of the Land, not the Essence of Ground Type Pokémon. There's nothing a ground Type Pokémon can do, that Arceus with the Earth Plate can't, for logical reasons as that authority to command the Earth is given them by fragments of Arceus, which are plates. And that's the same for all other Plates.
With that out of the way. DT argument won't work here, and I'm going to repeat that. He says the fact Arceus has the essence of all types doesn't mean he has the knowledge/know how to use it. Alright
1. The concept of knowledge/intelligence is an aspect of Arceus, so there's nothing he wouldn't be able to do with the plates.ie. Intelligence/knowledge is a non issue.
2. The same applies to any and all human capabilities/technologies. The Arc Phone made by Arceus surpasses any and all pokedex tech in the multiverse. But also that's kind of a cheat because it goes beyond human tech to include supernatural properties.
3. The difference between a human and a Pokémon is that Pokémon have powers, and humans dont. But even then, some humans can use psychic powers amongst other things. But it makes sense because humans and Pokémon were once the exact same beings. So trying to say humans can do things ghat, Arceus can't, doesn't make sense at all when that knowledge and intelligence is being given them by Arceus. The powers used to seal humans was given them by Arceus
I'll tackle OP main argument once again.
1. All Plates being created at the start of creation is a lie. The only plates created at that time is the one of defeated giants, the one he placed his own powers into, and the fragments of the multiverse.
2. Why do you think Pokémon get boosts in their power from plates in the first place. Because of their special relationship with the Plates. In the anime, a dispersed energy from the flame plates sent all Pokémon in the vicinity agitated. All for the simple reason that it is the bestower of their powers. The power of the plates are shared amongst the Pokémon to exercise the power to command an aspect of the Pokemon world.
3. If the power of defeated Giants refers to any Pokémon at all, then that Pokémon shouldn't have any powers because their powers have been taken for a plate. Which, clearly isn't the case. You're free to show me a Pokémon without superpowers I'll wait
4. Trying to seperate one ability from the other won't work here. Over 90% of the abilities are literally moves but passive. The other 10% is physiology based. So what do we do? We seperate. Because Arceus can't do the exact same they can? Moves can shut down abilities, Copy abilities, modify them, and so on. Why can't Arceus use their abilities again? When Transform, a
NORMAL Type move is a power bestowed to Pokémon by the Blank Plate. This is one of the exact reasons why I brought up the gamer and games. There are so many ways Arceus can use the abilities and powers of others via
MOVES. I won't repeat for the umpteenth time who owns the Essence of Types
5. Now Dark Matter. Dark Matter relies on Negative emotions to exist. Which wouldn't happen if Mesprit took 3 seconds to erase negative emotions from Pokémon. But plot. And no, everything in the multiverse is indirectly and directly made because of Arceus. Everything is. The same PMD game with Dark Matter has this:
This is the legendary Pokemon Arceus, which is said to have created everything ...?
Beyond space and time One heart
And it baffles me when you say Ultra Space wasn't made by Arceus. Who told you such a lie? Where are you getting your info from exactly. You're still using headcanon as usual
7. Events happen independently of Arceus. Yessire
The Original One is in all things, the original one is nowhere at all
From all creations, over all creations, does the Original One watch over all
Showings. What showings. You want Arceus to use all 1000 moves to know he has them? When the game makes it clear he literally has with him the power that allows Pokémon command over their environment.
8. Man made Pokémon like Porygon is a normal type. And I wonder who has the Essence of Normalcy. I just wonder
The Plates are a
concept. Arceus will not descend from heaven to give you a type. Pokémon are made to be given authority to control an aspect of reality. In fact that is the nature of every power in the cosmology. Humans aren't exempt. When Arceus took the power of the Giants for the Flame Plate, he didn't come down from Heaven to give Pokémon the Fire Type. They were naturally born with it